What do you think?
Rate this book
Escapism #2
Lost Boy: An extended trigger-free version of Losing Neverland
When Peter Pan discovers his forbidden magic, he’s faced with an ultimatum.
Stay in London, or escape to a whole new world. A place where a fairy named Tinker Bell is his most loyal companion, pirates rule the seas, mermaids are friends with the fae, and lost boys live out their childish dreams.
But leaving London comes with a price.
Wendy Moira Angela Darling.
When Peter decides to steal Wendy away one night, headed for the second star to the right, Tinker Bell’s jealousy grows. The lost boys turn on him. The mermaids and fae work against him. And an evil, dangerous shadow falls on Neverland.
Jas Hook.
Stay in London, or escape to a whole new world. A place where a fairy named Tinker Bell is his most loyal companion, pirates rule the seas, mermaids are friends with the fae, and lost boys live out their childish dreams.
But leaving London comes with a price.
Wendy Moira Angela Darling.
When Peter decides to steal Wendy away one night, headed for the second star to the right, Tinker Bell’s jealousy grows. The lost boys turn on him. The mermaids and fae work against him. And an evil, dangerous shadow falls on Neverland.
Jas Hook.
416 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 1, 2024
22 people are currently reading
629 people want to read
About the author
Evelyn Montgomery
22 books657 followersBorn & raised in California, Evelyn Montgomery now resides in Central Kentucky with her husband and three children.
Her love stories include fantasy, paranormal, retellings, contemporary romance, romantic suspense, romantic psychological thrillers and mysteries, rom com, small town romance & more.
One thing to always expect when reading an Evelyn Montgomery book is a plot twist you’d never see coming.
With no plans to stop writing any time soon, her goal is to keep producing a fictional world that isn’t forced, but genuine, heartfelt, and desirable.
Her love stories include fantasy, paranormal, retellings, contemporary romance, romantic suspense, romantic psychological thrillers and mysteries, rom com, small town romance & more.
One thing to always expect when reading an Evelyn Montgomery book is a plot twist you’d never see coming.
With no plans to stop writing any time soon, her goal is to keep producing a fictional world that isn’t forced, but genuine, heartfelt, and desirable.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 59 reviews
November 9, 2024
This is the dull version 😅. I had to compare Lost Boy and Losing Neverland (to see how big of a difference there was), and honestly, I thought Losing Neverland could have gone even darker, making Lost Boy feel a bit boring in comparison. I did enjoy the extended part in Lost Boy, but I’d still recommend Losing Neverland over this one 😇.
A dark, twisted reimagining of Peter Pan, blending fantasy with psychological suspense. Montgomery explores themes of trauma, memory, and love, following a protagonist trapped between haunting memories and a need to escape the shadows of the past.
This story is intense and layered, with each chapter peeling back secrets. Montgomery’s interpretation brings a gritty edge to the classic tale, making it a compelling read. It’s not my favorite Peter Pan retelling, but it was still an entertaining spin.
A dark, twisted reimagining of Peter Pan, blending fantasy with psychological suspense. Montgomery explores themes of trauma, memory, and love, following a protagonist trapped between haunting memories and a need to escape the shadows of the past.
This story is intense and layered, with each chapter peeling back secrets. Montgomery’s interpretation brings a gritty edge to the classic tale, making it a compelling read. It’s not my favorite Peter Pan retelling, but it was still an entertaining spin.
November 28, 2024
Review to come…
September 30, 2024
ALC Review
Book: Lost Boy
Author: Evelyn Montgomery
Narrators: Joe Arden & Maxine Mitchell
Rating: ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
What did I just listen to? I listened to this in 24 hours. I literally could not stop listening and I enjoyed every single minute.
I will say, I’ve never really watched Peter Pan before. Obviously I know the story, but I’ve never read the story or have seen the Disney version. But the way Evelyn Montgomery wrote this re-telling, I don’t think I missed much. This was such an amazing listen and I blame Evelyn for her world building.
Joe Arden as Peter Pan/Hook/all the other males was spectacular. Joe is one of the best in the business. He knows his craft and isn’t afraid to use it. The passion he puts in every single line is mesmerizing.
Maxine Mitchell as Wendy/ Tinkerbell/all the other females was hands down freaking amazing. Maxine is also one of the best in the business. Her portrayal of Tinkerbell and Wendy is fantastic. The emotion she put towards these characters was exactly what I craved!
Evelyn wrote a beautiful re-telling that I can guarantee I’ll be telling all my friends about. Looking forward to Saving Tink!!
Thank you BNA for the ALC!!
Book: Lost Boy
Author: Evelyn Montgomery
Narrators: Joe Arden & Maxine Mitchell
Rating: ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
What did I just listen to? I listened to this in 24 hours. I literally could not stop listening and I enjoyed every single minute.
I will say, I’ve never really watched Peter Pan before. Obviously I know the story, but I’ve never read the story or have seen the Disney version. But the way Evelyn Montgomery wrote this re-telling, I don’t think I missed much. This was such an amazing listen and I blame Evelyn for her world building.
Joe Arden as Peter Pan/Hook/all the other males was spectacular. Joe is one of the best in the business. He knows his craft and isn’t afraid to use it. The passion he puts in every single line is mesmerizing.
Maxine Mitchell as Wendy/ Tinkerbell/all the other females was hands down freaking amazing. Maxine is also one of the best in the business. Her portrayal of Tinkerbell and Wendy is fantastic. The emotion she put towards these characters was exactly what I craved!
Evelyn wrote a beautiful re-telling that I can guarantee I’ll be telling all my friends about. Looking forward to Saving Tink!!
Thank you BNA for the ALC!!
October 5, 2024
Ok this was absolutely such an amazing twist on Peter Pan.
I could not put this retelling down.
It was fast pace, thrilling, had great plots and was nice and spicy.
Honestly didn’t expect to be this into it and didn’t think it was going to blow me away the way it did.
Evelyn is a great story teller and did a fantastic job with this.
If you’re a Romantacy reader don’t miss out on this.
Read it or listen to it. The storyline is fantastic and I would 💯 recommend!
This is one of the best performances by Maxine Mitchell and Joe Arden. Their duet sparring magic is unmatched 🫶🏼
ALC provided by Blue Nose Audio
I could not put this retelling down.
It was fast pace, thrilling, had great plots and was nice and spicy.
Honestly didn’t expect to be this into it and didn’t think it was going to blow me away the way it did.
Evelyn is a great story teller and did a fantastic job with this.
If you’re a Romantacy reader don’t miss out on this.
Read it or listen to it. The storyline is fantastic and I would 💯 recommend!
This is one of the best performances by Maxine Mitchell and Joe Arden. Their duet sparring magic is unmatched 🫶🏼
ALC provided by Blue Nose Audio
January 17, 2025
Why is this rated higher than the original?
October 3, 2024
"I want to make you feel faint, Wendy. I want to make your world go black and be the only one that breathes you back to life. Gives you air."
Please note...this is an extended trigger-free version of Ms. Montgomery's Losing Neverland
I DO NOT even know where to begin with the absolute perfection Losing Neverland is. I am not a person that reads retellings but knew I would be reading Ms. Montgomery's and after reading it....I never want to watch a single Peter Pan movie or the cartoon because I want her story to be Peter and Wendy's real story!!!
This retelling is nothing like all the others I have heard about. There is a uniqueness to the plot, a twist that the reader finds out in the very beginning....which is not Evelyn's normal writing style. So once you know the big secret you in turn get the beautiful tale of how it came to be. Where things went so wrong between these two seventeen years ago.
