What do you think?
Rate this book
All's Fair #2
Fair Play
Fifty years ago, Roland Mills belonged to a violent activist group. Now, someone is willing to kill to prevent him from publishing his memoirs.
When ex-FBI agent Elliot Mills is called out to examine the charred ruins of his childhood home, he quickly identifies the fire for what it is--arson. A knee injury may have forced Elliot out of the Bureau, but it's not going to stop him from bringing the man who wants his father dead to justice.
Agent Tucker Lance is still working to find the serial killer who's obsessed with Elliot and can't bear the thought of his lover putting himself in additional danger. Straightlaced Tucker has never agreed with radical Roland on much--"opposing political viewpoints" is an understatement--but they're united on this: Elliot needs to leave the case alone. Now.
Tucker would do nearly anything for the man he loves, but he won't be used to gain Elliot access to the FBI's resources. When the past comes back to play and everything both men had known to be true is questioned, their fragile relationship is left hanging in the balance.
68,000 words
When ex-FBI agent Elliot Mills is called out to examine the charred ruins of his childhood home, he quickly identifies the fire for what it is--arson. A knee injury may have forced Elliot out of the Bureau, but it's not going to stop him from bringing the man who wants his father dead to justice.
Agent Tucker Lance is still working to find the serial killer who's obsessed with Elliot and can't bear the thought of his lover putting himself in additional danger. Straightlaced Tucker has never agreed with radical Roland on much--"opposing political viewpoints" is an understatement--but they're united on this: Elliot needs to leave the case alone. Now.
Tucker would do nearly anything for the man he loves, but he won't be used to gain Elliot access to the FBI's resources. When the past comes back to play and everything both men had known to be true is questioned, their fragile relationship is left hanging in the balance.
68,000 words
217 pages, Kindle Edition
First published November 10, 2014
89 people are currently reading
1025 people want to read
About the author
Josh Lanyon
223 books5,418 followersAuthor of 100+ titles of Gay Mystery and M/M Romance, Josh Lanyon has built her literary legacy on twisty mystery, kickass adventure, and unapologetic man-on-man romance.
Her work has been translated into twelve languages. The FBI thriller Fair Game was the first Male/Male title to be published by Italy’s Harlequin Mondadori and Stranger on the Shore (Harper Collins Italia) was the first M/M title to be published in print. In 2016 Fatal Shadows placed #5 in Japan’s annual Boy Love novel list (the first and only title by a foreign author to place on the list). The Adrien English series was awarded the All-Time Favorite Couple by the Goodreads M/M Romance Group. In 2019, Fatal Shadows became the first LGBTQ mobile game created by Moments: Choose Your Story.
She’s an EPIC Award winner, a four-time Lambda Literary Award finalist (twice for Gay Mystery), an Edgar nominee, and the first ever recipient of the Goodreads All Time Favorite M/M Author award.
Josh is married and lives in Southern California with her irascible husband, two adorable dogs, a small garden, and an ever-expanding library of vintage mystery destined to eventually crush them all beneath its weight.
Find other Josh Lanyon titles at www.joshlanyon.com
Follow Josh on Twitter, Facebook, and Goodreads.
Her work has been translated into twelve languages. The FBI thriller Fair Game was the first Male/Male title to be published by Italy’s Harlequin Mondadori and Stranger on the Shore (Harper Collins Italia) was the first M/M title to be published in print. In 2016 Fatal Shadows placed #5 in Japan’s annual Boy Love novel list (the first and only title by a foreign author to place on the list). The Adrien English series was awarded the All-Time Favorite Couple by the Goodreads M/M Romance Group. In 2019, Fatal Shadows became the first LGBTQ mobile game created by Moments: Choose Your Story.
She’s an EPIC Award winner, a four-time Lambda Literary Award finalist (twice for Gay Mystery), an Edgar nominee, and the first ever recipient of the Goodreads All Time Favorite M/M Author award.
Josh is married and lives in Southern California with her irascible husband, two adorable dogs, a small garden, and an ever-expanding library of vintage mystery destined to eventually crush them all beneath its weight.
Find other Josh Lanyon titles at www.joshlanyon.com
Follow Josh on Twitter, Facebook, and Goodreads.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 476 reviews
October 23, 2014
4 stars. Full review posted October 23, 2014
Elliot and Tucker have been living together on Goose Island for the last six months. They truly love each other and while they seem to have settled down, their relationship is still somewhat fragile. When they receive a phone call at 3 am with the frightening news that Elliot's father's house has been burned down, the upcoming investigation will be the cause of an unexpected stress test for their relationship.
Professor Roland Mills is the former leader of the Collective, an antiwar movement founded in the 60s. When Roland decided to publish his memoirs, someone started to threaten him. The threats culminate in attempted murder. It goes without saying that Elliot is concerned and fears for his father's life. Yet Roland isn't very cooperative. When he Elliot--under the watchful eye of Tucker--is more than ready to dig around in his father's intricate past to expose the perpetrator.
As hoped for, Fair Play turned out to be a worthy sequel to Fair Game. I'm quite obviously content with the outcome and did enjoy it very much.
What I especially dig about Elliot and Tucker's relationship is their dynamics. Tucker is the alpha with a capital A--in and out of the bedroom. And while Elliot practically craves to submit to Tucker between the sheets, he's quite alpha in other matters of the daily life and on the job. Meaning, when two powerful, obstinate and strong-willed alpha men must try to get along and compromise, it's bound to be difficult once in a while. And we all know that inconsiderate words can hurt. Fact was, Roland's case was at the root of Tucker and Elliot's collision course and did complicate their relationship. I really 'liked' to see them argue even more so because at its basis was something very profound: the urge to protect your better half. These two men foster a deep affection and love for each other. Yet sometimes it's hard to make yourself intelligible and it's even harder to back off. Though there were a couple meaningful and sensitive moments that I cherished very much. How could anyone resist and not melt in the face of a manly yet very affectionate embrace that offered so much support and comfort all at once? I love my men to be men, though not afraid to show affection and tenderness. And these two guys have exactly that in spades.
When you pick up a book written by Josh Lanyon you can always rely on one thing: very good writing. In that regard, he always delivers, be it a great or inferior read. I can't help and marvel at his ability to create very atmospheric and sensual moments. In Fair Play, I especially enjoyed his descriptions of rainy scenes or, of course, the very alluring smexy times. My favorite scene took place around the 70 % mark. It was spicy to boot and incredibly enticing. Tucker oozed dominance as all get out and, fact is, when two guys are worked up and a bit angry, the sex is even better and serves as a valve to let off steam. This scene made my girly bits tingle, for sure. It was hot as f@ck.
The story, which was paced somewhat slowly, provided a perfect development of the interesting plot. Though rather heavy on the investigative work without much action, it was engaging at any given moment and, as usual, a fascinating cast of secondary characters was the icing on yet another delicious cake freshly served by Josh Lanyon, the gifted storyteller. From the very beginning until the last page, I felt totally immersed and emotionally engaged in the riveting tale as well as Elliot and Tucker's challenging yet beautiful romance. Everything unfolded in front of my eyes to my satisfaction.
Recommended read.
All quotes are taken from the pre-published copy and may be altered or omitted in the final copy.
**ARC courtesy of Carina Press via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review**
Official release date: November 10th, 2014
Elliot and Tucker have been living together on Goose Island for the last six months. They truly love each other and while they seem to have settled down, their relationship is still somewhat fragile. When they receive a phone call at 3 am with the frightening news that Elliot's father's house has been burned down, the upcoming investigation will be the cause of an unexpected stress test for their relationship.
Professor Roland Mills is the former leader of the Collective, an antiwar movement founded in the 60s. When Roland decided to publish his memoirs, someone started to threaten him. The threats culminate in attempted murder. It goes without saying that Elliot is concerned and fears for his father's life. Yet Roland isn't very cooperative. When he Elliot--under the watchful eye of Tucker--is more than ready to dig around in his father's intricate past to expose the perpetrator.
As hoped for, Fair Play turned out to be a worthy sequel to Fair Game. I'm quite obviously content with the outcome and did enjoy it very much.
