What do you think?
Rate this book
Mistaken Identity at the Storyteller's Cottage
Welcome, guest, to The Storyteller's Cottage!
Inside these walls are the testimonies of hundreds of couples who have stayed here, each detailing their stories of finding true love. Do not take this lightly! Open your heart to the possibility of love, and let the legend do the rest!
~
Sheriff Becker Quinn liked his small town just the way it was. The last thing he needed was city-folk traipsing in and wreaking havoc. On Christmas Eve, as he responded to the call of a suspicious vehicle, the last thing he expected to find was a feisty woman sleeping in her car.
When Lenny Heckman purchased the small-town bakery in Avonbury, sight unseen, she hadn’t expected her introduction to the cozy little town to be spent behind bars. It didn’t help matters that the grumpy, sexy Sheriff had the appearance of a smoldering, untamed mountain man.
As Lenny settles into the legendary Storyteller’s Cottage, finding herself irresistibly drawn into its enchanting myth of guests discovering love within its walls, and despite butting heads, she’s also drawn to Sheriff Quinn.
When Lenny falls deliriously sick, it's Becker who comes to her rescue. The gentleness he exudes is something Lenny's not familiar with, and quickly doesn't want to let go of.
Perhaps starting over in Avonbury was the right choice after all...
~
All books in The Storyteller's Cottage series are set in the enchanting town of Avonbury, and the focal point is the magical Storyteller's Cottage. However, in each book, readers will be introduced to entirely new main characters, making each story a complete standalone. Reading the books in order is not a requirement. However, to truly capture the ongoing magic of Storyteller's Cottage, it is advised to delve into each and every book in the series!
Inside these walls are the testimonies of hundreds of couples who have stayed here, each detailing their stories of finding true love. Do not take this lightly! Open your heart to the possibility of love, and let the legend do the rest!
~
Sheriff Becker Quinn liked his small town just the way it was. The last thing he needed was city-folk traipsing in and wreaking havoc. On Christmas Eve, as he responded to the call of a suspicious vehicle, the last thing he expected to find was a feisty woman sleeping in her car.
When Lenny Heckman purchased the small-town bakery in Avonbury, sight unseen, she hadn’t expected her introduction to the cozy little town to be spent behind bars. It didn’t help matters that the grumpy, sexy Sheriff had the appearance of a smoldering, untamed mountain man.
As Lenny settles into the legendary Storyteller’s Cottage, finding herself irresistibly drawn into its enchanting myth of guests discovering love within its walls, and despite butting heads, she’s also drawn to Sheriff Quinn.
When Lenny falls deliriously sick, it's Becker who comes to her rescue. The gentleness he exudes is something Lenny's not familiar with, and quickly doesn't want to let go of.
Perhaps starting over in Avonbury was the right choice after all...
~
All books in The Storyteller's Cottage series are set in the enchanting town of Avonbury, and the focal point is the magical Storyteller's Cottage. However, in each book, readers will be introduced to entirely new main characters, making each story a complete standalone. Reading the books in order is not a requirement. However, to truly capture the ongoing magic of Storyteller's Cottage, it is advised to delve into each and every book in the series!
119 pages, Kindle Edition
Published December 3, 2024
5 people are currently reading
54 people want to read
About the author
Nalani Titcomb
19 books66 followersNalani Titcomb was born and raised on the beautiful Islands of Hawaii. She’s a single mother to an amazing son, whom she says is her greatest accomplishment. Family and faith are most important to her. Nalani began her writing journey after Hawaii went into its second complete lockdown during the Covid19 pandemic and self-published her first book, The Dark Side of Paradise, in 2020.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 127 reviews
December 4, 2024
This was way more than I expected.
How the author managed to cram so much pining, banter and heat into just over 100 pages I will never know, but I was here for it!
I am excited that this little novella is the start of a series in this cute small town setting and I will definitely be seeking out the next book!
Much love to Nalani Titcomb & Happily Booked PR for my ARC.
How the author managed to cram so much pining, banter and heat into just over 100 pages I will never know, but I was here for it!
I am excited that this little novella is the start of a series in this cute small town setting and I will definitely be seeking out the next book!
Much love to Nalani Titcomb & Happily Booked PR for my ARC.
December 11, 2024
I received this novella thanks to @happilybookedpr and @nalanititcomb and it was so good!!
Loved how Lenny and Becker met and their banter. Plus it has insta swoon moments.. like him taking care of her when she gets sick!
This is a perfect option for a fun quick read to get into the holiday/ winter mood! Lenny and Becker have a fun meet cute and I was laughing by the end of it! Lots of fun rom-com-y moments and I enjoyed every second of this book!
Plus it has insta swoon moments.. like him taking care of her when she gets sick (after he finds her doing something bizarre in the front yard… haha)
This was so cute, but I WANT MORE!!!! I want to know what happens next!! Like what suspense plot could we have for a book 2? Bakery burglar? Scone swiper?? There has to be a book 2.. PLEASE??!!
