Blending biography and archival history, After the Flood asks of Bob Dylan, “If your dreams are fulfilled at twenty, what do you do with the rest of your life?”
A prevailing narrative Bob Dylan, the voice of Sixties counterculture, disappeared in the 1970s in a haze of substance abuse, made arguably the worst music of his career, and was finally put to bed in the 1980s—only to be resurrected in 2016, when he was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature. Dylan’s concerts once began with an announcer intoning a deadpan version of just such a narrative. That is not this story.
Drawing on thousands of pages of archival materials, After the Flood reveals Dylan’s output during the last three decades as his most ambitious yet. Across an abecedarium of chapters surveying his albums, performances, films, and books since the early 1990s, celebrated poet Robert Polito shows how Dylan evolved a late musical style that has embodied and resisted its era—interweaving Ovid and Americana, film noir and the Civil War. Imaginatively researched, After the Flood is both an essential revision and continuation of the Dylan saga.
Robert Polito (born 1951) is an American academic, critic and poet. He has been Director of the Writing Program at The New School since 1992. He received the National Book Critics Circle Award and an Edgar Award for Savage Art: A Biography of Jim Thompson.
I was tempted to move this up to 4 stars, simply because the era of Dylan's career this covers is of immense interest to me.
I liked a lot of things about this book. It covers some great years and albums, gives some ideas for good concerts to listen to, and has some cool anecdotes. It weaves in interviews Bob has given over the years, and if you're like me, you read those 5x when they were first published.
This is the first book in a while where I thought, "this could have used an editor." Everything from simple mistakes (mistaking George W. for his father, George HW) to rambling and sometimes incoherent flourishes.
Again, there was a lot I liked, but the author seemed pretty into his own writing and style and showing off that it was a distraction for a lot of the journey.
Also, where was the chapter devoted to Together Through Life? Did I miss it?
The finest book I’ve read about Bob and the definitive investigation into the beautiful and mysterious artistic project at which he’s worked obsessively for the last 30 years
For the last year I have been listening to Bob Dylan like my life depended on it—usually around 1500 minutes a month. Last May I saw him in concert for the 4th time, in Spokane as part of the Outlaw Tour with Willie Nelson. A friend asked me recently what it was I liked about Dylan’s latest 6 albums, the focus of most of my current listening. I struggled to answer.
This book was just what I was looking for: an explanation of Dylan’s songwriting process as he reinvented himself yet again over the last 30 years. Dylan’s lyrics, so often mysterious, seem as familiar and inevitable as history. I could sense there was more there than was explained merely by his biography.
Polito’s book is best at illuminating the allusions and referents in Dylan lyrics. It is pretty dense and difficult at times, but in giving insight into Dylan’s encyclopedic knowledge of American experience and songcraft, Polito succeeds at helping me explain to my querying friend just why I firmly believe Dylan’s Nobel is richly deserved.
Not everyone will give this book 5 stars, but it scratched a very particular itch in this obsessive Dylan fan.
As a fan of all things late era Dylan, this book hit all the right spots. Deeply researched, full of passion, and well written, it was difficult for me to put this book down. Intense lyrical analysis, cultural history, and biography… it’s all in here. From good as I been to you and world gone wrong, which lead to the breakthroughs on time out of mind, love and theft, etc, all the way up to the Sinatra albums, which led to the rough and rowdy ways of the last few years, the author deep dives into it all.
If you’re looking for any sort of biography of Dylan, skip this book. Polito is entirely too self-impressed to make this book about an anyone but Robert Polito.
Robert Polito ‘After the Flood: Inside Bob Dylan’s Memory Palace’ – slovo po slovo – palača
Ponekad se čini da svake godine u svijetu izlazi dovoljno knjiga o Bobu Dylanu da njegov prosječan obožavatelj i ne treba drugu literaturu za čitanje. Velik dio tih naslova usredotočen je na njegove najslavnije dane iz šezdesetih, tako da smo se u 2026. već osvrnuli na dva naslova koji su se bavili sličnom tematikom i razdobljem, lanjsku “Jewish Roots, American Soli” Harryja Freedmana i hrvatski prijevod uspješnice “Dylan Goes Electric!” Elije Walda, a kroz tjedan dana izlazi i “Where the Music Had to Go” Jima Windolfa koja se bavi međusobnim utjecajem Dylana i Beatlesa.