What I especially dig about Elliot and Tucker's relationship is their dynamics. Tucker is the alpha with a capital A--in and out of the bedroom. And while Elliot practically craves to submit to Tucker between the sheets, he's quite alpha in other matters of the daily life and on the job. Meaning, when two powerful, obstinate and strong-willed alpha men must try to get along and compromise, it's bound to be difficult once in a while. And we all know that inconsiderate words can hurt. Fact was, Roland's case was at the root of Tucker and Elliot's collision course and did complicate their relationship. I really 'liked' to see them argue even more so because at its basis was something very profound: the urge to protect your better half. These two men foster a deep affection and love for each other. Yet sometimes it's hard to make yourself intelligible and it's even harder to back off. Though there were a couple meaningful and sensitive moments that I cherished very much. How could anyone resist and not melt in the face of a manly yet very affectionate embrace that offered so much support and comfort all at once? I love my men to be men, though not afraid to show affection and tenderness. And these two guys have exactly that in spades.
A muscle moved in Tucker's jaw. He said, I breathe better when you're close by."
The stark honesty of it felt like an arrow to the heart. How the hell could Tucker say things like that?
When you pick up a book written by Josh Lanyon you can always rely on one thing: very good writing. In that regard, he always delivers, be it a great or inferior read. I can't help and marvel at his ability to create very atmospheric and sensual moments. In Fair Play, I especially enjoyed his descriptions of rainy scenes or, of course, the very alluring smexy times. My favorite scene took place around the 70 % mark. It was spicy to boot and incredibly enticing. Tucker oozed dominance as all get out and, fact is, when two guys are worked up and a bit angry, the sex is even better and serves as a valve to let off steam. This scene made my girly bits tingle, for sure. It was hot as f@ck.
But there was no easing up in that all powerful body hug. Instead Tucker rested his head in the curve of Elliot's shoulder, his cheek pressed to Elliot's. He could feel the flicker of Tucker's eyelashes. Smell the ghost of his aftershave. Feel the bristle on his jaw. Feel his throat move every time he swallowed.
(…)
But all at once it occurred to him what Tucker was telling him, showing him. Safety. Protection. Support. Whatever Elliot needed from Tucker. But most of all, Dominance.
The story, which was paced somewhat slowly, provided a perfect development of the interesting plot. Though rather heavy on the investigative work without much action, it was engaging at any given moment and, as usual, a fascinating cast of secondary characters was the icing on yet another delicious cake freshly served by Josh Lanyon, the gifted storyteller. From the very beginning until the last page, I felt totally immersed and emotionally engaged in the riveting tale as well as Elliot and Tucker's challenging yet beautiful romance. Everything unfolded in front of my eyes to my satisfaction.
Recommended read.
All quotes are taken from the pre-published copy and may be altered or omitted in the final copy.
**ARC courtesy of Carina Press via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review**
Official release date: November 10th, 2014
February 19, 2022
3.5 stars
I agree with all my friends who love Tucker. He is wonderful, while Elliot is the one who occasionally deserves a frying pan in the head, even though he thinks otherwise. But I love them as a couple. I really like the dynamics between them, even when they disagree on something.
The mystery part was really good in the sense that I had no idea where it was going and it was interesting to witness it unfold. But I can't say that I was as engaged in that part of the story as I was in book 1. It's just my personal preference, since I'm not that interested in reading about political activist groups.
I was a bit underwhelmed by the final reveal, though. Looking back at the story, it feels a bit far-fetched. Also, I didn't understand all Roland's actions and why he couldn't have just talked to Elliot.
I agree with all my friends who love Tucker. He is wonderful, while Elliot is the one who occasionally deserves a frying pan in the head, even though he thinks otherwise. But I love them as a couple. I really like the dynamics between them, even when they disagree on something.
The mystery part was really good in the sense that I had no idea where it was going and it was interesting to witness it unfold. But I can't say that I was as engaged in that part of the story as I was in book 1. It's just my personal preference, since I'm not that interested in reading about political activist groups.
I was a bit underwhelmed by the final reveal, though. Looking back at the story, it feels a bit far-fetched. Also, I didn't understand all Roland's actions and why he couldn't have just talked to Elliot.
September 17, 2016
Written November 24, 2014
4.3 Stars - What's not to like? Nothing!
I'm still happy smiling
Book #2
Mr. Lanyon has done it again. He has convinced me that his books almost always are for me.
Yay, I got exactly what I expected
A good crime drama with two lovely manly men who have male problems and are talking men's language. ~ Jackpot, I'm happy!
***********************************************
Fair Playis the second book were we meet the former FBI agent and now College Professor, Elliot Mills and his lover, the FBI agent at the Seattle Division, Tucker Lance. They live together in Elliot's house on the island now. They say it, they show it and they agree that they love each other. (Thanksgod for that!!!) ...But that doesn't mean that everything is free from trouble all days.
I liked the first one, #1 - Fair Game (4.5 stars), in this series. It was actually my first Josh Lanyon novel back in February this year.
...Twenty-three JL books later (incl. some novellas - see my Lanyon shelf) was it with great anticipation that I began reading this just published new second part.
***********************************************
The crime plot this time has to do with events and stuff that happened years ago when Elliot's famous older father, Professor Roland Mills, a high-profile leftist writing his memoirs, was a young man. He was then, and still is, a man who wanted to change the world. A young political (red) hippie "fighter" —for peace and against war (Vietnam)— in the 60:s and 70:s.
It all starts on page one with an big fire. An arson fire in Elliot's older fathers house. So begins also a rapidly speeding interesting crime-story with twists, light action and surprises. I liked the storyline, the (history) plot and Elliot's crime investigation. Big plus for the plot in this part.
I must admit that I liked old 'Rollie'...a lot
The older Professor Mills is my kind of intelligent conscious older man. A man who cooks good food, still belive in great values and never stop to care (a lot) about his old friends, his loved son and to talk about important political justice issues. Just a lot of plus points to that character from this lady.
***********************************************
Most of all was this —luckily— a great second part about Elliot and Tucker and their new life as lovers and life-partners.
An after the book #1 HEA sequel, were we meet them and their everydays struggles a time after the first book ended. There are big feelings, grand love, questions about trust and steamy hot sex.
Lovely, lovely guys.
The heat and the feeling between Elliot and Tucker are described so well. Their relative roles between each other, their sex, dominance and submission, the intricate emotional game, their sometimes difficult emotions...etc. Everything feels so authentic and natural.
Tucker is from now on one of my favorite JL darlings.
A huge tough redhead. A big strong alpha male. A man who just wants to be loved and to get the chance to love (Elliot). Aawww that's so ... yummy!!
***********************************************
Looking forward to book #3. ??? ~ Yes really!! It will be more, JL himself talks about a trilogy (see here)
I LIKE - great storyline and great MC's
******
A worldwide BR with Rosa, Irina, Stas, Sofia and me.
4.3 Stars - What's not to like? Nothing!
I'm still happy smiling
Book #2
Mr. Lanyon has done it again. He has convinced me that his books almost always are for me.
Yay, I got exactly what I expected
A good crime drama with two lovely manly men who have male problems and are talking men's language. ~ Jackpot, I'm happy!
***********************************************
...on Goose Island (aka the real Anderson Island)
near Seattle, Washington State, U.S.
Fair Playis the second book were we meet the former FBI agent and now College Professor, Elliot Mills and his lover, the FBI agent at the Seattle Division, Tucker Lance. They live together in Elliot's house on the island now. They say it, they show it and they agree that they love each other. (Thanksgod for that!!!) ...But that doesn't mean that everything is free from trouble all days.
I liked the first one, #1 - Fair Game (4.5 stars), in this series. It was actually my first Josh Lanyon novel back in February this year.
...Twenty-three JL books later (incl. some novellas - see my Lanyon shelf) was it with great anticipation that I began reading this just published new second part.
***********************************************
The crime plot this time has to do with events and stuff that happened years ago when Elliot's famous older father, Professor Roland Mills, a high-profile leftist writing his memoirs, was a young man. He was then, and still is, a man who wanted to change the world. A young political (red) hippie "fighter" —for peace and against war (Vietnam)— in the 60:s and 70:s.
It all starts on page one with an big fire. An arson fire in Elliot's older fathers house. So begins also a rapidly speeding interesting crime-story with twists, light action and surprises. I liked the storyline, the (history) plot and Elliot's crime investigation. Big plus for the plot in this part.