What to expect:
Novella
Christmas Romance
Forced Proximity
One Bed
Small Town
Starting Over
Hilarious Meet Cute
Banter
Blurb
Welcome, guest, to The Storyteller’s Cottage!
Inside these walls are the testimonies of hundreds of couples who have stayed here, each detailing their stories of finding true love. Do not take this lightly! Open your heart to the possibility of love, and let the legend do the rest!
~~~
Sheriff Becker Quinn liked his small town just the way it was. The last thing he needed was city-folk traipsing in and wreaking havoc. On Christmas Eve, as he responded to the call of a suspicious vehicle, the last thing he expected to find was a feisty woman sleeping in her car.
When Lenny Heckman purchased the small-town bakery in Avonbury, sight unseen, she hadn’t expected her introduction to the cozy little town to be spent behind bars. It didn’t help matters that the grumpy, sexy Sheriff had the appearance of a smoldering, untamed mountain man.
As Lenny settles into the legendary Storyteller’s Cottage, finding herself irresistibly drawn into its enchanting myth of guests discovering love within its walls, and despite butting heads, she’s also drawn to Sheriff Quinn.
When Lenny falls deliriously sick, it’s Becker who comes to her rescue. The gentleness he exudes is something Lenny’s not familiar with, and quickly doesn’t want to let go of.
Perhaps starting over in Avonbury was the right choice after all…
Ebook- ARC COPY
Loved how Lenny and Becker met and their banter. Plus it has insta swoon moments.. like him taking care of her when she gets sick!
This is a perfect option for a fun quick read to get into the holiday/ winter mood! Lenny and Becker have a fun meet cute and I was laughing by the end of it! Lots of fun rom-com-y moments and I enjoyed every second of this book!
Plus it has insta swoon moments.. like him taking care of her when she gets sick (after he finds her doing something bizarre in the front yard… haha)
This was so cute, but I WANT MORE!!!! I want to know what happens next!! Like what suspense plot could we have for a book 2? Bakery burglar? Scone swiper?? There has to be a book 2.. PLEASE??!!
What to expect:
Novella
Christmas Romance
Forced Proximity
One Bed
Small Town
Starting Over
Hilarious Meet Cute
Banter
Blurb
Welcome, guest, to The Storyteller’s Cottage!
Inside these walls are the testimonies of hundreds of couples who have stayed here, each detailing their stories of finding true love. Do not take this lightly! Open your heart to the possibility of love, and let the legend do the rest!
~~~
Sheriff Becker Quinn liked his small town just the way it was. The last thing he needed was city-folk traipsing in and wreaking havoc. On Christmas Eve, as he responded to the call of a suspicious vehicle, the last thing he expected to find was a feisty woman sleeping in her car.
When Lenny Heckman purchased the small-town bakery in Avonbury, sight unseen, she hadn’t expected her introduction to the cozy little town to be spent behind bars. It didn’t help matters that the grumpy, sexy Sheriff had the appearance of a smoldering, untamed mountain man.
As Lenny settles into the legendary Storyteller’s Cottage, finding herself irresistibly drawn into its enchanting myth of guests discovering love within its walls, and despite butting heads, she’s also drawn to Sheriff Quinn.
When Lenny falls deliriously sick, it’s Becker who comes to her rescue. The gentleness he exudes is something Lenny’s not familiar with, and quickly doesn’t want to let go of.
Perhaps starting over in Avonbury was the right choice after all…
Ebook- ARC COPY
December 13, 2024
This is a cute novella. If you’re looking for a good story to get you in that Christmas spirit then this is the perfect book for you. I loved the banter and how the two meet. It would be a great story to tell the kids about how their parents met haha.
I would love to go find this cottage and experience the magic for myself. I would be looking for more books from this author.
I would love to go find this cottage and experience the magic for myself. I would be looking for more books from this author.
December 3, 2024
Loved it! Adorable read! It sucked me in and wouldn’t let me go. Perfect to read for the holiday! I love the background and the story behind this amazing cottage and the love the happens here. Highly recommend if you want a cozy quick read that will make your heart happy -Kerin
November 28, 2024
ARC Review
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This was a sweet cozy winter novella with charming characters, lots of snow and a cottage that might just have a touch of magic. It was a fast paced quick read where the story flowed well. I love the caretaking trope and Becker definitely delivered when Lenny was sick!
I would like to thank Nalani Titcomb and Happily Booked PR for the opportunity to read and review this novella.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This was a sweet cozy winter novella with charming characters, lots of snow and a cottage that might just have a touch of magic. It was a fast paced quick read where the story flowed well. I love the caretaking trope and Becker definitely delivered when Lenny was sick!
I would like to thank Nalani Titcomb and Happily Booked PR for the opportunity to read and review this novella.
November 29, 2024
I thought this was a cute Christmas love story.. the beginning of how they met was witty and cute. I hope to see more from this author
December 1, 2024
It's officially the holiday season and there's no better way to spend the chilly days than reading a cozy Christmas story. Nalani Titcomb delivered with Mistaken Identity at the Storyteller's Cottage!