Za razliku od ovih naslova, prvi značajniji dilanološki naslov ove godine dolazi u obliku knjige naslovljene “After the Flood” s podnaslovom “Inside Bob Dylan’s Memory Palace” autora pjesnika i biografa Roberta Polita koja se bavi Bobovim ponovnim usponom od devedesetih do danas i pokušava obuhvatiti sve elemente koje su ga ponovno učinile jednom od najznačajnih pojava u glazbi nakon razdoblja kreativne krize u osamdesetim godinama prošlog stoljeća
“Palača sjećanja” iz podnaslova odnosi se na zamišljeni prostor unutar uma u kojemu se pohranjuju “mnemoničke slike” za lakše pamćenje, a Polito je proveo mnogo vremena u Dylanovoj srhivi u Tulsi gdje je kopao po beskonačnim rukopisima glazbenika nobelovca kako bi sve te slike povezao i trasirao njegov rad s obzirom na njihovo slaganje u autorsku cjelinu koja čini njegov opus od sad već klasične povratničke ploče “Time Out of Mind” koja mu je priskrbila Grammy za album godine, do danas.
Predani fanovi Dylana sad napokon imaju na jednom mjestu golem popis izvora svih onih citata kojima je Dylan ispunio svoje pjesme unazad tridesetak godina, od “Odiseje” i rimskih pjesnika (nadasve Ovidija), preko Biblije i Williama Shakespearea, do pjesnika iz razdoblja američkog građanskog rata, do narodnih pjesama, blues glazbenika i opskurne literature (poznat je takav slučaj s “Confessions of a Yakuza” japanskog autora Junichija Sage). Polito u svojoj knjizi pokazuje kako Dylan sve ove izvore slaže jedne uz druge unutar svojih pjesama, stvarajući djela koja istovremeno imaju više značenja i tako postaju svevremenska i univerzalna.
Utisak koji sva ova saznanja ostavljaju graniči s nevjericom. je li moguće da je Dylan išao baš tako daleko u svojim promišljanjima pri stvaranju Frankensteinovog čudovišta sastavljenog od stoljeća i stoljeća glasova svojih mrtvih prethodnika i slaganju njegovih dijelova u cjelinu toliko koherentnu da slušatelju nije ni potrebno predznanje o tome otkuda koji stih zapravo dolazi, jer zvuče sasvim prirodno u obliku u kojemu su prezentirani? Dylan je, prema Politovu mišljenju, posljednji veliki intelektualac i erudit na današnjoj popkulturnoj sceni (uz eventualno Patti Smith) i u 26 poglavlja svoje knjige označenih po jednim slovom engleske abecede umjesto brojeva, uvjerit će i najsumnjičavijeg čitatelja da je uistinu tako.
Osim s autorskim albumima koje je Bob objavio u zadnjih trideset godina, Polito se bavi i svim ostalim Dylanovim aktivnostima koje su obilježile ovo razdoblje, a koje uključuju koncerte u sklopu tzv. Beskrajne turneje, knjige koje je napisao poput memoara “Chronicles Vol. I” i “The Philosophy of Modern Song“, ili filmova poput igranog “Masked and Anonymous”, koncertnog “Shadow Kingdom” i tek rubno drugih.
Obrađena je i genijalna radijska emisija “Theme Time Radio Hour“, kao i izlet kroz obrađivanje Velike američke pjesmarice kroz prizmu Franka Sinatre na tri albuma (od kojih je jedan čak trostruki!) pa sve do Nobelove nagrade i predavanja koje je imao održati prilikom njezina preuzimanja, premda pisac tvrdi da je zapravo njegovo pravo “nobelovsko predavanje” zapravo upisano u još uvijek aktualnom studijskom albumu “Rough and Rowdy Ways“.
(Kad bismo si dopustili jednu malu aktualnu digresiju, mogli bismo spomenuti i činjenicu da je Dylan upravo ovih dana pokrenuo i vlastiti Parteon na kojemu uz pomoć umjetne inteligencije stvara alternativnu verziju američke povijesti, pa bi možda bilo zanimljivo u nekom od eventualnih budućih izdanja ove knjige vidjeti Politovo objašnjenje kako se i ova bizarna crtica uklapa u širi Dylanov opus 21. stoljeća.)