I must admit that I liked old 'Rollie'...a lot
The older Professor Mills is my kind of intelligent conscious older man. A man who cooks good food, still belive in great values and never stop to care (a lot) about his old friends, his loved son and to talk about important political justice issues. Just a lot of plus points to that character from this lady.
“...one thing that stays with me, moves me, I guess, is how sincerely these kids believed they could change the world. They really believed that anything was possible. Thats everything was possible.”
“All you need is love”,...
***********************************************
Most of all was this —luckily— a great second part about Elliot and Tucker and their new life as lovers and life-partners.
An after the book #1 HEA sequel, were we meet them and their everydays struggles a time after the first book ended. There are big feelings, grand love, questions about trust and steamy hot sex.
Lovely, lovely guys.
The heat and the feeling between Elliot and Tucker are described so well. Their relative roles between each other, their sex, dominance and submission, the intricate emotional game, their sometimes difficult emotions...etc. Everything feels so authentic and natural.
“You mean you want breathing space. I breath better when you're close by.”
The stark honesty of it felt like an arrow to the heart. How the hell could Tucker say things like that? Elliots throat closed.’
Tucker is from now on one of my favorite JL darlings.
A huge tough redhead. A big strong alpha male. A man who just wants to be loved and to get the chance to love (Elliot). Aawww that's so ... yummy!!
***********************************************
Looking forward to book #3. ??? ~ Yes really!! It will be more, JL himself talks about a trilogy (see here)
I LIKE - great storyline and great MC's
******
A worldwide BR with Rosa, Irina, Stas, Sofia and me.
October 21, 2014
I love me some Lanyon. But I REALLY love me some Lanyon's Elliot and Tucker.
I think we all have our favorite Josh Lanyon books and couple. The world would probably say Jake and Adrian. But me? Elliot and Tucker. Fair Game was one of my favorites and their hard-fought road just to get to a happy-for-now...shouldn't have worked for me. But it so did. (also, if you're an audiobook type, you really should listen to book 1, Fair Game. I quite enjoyed the narrator, Ray Ramano)
I wasn't sure if Lanyon would come out with a book 2 but I almost sobbed tears of joy when I heard it was being released.
WHAT A TREAT. I loved it! Elliot and Tucker in this book were PERFECTION. Their relationship growth, with real life adult challenges and heavy emotion, yet with deep commitment and actual communication? YES! So few books actually have 2 grown men TALK to each other and FIGURE things out. And I couldn't get enough of the two of them. I hadn't realized how much I missed their friendship, their partnership, and what revealed itself so thoroughly in book 2, their love. It wasn't all roses for them. The battle of who can be more stubborn and sometimes over who can be more self-righteous reached epic proportions. But, the affection and the eventual compromises and just the honesty had me swooning.
I have to admit that the mystery element to the story, didn't entirely work for me. But that doesn't mean it wasn't really fascinating. It was just very detailed and I was sometimes lost in the side characters...who was who and was with who. And sometimes when side characters play too prominently in a story, I get a little irritated. I felt this way about Elliot's dad, to be frank. And because I was SO loving the Elliot & Tucker parts, the mystery stuff was a distraction (I'm a bratty reader, I know.)
Still, I didn't want the book to end. And I'm hoping Lanyon will be doing more Christmas Codas this year and we'll see another little scene out of Elliot & Tucker's life together. *sigh*. I just...want more of them.
If you haven't read Fair Game, do so immediately so you can jump right into Fair Play.
If you have read Fair Game, Fair Play is a FREAKING FEAST! Enjoy it!
July 11, 2018
To: R, Shile, and Simone, you ladies did not lie. It did get better!!
Not only did JF Harding do a better job narrating (which amazed me because I was fine with Sawyer Allerde’s narration), but the romance didn’t feel secondary in this installment. The romance being secondary in book 1 was easily forgiven because Josh Lanyon kept me so focused on the mystery, I didn’t feel cheated.
Anyway, book 2 *sigh* Tucker, Tucker, Tucker…OMG!! Even without his POV, the man stole my heart. The way he expresses his love for Elliot had me swooning. Simply beautiful. Elliot isn't as forthcoming with his affections, but he seemed to be getting there.
Like all relationships, these guys had their tiffs. How could they not?? Life gets stressful for an FBI agent and a former FBI agent turned Professor. Even though Elliot is no longer with the FBI, when he gets on a case he is like a dog with a bone. He is incredibly stubborn and persistent. And Tucker is so protective of him. Again, *sigh*…
The case in book 2 involves Elliot’s dad. Someone is out to stop him from publishing his memoirs. Again, JL proved to be the master of mystery story telling. Seriously, I don’t bother trying to guess anymore. It’s pointless. I just sit back and enjoy….
Not only did JF Harding do a better job narrating (which amazed me because I was fine with Sawyer Allerde’s narration), but the romance didn’t feel secondary in this installment. The romance being secondary in book 1 was easily forgiven because Josh Lanyon kept me so focused on the mystery, I didn’t feel cheated.
Anyway, book 2 *sigh* Tucker, Tucker, Tucker…OMG!! Even without his POV, the man stole my heart. The way he expresses his love for Elliot had me swooning. Simply beautiful. Elliot isn't as forthcoming with his affections, but he seemed to be getting there.
Like all relationships, these guys had their tiffs. How could they not?? Life gets stressful for an FBI agent and a former FBI agent turned Professor. Even though Elliot is no longer with the FBI, when he gets on a case he is like a dog with a bone. He is incredibly stubborn and persistent. And Tucker is so protective of him. Again, *sigh*…
The case in book 2 involves Elliot’s dad. Someone is out to stop him from publishing his memoirs. Again, JL proved to be the master of mystery story telling. Seriously, I don’t bother trying to guess anymore. It’s pointless. I just sit back and enjoy….
March 1, 2020
I should start off by saying I loved the narration and the romance part of this story, both of which are a strong 5 star. What I didn't like was the story itself. Elliot looking into a 60's radical group that his father was head of and trying to find out who is out to kill his father. Honestly, I did get bored and my mind wandered a few times. Thankfully, J.F. Harding's voice kept me going. Plus, I loved Elliot and Tucker together, in fact, I liked Tucker more in this one than I did Elliot. I don't know how many times I wanted to smack Elliot upside his head.
I am going to take a break before I jump into book 3, I have a feeling it will be intense.,
I am going to take a break before I jump into book 3, I have a feeling it will be intense.,
April 18, 2017
5 shiny stars just for Tucker.
I enjoyed this. The mystery was just right for me, but what got my heart racing was the romance part and Tucker, he is officially my book boyfriend. Tucker is all Alpha and really romantic. His love for Elliot is epic, he truly loves him and it shows through the pages. I do love Elliot but at some point I wanted to smack him and make him realize he had Tucker’s love..it was his to lose.
“Tucker said so softly the words were almost inaudible, "You're wrong, you know. I would let you get away with murder. Hell, I'd probably help you commit it, if that's what you wanted...”
Aww Tucker..
“Some guys say it with flowers,” Tucker said. “I bring you arson reports.”
I Loved it
I enjoyed this. The mystery was just right for me, but what got my heart racing was the romance part and Tucker, he is officially my book boyfriend. Tucker is all Alpha and really romantic. His love for Elliot is epic, he truly loves him and it shows through the pages. I do love Elliot but at some point I wanted to smack him and make him realize he had Tucker’s love..it was his to lose.
“Tucker said so softly the words were almost inaudible, "You're wrong, you know. I would let you get away with murder. Hell, I'd probably help you commit it, if that's what you wanted...”
Aww Tucker..
“Some guys say it with flowers,” Tucker said. “I bring you arson reports.”
I Loved it
July 30, 2017
5 unexpected stars - What did I just read?! - This book was great!
"A muscle moved in Tucker's jaw. "You mean you want breathing space. I breath better when you're close by."
I've read this book in one sitting and mostly on the edge of my seat.