Lenny relocates from Oregon to Massachusetts after her parents' deaths and finding her third partner cheating on her. She finds her way to Avonbury, Massachusetts on Christmas Eve after a road trip to move across the country, but due to a snowstorm and little experience with such weather conditions, Lenny falls asleep in her car when she loses her way at the end of the night. Sheriff Becker Quinn wakes her on Christmas morning, and she ends up in jail after a case of mistaken identity. Becker clears her after a call to her ex-fiance, and she heads into her future at the Storyteller's Cottage, where she is renting, and her newly bought bakery, which she has yet to see or start. The Cottage comes with a legend that if you're searching for love, your wish will be granted at the cottage. In a new town with no history of her own, and a John Krasinski look-a-like for a sheriff, Lenny's story is just beginning on Christmas Eve.
This is a quick, cozy romance Christmas novella with surprisingly well-developed characters and plot for such a short book. I thoroughly enjoyed this read!
Lenny relocates from Oregon to Massachusetts after her parents' deaths and finding her third partner cheating on her. She finds her way to Avonbury, Massachusetts on Christmas Eve after a road trip to move across the country, but due to a snowstorm and little experience with such weather conditions, Lenny falls asleep in her car when she loses her way at the end of the night. Sheriff Becker Quinn wakes her on Christmas morning, and she ends up in jail after a case of mistaken identity. Becker clears her after a call to her ex-fiance, and she heads into her future at the Storyteller's Cottage, where she is renting, and her newly bought bakery, which she has yet to see or start. The Cottage comes with a legend that if you're searching for love, your wish will be granted at the cottage. In a new town with no history of her own, and a John Krasinski look-a-like for a sheriff, Lenny's story is just beginning on Christmas Eve.
This is a quick, cozy romance Christmas novella with surprisingly well-developed characters and plot for such a short book. I thoroughly enjoyed this read!
December 3, 2024
“Legendary cottage known to bring your deepest dreams of love to life.”
Mistaken Identity at the Storyteller's Cottage by Nalani Titcomb is a delightful Christmas novella about fresh starts, laughter, and love.
📝 RATED (4/5): ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️ SPICE (3/5): 🔥 🔥 🔥
📖 Title: Mistaken Identity at the Storyteller's Cottage
✍🏻 Author: Nalani Titcomb (@nalanititcomb)
📚 PR & Marketing: @happilybookedpr
Lenny, seeking a new beginning after heartbreak, crosses paths with Becker, the grumpy but endearing Sheriff, in a hilarious first meeting. With charming miscommunication, a sprinkle of bad luck, and the enchanting magic of the cottage, this quick, spicy read delivers heartfelt romance. Perfect for fans of Hallmark movies and cozy holiday vibes!
—————————————————————
* I received an advanced copy of this book and am sharing my honest review voluntarily. A big thank you to the author for providing it!
Mistaken Identity at the Storyteller's Cottage by Nalani Titcomb is a delightful Christmas novella about fresh starts, laughter, and love.
📝 RATED (4/5): ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️ SPICE (3/5): 🔥 🔥 🔥
📖 Title: Mistaken Identity at the Storyteller's Cottage
✍🏻 Author: Nalani Titcomb (@nalanititcomb)
📚 PR & Marketing: @happilybookedpr
Lenny, seeking a new beginning after heartbreak, crosses paths with Becker, the grumpy but endearing Sheriff, in a hilarious first meeting. With charming miscommunication, a sprinkle of bad luck, and the enchanting magic of the cottage, this quick, spicy read delivers heartfelt romance. Perfect for fans of Hallmark movies and cozy holiday vibes!
—————————————————————
* I received an advanced copy of this book and am sharing my honest review voluntarily. A big thank you to the author for providing it!
December 13, 2024
Umm, this book was really good and it had me sucked in during the first chapters but unfortunately I started to have mixed feelings about when I got to chapter 7 when he literally removed her clothes (as well as his)and got into the tub with her inorder help reduce her temperature and she was hardly alert.
I know it a fast paced romance and he was trying to help her but still come on.NO just NO. I don't think anybody should do that kind of stuff especially when you hardly know the person. But then again it's a fast paced romance .I personally just didn't like that whole stuff and won't what it to be done to me.
The book was absolutely amazing and if you are in for a quick interesting read you should surely go for it.
Thank you author Nalani Titcomb and Happyilybookedpr for giving me this arc.
I know it a fast paced romance and he was trying to help her but still come on.NO just NO. I don't think anybody should do that kind of stuff especially when you hardly know the person. But then again it's a fast paced romance .I personally just didn't like that whole stuff and won't what it to be done to me.
The book was absolutely amazing and if you are in for a quick interesting read you should surely go for it.
Thank you author Nalani Titcomb and Happyilybookedpr for giving me this arc.
December 2, 2024
Welcome, guest, to The Storyteller's Cottage!
Inside these walls are the testimonies of hundreds of couples who have stayed here, each detailing their stories of finding true love. Do not take this lightly! Open your heart to the possibility of love, and let the legend do the rest!