Uza sve navedeno, autor povezuje i svoju vlastitu bolest koja ga je natjerala da se suoči sa smrtnošću s Dylanovom poodmaklom životnom dobi, kao što dodaje i poneku autobiografsku anegdotu koja njegov životni put na neki način spaja s onim njegovog predmeta interesa, pa to sve “After the Flood” čini mnogo osobnijom knjigom od onih kakve smo navikli čitati u žanru rock biografija.
Možda neki od tih dijelova neće biti jednako zanimljivi Bobovim fanovima kao ostatak sadržaja, dok će oni koji nisu slijepi sljedbenici svega vezanog za Dylana htjeti preskočiti opise različitih verzija pojedinih pjesama na nekim od posljednjih turneja, ali ovo putovanje kroz kasnu fazu rada vjerojatno najvećeg živućeg umjetnika u popularnoj glazbi svojim najvećim dijelom je jednako fascinantno koliko i iscrpno.
Za kraj, donekle je zanimljivo da je “After the Flood” izašao praktički istovremeno s knjigom “Lazarus” Alexandera Larmana koja se na sličan način bavi uskrsnućem Davida Bowieja u istoj dekadi te trasira njegov put do ponovnog uzdizanja u glazbeni panteon nakon razdoblja kreativne krize kasnih osamdesetih. Nešto više o tome mogli bismo možda reći u nekoj od narednih književnih recenzija na našem portalu.
Probably could only make sense to Dylanologists, making the case for Dylan's art since the 1990s. Draws upon research by Scott Warmuth and others on the many sources he draws upon in constructing his work, from Ovid to Timrod and many more.
I came for the promised "[imaginative] research" said to be "drawing on thousands of pages of archival materials" that this dylanologist insider accessed at the Tulsa archive. Instead, I was met early on with a pastiche of cut-and-pasted chunks from sources already familiar to any discerning Dylan fan--widely available biographies, interviews and magazine articles. To get to the promised insights drawn from the archives, I traversed pages filled with glaring errors that discredit many a reviewer's claims of academic or scholarly rigor in this volume. "Belmont Tench"? You mean BENMONT Tench of the Heartbreakers? And in 1991, George W. Bush was not president nor did he enter into a conflict with Iraq over Kuwait--you mean, George H. W. Bush, his father? And who was Clyde McFadder? You mean the singer Clyde MCPHATTER?
Here, I thought I'd pass on the book altogether when encountering these early on--as one Amazon reviewer claims to have done--but I skimmed/speedread ahead and did find some interesting, worthy analysis in the discussions about the albums Modern Times and Tempest, verging on Scott Warmuth territory, which hopefully will be the subject of its own book some day by Warmuth himself.
Otherwise, the book often reads like a bloated post on an Expecting Rain forum or a fan concert review on Bill Pagel's Bob Dates site. I enjoy reading those from time to time, in small doses, but I expected more from a book that promised far more than just one informed fan's opinions of what he likes or thinks of Dylan's work. Too many sentences with "I think," "I guess," or "my favorite song/concert/recording/etc. is probably..." for this book to be considered as serious academic work on Dylan. And the abecedarium chapter organization does not help, giving the book a very fragmented, scattershot feel that makes following the author's main thesis a difficult challenge, seemingly even to himself: one chapter begins—I kid you not—with the question "Where were we?" Exactly.
Organizing the chapters by alphabetical letters also creates so much repetition--how many descriptions and explanations of Theme Time Radio Hour can one Dylan fan take?--weighted down by so many long lists that occupy long paragraphs, some times pages: album track lists, concert dates, live playlists, recordings... One whole chapter is itself a list of quotes without commentary, including a quote by...ChatGPT. WTF. WTF, indeed...