I enjoyed it much more than the first book, Fair Game. To be honest I had a very hard time getting back to this series, even if I already had the second and third books. I was pretty disappointed in the first one. I couldn't find the magic everybody saw. Maybe I wasn't in a good mood back then. Anyway, when I got back to this one, I wasn't really hooked from the start, but I kept reading and I got completely hooked by all that mystery! I can't believe I suspected each and every one of them! I had some crazy thoughts. The suspense was killing me!
I ended loving Elliot and Tucker so much. These two hot men have something special. They are still adjusting to being together and their lives are as far from the ordinary as they can get! Tucker is an FBI agent, and Elliot is a former agent who was injured and chose to retire and be an Uni history teacher. But his life isn't boring at all. On the contrary. Arrows, traveling to Canada, digging his father's past something fierce. Boy my head was spinning!
Elliot never gave up and wanted to protect his father with all costs. He surprised me. And I have to admit I really understood his point regarding Tucker's actions.
I'm sorry we get only Elliot's point of view here. I also loved everything about Tucker - his strength, his brilliant mind, his cocky attitude, his dominant side and sometimes, his words melted me heart:
"I've got two priorities in life. You and my job. And yes, I will do whatever it takes in the interest of those two things. But as important as my job is to me, if it came down to you or the job, I'd quit tomorrow. And if you don't know that by now, there isn't anything more to say."
I'm going right to the next book. From the blurb I know I will be on the edge again. This author surely knows how to keep us entertained.
"A muscle moved in Tucker's jaw. "You mean you want breathing space. I breath better when you're close by."
I've read this book in one sitting and mostly on the edge of my seat.
I enjoyed it much more than the first book, Fair Game. To be honest I had a very hard time getting back to this series, even if I already had the second and third books. I was pretty disappointed in the first one. I couldn't find the magic everybody saw. Maybe I wasn't in a good mood back then. Anyway, when I got back to this one, I wasn't really hooked from the start, but I kept reading and I got completely hooked by all that mystery! I can't believe I suspected each and every one of them! I had some crazy thoughts. The suspense was killing me!
I ended loving Elliot and Tucker so much. These two hot men have something special. They are still adjusting to being together and their lives are as far from the ordinary as they can get! Tucker is an FBI agent, and Elliot is a former agent who was injured and chose to retire and be an Uni history teacher. But his life isn't boring at all. On the contrary. Arrows, traveling to Canada, digging his father's past something fierce. Boy my head was spinning!
Elliot never gave up and wanted to protect his father with all costs. He surprised me. And I have to admit I really understood his point regarding Tucker's actions.
I'm sorry we get only Elliot's point of view here. I also loved everything about Tucker - his strength, his brilliant mind, his cocky attitude, his dominant side and sometimes, his words melted me heart:
"I've got two priorities in life. You and my job. And yes, I will do whatever it takes in the interest of those two things. But as important as my job is to me, if it came down to you or the job, I'd quit tomorrow. And if you don't know that by now, there isn't anything more to say."
I'm going right to the next book. From the blurb I know I will be on the edge again. This author surely knows how to keep us entertained.
March 21, 2022
Series- All Fair
Book 2/3- Fair play
Rating- 3.5 Stars
Sub-genre- Sleuthing but not by an amateur.
The mystery in this book was okayish. I mean it was confusing as hell and it took me time to figure out the killer but still, I didn't enjoy it as much I did in book 1.
But, as per the relationship development in Josh Lanyon's books, this one gave us some major couple goals. I mean, it was a second chance romance and in book 1, the love interest Tucker who is an FBI agent acted like a dick. I thought again in this series I have to rely on mystery but no, then Tucker became the big softie, or maybe he was the same in book 1(we don't get his POV in the series).
"I don’t think it will hurt for us to have a little breathing space.”
A muscle moved in Tucker’s jaw. He said, “You mean you want breathing space. I breathe better when you’re close by.”
"I do want to protect you and what we have together. And I probably do—and maybe always will—put your back up when I cross the lines you’ve drawn. Because I know that everyone doesn’t get this, that this is worth protecting, worth fighting for.”
I know these lines do not feel special but believe me something like this in a JL mystery series looks like lines from Romeo-Juliet to me.😂😂😂
And, yeah our MC, Elliot is an ex-FBI but now teaches history in college. So, we have a lot of discussions around art and film history. I particularly enjoyed it when he talked about old western movies.
Book 2/3- Fair play
Rating- 3.5 Stars
Sub-genre- Sleuthing but not by an amateur.
The mystery in this book was okayish. I mean it was confusing as hell and it took me time to figure out the killer but still, I didn't enjoy it as much I did in book 1.
But, as per the relationship development in Josh Lanyon's books, this one gave us some major couple goals. I mean, it was a second chance romance and in book 1, the love interest Tucker who is an FBI agent acted like a dick. I thought again in this series I have to rely on mystery but no, then Tucker became the big softie, or maybe he was the same in book 1(we don't get his POV in the series).
"I don’t think it will hurt for us to have a little breathing space.”
A muscle moved in Tucker’s jaw. He said, “You mean you want breathing space. I breathe better when you’re close by.”
"I do want to protect you and what we have together. And I probably do—and maybe always will—put your back up when I cross the lines you’ve drawn. Because I know that everyone doesn’t get this, that this is worth protecting, worth fighting for.”
I know these lines do not feel special but believe me something like this in a JL mystery series looks like lines from Romeo-Juliet to me.😂😂😂
And, yeah our MC, Elliot is an ex-FBI but now teaches history in college. So, we have a lot of discussions around art and film history. I particularly enjoyed it when he talked about old western movies.
April 9, 2019
Returning to Elliot and Tucker is always an emotional roller coaster for me. They are my absolute favorite couple and team of all of Josh's books, and that includes my adoration for Adrien and Jake and Sam and Jason. Their relationship is raw, intense, and so very human. They both have hang-ups and weaknesses and combined strengths that paint them each to be gorgeous, three-dimensional characters. Elliot can be a jerk. Tucker can be an ass. But at the end of the day, the way the two men come back to each other and handle it, like adults, takes my breath away.
Fair Play brings us to the next step in their romance, and in the midst of feeling out where to call home, Elliot's father is nearly killed in a house fire. This danger on Roland's life--and Elliot's-- escalates in that subtle, suspenseful way that only Lanyon can write. 0 to 100 in nothing more than a well crafted scenic description or perfectly delivered dialogue. Before we know it, Roland has gone underground and Elliot is sifting through his father's manuscript, Power to the People, to uncover the mystery of Roland's past, who is looking to take him out, and most importantly: why.
We are treated to some intense, personal moments regarding Tucker's past, as well as him and Elliot coming to terms with the needs of the bedroom vs. the needs outside of it. Very well done. The uncertainty, longing, desire, and hesitation were extremely profound.
Every Josh Lanyon book is a treasure to me. But adventures with Elliot and Tucker are like a balm on my soul and a love letter to my heart.
Fair Play brings us to the next step in their romance, and in the midst of feeling out where to call home, Elliot's father is nearly killed in a house fire. This danger on Roland's life--and Elliot's-- escalates in that subtle, suspenseful way that only Lanyon can write. 0 to 100 in nothing more than a well crafted scenic description or perfectly delivered dialogue. Before we know it, Roland has gone underground and Elliot is sifting through his father's manuscript, Power to the People, to uncover the mystery of Roland's past, who is looking to take him out, and most importantly: why.
We are treated to some intense, personal moments regarding Tucker's past, as well as him and Elliot coming to terms with the needs of the bedroom vs. the needs outside of it. Very well done. The uncertainty, longing, desire, and hesitation were extremely profound.
Every Josh Lanyon book is a treasure to me. But adventures with Elliot and Tucker are like a balm on my soul and a love letter to my heart.
December 9, 2016
I'm wondering, when I'll GET BORED with Josh Lanyon's books?
Honestly, they are all soo similar, nearly identical!..
Jake ~ Tucker ~ Will ~ Max ~ ∞
Adrian ~ Elliot ~ Taylor ~ Swift ~ ∞
Good wines, fine meals, quiet jazz music in the background, beautiful guys, easily digestible mystery, hot sex, a nice ambience - on occasion stylish, every now and then excitingly dangerous, and this emotional relationship's mess, and the chemistry, and the desperate attempts to separate private and professional!..And...and...