Lenny (FMC): 31 • Looking for a Fresh Start • Dreams of Opening a Bakery • Sassy •
Becker (MMC): • Town Sheriff • Action Movie Lover • Cinnamon Roll • In Charge 😉 •
Tropes:
🧁 Sheriff x Baker
❄️ Novella
🧁 Christmas Romance
❄️ Forced Proximity
🧁 One Bed
❄️ Small New England Town
🧁 Starting Over
❄️ Meet Cute Hijinks
🧁 Banter
❄️ He Takes Care of Her When She is Sick
Rating: 🥐🥐🥐(3⭐️)
Spice: 🌶️🫑🫑 (1-2 scenes on page, quick, lacked full descriptions)
T/W: infidelity (not MCs, referenced)
A fun winter quick read with swoony moments and hilarious hijinks. I enjoyed seeing a softer side of Becker when he was taking care of Lenny. I did feel it was a bit rushed when Lenny jumped into bed with Becker right after she was found cooling off in the snow because she had a high fever. This just felt sudden and I even went back to see if I missed a chapter. I would’ve liked to see more relationship building or at least a time jump in the next chapter. Overall, this is a quick winter read with funny moments and a magic cottage.
I received an ARC copy and wanted to leave an honest review.
Inside these walls are the testimonies of hundreds of couples who have stayed here, each detailing their stories of finding true love. Do not take this lightly! Open your heart to the possibility of love, and let the legend do the rest!
Lenny (FMC): 31 • Looking for a Fresh Start • Dreams of Opening a Bakery • Sassy •
Becker (MMC): • Town Sheriff • Action Movie Lover • Cinnamon Roll • In Charge 😉 •
Tropes:
🧁 Sheriff x Baker
❄️ Novella
🧁 Christmas Romance
❄️ Forced Proximity
🧁 One Bed
❄️ Small New England Town
🧁 Starting Over
❄️ Meet Cute Hijinks
🧁 Banter
❄️ He Takes Care of Her When She is Sick
Rating: 🥐🥐🥐(3⭐️)
Spice: 🌶️🫑🫑 (1-2 scenes on page, quick, lacked full descriptions)
T/W: infidelity (not MCs, referenced)
A fun winter quick read with swoony moments and hilarious hijinks. I enjoyed seeing a softer side of Becker when he was taking care of Lenny. I did feel it was a bit rushed when Lenny jumped into bed with Becker right after she was found cooling off in the snow because she had a high fever. This just felt sudden and I even went back to see if I missed a chapter. I would’ve liked to see more relationship building or at least a time jump in the next chapter. Overall, this is a quick winter read with funny moments and a magic cottage.
I received an ARC copy and wanted to leave an honest review.
December 2, 2024
While this novella might be part of a series, it works perfectly as a standalone—you won’t miss any context to enjoy the fast-paced, steamy story. The meet-cute is hilariously unique, unlike any I’ve read before, setting the tone for a fun mix of romance and humor. Watching the grumpy sheriff wrestle with his internal “angel and devil” was both endearing and entertaining.
The transition from annoyance to lust to love happens quickly, but the banter and genuine care between the characters make it feel natural. The characters quirks and sitcom-style rom-com moments bring plenty of laughs, while the open-door spice keeps things sizzling.
This story is the perfect blend of humor, heart, and heat—a perfect read for winter vibes and lighthearted romance!
A quick heads-up: If you haven’t seen A Quiet Place (Parts 1 & 2) and plan to, watch them before reading this novella, as there are spoilers.
The transition from annoyance to lust to love happens quickly, but the banter and genuine care between the characters make it feel natural. The characters quirks and sitcom-style rom-com moments bring plenty of laughs, while the open-door spice keeps things sizzling.
This story is the perfect blend of humor, heart, and heat—a perfect read for winter vibes and lighthearted romance!
A quick heads-up: If you haven’t seen A Quiet Place (Parts 1 & 2) and plan to, watch them before reading this novella, as there are spoilers.
November 29, 2024
What a quick easy to read festive story this is to read, I lovely afternoon read. Lenny was taking her life in hand, no more putting her dreams on hold for a man. Three ex's and now she was making a stand, she was worth more than being cheated on. Except what she hadn't taken into account was the weather, and no longer being in the city. The snow came from nowhere and now its a blanket of white. Why did she drive. Now stuck and no way of asking for directions it meant a cold night in her car. Becker couldn't believe she slept in a car in this temperature was she stupid. But then she wouldn't answer his questions. Out of state plates her fiance has a record, defiantly needs further questioning. As sheriff he took his towns safety and security seriously. This was not what she expected on christmas eve spending the night in a cell. This is a perfect start to a story you won't want to put down. Can Lenny ever make a new start. Will Decker remember his professional procedures. Sit back and see if the Storyteller's Cottage can work it's magic again. I can't recommend enough
December 25, 2024
This was such a cute Christmas read! I loved the chemistry between the two main characters and their fun banter. It’s a short read, but the author packed into it, and I finished it in one sitting—I just couldn’t put it down!