You are taken to Neverland in chronological order with Lost Boy vs Losing Neverland that alternated between past and present. By the author taking us back to the beginning with them the reader is able to feel so much more connected to present day Peter and Wendy. They are each other's first loves....each other's only loves. They experience all of their firsts together. While this is a slow burn the author gives the reader plenty of tension build up and little sprinkles of spice here and there.
Along with Peter and Wendy there are familiar characters that play a part in their story....Tinker Bell, Tiger Lily, John, and numerous Lost Boys. Of course this wouldn't be an Evelyn Montgomery book if there weren't a few more plot twists thrown in the mix to have you guessing and/or questioning. Her writing, as always, flows poetically across every page. I do not know how she manages to continuously give her readers books that are written the way they are.
********AUDIO REVIEW********
Just like with Losing Neverland Maxine Mitchell and Joe Arden knock this one out of the park. They are in essence the same story but there are slight differences between their performances in the two. Maxine does a phenomenal Tinker Bell and we see/hear more of her in Lost Boy vs Losing Neverland. Joe's Hook has slightly more aggression in his voice at certain points in Losing Neverland vs Lost Boy but his Peter voice.....probably my favorite in Lost Boy (it is my favorite of the two after all). These two have truly taken these stories to the next level with their narration.
Please note...this is an extended trigger-free version of Ms. Montgomery's Losing Neverland
I DO NOT even know where to begin with the absolute perfection Losing Neverland is. I am not a person that reads retellings but knew I would be reading Ms. Montgomery's and after reading it....I never want to watch a single Peter Pan movie or the cartoon because I want her story to be Peter and Wendy's real story!!!
This retelling is nothing like all the others I have heard about. There is a uniqueness to the plot, a twist that the reader finds out in the very beginning....which is not Evelyn's normal writing style. So once you know the big secret you in turn get the beautiful tale of how it came to be. Where things went so wrong between these two seventeen years ago.
You are taken to Neverland in chronological order with Lost Boy vs Losing Neverland that alternated between past and present. By the author taking us back to the beginning with them the reader is able to feel so much more connected to present day Peter and Wendy. They are each other's first loves....each other's only loves. They experience all of their firsts together. While this is a slow burn the author gives the reader plenty of tension build up and little sprinkles of spice here and there.
Along with Peter and Wendy there are familiar characters that play a part in their story....Tinker Bell, Tiger Lily, John, and numerous Lost Boys. Of course this wouldn't be an Evelyn Montgomery book if there weren't a few more plot twists thrown in the mix to have you guessing and/or questioning. Her writing, as always, flows poetically across every page. I do not know how she manages to continuously give her readers books that are written the way they are.
********AUDIO REVIEW********
Just like with Losing Neverland Maxine Mitchell and Joe Arden knock this one out of the park. They are in essence the same story but there are slight differences between their performances in the two. Maxine does a phenomenal Tinker Bell and we see/hear more of her in Lost Boy vs Losing Neverland. Joe's Hook has slightly more aggression in his voice at certain points in Losing Neverland vs Lost Boy but his Peter voice.....probably my favorite in Lost Boy (it is my favorite of the two after all). These two have truly taken these stories to the next level with their narration.
October 10, 2024
CAPTIVATING!!!
I absolutely loved this book. Lost Boys answered so many questions that I was wondering while I was reading Losing Neverland. This book gave me so much insight about Peter’s and Wendy’s story. This phenomenal book made me cry so much. Evelyn you have captured my imagination with this phenomenal book. I will forever be a massive fan of yours because you have a way with words that has its claws so deep in me that it will be unrelenting and that’s why I I absolutely love Escapism series. I cannot wait to get my hands on Saving Tink so I can find out what happens. If you absolutely love a book that captures the innocence of happy thoughts, you need to get this book today. Actually, you need to get the entire series because it’s the best roller coaster of epic proportions and you won’t regret it. Evelyn thank you so so much for writing this beautiful extended version.
I absolutely loved this book. Lost Boys answered so many questions that I was wondering while I was reading Losing Neverland. This book gave me so much insight about Peter’s and Wendy’s story. This phenomenal book made me cry so much. Evelyn you have captured my imagination with this phenomenal book. I will forever be a massive fan of yours because you have a way with words that has its claws so deep in me that it will be unrelenting and that’s why I I absolutely love Escapism series. I cannot wait to get my hands on Saving Tink so I can find out what happens. If you absolutely love a book that captures the innocence of happy thoughts, you need to get this book today. Actually, you need to get the entire series because it’s the best roller coaster of epic proportions and you won’t regret it. Evelyn thank you so so much for writing this beautiful extended version.
January 7, 2025
Lost Boy answered so many questions that I had when I was reading Losing Neverland. This book gave me so much insight about Peter's and Wendy's stories. Let’s be real, I am now nervously waiting to get my hands on Saving Tink so I can find out what happens. She is really ticking me off. You need to get the entire series because it's the best roller coaster ride and you won't regret it. The audio of this book was just perfect and the duet narration for this book was on point. It was flawless and I loved every second!
January 21, 2025
I had to take a break and compose my thoughts. This book is depressing. The story is good but also frustrating at the same time🤬😫😮💨
Now, the third book, I really don't like Tinker Bell. That btch irritates the hell out of me but for the sake of the first two books, I'll read it, mainly because I still have questions.😮💨
Now, the third book, I really don't like Tinker Bell. That btch irritates the hell out of me but for the sake of the first two books, I'll read it, mainly because I still have questions.😮💨
July 14, 2025
**Audiobook review**
Multi POV (though mainly dual POV), Full Duet Narration
OH. MY. GOD. I LOVED this book SOOO much!!!! Originally, after reading the reviews for Lost Boy, I had no plans to read it as I thought I would basically just be re-reading Losing Neverland, but boy, am I glad I chose to take a chance and listen to/read this book anyways!!
After finishing Losing Neverland, I was a little confused as to what happened at the end with Peter & Wendy. Did they live? Did they die? I hoped Lost Boy would answer my questions about the ending but it answered so many more questions about Losing Neverland I didn't realize I had until discovering the answers in Lost Boy. Not only is Lost Boy an extended version of Losing Neverland but it is told in chronological order instead of flipping between the past and present which made things a lot clearer.
Once again, the narrators did an amazing job bringing all of the characters to life. Their chemistry is great and it was awesome to listen to them going back and forth such as when Peter & Wendy were fighting. The relationship between Peter & Wendy is so beautiful. The love he has for her both broke and healed me.
If I could, a few minor things I would change would be to add back some of the triggers from Losing Neverland. As I was listening to some of the chapters I felt they could have done with some of the explicitness from Losing Neverland both in language and sexual content. I would also try to find a way to take pieces of Joe Arden's narration from both books when he was reading as Hook as I found him to be a bit more psychotic in Losing Neverland and a little more reserved in Lost Boy. There were moments while listening to Lost Boy I found myself missing the psychotic edge in Hook's voice.
Multi POV (though mainly dual POV), Full Duet Narration
OH. MY. GOD. I LOVED this book SOOO much!!!! Originally, after reading the reviews for Lost Boy, I had no plans to read it as I thought I would basically just be re-reading Losing Neverland, but boy, am I glad I chose to take a chance and listen to/read this book anyways!!
After finishing Losing Neverland, I was a little confused as to what happened at the end with Peter & Wendy. Did they live? Did they die? I hoped Lost Boy would answer my questions about the ending but it answered so many more questions about Losing Neverland I didn't realize I had until discovering the answers in Lost Boy. Not only is Lost Boy an extended version of Losing Neverland but it is told in chronological order instead of flipping between the past and present which made things a lot clearer.