I did find one sentence close to the end of the book that encapsulates many of my problems with it. It features the "I'm guessing" opinionated tone, repeats the word "already" (kind of ironic) and reveals there is no rigor here in the editing or proofreading. Here it goes, verbatim, from the U chapter: “Part of the snag in The Nobel Lecture, I’m guessing, is that he already had already delivered that retrospective address, touching on the legacies that informed his own creative practices, with his MusiCares speech the previous year. ”
Well, I'll tell you what. I've been a fan of Dylan since the '60's, have many of his albums, have seen him in concert twice, and agree that his "later phase" albums - Time Out of Mind, Love and Theft, Modern Times, and Rough and Rowdy Ways - are terrific (even though, sorry! By Rough and Rowdy Ways his voice is completely shot). I've also read Chronicles and The Philosophy of Modern Song. But I really wonder who on earth is SO into Dylan that he's going to parse every song, every lyric, every CONCERT, for goodness sake, the way it's done here. Page after page the author lists classic novelists, poets, and other musicians in a never-ending flood of words, words, words. Also, even though I consider myself reasonably literate, I ran across six or so words that I had to look up, and in almost every case (I'll give a pass for "abecedarium") there is a simpler word that would have done the trick just fine. Pretentious? Just a little! I don't know and I'll never know, but I suspect that Dylan himself would roll his eyes a time or two here. This reminds me more than a little of A. J. Weberman, who thought he could unlock the "secret" of Dylan by rummaging through his garbage. Why don't we just enjoy the mystery a little?
This book covers Dylan’s oeuvre from the 1990s until today, but don’t expect a history or biography. This hits the highlights during that time—the albums, the tours, Chronicles, Theme Time Radio, the Nobel Prize—but you’re not given a lot of biographical context or narrative structure. (Not a criticism, but noting it for people expecting a different sort of book!)
Instead, Polito gives facts, quotes (by/about Dylan; about other related cultural things), and contextual information (Shakespeare, Ovid, Henry Timrod, Orson Welles). Polito also occasionally places himself in the book—Dylan concerts he was at, and some less directly related anecdotes. Apart from the times he was talking about himself visiting the Dylan archive in Tulsa, I didn’t find the autobiographical details necessary, but nor did I find them off-putting.
The research for this book is phenomenal. In addition to all the facts and quotes, Polito uses that research (or sometimes maybe just his own innate knowledge) to provide close readings of Dylan’s lyrics. People who enjoy the study of literature will appreciate seeing some of those allusions and cribbings laid bare.
Not the book I expected, but a worthwhile read nevertheless.
Thank you, Liveright Publishing and Goodreads for the advance copy.
AFTER THE FLOOD is well-researched and crammed with information about the second half of Bob Dylan’s career. I welcomed the view into a legendary artist’s later life—how often do we focus on only the beginnings? However, I think the book was attempting a bit too much. The abcedarian structure left me disoriented at times. The author occasionally veered into his personal experiences, which I enjoyed, but it was rare enough that it felt a bit random when the vignettes came up. Maybe someone who is better-versed in Dylan lore would love this full immersion, but for me, as a newcomer, it was too much of a firehose.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
I'm not going to lie: the abecedarium and memory palace elements here don't really hold together the entire book as far as structures go. But come on. I'm not giving a book that has fun tidbits about post-1991 Bob less than five stars. My favorite bits both come from an interview with Mikal Gilmore in Rolling Stone: one is when Gilmore asks Bob if naming his album Tempest is a swan-song thing, since The Tempest was Shakespeare's last play, and Bob points out that Tempest and The Tempest are different titles; and the other is when Gilmore asks him about lifting lines from the drippy, pro-Confederacy poet Henry Timrod, Bob says something like, I'd like to see anybody else write songs that rip off Henry Timrod and see where that gets them.
This intensely detailed overview of the most recent 35 years of Bob Dylan's career is chock full of literary attributions and references to individual song performances out of the thousands of concerts the man played over that period. Familiarity with both may be the best way to appreciate this work. Personally, I was surprised the author didn't mention the obvious (to me, anyway) precursor of "Matty Groves" in "Tin Angel", and while the personal details, such as the author's illness during the writing of the book, are unnecessary for a biography, they were minimal. (Thanks to NetGalley for the advance proof.)
I’m a big fan of Mr Polito’s Jim Thompson book, and now this one as well. Uncle Bob played 3,000 concerts between 1991 and 2024 (!)* and this book concentrates on that time frame, analyzing and reviewing recordings and concerts from that era. The subtitle (“Memory Palace”) is apt, as a couple of people mention Dylan as having an astonishing, even freakish memory. Somehow not surprising.