Doesn't it sound familiar to you? Yes, sure. But Josh Lanyon manages every time to retell ALMOST the same story anew, and at the same time in such deliciously the same way....because it is exactly what we expect to find there, when we pick up our next Josh Lanyon, don't we?...
Because of...
...good wines, fine meals, quiet jazz music in the background, beautiful guys, interesting plot, hot sex, a nice ambience - on occasion stylish, every now and then excitingly dangerous, and this emotional relationship's mess, and the chemistry, and the desperate attempts to separate private and professional!..
March 22, 2017
4 Stars!
In and amongst the standard mystery that is prevalent in all of Lanyon's works, there is also a peek into the lives of Elliot and Tucker, who have really made strides in their budding relationship. It's six months later and they've only gotten closer, but it seems the latest attack on Elliot's father could quite possibly come between them. Elliot pursues the whodunnit relentlessly and toes the legal line, discovering more and more about his father's illustrious, liberal past. Of course, this obviously doesn't sit well with Tucker at all.
What I appreciated the most here was the relationship between these two stubborn men, as they navigate and test boundaries. I swooned at Tucker's dominance, his unabashed love for Elliot - that though not blatant, he lays his heart on his sleeve over and over. What's not to like about a gruff alpha not afraid to express his feelings?? Yes! Elliot could take some notes out of Tucker's playbook.
So this was one of the sexier Lanyon books I've come across, and lo and behold, the abrupt ending did not make me want to hit someone. A very enjoyable mystery with great family and relationship dynamics. Looks like there'll be more, and I'm quite pleased with that prospect.
In and amongst the standard mystery that is prevalent in all of Lanyon's works, there is also a peek into the lives of Elliot and Tucker, who have really made strides in their budding relationship. It's six months later and they've only gotten closer, but it seems the latest attack on Elliot's father could quite possibly come between them. Elliot pursues the whodunnit relentlessly and toes the legal line, discovering more and more about his father's illustrious, liberal past. Of course, this obviously doesn't sit well with Tucker at all.
What I appreciated the most here was the relationship between these two stubborn men, as they navigate and test boundaries. I swooned at Tucker's dominance, his unabashed love for Elliot - that though not blatant, he lays his heart on his sleeve over and over. What's not to like about a gruff alpha not afraid to express his feelings?? Yes! Elliot could take some notes out of Tucker's playbook.
So this was one of the sexier Lanyon books I've come across, and lo and behold, the abrupt ending did not make me want to hit someone. A very enjoyable mystery with great family and relationship dynamics. Looks like there'll be more, and I'm quite pleased with that prospect.
February 12, 2020
Elliott and Tucker are now living together on Goose Island. When Elliott's fathers house is burnt down in an arson attack, Elliott starts to look for answers as to why. Turns out his father has decided to write his memoirs and there are a good few people not at all happy about it. Tucker is trying desperately to keep Elliott from danger, which causes massive arguments between the two, but nothing will stop Elliott from finding answers. Love this series and, love these two together
July 11, 2020
I like Elliot slightly better toward the end of this book when he finally SPEAKS HIS EMOTIONS TO TUCKER! And when he internally realizes Tucker's POV.
And Tucker is still my fave and who I read for. Every time I come to his pain, his heartache, my heart aches. Elliot? Don't care, honestly.
The suspense was fine but I really didn't read that much into it.
However, I DID read closely enough to have a theory who the bad guy in book 3 is...
And Tucker is still my fave and who I read for. Every time I come to his pain, his heartache, my heart aches. Elliot? Don't care, honestly.
The suspense was fine but I really didn't read that much into it.
However, I DID read closely enough to have a theory who the bad guy in book 3 is...
November 23, 2014
I just can't decide on my rating. And I wanted to use this gif.
Reviewy review later.
December 17, 2016
Reread #2837429834 December 16, 2016:
MMMMMMM, TUCKER.
5 STARS.
-----
3.5 stars.
Mmmmm, Tucker.
MMMMMMM, TUCKER.
5 STARS.
-----
3.5 stars.
Mmmmm, Tucker.
March 25, 2017
Another great mystery from, JL!
When I finished the first book Elliot and Tucker were moving in together and talking about the future. It's pretty obvious in this book the guys may have moved a bit fast as Elliot was afraid they were doing in the first book. They are clashing quite a bit in this one. I think their biggest problem is they were only lovers before and didn't spend much if anytime outside of the bedroom together. They have a nice routine down and living together seems to be working. It's their personalities that are clashing a bit. Mostly it's Tucker's domineering traits that are getting to Elliot the most. Although Elliot likes the domineering Tucker in the bedroom, it is the outside of the bedroom he's finding it hard to put up with. Tucker on the other hand is finding Elliot's stubbornness and his indecisiveness hard to deal with. He hasn't quite found his feet in the relationship because of Elliot's confusing ways. Eventually after a few misunderstanding and some raw honestly these men get it together.
Tucker's very honest in his feeling's for Elliot especially when Elliot tries to pull back.
He has an honesty about himself that is just refreshing in a character. He's very secure in his feeling's for Elliot while Elliot still stumbles over the 'I love you's'. It's very sweet seeing their relationship blossom and to see Elliot become more confident in the love he feels for Tucker.
Besides this growing relationship we of course have the great mystery of who is trying to kill Elliot's father, Roland.
After getting a phone call from one of his father's neighbors that his child home has been burnt to the ground Elliot rushes off to make sure his father is OK. His dad seems to be taking this all to well which of course rises Elliot and Tucker's suspicion that more is going on and that Roland is keeping a lot to himself. That turns out to be true and Elliot is once again thrown into another mystery mind bender of "who done it?" when the fire proves to have been arson. I was once again a crappy side kick detective since I still had no clue who it was until the end. Go figure. LOL
This had great suspense, interesting new characters, and a really intriguing look at Roland's past that eventually played deadly into his future.
Great MM romance/crime mystery. Definitely recommend this one to those who enjoy this trope. Happy reading, dolls! xx
When I finished the first book Elliot and Tucker were moving in together and talking about the future. It's pretty obvious in this book the guys may have moved a bit fast as Elliot was afraid they were doing in the first book. They are clashing quite a bit in this one. I think their biggest problem is they were only lovers before and didn't spend much if anytime outside of the bedroom together. They have a nice routine down and living together seems to be working. It's their personalities that are clashing a bit. Mostly it's Tucker's domineering traits that are getting to Elliot the most. Although Elliot likes the domineering Tucker in the bedroom, it is the outside of the bedroom he's finding it hard to put up with. Tucker on the other hand is finding Elliot's stubbornness and his indecisiveness hard to deal with. He hasn't quite found his feet in the relationship because of Elliot's confusing ways. Eventually after a few misunderstanding and some raw honestly these men get it together.
Tucker's very honest in his feeling's for Elliot especially when Elliot tries to pull back.
He has an honesty about himself that is just refreshing in a character. He's very secure in his feeling's for Elliot while Elliot still stumbles over the 'I love you's'. It's very sweet seeing their relationship blossom and to see Elliot become more confident in the love he feels for Tucker.
Besides this growing relationship we of course have the great mystery of who is trying to kill Elliot's father, Roland.
After getting a phone call from one of his father's neighbors that his child home has been burnt to the ground Elliot rushes off to make sure his father is OK. His dad seems to be taking this all to well which of course rises Elliot and Tucker's suspicion that more is going on and that Roland is keeping a lot to himself. That turns out to be true and Elliot is once again thrown into another mystery mind bender of "who done it?" when the fire proves to have been arson. I was once again a crappy side kick detective since I still had no clue who it was until the end. Go figure. LOL
This had great suspense, interesting new characters, and a really intriguing look at Roland's past that eventually played deadly into his future.
Great MM romance/crime mystery. Definitely recommend this one to those who enjoy this trope. Happy reading, dolls! xx
May 5, 2024
yay, re-read time! I'm going to try the audio version now... JF Harding was fantastic and I enjoyed the book even more the second time through.
my review from September 2015
Loved this one so much I was re-reading it almost before I was finished. God I love Elliot - he is an amazing character. I am continuously blown away by Josh Lanyon's incredible ability to write characters which such variety and depth. Between Fair Game (which I also re-read just as quickly) and this book the characters develop so perfectly with the plots in both books... it is absolutely amazing. What a gifted author. She also sets it up a great story for book number three - I only hope it comes out really, really soon.
my review from September 2015
Loved this one so much I was re-reading it almost before I was finished. God I love Elliot - he is an amazing character. I am continuously blown away by Josh Lanyon's incredible ability to write characters which such variety and depth. Between Fair Game (which I also re-read just as quickly) and this book the characters develop so perfectly with the plots in both books... it is absolutely amazing. What a gifted author. She also sets it up a great story for book number three - I only hope it comes out really, really soon.