Once again, the narrators did an amazing job bringing all of the characters to life. Their chemistry is great and it was awesome to listen to them going back and forth such as when Peter & Wendy were fighting. The relationship between Peter & Wendy is so beautiful. The love he has for her both broke and healed me.
If I could, a few minor things I would change would be to add back some of the triggers from Losing Neverland. As I was listening to some of the chapters I felt they could have done with some of the explicitness from Losing Neverland both in language and sexual content. I would also try to find a way to take pieces of Joe Arden's narration from both books when he was reading as Hook as I found him to be a bit more psychotic in Losing Neverland and a little more reserved in Lost Boy. There were moments while listening to Lost Boy I found myself missing the psychotic edge in Hook's voice.
May 17, 2024
I'm reeling. I thought I knew what I was getting into. I probably should have waited to read this until I was more emotionally prepared. Maybe it's because I'm mid-Iron-Flame, maybe it's because of reality, but this book had me depressed for three days straight. I had a heavy cloud hanging over my head and a weight on my chest that I couldn't get rid of. But you know what? Peter was right. Like Wendy, I should have asked him for air. Because when he finally breathed life back into me, I devoured the rest of this book. It was evocative and moving. On a technical note, I was pleasantly surprised by the parallels between this and the original story. I will be recommending this to all my dark romance lovers, and I absolutely cannot wait for the next book. Gosh. This is going to stick with me for a while. 4.5 stars rounded up.
October 5, 2024
I had the chance to dive into Lost Boy after reading Losing Neverland, and it was such a surprise! Lost Boy is a trigger-free, extended version of Losing Neverland, but I never expected it to pull me in the way it did. Both books reimagine Peter Pan through Evelyn Montgomery’s lens, but Lost Boy opened up the world in ways I didn’t expect.
The story grabbed me right from the start. We all know the classic Peter, Wendy, Tinkerbell, and Hook story, but Evelyn flips it upside down, adding twists you'd find in modern fantasy novels. And at its heart, it’s still a love story. Lost Boy digs deeper into the magic and relationships than Losing Neverland ever did, especially with Peter and Wendy. And Tink? Well, Maxine Mitchell brought a version of Tinkerbell I didn’t even know I needed!
I was skeptical at first. I thought that without the darker, spicier elements of Losing Neverland, Lost Boy would feel a bit flat. I was wrong. While there’s no sexual content that would label it a dark romance, it’s still 100% a romance. Evelyn did an amazing job showing the characters’ emotions and chemistry without leaning on the usual tropes. The story itself is like a love letter to magic, where all you need are happy thoughts to believe in love.
Even though Lost Boy is longer and parts overlap with Losing Neverland, it never dragged. The added depth and backstory kept things moving, and I constantly found myself wondering what would happen next. Without giving too much away, the richer details of Peter and Wendy’s love story—both past and present—made this retelling feel more complete.
Let me just say, Joe Arden and Maxine Mitchell completely knocked it out of the park. I’ve been a fan of both for a while, but this performance really stood out. Joe Arden, especially, blew me away. His portrayal of Peter was so raw and vulnerable, capturing that sweet confusion of growing up and discovering love. And his Hook? Dark and dangerous—exactly what you want.
Maxine Mitchell, though? Wow. I’ve mostly heard her narrate contemporary and dark romances, so hearing her switch between the innocence of Wendy and the evil of Tinkerbell was amazing. She brought a new, dark twist to Tink that I didn’t even know I needed, and I loved every minute of it. Their pacing was perfect too—no need to speed up the audio, as
their rhythm and delivery kept me engaged the entire time.
All the characters in Lost Boy were so well-developed, you really feel all their struggles and emotions. Joe Arden and Maxine Mitchell took what Evelyn Montgomery wrote and brought each character to life in their own unique way. Peter and Wendy’s love story was especially touching, and Tink was that character you loved to hate.
Blue Nose Audio always does an amazing job, and this audiobook was no exception. The duet narration flowed seamlessly, and the production quality was top-notch. The sound was super clear, and the narrators made some creative choices that fit perfectly into the story.
If you're into fantasy romance, Lost Boy is definitely worth a listen. It’s not as dark as Losing Neverland, so if you’re after those edgy vibes, you might miss them. But honestly, the extra backstory and the way the world is built in Lost Boy totally make up for it. I wish Evelyn Montgomery would do another book that mixes the dark romance from Losing Neverland with all the backstory from Lost Boy. That would be amazing!
The story grabbed me right from the start. We all know the classic Peter, Wendy, Tinkerbell, and Hook story, but Evelyn flips it upside down, adding twists you'd find in modern fantasy novels. And at its heart, it’s still a love story. Lost Boy digs deeper into the magic and relationships than Losing Neverland ever did, especially with Peter and Wendy. And Tink? Well, Maxine Mitchell brought a version of Tinkerbell I didn’t even know I needed!
I was skeptical at first. I thought that without the darker, spicier elements of Losing Neverland, Lost Boy would feel a bit flat. I was wrong. While there’s no sexual content that would label it a dark romance, it’s still 100% a romance. Evelyn did an amazing job showing the characters’ emotions and chemistry without leaning on the usual tropes. The story itself is like a love letter to magic, where all you need are happy thoughts to believe in love.
Even though Lost Boy is longer and parts overlap with Losing Neverland, it never dragged. The added depth and backstory kept things moving, and I constantly found myself wondering what would happen next. Without giving too much away, the richer details of Peter and Wendy’s love story—both past and present—made this retelling feel more complete.
Let me just say, Joe Arden and Maxine Mitchell completely knocked it out of the park. I’ve been a fan of both for a while, but this performance really stood out. Joe Arden, especially, blew me away. His portrayal of Peter was so raw and vulnerable, capturing that sweet confusion of growing up and discovering love. And his Hook? Dark and dangerous—exactly what you want.
Maxine Mitchell, though? Wow. I’ve mostly heard her narrate contemporary and dark romances, so hearing her switch between the innocence of Wendy and the evil of Tinkerbell was amazing. She brought a new, dark twist to Tink that I didn’t even know I needed, and I loved every minute of it. Their pacing was perfect too—no need to speed up the audio, as
their rhythm and delivery kept me engaged the entire time.
All the characters in Lost Boy were so well-developed, you really feel all their struggles and emotions. Joe Arden and Maxine Mitchell took what Evelyn Montgomery wrote and brought each character to life in their own unique way. Peter and Wendy’s love story was especially touching, and Tink was that character you loved to hate.
Blue Nose Audio always does an amazing job, and this audiobook was no exception. The duet narration flowed seamlessly, and the production quality was top-notch. The sound was super clear, and the narrators made some creative choices that fit perfectly into the story.
If you're into fantasy romance, Lost Boy is definitely worth a listen. It’s not as dark as Losing Neverland, so if you’re after those edgy vibes, you might miss them. But honestly, the extra backstory and the way the world is built in Lost Boy totally make up for it. I wish Evelyn Montgomery would do another book that mixes the dark romance from Losing Neverland with all the backstory from Lost Boy. That would be amazing!
July 1, 2025
Lost Boy 😭❤️😍
✨What if Peter Pan never stayed the hero? What if Neverland demanded a darker price?
Wendy was his light until she became the reason he turned into Hook.
A romantasy retelling where innocence dies, and monsters rise. 🌙🗡️
📖 Plot Summary
Lost Boy is a dark, romantasy retelling of Peter Pan. It follows Peter Pan as he discovers a forbidden magic and faces a choice: remain in London or journey to Neverland.