Mr Polito does an astonishing job himself, finding Homer, Ovid and Roman history elements in the more recent recordings. The reader puzzling over extensive War of 1812 references in “Tempest” might feel he’s stayed a little too long at the party. When a reviewer asks Bob if “Tempest” is a reference to the Shakespeare play, he replies, “No, that was ‘THE Tempest.’ Totally different.” Good old Bob.
Concert song analysis are abundant, sincere, and quite good. Jim Thompson and Bob Dylan. That’s the good stuff, right there. Well done.
————— *The Grateful Dead are generally credited with 2,350 and The Rolling Stones claimed 2,000 in 2006.
This is the best book on Bob Dylan written by anyone in the 21st century. The concept is novel: It focuses entirely on his output since he won the Grammy Lifetime Achievement award in 1991 (i.e., the point where most other Dylan books are beginning to wind up). It is also the first book to take the kind of research done by the likes of Scott Warmuth, which assiduously tracks the relentless use of references and quotations in Dylan's recent work (not only in his songs but in his memoir Chronicles and in the screenplay for Masked and Anonymous), and use it as a jumping off point for substantial analysis. I loved every page.
I once heard that Bob Dylan is for "pretentious people." As a fan, I was offended by this. After reading this book I see why people might get that impression. At times the book was a slog and the author seems more interested in the parallels in his life to Dylan's than focusing on his subject. Still, there are lots of interesting tidbits from the last 30 years, things I didn't know. There were chapters on faith, the writing process, touring, piano vs. guitar, the plagiarism controversy and much more. If you enjoyed the last 6 original albums and want to learn more about them, you will probably enjoy this book.
An insanely well-researched, comprehensive deep dive into Bob Dylan’s memory palace and his journey as an artist over the last 30 or so years. I enjoyed this very much and could tell just how much effort and care were put into this. I think it’s a tall task for anyone to confine Bob to words or pages, but Polito does a great job acknowledging Bob’s mysterious, ever-changing, singular ways, and how his reinvention as an artist resulted from who he was at his core: an archivist and a performer.
I hardly need convincing that Dylan’s latter-day albums and activities (here including everything from 1991 onward, though with basically no mention of Together Through Life) are as compelling and as rich as anything he did during his first act. It’s good to see this period receive the critical analysis it deserves, and stimulating to consider how Dylan has reinvented himself by leveraging personal and cultural memory. This book can sometimes circle around its point, and I wish it offered a more linear and precise argument, but it’s still a deeply rewarding survey.
Polito provides a talmudic examination of Dylan's expansive career since 1991 in abecedarian sequence. It’s not for the casual fan or even a curious fan. This is a serious study of Dylan’s wonderful and remarkable second 30 years in show business. It will certainly be quoted in the myriad biographies to come, which might’ve been on Polito’s mind as he sneaks in some biography of his own to coattails Dylan into eternity
For the most part, I found After the Flood fascinating, especially learning about Dylan's collage writing style (mixing blues, folk, classic literature like Ovid & the Bible), Modern Times, Tempest, & Rough & Rowdy Ways. I lost interest around page 230 in the "Almost Like Folk Music" chapter, which talked about his Sinatra albums: Shadows in the Night, Fallen Angels, & Triplicate. The book barely mentions Together Through Life.
An entertaining breakdown of Bob Dylan’s last 30 years, that I enjoyed, even if it didn’t offer too much new to me. I was hoping to come away with an appreciation for why this period of Dylan matters, but it was good to reminisce still.
Highlights were the deep dives into the classical and literary references.
This book focuses on Dylan's career after Time Out of Mind. I don't know if we have enough contextualizing information to really write about this period in the same way Elijah Wald writes about those early years in Dylan Went Electric. But I'm glad people are beginning to write about this period as it has some great stuff in it.
Gave me more appreciation for Bob Dylan's later work (1990s - present). The author presents the topics in the form of an abecedary and jumps around from topic to topic. I found it easier to read it as short essays rather than a straight forward narrative nonfiction account.
It's always good to get a refresher course on Bobby D, but I had thought this was more of a look at his past 30 years but author dude pulls you right back to the start. Good trip down memory lane.