The Epic Women of Homer: Exploring Women's Roles in the Iliad and Odyssey

by Eirene S. Allen

Reexamines the women of Homer's Iliad and Odyssey, restoring their essential roles and challenging traditional heroic narratives.

Our earliest written sources for Greek mythology, Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey, feature women prominently as drivers of the narratives. Though they occupy a variety of roles and speak eloquently for themselves in every role, these women have been obscured by the assumption that each epic’s central hero, Achilles and Odysseus, respectively, is also its singular hero. And yet, the story of the Iliad is not the story of Achilles, just as the story of the Odyssey is not the story of Odysseus alone. Contrary to centuries of reception, the epics are not only about fearless yet flawed men but rather explore and develop the contours of belonging and community in times of war and peace.

The Epic Women of Homer untangles the women of the Iliad and the Odyssey from centuries of narrative constraints to recover their essential meaning and importance. In the process, The Epic Women of Homer challenges the commonplace assumption that the Homeric hero is ‘an individual’ who fights for ‘personal glory’, a misconception further fuelled by a lack of understanding of the oral tradition out of which Homer’s epics emerged in which linguistic and thematic patterning exists at every level. Analysing Homer’s goddesses and heroes through the lens of these patterns, their recurrence and variation reveal them to be preeminent in a wide range of skills, all of which are necessary, and yet the essence of each is in their relationships with others.

The Epic Women of Homer re-establishes these goddesses and heroines to their esteemed positions in ancient Greece and reintroduces them to the modern world.

Genres: Nonfiction, History, Feminism, Classical Studies, Literary Criticism

224 pages, Hardcover

Published March 30, 2025

Reviews

[Linniegayl · Rating 5 out of 5]

I read this for a class and quite enjoyed it. The text reads like a close reading of selected passes of the Iliad and the Odyssey, and I found that instructive. I suspect when I reread the two (it will undoubtedly happen sometime this year) I will get much more out of the texts than I have in previous readings.

[Mariana · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book is wonderful! Dr. Eirene Allen not only offers us illuminating approaches to the voices of female figures in the Homeric epic, she also allows us to have a vision of dualities that sometimes go unnoticed. In addition, she offers a deep analysis of figures that are sometimes not taken into account, such as Eurycleia in the Odyssey. Essential reading!
It should also be emphasized that it is not only a research work but also a translation where we see the hard and wonderful work of the author when translating several of the most crucial moments of Homer into female voices, beautiful translations.
I will do a longer analysis for the blog in the next few days.
Totally recommended!!

[Susie Helme · Rating 4 out of 5]

Homer (whoever he/they were) didn’t just tell the stories of both the Greeks and the Trojans.
Where most ancient literature barely mentioned slaves, captives or even wives, Homer’s women are fully formed. The grief and heartbreak of the Trojan women is vividly portrayed, and Helen, the captive queen who causes the war, is a complex protagonist. The victim of sexual violence (or was it love?), her fate depends on the outcome of battle between men. Still, she exercises agency, and in her voice is placed the final lament in the Iliad.
Allen concentrates on precise line by line translation of the Greek, which at first it may seem a bit pedantic to non-Greek readers. I majored in historical linguistics, however, so I find it fascinating. But we must stick through it, otherwise, we miss too much.
In some translations Telemachus’ scolding Penelope to return to ‘the loom and the distaff’ can sound like teenage misogyny, until we understand that Penelope is Odysseus’ histos, his loom and his mast, a weaving term with connotations of ship-building and of pillars that hold up the rooves of family and dynasty.
Allen studies women’s roles as queen, captive, goddess or heroine, a structure I found not the most systematic. For example, the same scene of Telemachus scolding his mother is discussed in several different places.
A woman’s status was defined in relation to the men in her life. The bard implies, though, that the roles are complementary—we couldn’t have had the heroes without the heroines; it is the women who sing the laments, tend the shrines and keep the legends alive.
What you won’t find anywhere else is the amazing appendix featuring nuanced and insightful discussions on words and phrases (such as histos) within the cultural context of Homer’s age.
This review first appeared in Historical Novels Review.

[Kalliope Ormond · Rating 3 out of 5]

The author makes some very good points, but a lot of the text just feels like she is repeating what the text says/makes obvious. While the former sections were certainly useful, the presence of the latter made the book not so helpful to me in my studies.

Still, an interesting read.

[Tamara Rendell · Rating 5 out of 5]

A fascinating book that emphasises the historical context and really delves into what the symbolism of events, objects, tasks, and the nature and actions of characters meant or may have meant to Homer's original audience. Much of these meanings are not immediately apparant to a modern reader, and I have not come across many of these points before. It was all very helpful to understanding these epics!
A highlight is Eirene S. Allen's translations sprinkled throughout the book: they have a wonderful clarity and rhythm, and offer the opportunity for Allen to explain her process for choosing certain english words and phrasing; explaining in the process the broad meanings contained in the originals. All this makes for a valuable book that I recommend to anyone interested in understanding Homer and the Classical Greek world.