He chooses the latter, kidnapping Wendy Darling and unlocking a chain of events Tinker Bell's jealousy, a rebellion by the Lost Boys, threats from mermaids, fae intrigue, and the ominous rise of Jas Hook, a darker version of Captain Hook.
This version is an extended, trigger‑free take on the earlier Losing Neverland, going deeper into the narrative and characters. It unpacks the psychological and emotional fallout of Peter’s decisions, adding fresh conflict and depth.
🧍♂️ Main Characters
Peter Pan / Jas Hook – Dual identity: the eternal boy thrust into maturity and the darker persona of Jas that emerges as tensions escalate.
Wendy Moira Angela Darling – Portrayed as empathetic yet conflicted, navigating love, betrayal, and surviving the repercussions of Peter’s actions.
Tinker Bell – Wendy’s fairy protector whose jealousy becomes destructive as Peter’s relationship with Wendy deepens.
Lost Boys – Initially loyal, they turn hostile as Peter's choices endanger their fragile order in Neverland.
Mermaids & Fae – Mysterious factions in Neverland whose allegiances shift, adding magical tension.
The Shadow/Evil Force – A foreboding influence in Neverland, aligning with Jas’s rise.
🧠 Themes
Choices & Consequences – Peter’s forbidden magic acts as a catalyst that reshapes Neverland’s dynamics demanding loyalty, sacrificing innocence, and catapulting characters into power struggles.
Jealousy & Betrayal – Tinker Bell’s envy morphs from rivalry into something darker, showcasing the fragility of devotion.
Identity & Transformation – Peter oscillates between youthful freedom and darker authority (Jas Hook), Wendy transforms from rescued to survivor, and even the Lost Boys face painful growth.
Power Structures – The story deconstructs Neverland’s utopian ideal, revealing the political undercurrents between boys, magical creatures, and hidden forces.
Love vs. Duty – Peter and Wendy’s romance conflicts with their shifting loyalties—to each other, to their roles, and to Neverland’s power.
📝 Quotes from Lost Boy
To love Peter Pan is to fall in love with tragedy.
There is no Neverland without Wendy. And no Peter without pain.
He was never meant to grow up but I made him.
Jas Hook wasn’t born. He was broken into existence.
Tinker Bell glowed with fury; even fairies aren’t immune to heartbreak.
The magic always asks for something back. Sometimes it’s you.
Rating ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
✨What if Peter Pan never stayed the hero? What if Neverland demanded a darker price?
Wendy was his light until she became the reason he turned into Hook.
A romantasy retelling where innocence dies, and monsters rise. 🌙🗡️
📖 Plot Summary
Lost Boy is a dark, romantasy retelling of Peter Pan. It follows Peter Pan as he discovers a forbidden magic and faces a choice: remain in London or journey to Neverland.
He chooses the latter, kidnapping Wendy Darling and unlocking a chain of events Tinker Bell's jealousy, a rebellion by the Lost Boys, threats from mermaids, fae intrigue, and the ominous rise of Jas Hook, a darker version of Captain Hook.
This version is an extended, trigger‑free take on the earlier Losing Neverland, going deeper into the narrative and characters. It unpacks the psychological and emotional fallout of Peter’s decisions, adding fresh conflict and depth.
🧍♂️ Main Characters
Peter Pan / Jas Hook – Dual identity: the eternal boy thrust into maturity and the darker persona of Jas that emerges as tensions escalate.
Wendy Moira Angela Darling – Portrayed as empathetic yet conflicted, navigating love, betrayal, and surviving the repercussions of Peter’s actions.
Tinker Bell – Wendy’s fairy protector whose jealousy becomes destructive as Peter’s relationship with Wendy deepens.
Lost Boys – Initially loyal, they turn hostile as Peter's choices endanger their fragile order in Neverland.
Mermaids & Fae – Mysterious factions in Neverland whose allegiances shift, adding magical tension.
The Shadow/Evil Force – A foreboding influence in Neverland, aligning with Jas’s rise.
🧠 Themes
Choices & Consequences – Peter’s forbidden magic acts as a catalyst that reshapes Neverland’s dynamics demanding loyalty, sacrificing innocence, and catapulting characters into power struggles.
Jealousy & Betrayal – Tinker Bell’s envy morphs from rivalry into something darker, showcasing the fragility of devotion.
Identity & Transformation – Peter oscillates between youthful freedom and darker authority (Jas Hook), Wendy transforms from rescued to survivor, and even the Lost Boys face painful growth.
Power Structures – The story deconstructs Neverland’s utopian ideal, revealing the political undercurrents between boys, magical creatures, and hidden forces.
Love vs. Duty – Peter and Wendy’s romance conflicts with their shifting loyalties—to each other, to their roles, and to Neverland’s power.
📝 Quotes from Lost Boy
To love Peter Pan is to fall in love with tragedy.
There is no Neverland without Wendy. And no Peter without pain.
He was never meant to grow up but I made him.
Jas Hook wasn’t born. He was broken into existence.
Tinker Bell glowed with fury; even fairies aren’t immune to heartbreak.
The magic always asks for something back. Sometimes it’s you.
Rating ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
October 4, 2024
**Audio Review**
Wow...just wow.
I thought that I was blown away by Losing Neverland, but this story and the bonus content managed to elevate things even more! This story of Peter, Wendy, Hook, and the Neverland crew is not what we grew up on. You think you know what you're getting into, but the story is far removed from what Disney created. There is a plot twist at the very beginning of the book, which I love!, and it sets the scene for the remainder of our story. I loved how Lost Boy built upon what we had already learned in Losing Neverland, and answered some questions that I had about the storyline.
To start, the atmospheric language that Evelyn uses is stunning - it paints such a vivid picture of both London and Neverland. It begs the reader to use their imagination, to immerse themselves completely in the story. I enjoyed the linear timeline of the story in Lost Boy, versus the back-and-forth of Losing Neverland. It allowed for a more natural progression, particularly in the case of Peter, who transforms from a seemingly innocent youth into a jaded and weary adult. Jas Hook enters the picture as an angry, bitter, resentful man. Wendy blossoms from a naive young woman into a married mother of twin girls, but she never forgets her nightly visits from Peter. Tinkerbell was my personal favorite, as she was such a deviant little fae, hell bent on ruining everything between Peter and Wendy.
The characters are well defined in their mannerisms and thought processes, and they practically leap out of your ear buds (or off of the page). In the case of the audiobook, Joe and Maxine seriously nailed every single character, whether main or side. Joe as Peter and as Hook is passionate, truly showing a wide range of voice acting chops. His narration is immersive and evocative, nothing short of what we expect from a Joe Arden performance. Maxine truly stole the show on this one, as both Wendy and Tinkerbell. Her commitment to bringing the vengeful, spiteful side out of Tink was breathtaking! By far one of her best performances, and showcases why she's one of the best in the business.
Highly recommend this audio to anyone who is a fan of retellings, romantasy, and great narration. Thank you to Evelyn and Blue Nose for the opportunity to review the audiobook!
Wow...just wow.
I thought that I was blown away by Losing Neverland, but this story and the bonus content managed to elevate things even more! This story of Peter, Wendy, Hook, and the Neverland crew is not what we grew up on. You think you know what you're getting into, but the story is far removed from what Disney created. There is a plot twist at the very beginning of the book, which I love!, and it sets the scene for the remainder of our story. I loved how Lost Boy built upon what we had already learned in Losing Neverland, and answered some questions that I had about the storyline.
