°❀⋆.ೃ࿔*:・ Despite this being number 5 from the “Meant to Be” series of Modern Disney retellings, this was my first time reading one of the stories and I really enjoyed it! Mulan is one of my favourite Disney princesses and I admired her so much for her bravery, resilience, and determination in saving her father from the war and bringing honour to her family. I think that the author did a great job at honouring the lessons behind Mulan in her modern take of the classic Disney tale and the legendary Chinese heroine 🇨🇳
°❀⋆.ೃ࿔*:・ The thing I admired most of Hua Mulan in this story was her unwavering spirit. She fought tooth and nail to prove she was just as good as the men at work, pulling all-nighters and studying things so thoroughly that she can’t make any mistake. She undergoes significant character development in this as she realizes that she deserves to be loved for who she is and not the plentiful masks that she puts on at work, in front of family, and in front of the world. I loved getting to see her work hard and successfully prove her worth with Li Shang and his family at Wutai Gold because it was so satisfying to see that although she was very close to giving up, she persevered and kept going in order to honour her father’s wish. Through it all and her strength coming from her family, she still powers through and uncovers that she does have the power to do anything she wants out of life, her career, and her relationships.
°❀⋆.ೃ࿔*:・ Her love for her family is so overwhelming that she clearly does all she can in the book just to fulfill this one business acquisition for her father, even if it means throwing herself into a setting completely out of her league and setting herself up for humiliation and embarrassment. And yet despite all this, she still feels it in her heart that she isn’t good enough for her parents because of others’ expectations of her. This hit home for me as a Filipina growing up with similar experiences, and it felt so nice to be seen by a woman of colour not knowing how to make things right and not disappoint anyone. We have to work twice as hard to be taken seriously and not be degraded to stereotypes and offensive beliefs that the media churns out in mainstream TV and movies to this day. I loved that Mulan overcomes the odds and finds the strength in her to challenge gender stereotypes and prove those who doubted her wrong. I loved that her parents, like my own which I’m so grateful for, are so supportive of Mulan and want to see her grow and develop as who she truly is while finding real happiness. I think that’s such an important message that was showcased in this book 💕
°❀⋆.ೃ࿔*:・ The secondary characters were pretty enjoyable to read about. I loved Mushu and Mulan’s relationship, and how they honoured it from the original Disney movie of the two of them having each other’s backs. Mushu was relatable in that lots of people, especially those from Asians cultures, feel a lot of pressure of not knowing what they want to do with the rest of their lives. Shang was so cinnamon-roll coded and I loved his character. While he appeared just as traditionally masculine in morals and beliefs like the rest of his family, he treats his mom like she is his entire world and challenges gender stereotypes. He surprisingly loves to cook, clean, and take care of people and it was shown in a way that didn’t feel performative or that it was for the sake of contrasting him with Mulan. I loved Shang’s mother, Auntie Jiayi, and how she teamed up with Mulan to finally give herself her voice a chance and to go after what she wanted. It was heartwarming to see Auntie Jiayi share her stories with Mulan as so much of our family’s history and culture is passed down from those we care about. I was happy that she finally got to where Mushu, Shang, and Auntie Jiayi ended up, although it would’ve been more interesting to see more from them as the epilogue and overall ending felt a bit rushed 💬
°❀⋆.ೃ࿔*:・ On one hand, I do agree that the romance was lacking a bit and tended to lean towards insta-love. I think it would have been better showcased as a coming-of-age or general fiction story more so than a romance, but I do see a different perspective in comparison to those saying in their reviews that the book wasn’t good because of the romance. I think the book stayed true to Mulan’s story in essence in that her entire life didn’t revolve around finding a partner or falling in love. Her story, at its core, is her struggling to find who she truly is in a world where she has to prove herself worthy of something ten times more than the average man and doing everything she can in order to make her family proud. While this story did focus heavily on her career and her battling against sexism, I would say it did Mulan’s story justice for its modern time and setting
°❀⋆.ೃ࿔*:・ Mulan is a loyal daughter and a faithful friend foremost before she can even find it in herself to find love, so the way her journey had progressed throughout the book was very satisfying to see. I’m a hardcore hopeless romantic but I think the decision to prioritize Mulan’s self-discovery and her obstacles in the way of her journey was more important to emphasize than her love story. It shows that women are more than capable of chasing their dreams and doing things that they be otherwise stereotyped as not being able to do as effectively as men but also being sensitive to rely on their loved ones as well. We can be strong and independent while allowing ourselves to be taken care of by others. We can have the best of both worlds 🌸❣️
Tropes:
- Private equity VP FMC x whiskey brand CEO MMC 📁💼
- Modern Disney retelling 🏰
- Female empowerment and gender equality
- POC representation, Chinese-American MCs 🇨🇳
- Mentions of sexism and misogyny
- Romance sub-plot 💓
- Fish out of water 🐟
- Forbidden romance
- Closed-door romance 🚪
Thank you to Jesse Q. Sutanto, Hyperion Avenue, and NetGalley for providing me with a free eARC in exchange for my honest review!