What do you think?
Rate this book
Lily Of The Valley
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31 reviews
October 6, 2025
Why nice art if all else bad?
This was unhinged. I am not even going to bother going into much detail; just the most toxic and abusive situation with pointless suffering that didn’t really have any purpose. Then at the end it gets worst. The plot was nearly non-existent, the characters were barely 2-dimensional and………just ugh.
I kept reading because I was wondering if it would get better at the end and it was short.
This was unhinged. I am not even going to bother going into much detail; just the most toxic and abusive situation with pointless suffering that didn’t really have any purpose. Then at the end it gets worst. The plot was nearly non-existent, the characters were barely 2-dimensional and………just ugh.
I kept reading because I was wondering if it would get better at the end and it was short.
March 12, 2025
cough i definitely didn't cry over a manhwa that's basically ntr corn... BUT I FEEL SO BAD FOR ANNA?? LILY DOES NOT DESERVE HER AT ALL JUST GO BACK TO ROSE AND ENJOY YOUR FAKE LOVE
this is an absolute mockery of a gl and i'm SICK of seeing gl so sexualized
i might be overanalyzing because i genuinely think the author just meant this to be ntr corn but if i were trying to make light of this, it actually has a pretty good deeper meaning behind it. the whole ending with lily regretting her choice when she chooses rose over anna is so deserved. she's so fucking annoying and can't realize that love isn't perfect and sometimes you actually have to try and suffer a little bit to get real love. she ends up stuck with rose and crazy harem and replaces what she could have had with anna for fake love with rose.
but honestly, i think that's overanalyzing a little bit, im pretty sure this is just pure corn... shame the art is beautiful
this is an absolute mockery of a gl and i'm SICK of seeing gl so sexualized
i might be overanalyzing because i genuinely think the author just meant this to be ntr corn but if i were trying to make light of this, it actually has a pretty good deeper meaning behind it. the whole ending with lily regretting her choice when she chooses rose over anna is so deserved. she's so fucking annoying and can't realize that love isn't perfect and sometimes you actually have to try and suffer a little bit to get real love. she ends up stuck with rose and crazy harem and replaces what she could have had with anna for fake love with rose.
but honestly, i think that's overanalyzing a little bit, im pretty sure this is just pure corn... shame the art is beautiful
April 7, 2025
-1 estrella
No pierdan el tiempo leyendo esto como yo lo hice por favor !!!!!
No pierdan el tiempo leyendo esto como yo lo hice por favor !!!!!
December 14, 2024
Read enough to say this was garbage
November 14, 2024
this is shit lol
October 9, 2025
Beautiful art, and could’ve been an interesting and good turn around story. Unfortunately this author writes for a certain weird audience so.. yeah
*Read this last year, just found out it’s on here*
*Read this last year, just found out it’s on here*
March 20, 2025
i genuinely don’t even want to rate this 1 star it’s that bad
September 13, 2025
the low rating is because yall homophobic asf this yurislop was fire!!
August 16, 2025
I don't like fl, like how she chose the red flag😔🙏
April 13, 2025
Pros - the art was beautiful. Details of clothing, facial expressions, bodies, etc- fantastic.
The story itself is supposed to be more of a physiological mind game fuckery- and if you’re looking for that then congrats! You found a decent story lol. But… caution to those who are not.
I always try to do no spoiler reviews so- I feel like I can’t really go in depth into why I wasn’t a big fan of this… mostly cause I didn’t get the ending I wanted. Judging from other reviews here - I’m not the only one lol. Anyway- 5/10. It’s alright. Wouldn’t read again.
The story itself is supposed to be more of a physiological mind game fuckery- and if you’re looking for that then congrats! You found a decent story lol. But… caution to those who are not.
I always try to do no spoiler reviews so- I feel like I can’t really go in depth into why I wasn’t a big fan of this… mostly cause I didn’t get the ending I wanted. Judging from other reviews here - I’m not the only one lol. Anyway- 5/10. It’s alright. Wouldn’t read again.
June 12, 2025
No. Just no. Let me take care of Anna and I'll think about it.
In all seriousness, the art is beautiful, as always. But the story was not really it. It has the themes of manipulation, abuse, and the likes. It didn't give the happy ending that I was wishing for but that's just me. This manhwa is not for me.
In all seriousness, the art is beautiful, as always. But the story was not really it. It has the themes of manipulation, abuse, and the likes. It didn't give the happy ending that I was wishing for but that's just me. This manhwa is not for me.
January 30, 2025
Si la falta de afecto familiar, la baja autoestima, la indecisión y la incapacidad para pensar de forma cuerda se juntaran, esta cosa sería el resultado. No esperaba nada, y aun así, salí decepcionada. Horrible.