To start, the atmospheric language that Evelyn uses is stunning - it paints such a vivid picture of both London and Neverland. It begs the reader to use their imagination, to immerse themselves completely in the story. I enjoyed the linear timeline of the story in Lost Boy, versus the back-and-forth of Losing Neverland. It allowed for a more natural progression, particularly in the case of Peter, who transforms from a seemingly innocent youth into a jaded and weary adult. Jas Hook enters the picture as an angry, bitter, resentful man. Wendy blossoms from a naive young woman into a married mother of twin girls, but she never forgets her nightly visits from Peter. Tinkerbell was my personal favorite, as she was such a deviant little fae, hell bent on ruining everything between Peter and Wendy.
The characters are well defined in their mannerisms and thought processes, and they practically leap out of your ear buds (or off of the page). In the case of the audiobook, Joe and Maxine seriously nailed every single character, whether main or side. Joe as Peter and as Hook is passionate, truly showing a wide range of voice acting chops. His narration is immersive and evocative, nothing short of what we expect from a Joe Arden performance. Maxine truly stole the show on this one, as both Wendy and Tinkerbell. Her commitment to bringing the vengeful, spiteful side out of Tink was breathtaking! By far one of her best performances, and showcases why she's one of the best in the business.
Highly recommend this audio to anyone who is a fan of retellings, romantasy, and great narration. Thank you to Evelyn and Blue Nose for the opportunity to review the audiobook!
October 3, 2024
I just dipped my toe into Evelyn Montgomery’s dark Peter Pan universe with “Lost Boy”…and I have been in a book hangover since.
I’ve never listened to a dark romantasy story, and how lucky am I to have been fully whisked away to Neverland by way of Maxine Mitchell and Joe Arden? This is a duet style narration and I’d be remiss in saying that the reason I have been brought to audiobooks is because of Maxine and Joe. The clear magic they wield behind their respective mics is spellbinding.
Joe and Maxine navigate this dark Neverland tale with finesse and distinction. Maxine’s Tinkerbell is melodic yet savage; I’ve never heard Maxine in such a role and I’ll be damned if this isn’t one of her best. I had chills each and every time she entered my buds as Tink. Another standout character, though not nearly as present, is Wendy’s mother. The precision in which she delivers this performance is staggering. And Wendy, my stars, she was made for the whimsy and wondrous that consumes the female lead in this universe. The versatility of Maxine in this particular story created such a visual landscape for me as I listened. As always, I am in awe of her very powerful performance.
Of equal magnificence is Joe’s ability to transform a coming of age Peter to a jaded Peter, not to mention his portrayal as a time worn Jas Hook. Joe creates room in his performance for tenderness during scenes as a young Peter experiencing a “first time” moment with Wendy. Joe’s Hook performance commands power, and also hints at some underlying truths in the story. Joe is a master of timing and gravity in his performance. There were many times I felt such a pull in my heart because of how well Joe performed the duality that Peter experiences in wanting to have Wendy in his world and not being able to give up that world to be with her.
Evelyn, this story has become wrapped around my heart and gave me an escape I never knew I needed. As someone who regularly listened to contemporary romance and dark romance, I loved how this fit both genres but was altogether a fantasy story. I was so mesmerized that I truly forgot this was out of my normal repertoire.
Performances: ✨✨✨✨✨
Spice: 🌶️
I’ve never listened to a dark romantasy story, and how lucky am I to have been fully whisked away to Neverland by way of Maxine Mitchell and Joe Arden? This is a duet style narration and I’d be remiss in saying that the reason I have been brought to audiobooks is because of Maxine and Joe. The clear magic they wield behind their respective mics is spellbinding.
Joe and Maxine navigate this dark Neverland tale with finesse and distinction. Maxine’s Tinkerbell is melodic yet savage; I’ve never heard Maxine in such a role and I’ll be damned if this isn’t one of her best. I had chills each and every time she entered my buds as Tink. Another standout character, though not nearly as present, is Wendy’s mother. The precision in which she delivers this performance is staggering. And Wendy, my stars, she was made for the whimsy and wondrous that consumes the female lead in this universe. The versatility of Maxine in this particular story created such a visual landscape for me as I listened. As always, I am in awe of her very powerful performance.
Of equal magnificence is Joe’s ability to transform a coming of age Peter to a jaded Peter, not to mention his portrayal as a time worn Jas Hook. Joe creates room in his performance for tenderness during scenes as a young Peter experiencing a “first time” moment with Wendy. Joe’s Hook performance commands power, and also hints at some underlying truths in the story. Joe is a master of timing and gravity in his performance. There were many times I felt such a pull in my heart because of how well Joe performed the duality that Peter experiences in wanting to have Wendy in his world and not being able to give up that world to be with her.
Evelyn, this story has become wrapped around my heart and gave me an escape I never knew I needed. As someone who regularly listened to contemporary romance and dark romance, I loved how this fit both genres but was altogether a fantasy story. I was so mesmerized that I truly forgot this was out of my normal repertoire.
Performances: ✨✨✨✨✨
Spice: 🌶️
October 2, 2024
Brilliant Story, Retelling & Narration🎧 Escapism at its Best!
Lost Boy
Escapism, Book 2
By: Evelyn Montgomery
Narrated by: Maxine Mitchell, Joe Arden
Wow, Evelyn Montgomery’s unique and fascinating retelling/reimagining of a classic fairytale, puts a whole new spin on Peter Pan and Wendy Moira Angela Darling’s story and it is escapism at its best! She included all the great secondary characters, including Tinker Bell, Wendy’s brothers, other lost boys, the mermaids, and puts an interesting twist on who Jas Hook is. I loved how she paralleled some of J.M. Barrie’s storylines, built on them, making them her own, while adding more of a dark and twisted flare and even more layers to the story. She takes you on a ride, Peter and Wendy’s journey and what a journey it is, lots of twists and turns, unexpected villains and betrayals. There is never a dull moment in this cleverly plotted story, a story that has plenty of drama, angst, twists and turns, some suspenseful moments, heartfelt emotions, and a fated romance. Evelyn Montgomery, thank you for this excellent story and the wild ride.
🎧📚🎧And for the amazing narration, Evelyn Montgomery could not have chosen a better cast to bring her characters to life. Maxine Mitchell and Joe Arden’s performance does not just knock this book out of the park, but out of the stratosphere. No one covers the role of villains like Joe Arden and he delivers a bone chilling performance in that role and all others. Maxine Mitchell is just as amazing as Wendy, showcasing all sides of her personality perfectly and through the ages, too. She also aced it as Tink and all the other secondary characters. Their pacing and tone are spot on and they capture all the characters’ emotions and have you feeling them all. They are entertaining storytellers and their talent knows no bounds. Thank you for another exceptional listen.
Lost Boy
Escapism, Book 2
By: Evelyn Montgomery
Narrated by: Maxine Mitchell, Joe Arden
Wow, Evelyn Montgomery’s unique and fascinating retelling/reimagining of a classic fairytale, puts a whole new spin on Peter Pan and Wendy Moira Angela Darling’s story and it is escapism at its best! She included all the great secondary characters, including Tinker Bell, Wendy’s brothers, other lost boys, the mermaids, and puts an interesting twist on who Jas Hook is. I loved how she paralleled some of J.M. Barrie’s storylines, built on them, making them her own, while adding more of a dark and twisted flare and even more layers to the story. She takes you on a ride, Peter and Wendy’s journey and what a journey it is, lots of twists and turns, unexpected villains and betrayals. There is never a dull moment in this cleverly plotted story, a story that has plenty of drama, angst, twists and turns, some suspenseful moments, heartfelt emotions, and a fated romance. Evelyn Montgomery, thank you for this excellent story and the wild ride.