September 2, 2015
I love me some Josh Lanyon!
February 1, 2017
3.5 stars
I loved Fair Game which was released four years ago. I thought it was engaging with familiar type of story coming from Josh Lanyon. Truthfully, I didn't think the story NEEDED a sequel. Having said that, since I proclaimed myself a Lanyon fan, when I saw there was a new story about Tucker and Elliott, I had to read it. Unfortunately, in my humble opinion, the sequel didn't live up to my expectation -- even if I already set it low considering I didn't see the sequel as necessary in the first place.
The good stuffs... well, I did like the difficult dynamic relationship between Elliott and his father. Yes, his father. Not Tucker. That one fell to my 'bad' stuffs. Anyway, in my review for Fair Game, I wrote "I think. It's great reading those scenes between Elliott and his father". I genuinely thought that parental figure was uncommon in Lanyon's books so I welcomed Roland with open hands.
It was really good to read about an older generation who was a former radical and against government but ended up having a son who used to work in FBI. Both of them were very stubborn too. So the push-pull between father and son was the element I wholeheartedly enjoyed from this story. Besides, everything that Elliott did to uncover the mystery of who targeted his father -- despite Roland being adamant of Elliott chasing the clues -- was because he loved Roland.
The not-so-good stuffs ... I guess it came down to the historical context of this story. I am not an American. The 60's America is totally different with the 60's Indonesia. So it was quite hard for me to build up interest on something quite too political, related to America in the 60's, which was the basis of the mystery. Oh, it was okay to read about this bunch of young radical groups but at the same time, I didn't really care about it. Not like it made any impact on me what-so-ever, you know?
Now, the bad stuffs ... at least for me. I spent majority of this book being pretty annoyed with Elliott. In how he handling the mystery, in how he dealt with his father, AND how he dealt with Tucker. Duly noted that Lanyon is the best when presenting miscommunication between the lovers ... like the silent treatment or the unspoken words, they just work really well from Lanyon's pen ... but this time, I just thought that Elliott was being unfair to Tucker.
No matter the situation, Elliott was still the civilian and Tucker the FBI agent. So asking Tucker for help with the mystery, when it could bring trouble to Tucker, and then being prickly about it, well, it made me want to knock Elliott on the head. I also didn't like how Elliott was questioning how Tucker felt for him, whether he thought Elliott wasn't important. What was wrong with you, Elliott?!? At some point I did understand some of Elliott's stance, but still, I wasn't really happy with him.
So in overall, the not-so-good stuffs and the bad stuffs made me only able to give this 3.5 stars on my rating spectrum. It wasn't bad, I liked some parts of it, but this was the kind of sequel which I wasn't sure was significant in the whole grand scheme of thing.
The review is based on ADVANCED UNCORRECTED PROOFS provided by the publisher via Netgalley for an exchange of fair and honest review. No high rating is required. I assume any error will be edited and cleaned for the published version.
I loved Fair Game which was released four years ago. I thought it was engaging with familiar type of story coming from Josh Lanyon. Truthfully, I didn't think the story NEEDED a sequel. Having said that, since I proclaimed myself a Lanyon fan, when I saw there was a new story about Tucker and Elliott, I had to read it. Unfortunately, in my humble opinion, the sequel didn't live up to my expectation -- even if I already set it low considering I didn't see the sequel as necessary in the first place.
The good stuffs... well, I did like the difficult dynamic relationship between Elliott and his father. Yes, his father. Not Tucker. That one fell to my 'bad' stuffs. Anyway, in my review for Fair Game, I wrote "I think. It's great reading those scenes between Elliott and his father". I genuinely thought that parental figure was uncommon in Lanyon's books so I welcomed Roland with open hands.
It was really good to read about an older generation who was a former radical and against government but ended up having a son who used to work in FBI. Both of them were very stubborn too. So the push-pull between father and son was the element I wholeheartedly enjoyed from this story. Besides, everything that Elliott did to uncover the mystery of who targeted his father -- despite Roland being adamant of Elliott chasing the clues -- was because he loved Roland.
The not-so-good stuffs ... I guess it came down to the historical context of this story. I am not an American. The 60's America is totally different with the 60's Indonesia. So it was quite hard for me to build up interest on something quite too political, related to America in the 60's, which was the basis of the mystery. Oh, it was okay to read about this bunch of young radical groups but at the same time, I didn't really care about it. Not like it made any impact on me what-so-ever, you know?
Now, the bad stuffs ... at least for me. I spent majority of this book being pretty annoyed with Elliott. In how he handling the mystery, in how he dealt with his father, AND how he dealt with Tucker. Duly noted that Lanyon is the best when presenting miscommunication between the lovers ... like the silent treatment or the unspoken words, they just work really well from Lanyon's pen ... but this time, I just thought that Elliott was being unfair to Tucker.
No matter the situation, Elliott was still the civilian and Tucker the FBI agent. So asking Tucker for help with the mystery, when it could bring trouble to Tucker, and then being prickly about it, well, it made me want to knock Elliott on the head. I also didn't like how Elliott was questioning how Tucker felt for him, whether he thought Elliott wasn't important. What was wrong with you, Elliott?!? At some point I did understand some of Elliott's stance, but still, I wasn't really happy with him.
So in overall, the not-so-good stuffs and the bad stuffs made me only able to give this 3.5 stars on my rating spectrum. It wasn't bad, I liked some parts of it, but this was the kind of sequel which I wasn't sure was significant in the whole grand scheme of thing.
The review is based on ADVANCED UNCORRECTED PROOFS provided by the publisher via Netgalley for an exchange of fair and honest review. No high rating is required. I assume any error will be edited and cleaned for the published version.
March 30, 2017
I remembered more than I thought I did, so I just skimmed it. Now for book 3!
-------Orig review Nov 2014-----
4.5 Stars
Fair Play is the second book in Josh Lanyon's All's Fair series, following Fair Game. In this installment, Elliot and Tucker have been living together for about 6 months. Elliot's injuries from the sculptor case are healing nicely and he is back teaching. Tucker is still working on that case, but he doesn't like to talk about it to Elliot.
This story starts off with a 3am phone call, which is never a good thing. No one is likely to call at 3am just to say Hi or to ask if you're up for a cup of coffee. Nope. 3am phone calls are never good. In this case, Elliot's dad is the one in the cross hairs, so to speak. His activist past is coming back to haunt him. He tries to downplay all of it, but Elliot knows there is more than meets the eye here.
So we have a suspense story, which is pretty good. Josh Lanyon does suspense really well. And we have Elliot's and Tucker's relationship, which does get strained at times. Pretty realistic considering we're dealing with two alpha males, one of whom is still law enforcement and the other used to be (and it's tough to just let go of all that training). The one place Elliot lets Tucker completely call the shots is in bed. And wow. Yeah, that's hot.
Both Elliot and Tucker struggle to communicate in Fair Play. Neither of them are even considering calling it quits, but they really have trouble fully trusting each other. Boundaries get blurred and tensions run high at times. But while they struggle, they also recognize that they are each, half of a whole. So they work at it and they fight (and have amazing angry sex) and then finally talk things out and come out stronger for it.
I adore Elliot and Tucker and I'd certainly be interesting in reading more of their adventures.
Recommended.
-------Orig review Nov 2014-----
4.5 Stars
Fair Play is the second book in Josh Lanyon's All's Fair series, following Fair Game. In this installment, Elliot and Tucker have been living together for about 6 months. Elliot's injuries from the sculptor case are healing nicely and he is back teaching. Tucker is still working on that case, but he doesn't like to talk about it to Elliot.