What to expect:
⭐️Forced Proximity
⭐️Small town
⭐️One bed
Definitely recommend if you’re looking for a sweet, quick romance with minimal spice 🌶️
What to expect:
⭐️Forced Proximity
⭐️Small town
⭐️One bed
Definitely recommend if you’re looking for a sweet, quick romance with minimal spice 🌶️
January 10, 2025
This was a great quick read (novella). Lenny and Becker were great from start to finish.
Thank you Nalani for an ARC copy!
Thank you Nalani for an ARC copy!
December 16, 2024
Want a cute Christmas novella with funny banter? Then this book might just be for you this holiday year. I think that Lenny and Becker had a very good meet cute especially when is is something that would totally happen in real life. I really liked the ‘magical’ cabin and how it brought people together. I really liked the banter in the book, I understand that its a novella but I would have like more back story and a little more build up, but that just my opinion.
blurb…
Welcome, guest, to The Storyteller's Cottage!
Inside these walls are the testimonies of hundreds of couples who have stayed here, each detailing their stories of finding true love. Do not take this lightly! Open your heart to the possibility of love, and let the legend do the rest!
~~~
Sheriff Becker Quinn liked his small town just the way it was. The last thing he needed was city-folk traipsing in and wreaking havoc. On Christmas Eve, as he responded to the call of a suspicious vehicle, the last thing he expected to find was a feisty woman sleeping in her car.
When Lenny Heckman purchased the small-town bakery in Avonbury, sight unseen, she hadn’t expected her introduction to the cozy little town to be spent behind bars. It didn’t help matters that the grumpy, sexy Sheriff had the appearance of a smoldering, untamed mountain man.
As Lenny settles into the legendary Storyteller’s Cottage, finding herself irresistibly drawn into its enchanting myth of guests discovering love within its walls, and despite butting heads, she’s also drawn to Sheriff Quinn.
When Lenny falls deliriously sick, it's Becker who comes to her rescue. The gentleness he exudes is something Lenny's not familiar with, and quickly doesn't want to let go of.
Perhaps starting over in Avonbury was the right choice after all...
blurb…
Welcome, guest, to The Storyteller's Cottage!
Inside these walls are the testimonies of hundreds of couples who have stayed here, each detailing their stories of finding true love. Do not take this lightly! Open your heart to the possibility of love, and let the legend do the rest!
~~~
Sheriff Becker Quinn liked his small town just the way it was. The last thing he needed was city-folk traipsing in and wreaking havoc. On Christmas Eve, as he responded to the call of a suspicious vehicle, the last thing he expected to find was a feisty woman sleeping in her car.
When Lenny Heckman purchased the small-town bakery in Avonbury, sight unseen, she hadn’t expected her introduction to the cozy little town to be spent behind bars. It didn’t help matters that the grumpy, sexy Sheriff had the appearance of a smoldering, untamed mountain man.
As Lenny settles into the legendary Storyteller’s Cottage, finding herself irresistibly drawn into its enchanting myth of guests discovering love within its walls, and despite butting heads, she’s also drawn to Sheriff Quinn.
When Lenny falls deliriously sick, it's Becker who comes to her rescue. The gentleness he exudes is something Lenny's not familiar with, and quickly doesn't want to let go of.
Perhaps starting over in Avonbury was the right choice after all...
November 30, 2024
4 ⭐️ 3 🌶
🎄Small town
🎄Mistaken identity
🎄One bed
🎄Banter
🎄Starting over
Lenny (FMC) purchased a bakery in a small town, and wanted to fresh start after finding out that her boyfriend had cheated on her.
On her way to the accommodation, Lenny gets lost, and pulls over to the side of the road to rest overnight. Waking up to the grumpy and good looking Sheriff Becker Quinn knocking on her window, and accusing her of being a potential burglar, Lenny is shocked and confused, and the Sheriff puts her behind bars until he can figure out who she is.
After Lenny's mistaken identity is cleared up, the Sheriff drives Lenny up to her accommodation, which is at legendary The Storyteller's Cottage. Becker tells Lenny about the legends and stories that surround the cottage. Lenny settles in and finds a journal of past visitors, and is drawn to the mystery and charm of the cottage. Even though Lenny butts heads with the Sheriff, she also finds him extremely handsome and attractive. Little does she know that Sheriff Quinn is drawn to her too.
When Lenny falls quite ill, Sheriff Quinn finds her delirious and out in the snow. Survival instincts kick in, and Sheriff Quinn will do what it takes to take care of Lenny.
This book was sweet, swoony, cozy and utterly adorable.
Absolutely loved it!
I would like to thank Nalani Titcomb and Happily Booked PR for the opportunity to read and review this novella. (ARC review)
🎄Small town
🎄Mistaken identity
🎄One bed
🎄Banter
🎄Starting over
Lenny (FMC) purchased a bakery in a small town, and wanted to fresh start after finding out that her boyfriend had cheated on her.