🎧📚🎧And for the amazing narration, Evelyn Montgomery could not have chosen a better cast to bring her characters to life. Maxine Mitchell and Joe Arden’s performance does not just knock this book out of the park, but out of the stratosphere. No one covers the role of villains like Joe Arden and he delivers a bone chilling performance in that role and all others. Maxine Mitchell is just as amazing as Wendy, showcasing all sides of her personality perfectly and through the ages, too. She also aced it as Tink and all the other secondary characters. Their pacing and tone are spot on and they capture all the characters’ emotions and have you feeling them all. They are entertaining storytellers and their talent knows no bounds. Thank you for another exceptional listen.
October 22, 2024
** Note**
I was given the amazing opportunity to be able to review two versions of this story. Losing Neverland is the darker copy full of triggers (please check trigger warnings before proceeding) while Lost Boy is the extended and trigger free version. That being said, some parts of my review may sound familiar.
Lost Boy is a retelling of J.M. Barrie’s classic story, Peter Pan and Wendy. However, this isn’t your typical fairytale, it’s dark with twists and a rather large secret. You know that story that is loved by many and has been told many times in a variety of ways? Everything you know about the boy who wouldn’t grow up and the notorious captain is about to change. Grab some pixie dust, set your sights on the second star to the right and straight on till morning, and get ready to view this classic story a little bit differently.
The concept of this is fantastic! I love a great twist in a retelling of a classic tale. While I love a good guy hero, give me anti-hero who gets the girl any day. This dark romantasy is thrilling, it’s hot and spicy, and edgy. I had some issues with Losing Neverland and some holes in the story, but Lost Boy changed everything. I couldn’t stop listening to this audiobook.
Want to know why I couldn’t stop listening? It’s because of the amazing work of narrators Joe Arden and Maxine Mitchell! Every time these two step into the booth and record duet style, they make pure magic. They masterfully crafted a new life in Lost Boy. Listeners get every wicked laugh of Captain Hook to the boyish charm of Peter Pan from Joe Arden as he seamlessly switched from the dark side to the light. With our leading lady, Maxine Mitchell flawlessly brings Wendy Darling to life. From all of her hurt and pain, both past and present to her childlike wonder of Neverland. I can’t wait to see what these two do next!
I was given the amazing opportunity to be able to review two versions of this story. Losing Neverland is the darker copy full of triggers (please check trigger warnings before proceeding) while Lost Boy is the extended and trigger free version. That being said, some parts of my review may sound familiar.
Lost Boy is a retelling of J.M. Barrie’s classic story, Peter Pan and Wendy. However, this isn’t your typical fairytale, it’s dark with twists and a rather large secret. You know that story that is loved by many and has been told many times in a variety of ways? Everything you know about the boy who wouldn’t grow up and the notorious captain is about to change. Grab some pixie dust, set your sights on the second star to the right and straight on till morning, and get ready to view this classic story a little bit differently.
The concept of this is fantastic! I love a great twist in a retelling of a classic tale. While I love a good guy hero, give me anti-hero who gets the girl any day. This dark romantasy is thrilling, it’s hot and spicy, and edgy. I had some issues with Losing Neverland and some holes in the story, but Lost Boy changed everything. I couldn’t stop listening to this audiobook.
Want to know why I couldn’t stop listening? It’s because of the amazing work of narrators Joe Arden and Maxine Mitchell! Every time these two step into the booth and record duet style, they make pure magic. They masterfully crafted a new life in Lost Boy. Listeners get every wicked laugh of Captain Hook to the boyish charm of Peter Pan from Joe Arden as he seamlessly switched from the dark side to the light. With our leading lady, Maxine Mitchell flawlessly brings Wendy Darling to life. From all of her hurt and pain, both past and present to her childlike wonder of Neverland. I can’t wait to see what these two do next!
October 12, 2024
Lost Boy written by Evelyn Montgomery takes us deeper into Peter and Wendy’s back story. I particularly liked how Evelyn wove the past and present intricately from all the characters perspectives, Peter/Hook, Wendy and we can’t forget Tinker Bell! Oh and couple other characters surprised me too!
The vulnerabilities of the characters are shared with us the reader/listener as Peter and Wendy embrace their unique experience together and take us on the journey that is Lost Boy. We see all the tension, conflict and tenderness you’d expect as they explore their feelings and emotions for each other. Love is not meant to be easy.
I do feel Peter was a little selfish at times, however both he and Wendy learned from each other as they strengthened their bond of trust.
The incredible performances from Maxine Mitchell and Joe Arden portraying the intense darkness and emotional turmoil of Peter and Wendy, had my headphones glued to my head! I didn’t want to stop listening. The transitioning between all the characters from Maxine and Joe is fantastic as always, in particular capturing the personalities of Wendy/Tinker Bell, Peter/Hook.
Thank you Evelyn for crafting this extended trigger-free version that has captivated and taken me on an incredible adventure! Having also read/listened to Losing Neverland I feel this has enhanced my enjoyment of this series.
The vulnerabilities of the characters are shared with us the reader/listener as Peter and Wendy embrace their unique experience together and take us on the journey that is Lost Boy. We see all the tension, conflict and tenderness you’d expect as they explore their feelings and emotions for each other. Love is not meant to be easy.
I do feel Peter was a little selfish at times, however both he and Wendy learned from each other as they strengthened their bond of trust.
The incredible performances from Maxine Mitchell and Joe Arden portraying the intense darkness and emotional turmoil of Peter and Wendy, had my headphones glued to my head! I didn’t want to stop listening. The transitioning between all the characters from Maxine and Joe is fantastic as always, in particular capturing the personalities of Wendy/Tinker Bell, Peter/Hook.
Thank you Evelyn for crafting this extended trigger-free version that has captivated and taken me on an incredible adventure! Having also read/listened to Losing Neverland I feel this has enhanced my enjoyment of this series.
October 8, 2024
I have listened to both Lost Boy and Losing Neverland, and what I loved most about this book is the order of the chapters. I love how we got the backstory of Wendy and Peter before moving on to the "present day." I thought the pacing of this book was done very well. There was so much more to the story that drew me, and things I missed became clearer. Diving in deeper to their past gave me a sense of their future. All of the missing pieces started to come together. I loved the twists and turns of who each character was in this retelling. Jake, especially, that one threw me for a loop in both books and was not expecting it and learning more about the situation in this book was really cool.
I love that there is a trigger free book for this series. It did not take away from the overall story and was done really well. While I love spice and don't mind most triggers, I loved how the main focus was the story while also not losing the balance of romantic chemistry between Wendy and Peter.
The audio of this book was just as on point as Losing Neverland. Dual narration for this book was perfect. Maxine Mitchell's Tinkerbell gets me every time. I love it! And I loved how Joe Arden so easily swapped between Hook's personality and Peter's. It was flawless.
I love that there is a trigger free book for this series. It did not take away from the overall story and was done really well. While I love spice and don't mind most triggers, I loved how the main focus was the story while also not losing the balance of romantic chemistry between Wendy and Peter.
The audio of this book was just as on point as Losing Neverland. Dual narration for this book was perfect. Maxine Mitchell's Tinkerbell gets me every time. I love it! And I loved how Joe Arden so easily swapped between Hook's personality and Peter's. It was flawless.