This story starts off with a 3am phone call, which is never a good thing. No one is likely to call at 3am just to say Hi or to ask if you're up for a cup of coffee. Nope. 3am phone calls are never good. In this case, Elliot's dad is the one in the cross hairs, so to speak. His activist past is coming back to haunt him. He tries to downplay all of it, but Elliot knows there is more than meets the eye here.
So we have a suspense story, which is pretty good. Josh Lanyon does suspense really well. And we have Elliot's and Tucker's relationship, which does get strained at times. Pretty realistic considering we're dealing with two alpha males, one of whom is still law enforcement and the other used to be (and it's tough to just let go of all that training). The one place Elliot lets Tucker completely call the shots is in bed. And wow. Yeah, that's hot.
Both Elliot and Tucker struggle to communicate in Fair Play. Neither of them are even considering calling it quits, but they really have trouble fully trusting each other. Boundaries get blurred and tensions run high at times. But while they struggle, they also recognize that they are each, half of a whole. So they work at it and they fight (and have amazing angry sex) and then finally talk things out and come out stronger for it.
I adore Elliot and Tucker and I'd certainly be interesting in reading more of their adventures.
Recommended.
December 8, 2021
Always felt this the weaker of the series but in re-read got to say I didn't like it. The mystery is boring, what is the active investigation? It's more delving into the past than worry over current threat and feels more like interfering than genuine concern. Elliot is not very likeable, he ignores anything that doesn't suit him, railroads over those close to him. Tucker was more sympathetic but cast in the Riordan mold, here as a foil.
That sex scene is still bothersome.
-- --
I do like these guys. And that slight difference of the civilian detective being ex-FBI so qualified rather a precocious bumbler. It adds something to the relationship too, the being strong and capable warring with need to protect.
The relationship between Elliot and his father was my main interest in this one, they bump heads; have different ideology, yet are very similar, equally stubborn.
Elliot and Tucker (are people really named Tucker?) is a work in progress, Tucker a little reserved for all the directness of his personality. They're sexual dynamic was more stressed in this book than the previous and I'm not entirely sure about the point being made with one scene. I could understand where Tucker was coming from and didn't doubt Elliot's engagement, yet the timing... it still felt that bit off to me.
The mystery was less interesting to me with this book feeling more (American) politics than crime mystery.
That sex scene is still bothersome.
-- --
I do like these guys. And that slight difference of the civilian detective being ex-FBI so qualified rather a precocious bumbler. It adds something to the relationship too, the being strong and capable warring with need to protect.
The relationship between Elliot and his father was my main interest in this one, they bump heads; have different ideology, yet are very similar, equally stubborn.
Elliot and Tucker (are people really named Tucker?) is a work in progress, Tucker a little reserved for all the directness of his personality. They're sexual dynamic was more stressed in this book than the previous and I'm not entirely sure about the point being made with one scene. I could understand where Tucker was coming from and didn't doubt Elliot's engagement, yet the timing... it still felt that bit off to me.
The mystery was less interesting to me with this book feeling more (American) politics than crime mystery.
February 11, 2015
3.5
Fair Game was my first Lanyon and I loved it. I didn't really think it needed a sequel but I gladly welcomed it.
Like everything I've ever read by Lanyon, the writing grabbed me. This is an easy and entertaining read.
The mystery is interesting and well written. What i didn't understand was how Elliot or Roland thought that there could or should be any other outcome than how it turned out.
I was frustrated with some of Elliot's actions. His total lack of respect for Tucker's job really bothered me especially since Elliot used to be FBI himself. He still has trouble with the fact that he's no longer on the job so his actions putting Tucker's job at risk seem especially insensitive.
I enjoyed seeing Tucker and Elliot again but I didn't get enough of their relationship in this book. There were also some subplots brought up that didn't get satisfying resolutions. Thankfully there's a a third book planned because this one does need a sequel.
BR with Irina, Ingela, sofia and Rosa
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
Fair Game was my first Lanyon and I loved it. I didn't really think it needed a sequel but I gladly welcomed it.
Like everything I've ever read by Lanyon, the writing grabbed me. This is an easy and entertaining read.
The mystery is interesting and well written. What i didn't understand was how Elliot or Roland thought that there could or should be any other outcome than how it turned out.
I was frustrated with some of Elliot's actions. His total lack of respect for Tucker's job really bothered me especially since Elliot used to be FBI himself. He still has trouble with the fact that he's no longer on the job so his actions putting Tucker's job at risk seem especially insensitive.
I enjoyed seeing Tucker and Elliot again but I didn't get enough of their relationship in this book. There were also some subplots brought up that didn't get satisfying resolutions. Thankfully there's a a third book planned because this one does need a sequel.
BR with Irina, Ingela, sofia and Rosa
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
August 13, 2024
2022 ebook
Love Tucker and Elliot. ❤
2021 audio
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
2019 audio review
Doing a series re-listen because i need my JL fix. 😁 I LOVE this series and highly recommend. The nuances of Tucker and Elliot navigating their relationship is so wonderdul and if you aren't paying attention will miss the significance of. Both are alpha take charge men, bringing their personal and yes professional lives together. That's hard in normal circumstances, but add in possible attempted murder involving Elliot's father, and things between T & E are stressed. Thankfully they love each other and are ready to work through the challenges. I am soooo excited to jump in to book 3. I know what's comingand the build up is almost killing me. 😁❤
2016 audio review
I really loved this book! A friend gifted me the audio, which was great because I was able to listen to it as I drove to a meeting this week. A note about the narrator: he was good. I haven't checked (lazy) to see if same narrator as first book, but he sounded different so assume not same narrator. I thought the narrator voice was good, not distracting or sharp in any way. Very smooth and I was able to tell the difference in who was speaking. Good job! I would listen to him again. :)
I loved the first book, and really enjoyed seeing more of Elliot and Tucker in this book. Their relationship isn't easy; they are both alpha men with strong opinions. But it's all based in their love of each other; not wanting the other to be hurt - or killed.
It seems Elliot can't get away from danger even though he is no longer with the FBI. I felt bad for Elliot because his dad was involved in this case and Elliot was worried that he might get hurt. There are a lot of moving parts to this one (as is the case with most mysteries, duh), and sometimes it was hard to keep track of all the players (not sure if that's because it was audio or what, but I had to constantly remind myself who was who).
I thoroughly enjoyed this story and can't wait to read book 3 which I am sooo excited to read. Squee!!!!! I can't get enough of Tucker or Elliot because they are very strong men and I love to see them relax with each other.
I can't say much about the plot beyond what's in the blurb or risk spoiling it. I will say it didn't go the way I expected it to, which is a real treat because I can often solve the "case" ahead of time. Not this time though. I was really trying to guess what was going on till the end when it was revealed. Loved that!!
If you like Josh Lanyon (and who doesn't?) then you MUST add this series to your list. Highly recommend.
Love Tucker and Elliot. ❤
2021 audio
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
2019 audio review
Doing a series re-listen because i need my JL fix. 😁 I LOVE this series and highly recommend. The nuances of Tucker and Elliot navigating their relationship is so wonderdul and if you aren't paying attention will miss the significance of. Both are alpha take charge men, bringing their personal and yes professional lives together. That's hard in normal circumstances, but add in possible attempted murder involving Elliot's father, and things between T & E are stressed. Thankfully they love each other and are ready to work through the challenges. I am soooo excited to jump in to book 3. I know what's comingand the build up is almost killing me. 😁❤
2016 audio review
I really loved this book! A friend gifted me the audio, which was great because I was able to listen to it as I drove to a meeting this week. A note about the narrator: he was good. I haven't checked (lazy) to see if same narrator as first book, but he sounded different so assume not same narrator. I thought the narrator voice was good, not distracting or sharp in any way. Very smooth and I was able to tell the difference in who was speaking. Good job! I would listen to him again. :)
I loved the first book, and really enjoyed seeing more of Elliot and Tucker in this book. Their relationship isn't easy; they are both alpha men with strong opinions. But it's all based in their love of each other; not wanting the other to be hurt - or killed.
It seems Elliot can't get away from danger even though he is no longer with the FBI. I felt bad for Elliot because his dad was involved in this case and Elliot was worried that he might get hurt. There are a lot of moving parts to this one (as is the case with most mysteries, duh), and sometimes it was hard to keep track of all the players (not sure if that's because it was audio or what, but I had to constantly remind myself who was who).