On her way to the accommodation, Lenny gets lost, and pulls over to the side of the road to rest overnight. Waking up to the grumpy and good looking Sheriff Becker Quinn knocking on her window, and accusing her of being a potential burglar, Lenny is shocked and confused, and the Sheriff puts her behind bars until he can figure out who she is.
After Lenny's mistaken identity is cleared up, the Sheriff drives Lenny up to her accommodation, which is at legendary The Storyteller's Cottage. Becker tells Lenny about the legends and stories that surround the cottage. Lenny settles in and finds a journal of past visitors, and is drawn to the mystery and charm of the cottage. Even though Lenny butts heads with the Sheriff, she also finds him extremely handsome and attractive. Little does she know that Sheriff Quinn is drawn to her too.
When Lenny falls quite ill, Sheriff Quinn finds her delirious and out in the snow. Survival instincts kick in, and Sheriff Quinn will do what it takes to take care of Lenny.
This book was sweet, swoony, cozy and utterly adorable.
Absolutely loved it!
I would like to thank Nalani Titcomb and Happily Booked PR for the opportunity to read and review this novella. (ARC review)
December 11, 2024
I received an early copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️.5
This was a sweet, quick, holiday novella about a young woman, Lenny, who has decided to make a fresh start in a new state, far from her old life. She travels across the country (Oregon to Massachusetts) where she’s found the perfect location to open a bakery. She rolls into town in the middle of a snow storm, which has caused her to lose her way to the cabin she’s renting. She decides to pull over and park, sleeping in her car, until the sun comes up and she can see better, while hoping the snow has stopped. Unfortunately, the town sheriff wakes her up and takes her down to the station after receiving reports of a “suspicious vehicle” are made. Once at the station they realize it’s a case of mistaken identity, and so the sheriff gets her to her rented cabin and helps her settle in. He goes back to check on her a few days later and finds her rolling around in the snow and delirious. Upon further investigation he realizes she’s got an awful fever, and she was trying to cool off in the snow. He gets her inside and takes care of her, which is when the spark begins! Again, this was a sweet read, happiness from start to finish, a mild enemies-to-lovers in this small town romance. Minimal spice, but all leading towards a HEA. I highly recommend if you’re in the mood for a quick holiday romance.
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️.5
This was a sweet, quick, holiday novella about a young woman, Lenny, who has decided to make a fresh start in a new state, far from her old life. She travels across the country (Oregon to Massachusetts) where she’s found the perfect location to open a bakery. She rolls into town in the middle of a snow storm, which has caused her to lose her way to the cabin she’s renting. She decides to pull over and park, sleeping in her car, until the sun comes up and she can see better, while hoping the snow has stopped. Unfortunately, the town sheriff wakes her up and takes her down to the station after receiving reports of a “suspicious vehicle” are made. Once at the station they realize it’s a case of mistaken identity, and so the sheriff gets her to her rented cabin and helps her settle in. He goes back to check on her a few days later and finds her rolling around in the snow and delirious. Upon further investigation he realizes she’s got an awful fever, and she was trying to cool off in the snow. He gets her inside and takes care of her, which is when the spark begins! Again, this was a sweet read, happiness from start to finish, a mild enemies-to-lovers in this small town romance. Minimal spice, but all leading towards a HEA. I highly recommend if you’re in the mood for a quick holiday romance.
May 16, 2025
Rating: 4⭐️/5
“Good afternoon. Are you an Angel or a Devil today?”
After a two-week cross-country road trip fueled by heartbreak and lack of sleep, 31-year-old Eleanor “Lenny” Heckmen is done with Portland—and done with cheating boyfriends (three in a row, no less). With nothing but big bakery dreams and a playlist of regret, she rolls into a tiny New England town hoping for a fresh start. There, she meets Sheriff Quinn Becker—a grumpy sheriff with unresolved Jenny trauma (yes, because her name rhymes with his ex’s). Things spiral from “oops, I parked illegally” to getting arrested, to sharing space in a cozy, possibly enchanted cottage. Toss in forced proximity, small-town chaos, and a snowstorm’s worth of tension, and you’ve got a fast, flirty ride—like a Hallmark movie with a dash of spice!
This festive little novella is the perfect blend of cozy chaos and small-town charm. From hilarious meet-cute antics to snowstorms and sickbed caretaking, it’s got all the holiday rom-com energy you could want. The pacing felt a tad fast—one minute she’s feverish in the snow, the next she’s in bed with the sheriff—but Becker’s unexpected soft side and the cottage’s magical vibes make it easy to forgive. It’s sweet, spicy, and totally worth curling up with for a snow day escape—I loved it!
A big thanks to Happily Booked PR and Nalani Titcomb for sending me a digital ARC of this book!
—
#lateARCreview
“Good afternoon. Are you an Angel or a Devil today?”