October 8, 2024
Lost Boy is a trigger-free, extended version, of Losing Neverland and what I loved most about this book is the order of the chapters and how everything flowed so smoothly. I love how we got more of the backstory of Wendy and Peter before switching to the "present day." There was so much more to the story in this one and that drew me back in, and I feel like things that I missed, became a little clearer. Diving in deeper to their past gave me a sense of their future and some of the missing pieces started falling into place. I loved the twists and turns of who each character was in this retelling! Jake, especially, threw me for a loop in both books which I was not expecting and then learning more about the situation in this book was really intriguing.
I love that there is a trigger free book included in this series. It didn’t take away from the overall story and was done quite well in my opinion. While I love spice and don't really have any triggers, I loved how the main focus was the story, while also not losing the balance of romantic chemistry between Wendy and Peter in the process.
The audio of this book was just as perfect as Losing Neverland and the duet narration for this book was on point. Maxine’s Tink gets me every time! I absolutely love it! And I love how Joe Arden can so effortlessly transition between Peter’s personality and Hook’s. It was flawless and I loved every second of this extended audio!
I love that there is a trigger free book included in this series. It didn’t take away from the overall story and was done quite well in my opinion. While I love spice and don't really have any triggers, I loved how the main focus was the story, while also not losing the balance of romantic chemistry between Wendy and Peter in the process.
The audio of this book was just as perfect as Losing Neverland and the duet narration for this book was on point. Maxine’s Tink gets me every time! I absolutely love it! And I love how Joe Arden can so effortlessly transition between Peter’s personality and Hook’s. It was flawless and I loved every second of this extended audio!
October 14, 2024
Lost Boy by Evelyn Montgomery offers a deeper, richer understanding of Wendy and Peter’s story, while shedding more light on Tinkerbell's role. Having already read Losing Neverland, I found that Lost Boy not only filled in many of the gaps but also delivered a few surprises that took me off guard. Evelyn thoughtfully marks the chapters that are different than Losing Neverland, but even in the other chapters, there are nuances and important details that bring more depth to the story.
Evelyn’s writing continues to beautifully capture the raw intensity of Peter and Wendy’s connection, their inner struggles, and the profound themes of love and forgiveness. The emotional weight of the characters makes this a book you can’t easily walk away from. Maxine and Joe, as always, deliver absolutely stunning performances in the audiobook—some of their most powerful work yet, in my opinion.
My only small critique is that Lost Boy feels like the version of the story that should be experienced first. If you're only following the asterisked chapters, you're missing so many key moments that add richness to the entire narrative, as well as will be important to understanding Saving Tink.
Evelyn’s writing continues to beautifully capture the raw intensity of Peter and Wendy’s connection, their inner struggles, and the profound themes of love and forgiveness. The emotional weight of the characters makes this a book you can’t easily walk away from. Maxine and Joe, as always, deliver absolutely stunning performances in the audiobook—some of their most powerful work yet, in my opinion.
My only small critique is that Lost Boy feels like the version of the story that should be experienced first. If you're only following the asterisked chapters, you're missing so many key moments that add richness to the entire narrative, as well as will be important to understanding Saving Tink.
October 5, 2024
I'm obsessed with this book!! From start to finish this book kept me enthralled the entire time. For fans of Peter Pan you will want to read/listen to this retelling. When Peter Pan discovers that he has forbidden magic he must decide if he will stay in London, or escape to a whole new world. Leaving means leaving Wendy Darling behind. However, Peter Pan decides to steal Wendy away one day, which makes Tinker Bell's jealousy grow. Then the lost boys, mermaids and fae start to work against him.
Evelyn is a new to me author. I love her storytelling style. She included lots of parallels from the original Peter Pan, but also included her own spin on the tale. Told in multiple povs. I thought that it was great to add the other perspectives because I got to understand the characters on a deeper, emotional level. The character development was great. The pacing of the story was well done. There was never a dull moment.
As for the audiobook narration, it was incredible! Performed in duet narration by Joe Arden and Maxine Mitchell. They were perfect as Peter Pan and Wendy. Joe conveyed Peter Pan with so much heart. He showed Peter's carefree attitude and portrayed his love for Wendy with so much emotion. Maxine conveyed Wendy with a soft tone and I loved how she voiced Tinker Bell and Tiger Lily. There was distinct tones for both. Maxine captured Tinker Bell's jealousy and brattiness. Together Joe and Maxine brought this story and characters to life.
Coming soon to audio!!
Thank you to bluenoseaudio for my ALC in exchange for an honest review.
Evelyn is a new to me author. I love her storytelling style. She included lots of parallels from the original Peter Pan, but also included her own spin on the tale. Told in multiple povs. I thought that it was great to add the other perspectives because I got to understand the characters on a deeper, emotional level. The character development was great. The pacing of the story was well done. There was never a dull moment.
As for the audiobook narration, it was incredible! Performed in duet narration by Joe Arden and Maxine Mitchell. They were perfect as Peter Pan and Wendy. Joe conveyed Peter Pan with so much heart. He showed Peter's carefree attitude and portrayed his love for Wendy with so much emotion. Maxine conveyed Wendy with a soft tone and I loved how she voiced Tinker Bell and Tiger Lily. There was distinct tones for both. Maxine captured Tinker Bell's jealousy and brattiness. Together Joe and Maxine brought this story and characters to life.
Coming soon to audio!!
Thank you to bluenoseaudio for my ALC in exchange for an honest review.
October 1, 2024
So Evelyn goes a step further than Losing Neverland and takes off all the trigger barriers to give us an even more raw, more grisly and more darker read. It's the same story but no holds barred. I loved the first one so liking this was a given. I'm a dark reader and this book spoke to me at a deeper level.
I enjoyed Joe and Maxine again and would love to read more Evelyn books
5 stars
Follow me on:
Email🌻 Bookbub 🌻 Twitter🌻 Instagram🌻 Blog🌻 Facebook🌻 Amazon 🌻
I enjoyed Joe and Maxine again and would love to read more Evelyn books
5 stars
Follow me on:
Email🌻 Bookbub 🌻 Twitter🌻 Instagram🌻 Blog🌻 Facebook🌻 Amazon 🌻
October 8, 2024
Lost Boy, the trigger-free extended version of Evelyn Montgomery’s Losing Neverland because I wasn’t sure what was going to be removed. I thought maybe taking out some of those intense moments might change how I viewed the story.
But boy was I wrong! Yes, things were changed, but SO MUCH was added and enhanced!
What I loved most about this story was the deeper dive into Peter and Wendy’s story! Evelyn does a beautiful job of crafting characters in a way that we can recognize these iconic characters as we’ve known them but adding in touches of uniqueness and an extra level of complexity that makes the experience so enthralling!
Like in LN, Joe Arden and Maxine Mitchell reach new heights with their performances in Lost Boy. There is so much nuance to the way they craft these characters and it elevates the moments of sincerity and quiet just as much as it does the action-packed suspenseful ones!
But boy was I wrong! Yes, things were changed, but SO MUCH was added and enhanced!
What I loved most about this story was the deeper dive into Peter and Wendy’s story! Evelyn does a beautiful job of crafting characters in a way that we can recognize these iconic characters as we’ve known them but adding in touches of uniqueness and an extra level of complexity that makes the experience so enthralling!
Like in LN, Joe Arden and Maxine Mitchell reach new heights with their performances in Lost Boy. There is so much nuance to the way they craft these characters and it elevates the moments of sincerity and quiet just as much as it does the action-packed suspenseful ones!