January 5, 2026
Art: 5/5 stars
Full color, fully rendered with a 3d effect and hyper-realistic backgrounds. Did the mangaka sell their soul?
Story: 4.5/5
I didn't expect the ending, mostly because of clichés. Very happy about the surprise.
Characters: 4/5
I really liked Anna, especially the way she contributed to positively surprising ending. Saw myself in her.
Themes: 5/5
The execution of the question "what is love? Is it romance or pleasure? Or both?" is really really well done here. Especially how there's no clear answer and left for the reader to decide, as well as highlighting how different it is for everyone, including all three main characters.
~
I could rate it 5 stars, but I didn't like that one hetero sex scene, so minus 0.25 stars it is. Luckily it was very short. :')
Overall very recommended. It has GL smut, gorgeous art, deep characters especially for that length, ace rep, psychological exploration, good writing, breaking from clichés, polyamory, harem, and is so short you can read it in one go. Deserves to be sold in bookstores.
-Ayxan Solongo, 14.10.25
Full color, fully rendered with a 3d effect and hyper-realistic backgrounds. Did the mangaka sell their soul?
Story: 4.5/5
I didn't expect the ending, mostly because of clichés. Very happy about the surprise.
Characters: 4/5
I really liked Anna, especially the way she contributed to positively surprising ending. Saw myself in her.
Themes: 5/5
The execution of the question "what is love? Is it romance or pleasure? Or both?" is really really well done here. Especially how there's no clear answer and left for the reader to decide, as well as highlighting how different it is for everyone, including all three main characters.
~
I could rate it 5 stars, but I didn't like that one hetero sex scene, so minus 0.25 stars it is. Luckily it was very short. :')
Overall very recommended. It has GL smut, gorgeous art, deep characters especially for that length, ace rep, psychological exploration, good writing, breaking from clichés, polyamory, harem, and is so short you can read it in one go. Deserves to be sold in bookstores.
-Ayxan Solongo, 14.10.25
March 13, 2025
3.5⭐
QUE RABIA QUE LILY NO SE HAYA DADO CUENTA ANTES POR FAVOR ES TAN INGENUA.
No es culpa de Lily la manipulación que sufrió por Rose, pero fue su decisión quedarse, debiste creerle a Anna, ella no te quería dolo para algo sexual, siento que literal es como la frase de "si me amas entonces dame esto" refiriéndose a tener sexo.
QUE RABIA QUE LILY NO SE HAYA DADO CUENTA ANTES POR FAVOR ES TAN INGENUA.
No es culpa de Lily la manipulación que sufrió por Rose, pero fue su decisión quedarse, debiste creerle a Anna, ella no te quería dolo para algo sexual, siento que literal es como la frase de "si me amas entonces dame esto" refiriéndose a tener sexo.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 21, 2025
I read this so long ago, I can’t even rmb the date….
I kinda feel like she had a vision yk? AND I SAW THE VISION—it’s just that it feels like she was going in a decent direction and then decided to take a huge fucking U-turn….
the author just executes shit HORRIBLY and it pains me bcs she has such a good art style 😭😭.
AND DONT GET ME STARTED ON THE ENDING. BFFR.
I kinda feel like she had a vision yk? AND I SAW THE VISION—it’s just that it feels like she was going in a decent direction and then decided to take a huge fucking U-turn….
the author just executes shit HORRIBLY and it pains me bcs she has such a good art style 😭😭.
AND DONT GET ME STARTED ON THE ENDING. BFFR.
October 19, 2024
Qué final de mrda 🙂
December 16, 2024
Romance?????? No hubo tal romance
February 13, 2025
Me pareció interesante. Pero me dió pena mucho la otra protagonista. Pero bueno.
Read
February 18, 2025anna merecía más, no merecía nada de eso
March 19, 2025
hmm im not sure what to rate this.. 2.75⭐️?
May 20, 2025
anna, choose me, i swear i'm not like lily plssssss
June 12, 2025
Ugh 🙄
July 14, 2025
Too much drama, but the drawing style is beautiful and sex scenes are hot.
After abandoning toxic BL will I fall into a trap of toxic GL. Who knows? (Definitely. Please, stop)
After abandoning toxic BL will I fall into a trap of toxic GL. Who knows? (Definitely. Please, stop)
August 31, 2025
el dibujo es hermoso como siempre, pero me gustaria qué le dedicara más tiempo a pensar en las tramas de sus manhwas.
October 19, 2025
worst manhwa I've ever read
November 20, 2025
me enojo de solo pensar en como terminó
December 29, 2025
Me sorprendió el final
December 31, 2025
WHAT WAS TS AAFFFFFFGGG ANNA IL CHERISHYOU
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31 reviews