After a two-week cross-country road trip fueled by heartbreak and lack of sleep, 31-year-old Eleanor “Lenny” Heckmen is done with Portland—and done with cheating boyfriends (three in a row, no less). With nothing but big bakery dreams and a playlist of regret, she rolls into a tiny New England town hoping for a fresh start. There, she meets Sheriff Quinn Becker—a grumpy sheriff with unresolved Jenny trauma (yes, because her name rhymes with his ex’s). Things spiral from “oops, I parked illegally” to getting arrested, to sharing space in a cozy, possibly enchanted cottage. Toss in forced proximity, small-town chaos, and a snowstorm’s worth of tension, and you’ve got a fast, flirty ride—like a Hallmark movie with a dash of spice!
This festive little novella is the perfect blend of cozy chaos and small-town charm. From hilarious meet-cute antics to snowstorms and sickbed caretaking, it’s got all the holiday rom-com energy you could want. The pacing felt a tad fast—one minute she’s feverish in the snow, the next she’s in bed with the sheriff—but Becker’s unexpected soft side and the cottage’s magical vibes make it easy to forgive. It’s sweet, spicy, and totally worth curling up with for a snow day escape—I loved it!
A big thanks to Happily Booked PR and Nalani Titcomb for sending me a digital ARC of this book!
—
#lateARCreview
December 5, 2024
This was a very fun & fast read! Light hearted and sexy, definitely a change of pace from my TBR currently. Loved it!
Just enough spice without it being over the top.
Lenny Heckman is starting over. She needs to get away from the string of bad relationships plaguing her. So she decides to move across the country. Her desire to establish a new life in an unknown town gets a rough start when she’s sleeping in her car during a snow storm and gets accused of being a suspicious person. Sheriff Becker Quinn does take kindly to strange troublemakers in his town. So he locks Lenny up until he can verify her story. Offering to drive her to the cottage she’s renting, Becker starts realizing that there’s more here than just his duty to protect and serve. There’s an attraction. The Storyteller’s Cottage is a local site of lore that those who stay there, find love. When Lenny falls seriously ill, it’s Becker who nurses her back to health, at the cottage. Something is drawing them together. Is it the legend of the Storyteller’s Cottage? According to the guestbook journal entries, many who have come before believe it is.
This one had me laughing out loud many times.
Just enough spice without it being over the top.
Lenny Heckman is starting over. She needs to get away from the string of bad relationships plaguing her. So she decides to move across the country. Her desire to establish a new life in an unknown town gets a rough start when she’s sleeping in her car during a snow storm and gets accused of being a suspicious person. Sheriff Becker Quinn does take kindly to strange troublemakers in his town. So he locks Lenny up until he can verify her story. Offering to drive her to the cottage she’s renting, Becker starts realizing that there’s more here than just his duty to protect and serve. There’s an attraction. The Storyteller’s Cottage is a local site of lore that those who stay there, find love. When Lenny falls seriously ill, it’s Becker who nurses her back to health, at the cottage. Something is drawing them together. Is it the legend of the Storyteller’s Cottage? According to the guestbook journal entries, many who have come before believe it is.
This one had me laughing out loud many times.
December 4, 2024
Lenny is looking to start over by driving across the country and buying a bakery in a small town, sight unseen. When she gets caught in a blizzard on Christmas, she starts to rethink her plan, especially when she is detained by a hot police officer, Sheriff Becker, for sleeping in her car. Once her name is cleared and she starts to settle in she learns that the cottage she is staying at is known for helping it's residents find love. Will Lenny be blessed by the Storyteller's Cottage too?
This was such a cute holiday story. It's hard to get people attached to characters and build excellent chemistry in a novella, but this one definitely succeeds. I loved the story, the tension, and the buildup. Becker's angel and demon situation got a little strange the longer it went on, but it still made me laugh in an awkward way. It's a really cute, feel-good story, mostly closed door spice, great for some cozy holiday reading.
This was such a cute holiday story. It's hard to get people attached to characters and build excellent chemistry in a novella, but this one definitely succeeds. I loved the story, the tension, and the buildup. Becker's angel and demon situation got a little strange the longer it went on, but it still made me laugh in an awkward way. It's a really cute, feel-good story, mostly closed door spice, great for some cozy holiday reading.
December 13, 2024
Cute, easy cozy little holiday read. The concept of the Storytellers Cottage is adorable! Imagine staying at a place that is rumored to lead its occupants to their “true love”. And the journal that the renters leave …so cute!!
Lenny gets “trapped” on the side of the road during a snowstorm as she makes her way across country. Waking up to the sound of someone tapping on her car window, brings Lenny face to face with the very attractive Sheriff Becker. Misunderstandings ensue, which lead to handcuffs (not in the good way lol) and the town jail lol. Not the best first impression, but def a unique meet cute.
I would have liked to know a bit more about Lenny’s past, and her past relationship that was mentioned. And I get it, this is a short story, so the pace is quick, but it did feel a little rushed to me. I wanted a bit more time to connect with the characters.
Love the concept of this series and hope we hear more about Lenny and Becker in the next book.
