Justice Ahmadi was on the five member bench that had been constitut3ed to look into the constitutional validity of the Ayodhya Act. Tremendous pressure was brought on him to rule in favour of the Government, but as his biographer (and granddaughter), Insiyah Vahanvaty, notes “But, in the depths of his being, (Justice Ahmadi) realized the truth. This wasn’t a choice; it was a litmus test. In a test of integrity and ideals, there really was no option.” Justice Ahmadi passed that test, but one is left, wondering how many others will perform as well in a similar test. During his long and illustrious tenure as a judge, Justice Ahmadi was a part of several landmark judgements which continue to be quoted even today. This biography not only describes the rulings, but goes into the thought process behind them, making it a treasure trove for anyone interested in the Indian legal system. The author uses his unfinished autobiography as the primary source of material, and supplements it with interviews with people close to him, which ensures a well rounded and intimate portrait of the man. This book will appeal to anybody who is either interested in the legal profession or who cares to understand the principles on which the country was founded and the many challenges that the nation has faced. This book is an intimate portrait of Justice Ahmadi and will interest people who would like to read about, a man who began life without much backing yet was able to make it to the pinnacle of his career based on strong values, hard work and the courage of conviction. A more detailed review here: https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2024/10/...
The book tells the inspiring story of Justice Aziz Mushabber Ahmadi, a key figure in India's judiciary. Written from the perspective of his granddaughter, this biography highlights Ahmadi’s unwavering commitment to justice and the Constitution during his tenure as Chief Justice of India from 1994 to 1997.
Ahmadi is portrayed as a “Citizen’s Judge,” known for his fair approach and dedication to protecting fundamental rights. His journey from local courts in Ahmedabad to the highest level of the Indian judiciary showcases his perseverance and influence. He made significant contributions to important cases, like Bommai and Indira Sawhney, which addressed vital issues in Indian law.
One notable aspect of the book is Ahmadi's dissents, where he often disagreed with mainstream opinions. His willingness to challenge government power over controversial issues demonstrates his courage and integrity. The author combines personal stories, family memories, and Ahmadi’s own words, giving readers a deeper understanding of his character.
Overall, it is an engaging tribute to a man who stood up for justice, making it a must-read for anyone interested in Indian law and social justice.