I chose to read this book because it’s not often you get to read a book about Egyptian mythology. This book’s central story is around the myth of Isis and Nephtysis, Egyptian gods, sisters, and sisters in law, who find that after multiple rounds of betrayal, grief, and violence, have nothing but their bonds of sisterhood left to embrace them. This novel touches on the British Invasion of Egypt, Egyptomania and its subsequent grave robbery, plundering of stolen goods, and illegal trade/black market sales. Along the way, questions about how we respect the dead, our responsibility to preserve cultures and prevent cultural robbery, and the impacts of imperialism are all addressed in this novel. Those are the parts of this novel that resonated the most for me.
What I struggled with though, was the characterization and pacing. The author makes a note in her author’s note that she is influenced by the Victorian era and a love for Dickens - so no surprise that there is a touch of the Victorian melodrama in this work. It works for some, but it’s not my cup of tea. As a result, I feel like the four central characters are a bit one dimensional and flat. Clemmie is your stereotypical female protagonist who is just “different” because she likes to study and doesn’t care for romance. Rowland is the brooding but handsome soldier with a tortuous past. Celia is the epitome of superficial girlhood and a vacuous mind. Oswald is the typical brash British man, happy to kill, loot, plunder. And along the way we have the stereotypical evil villain, the evil native countrymen who undermine their nation’s history, and the wise indigent character who is somehow the trust sidekick and yet the impetus for any of the character’s growth. For some people that sounds like a good plot, but for me, it falls flat.
My other big qualm was the pacing of this book. It took 50-60% of the novel for the plot to actually move forward, so I definitely struggled in the first half of this book. I think the overall quality of the book suffers a little because of that - especially when each chapter is oscillating in time between the present day to up to five years prior to the current timeline. In all, this was an interesting read and a promising debut read, but there were some elements that just weren’t for me.
My thanks to NetGalley, Random house publishing group - Ballantine books, and the author for allowing me to read this advance reader copy in exchange for a fair and honest review!