I thoroughly enjoyed this story and can't wait to read book 3 which I am sooo excited to read. Squee!!!!! I can't get enough of Tucker or Elliot because they are very strong men and I love to see them relax with each other.
I can't say much about the plot beyond what's in the blurb or risk spoiling it. I will say it didn't go the way I expected it to, which is a real treat because I can often solve the "case" ahead of time. Not this time though. I was really trying to guess what was going on till the end when it was revealed. Loved that!!
If you like Josh Lanyon (and who doesn't?) then you MUST add this series to your list. Highly recommend.
February 19, 2022
The mystery was very well-thought, as always with Josh Lanyon, and, just as in the first book, I had no idea who the culprit was until Elliot spelled it out for me, but I’ve to admit that the political/anarchist angle didn’t interest me very much.
I appreciated all the investigative work and the cleverness of the plot, but, unlike in the first book where the two parts held my interest in equal amounts, here it was the relationship development I was focused on. Obviously, Elliot and Tucker’s relationship, I loved seeing them learning how to make it work despite the conflicts, but Elliot and Roland’s relationship too.
There was a scene that disturbed me a little while it was unfolding. It was the
On the other hand, I loved every single time Tucker came out with one of his matter-of-fact declarations about how much he cares about Elliot. Adorable.
I appreciated all the investigative work and the cleverness of the plot, but, unlike in the first book where the two parts held my interest in equal amounts, here it was the relationship development I was focused on. Obviously, Elliot and Tucker’s relationship, I loved seeing them learning how to make it work despite the conflicts, but Elliot and Roland’s relationship too.
There was a scene that disturbed me a little while it was unfolding. It was the
On the other hand, I loved every single time Tucker came out with one of his matter-of-fact declarations about how much he cares about Elliot. Adorable.
June 1, 2018
Overall book rating: 4.5
Audio Book: J. F. Harding – 4.5
Book Cover: 3.5
When Tucker holds Elliot... I melt.
Book two was SO good! Yes, the guys learn that their relationship still has to grow, that things don’t just fall into place. That there will be stormy waters.
But Then there’s Tucker!
Big Strong Tucker who BREAKS ALL THE RULES WITH HIS strait forward manner. Tucker who’s “Strong Enough” for both of them when it counts. Tucker who bluntly communicates his feelings and emotions to the man he loves.
Tucker who disarms Elliot, not just with his dominance but with his gentle way. Protecting what belongs to him. Protecting who he belongs to.
I would have loved to have his point of view together with that of Elliot but I still really loved this story. I could FEEL it and that makes it great.
There are so many little things in this story that made me rewind and re-listen. I’m not going to put them all on paper, it’s painted all over some very good reviews all around and I can’t say it any better.
But know you know what I thought of this book. I LOVE Elliot and Tucker!
Audio Book: J. F. Harding – 4.5
Book Cover: 3.5
When Tucker holds Elliot... I melt.
Book two was SO good! Yes, the guys learn that their relationship still has to grow, that things don’t just fall into place. That there will be stormy waters.
But Then there’s Tucker!
Big Strong Tucker who BREAKS ALL THE RULES WITH HIS strait forward manner. Tucker who’s “Strong Enough” for both of them when it counts. Tucker who bluntly communicates his feelings and emotions to the man he loves.
Tucker who disarms Elliot, not just with his dominance but with his gentle way. Protecting what belongs to him. Protecting who he belongs to.
I would have loved to have his point of view together with that of Elliot but I still really loved this story. I could FEEL it and that makes it great.
There are so many little things in this story that made me rewind and re-listen. I’m not going to put them all on paper, it’s painted all over some very good reviews all around and I can’t say it any better.
But know you know what I thought of this book. I LOVE Elliot and Tucker!
June 8, 2017
Amazing. Baffling. Convoluted. Diverting. Engaging. Fascinating. Glorious...
See what i just did?
Word play! Ha ha
Really a mix of all those I listed up there. There are lot of elements at play here: a 20 year old murder mystery within a mystery with lots of political ideologies and flashbacks of anti-war movement of yesteryear America (something one doesn't get to see in romances that often); a slight hint of American History being taught through films (our H is a History prof, after all) and the complex but endearing relationship of our homosexual protags.
This book definitely had a lot of layers in the guise of a mere M/M Romantic Suspense. I do not know how to categorize it, so shelving to my "don't know where else to put it" shelf
upping to full solid 5 stars. In hindsight, I loved this installment.
See what i just did?
Word play! Ha ha
Really a mix of all those I listed up there. There are lot of elements at play here: a 20 year old murder mystery within a mystery with lots of political ideologies and flashbacks of anti-war movement of yesteryear America (something one doesn't get to see in romances that often); a slight hint of American History being taught through films (our H is a History prof, after all) and the complex but endearing relationship of our homosexual protags.
This book definitely had a lot of layers in the guise of a mere M/M Romantic Suspense. I do not know how to categorize it, so shelving to my "don't know where else to put it" shelf
upping to full solid 5 stars. In hindsight, I loved this installment.
November 24, 2014
I could not get into it as I usually do a Lanyon but then I realised that Lanyon too is keeping us a step back from fully connecting with the characters. Same as we get Tucker second hand from Eliott’s point of view whilst Elliott not being the most effusive of guys. The main theme between these guys remains their communication or lack thereof and their perceptions of each other. Slowly the onion begins to peel but I think we got a while to get to the core. In the meantime we get the slow give and take of wanting to make things work because
”I breathe better when you're close by."And that makes this worthwhile.
Mystery-wise this was one were Lanyon continually changed our focus, leaving us unsure on our feet and hitting us with a zinger at the end – enjoyed that.
BR with Irina, Rosa, Ingela & Otila on the 20th Nov 2014 Our BR thread link
November 20, 2014
3.75 stars
Josh Lanyon's writing is always solid, especially with relationship building and I loved the emerging dynamics in Elliot and Tucker's relationship. They are a strong couple that have a lot to balance and I like that they communicate for the most part. I also liked seeing more of Elliot's relationship with Roland. The mystery started off strong, but lost me a little bit with the number of Roland's friends that were involved. I did, however, like getting a little more about Tucker's past. Looking forward to more.
Josh Lanyon's writing is always solid, especially with relationship building and I loved the emerging dynamics in Elliot and Tucker's relationship. They are a strong couple that have a lot to balance and I like that they communicate for the most part. I also liked seeing more of Elliot's relationship with Roland. The mystery started off strong, but lost me a little bit with the number of Roland's friends that were involved. I did, however, like getting a little more about Tucker's past. Looking forward to more.
September 8, 2021
I was right, when I said in my review of the previous book that I see a lot of conflict in the future. Heh. :)
I was off to a good start with this one. Right off the bat the tone of the book grabbed me within the first 2 pages.
I think I enjoyed this more than book 1 because of the personal involvement in the case. It's always more exciting when the MC has a stake in it.
I only understood the gist of the war stuff. I'm not American, and I don't know the history. Not sure which war they were talking about (was it Vietnam?), but that wasn't really the point. It was nice to see and feel how passionate Roland (Elliot's father) was and still is. I also loved seeing the love between father and son.
I loved the relationship dynamic also. The conflict was not what I expected. And I enjoyed watching Elliot figuring out what's wrong between them and how to fix it, if it needed fixing. Also it was endearing seeing Tucker be more affectionate and forthcoming with his feelings, than Elliot.
I liked it.
I was off to a good start with this one. Right off the bat the tone of the book grabbed me within the first 2 pages.
I think I enjoyed this more than book 1 because of the personal involvement in the case. It's always more exciting when the MC has a stake in it.
I only understood the gist of the war stuff. I'm not American, and I don't know the history. Not sure which war they were talking about (was it Vietnam?), but that wasn't really the point. It was nice to see and feel how passionate Roland (Elliot's father) was and still is. I also loved seeing the love between father and son.
I loved the relationship dynamic also. The conflict was not what I expected. And I enjoyed watching Elliot figuring out what's wrong between them and how to fix it, if it needed fixing. Also it was endearing seeing Tucker be more affectionate and forthcoming with his feelings, than Elliot.
I liked it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 476 reviews