A Fun Romp, But It Falls Short of Its Initial Promise
For me this started out laugh-out-loud funny. The beginning was almost like a reprise of the Christmas Carol. I mean, (real life best selling science fiction author) Hugh Howey, who is now a zombie who eats books, is visited by Kurt Vonnegut. Bombo Dawson, accidental best selling writer, fat man, and doughnut eater extraordinaire gets a visit from Tolstoy, who praises his work. Alistair Foley, a snippy creative writing teacher who gives Bombo his only one star review on Amazon and has never published his novel, gets a visit from a dolorous Thornton Wilder, who tells him his novel still needs work. Thus, the novel gets off to a promising start.
All of these writers have gotten visits from "ghost writers" (haha---dead famous authors) begging their help to save the Legendarium, a sort of metaphysical library that is a repository of stories--famous and unknown, published and lost. The Legendarium is failing and needs help.
Howey, now a zombie (apparently he fought off a zombie apocalypse in a previous book I didn't read called "Hugh Howey Must Die"), is chained to his desk to keep from destroying everything around him. He begs off, as he is not in a position to help.
Dawson and Foley reluctantly agree to go on this journey. Dawson temporarily takes leave of his wife, Carol, whom he describes as "Communist, vegetarian, and smoking hot" to go on this quest. Foley, who teaches creative writing at a community college is worried about missing his next class, but Wilder assure him that time in the Legendarium takes up no time in the "real world".
Dawson, and Foley, predictably, loath each other from the second they meet and are at each others' throats the whole time they journey through the Legendarium. They agree on almost nothing. Foley works out and puts down Dawson for being fat and out of shape, and constantly complaining that he's hungry and wants doughnuts and a cigar. Dawson snarks about Alistair's pony tail. They can barely agree about literature also. Dawson hates fantasy, likes Hemingway, Tolkien, and Lewis Carol. Foley hates Hemingway, but likes Hugh Howey, JK Rowling, and science fiction. Foley despises Lewis Carol. Foley sneers at self-publishing. Dawson, of course, is a self-published author. They are astonished when they find they both like "Moby Dick". But, in spite of it all, they reluctantly learn to respect each other. Foley considers deleting his bad review of Dawson's book; Dawson advises Foley to publish his novel.
I thought their actual trip through the Legendarium fell a bit short of the initial promise of the book. The rest of the book wasn't quite as funny as the beginning. Also I found the literary pastiche didn't quite cohere.
Tolstoy pushes them through the trap door to the Legendarium and the first place they end up is Wonderland. (I love Lewis Carol and found the Wonderland depicted here to be a bit pallid).
A knight--possibly the White Knight from "Through the Looking Glass" but it's not clear-- wants to kill the Jabberwock, but he's lost the Vorpal sword (as the Cheshire cat informs our heroes). And apparently the evil Mimsy Borogroves are causing problems everywhere.
Our heroes end up on a space ship called the Alamo-2 from a story called "Beyond the Stars" (????) by fictious African American author Russell Benjamin, that supposedly inspired Martin Luther King to become president in an alternate reality. Captain Haley dies, because they have failed to bring back plants to save him (which was supposed to have been their mission). The Mimsy Borogroves show up disguised as evil Martians and destroy the ship.
They are then transported to the Prohibition Era and end up in a "lost" Hemingway story called "The Pugilist". Foley interferes with the story line (realizing too late that their mission is to keep the story intact). The original story was that the pugilist, Jack, bet his competitor Daniel a night with his girlfriend, Agnes, a beautiful woman, if he loses the boxing match. He loses and hangs himself. However, Foley persuades Agnes to ditch Jack (which wasn't supposed to happen as it wasn't in the original story). So they fail again.
Finally, they end up in "Moby Dick" on the Pequod, while Ahab battles the White Whale. Amazingly, both Dawson and Foley love "Moby Dick" and they finally realize their mission is to keep the story line intact (the degradation of the Legendarium means the stories are falling apart). They retrieve the Vorpal sword (it's stuck into Moby Dick's side) and save the Legendarium. Both men return to their lives.
Anyway, I found the part of the story that took place in the Legendarium somewhat less engaging than the beginning of the tale. The versions of Wonderland and the Pequod were a little pallid compared to the original stories.
Still this is a fun, engaging, and refreshing story, in spite of its flaws.
The battle between Dawson and Foley keeps things interesting.