October 8, 2024
Evelyn Montgomery! Ma’am, you gave us readers even more and I am here for it. Lost boys has more story to tell minus the triggers. Peter and Wendy’s relationship has more to it than what we got in Losing Neverland. The pull between them is strong, but so is the pull to Neverland. What will Peter do? 20 years of walls, of pain, of want. Tink acts as a puppeteer holding all the strings and she doesn’t like it if those strings are cut. Her vengeance is fierce. “I do love playing tricks, and Wendy was always my favorite ruse.”-Tink
This story had so much more than I expected. And to listen to it was captivating. Maxine Mitchell and Joe Arden captivate us with their talented voices. Maxine’s Tink is my favorite voice of hers to date I think. Joe really delivers a yearning and heartbreaking voice to Peter that gives us all the feels. Magnificent work and I am just wowed by their capabilities! Blue Nose Audio knows how to deliver a great duet narration production.
This story had so much more than I expected. And to listen to it was captivating. Maxine Mitchell and Joe Arden captivate us with their talented voices. Maxine’s Tink is my favorite voice of hers to date I think. Joe really delivers a yearning and heartbreaking voice to Peter that gives us all the feels. Magnificent work and I am just wowed by their capabilities! Blue Nose Audio knows how to deliver a great duet narration production.
February 23, 2025
Tropes
First Love
Fae
Peter Pan Retelling
Touch her and died
Lovers to Enemies to Lovers
Second chance
Fated Mates
“Wendy, I’ve finally realized, I was never lost,” my brow furrows as I study him, and he smiles. “Everything I’ve ever known began with you. As long as I have you, I’ll never be lost,” he smiles and leans in closer. “I found what I was looking for. You. It’s always been you. Because loving you? It’s like coming home”
The Lost Boy is an extended version of Losing Neverland (trigger-free). I did not realize that this book was really an expanded version of the original one when I started reading it. I wish I could go back in time and completely omit the first book. It would have been fantastic if she had never begun the other book and instead had started with this one. I thought this book was fantastic. Even though Peter Pan and Wendy’s love tale was heartbreaking at times, I loved it. This book provided me with a great retelling of Peter Pan, which I like. I’m happy I continued with the series and gave it another shot. I was captivated by this tale. I’m hoping that book three is just as good.
First Love
Fae
Peter Pan Retelling
Touch her and died
Lovers to Enemies to Lovers
Second chance
Fated Mates
“Wendy, I’ve finally realized, I was never lost,” my brow furrows as I study him, and he smiles. “Everything I’ve ever known began with you. As long as I have you, I’ll never be lost,” he smiles and leans in closer. “I found what I was looking for. You. It’s always been you. Because loving you? It’s like coming home”
The Lost Boy is an extended version of Losing Neverland (trigger-free). I did not realize that this book was really an expanded version of the original one when I started reading it. I wish I could go back in time and completely omit the first book. It would have been fantastic if she had never begun the other book and instead had started with this one. I thought this book was fantastic. Even though Peter Pan and Wendy’s love tale was heartbreaking at times, I loved it. This book provided me with a great retelling of Peter Pan, which I like. I’m happy I continued with the series and gave it another shot. I was captivated by this tale. I’m hoping that book three is just as good.
October 8, 2024
AUDIOBOOK REVIEW:
Lost Boy is book 2 in the Escapism series. It's exactly what the title says...an extended trigger free version of Losing Neverland. Lost Boy is still a dark romantasy with plenty of steam, but cleaned up a bit to make it a shade of gray. This is a version of Peter and Wendy that is NOT the Disney version, so get that image out of your head to start with. It is like 'the rest of the story" 17 years after Wendy leaves Neverland. It's gritty with plot twists, intrigue, suspense...just a fresh take on the story we all know. Bravo, Ms. Montgomery, for providing a trigger-free version so everyone can enjoy this gem!
The narration for this is still Joe Arden and Maxine Mitchell. They are absolutely the perfect pair to voice Peter and Wendy (and the plethora of other characters in the story). Loved them. 5/5 stars!
Lost Boy is book 2 in the Escapism series. It's exactly what the title says...an extended trigger free version of Losing Neverland. Lost Boy is still a dark romantasy with plenty of steam, but cleaned up a bit to make it a shade of gray. This is a version of Peter and Wendy that is NOT the Disney version, so get that image out of your head to start with. It is like 'the rest of the story" 17 years after Wendy leaves Neverland. It's gritty with plot twists, intrigue, suspense...just a fresh take on the story we all know. Bravo, Ms. Montgomery, for providing a trigger-free version so everyone can enjoy this gem!
The narration for this is still Joe Arden and Maxine Mitchell. They are absolutely the perfect pair to voice Peter and Wendy (and the plethora of other characters in the story). Loved them. 5/5 stars!
October 8, 2024
I wish I liked this more. The duet narration/performance was outstanding. But it wasn’t enough to make me enjoy the confusing story. It ended and I am still not even sure what happened at any point. But I I’ll never forget it that they were separated for “seventeen years” or “nearly two decades”, the latter making more sense since it had to be longer than 17 years as she had 17 year old daughters and hadn’t seen Peter/Hook since before she even knew she was pregnant. Is that a petty complaint? Maybe, but it was irritating as hell.
Maxine and Joe were phenomenal, as always. Each giving life to many characters they distinct and recognizable.
But had I picked this up on my own and not an ALC, I would have given up on it about 20% in.
Maxine and Joe were phenomenal, as always. Each giving life to many characters they distinct and recognizable.
But had I picked this up on my own and not an ALC, I would have given up on it about 20% in.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 9, 2024
This book is an extended trigger-free version of Losing Neverland and I've been hooked from the start! Lost Boy introduces us to new characters and we learn more about the past of Peter and Wendy.
I have had the privilege of receiving an ALC from Bluenose audio. Performed in duet by Joe Arden and Maxine Mitchell, the narration is perfection as always. Joe is so talented when he has to play characters that are edgy or vulnerables like Hook and young Peter. This is the first time I hear Maxine play a jealous and nasty character like Tinkerbell and OMG! She's phenomenal! And her young Wendy, her voice is so pure and innocent. She blow my mind! We understand why we call her Queen Maxine. Also the breathing, wimpers and laughing add so much to the story as a listener.
If I could I would give more than 5 stars!
I have had the privilege of receiving an ALC from Bluenose audio. Performed in duet by Joe Arden and Maxine Mitchell, the narration is perfection as always. Joe is so talented when he has to play characters that are edgy or vulnerables like Hook and young Peter. This is the first time I hear Maxine play a jealous and nasty character like Tinkerbell and OMG! She's phenomenal! And her young Wendy, her voice is so pure and innocent. She blow my mind! We understand why we call her Queen Maxine. Also the breathing, wimpers and laughing add so much to the story as a listener.
If I could I would give more than 5 stars!
October 7, 2024
I’m a sloot for Peter Pan retellings and this was such a good one! It was fast paced, plot driven, swoon worthy, and really pulled at your heart strings for the love Wendy and Peter had for each other. This was definitely a different spin on the story of Wendy and Peter and I would say if you enjoy Romantasy books then I highly suggest picking this copy up!
Thanks to Blue Nose Audio I was able to listen to this in audio with Maxine Mitchell and Joe Arden. Evelyn is an amazing story teller, and these two narrators in duet style really brought Evelyn’s story to life. They were absolutely PHENOMENAL!
Thanks to Blue Nose Audio I was able to listen to this in audio with Maxine Mitchell and Joe Arden. Evelyn is an amazing story teller, and these two narrators in duet style really brought Evelyn’s story to life. They were absolutely PHENOMENAL!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 59 reviews