Actual Rating: 3.5 stars
I'm gonna start this off with a rant about a totally different book. Trust me, it's relevant to this review.
Remember that book called The 5th Wave? You know, where those "aliens" wreak havoc on the human race and supposedly want to kill off our species by, er, "destroying our humanity"? Somehow? If you're like me, you hated that book. The premise was amazing -- but the execution was awful. Yancey succumbed to the gooiest lovey-dovey story he possibly could have, with side notes by Cassie's younger brother and love-interest-fail Ben. What happened to "destroying the humanity within" when the so-called "aliens" start falling in love with humans? (yaaaaaawwwwwnnnnnnnn)
SPOILER ALERT: The "aliens" in The 5th Wave (and the Infinite Sea) aren't actually aliens at all. It's literally just random military dudes with the technological prowess to feign a Mothership in earth's atmosphere and cause natural disasters on such a titanic scale that literally their plans could've gone to hell if one of them tripped over a rock. What makes me even angrier is that, you know, both of those books are being marketed as alien books, the best sci-fi alien invasion books in today's YA lit, yada, yada, yada, YADA, and the 5th Wave is obviously becoming a movie.
Rant over.
Now let's get to this review. In my opinion, "Survival Colony 9" was everything that T5W should have been. It's gritty. The aliens are terrifying (AND THEY'RE REAL, TOO!) So this is a true alien invasion book.
For the most part, SC9 is all about the group dynamic. Bellin does an excellent job showing power roles within the colony and how the colony overall is affected by leader's decisions, mutinous uprising, and individual self-interest. And the world of the book was a great setting. Everywhere is dangerous. There's nowhere, NOWHERE to hide. In the entire book, there is exactly ONE small group of buildings they camp out in. Otherwise, they're trekking across a desert, in the wide open, dying on the run. If the heat doesn't kill them, literally the only way to avoid these alien body snatchers is to never sleep -- and even then you better have a flamethrower, or else you're screwed.
There is a reason I didn't give this 4-stars. Simply put, though the environment was well-crafted and believable, I don't think the environment itself was dangerous enough. We're led to believe it's very, very, VERY hot. These people have no shade, they're drinking VERY little water, and the water they DO drink is contaminated with oil (unless it rains, which is like twice a year).
But despite those crappy living conditions, nobody died. Or got sick. Or collapsed from heat stroke. Nothing like that. No matter how dangerous the natural conditions were, the only real threat came from the Skaldi (the aliens, and trust me, whenever the Skaldi attack, it's bad news. I cringed on several occasions).
The other reason I couldn't give this 4 stars is because I didn't feel like the MC, Querry, was 14 years old (he was supposed to be). The 14-year-old would slip in sometimes...but mostly it was left to the side. I know he lost his memory and his dad basically put him through boot camp the rest of the time, but Querry's voice just felt like it could've been any age. In fact, I'd go so far as to say I felt like he realistically could have been 22 years old and it wouldn't have changed the story. I *needed* to feel a unique voice, and I didn't get it.
Back to some positives. Going along with the group mentality themes, I also liked how this wasn't a constant action-packed blockbuster. Bellin took his time. Admittedly, the first 150 pages are slow. There isn't a single Skaldi attack (a terrifying flashback at the beginning, but that's it). But for me, it worked. That build up to the first action scene packed in so much tension that the entire, you were waiting for an attack. It wasn't *if* there's going to be an attack, it's *when*. The slow build led perfectly into the first attack, and...wow. It paid off.
After the first attack, the book switches gears. The pace picks up, the group dynamic changes, and you really don't know what to expect. I liked how *anyone* could've been Skaldi. It increased the tension.
Toward the end of the book, however, I felt like things started coming too easily. Yes, Querry steps up to the plate and takes certain matters into his own hands, but I felt like the book started rushing at that point. And in the climax... Climaxes are hit-or-miss. They're difficult to pull off. I'm a writer, I know how hard it is to make a novel's climax WORK. And personally, this one fell short of my expectations. It was certainly action-packed, but it didn't last very long and the tension that the first half of the book had surrounding the deadliness of the Skaldi seemed to taper. The Skaldi pretty much didn't fight. And Querry's "Special Power" twist seemed too convenient. It wasn't explained, and I felt like, as a reader, I needed his power to be physically grounded rather than used as a deus-ex-machina at the last second.
All that being said, yes, Survival Colony 9 is worth a read. Think "The Walking Dead" with aliens. The aliens, like the zombies, show up here and there, but mostly you get to see the group dynamic and power struggles. As a side note, imagine watching the Walking Dead from Carl's POV. That's what this book feels like. His dad is in charge of the colony, and he's sorta doing his own thing till the end.
There's a sequel coming out in Summer 2016 called "Scavenger of Souls". And the cover looks amazing. Am I going to read it? Yes! I wasn't so attached to Querry, but the world and the threat of the Skaldi hooked me. I feel like we haven't really seen what the survival colonies are up against, and I feel like Bellin will continue to grow his story. I'm excited to read it for sure!
Characters: 2.5/5
World: 3/5
Style: 4/5
Plot: 3/5
Cover: 5/5 (it's soooo beautiful)