Lenny gets “trapped” on the side of the road during a snowstorm as she makes her way across country. Waking up to the sound of someone tapping on her car window, brings Lenny face to face with the very attractive Sheriff Becker. Misunderstandings ensue, which lead to handcuffs (not in the good way lol) and the town jail lol. Not the best first impression, but def a unique meet cute.
I would have liked to know a bit more about Lenny’s past, and her past relationship that was mentioned. And I get it, this is a short story, so the pace is quick, but it did feel a little rushed to me. I wanted a bit more time to connect with the characters.
Love the concept of this series and hope we hear more about Lenny and Becker in the next book.
December 13, 2024
This adorable cozy rom comfy Christmas novella was just what I needed this holiday season.
Great interactions and banter between Lenny our FMC , who is starting over life after some heart break in a new place with a fresh start, and Becker our grumpy sheriff MMC, who has excellent swoon worthy moments in this book like when Lenny gets sick and he takes care of her I am an absolute sucker for that micro trope think it comes from all the anime I watched as a teen!
Their hilarious fateful beginning soon turns sizzle steamy with those swoon worthy moments sprinkled in that lead me to say I would spend more than just one night in Becker’s jail
If you like short darling novellas with a theme to fit the season, forced proximity, one bed trope, small town vibes with banter that turns gooey then this is for you! It’s a standalone and is part of a collection in this series.
I give this a solid ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ and a 🌶️ on the spice scale!
Great interactions and banter between Lenny our FMC , who is starting over life after some heart break in a new place with a fresh start, and Becker our grumpy sheriff MMC, who has excellent swoon worthy moments in this book like when Lenny gets sick and he takes care of her I am an absolute sucker for that micro trope think it comes from all the anime I watched as a teen!
Their hilarious fateful beginning soon turns sizzle steamy with those swoon worthy moments sprinkled in that lead me to say I would spend more than just one night in Becker’s jail
If you like short darling novellas with a theme to fit the season, forced proximity, one bed trope, small town vibes with banter that turns gooey then this is for you! It’s a standalone and is part of a collection in this series.
I give this a solid ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ and a 🌶️ on the spice scale!
December 13, 2024
Lenny finds her way to Avonbury, Massachusetts on Christmas Eve during a road trip to move across the country after her parents' deaths and finding her third partner cheating on her., but due to a snowstorm she decided to stop the car at side , sleep in her car. Next day she was waken up by Sheriff Becker Quinn, brough to jail due to a mistaken identity. As Lenny settles into the legendary Storyteller’s Cottage, finding herself irresistibly drawn into its enchanting myth of guests discovering love within its walls, and despite butting heads, she’s also drawn to Sheriff Quinn. When Lenny falls sick, it's Becker who comes to her rescue.
This is a short insta love cozy read. Quinn was so sweet and protective with her. The banter between them at start was so fun. He went above and beyond for her to keep her safe. She was stubborn and strong. Moving across country to live a new life after so much have happened. I love their story, it was so cute and adorable.
This is a short insta love cozy read. Quinn was so sweet and protective with her. The banter between them at start was so fun. He went above and beyond for her to keep her safe. She was stubborn and strong. Moving across country to live a new life after so much have happened. I love their story, it was so cute and adorable.
January 2, 2025
This is a really cute novella about a cottage with stories of people finding love within the walls. People have written in journals detailing their stories of finding love when they least expected.
Lenny is moving across the country and gets caught in a blizzard when she meets Becker. Her morning quickly lands her in jail starting a journey she wasn't looking for. Lenny finds the journal when she finally makes it to the cottage discovering the small cottage's secrets.
Lenny starts to document her journey as her relationship unfolds with Becker and her fresh start. Becker and Lenny's start is a bit different when she gets very sick, but it ends up being really sweet with the banter back and forth.
I felt like this story just kind of ends even though Lenny makes her final entry. I know this was a novella, but it felt like it was just over. It was fast paced and the story was great. The characters were wonderful, but it felt like an extra chapter would have been nice.
Lenny is moving across the country and gets caught in a blizzard when she meets Becker. Her morning quickly lands her in jail starting a journey she wasn't looking for. Lenny finds the journal when she finally makes it to the cottage discovering the small cottage's secrets.
Lenny starts to document her journey as her relationship unfolds with Becker and her fresh start. Becker and Lenny's start is a bit different when she gets very sick, but it ends up being really sweet with the banter back and forth.
I felt like this story just kind of ends even though Lenny makes her final entry. I know this was a novella, but it felt like it was just over. It was fast paced and the story was great. The characters were wonderful, but it felt like an extra chapter would have been nice.
December 4, 2024
First and foremost, where does one find a cabin like this? (asking for a friend)
I loved this story from the beginning. Lenny just had an energy about her that you never expected what came out of her mouth. She is getting out of a relationship in which her fiance cheated on her and what did she do? She started driving with no destination in mind somewhere in Kansas she comes upon an ad in for a bakery that is for sale in Avonbury, Massachusetts and just decides to wing it and buy it. Becker is the sheriff of this small town.
From her “arrest” to everything that followed I laughed, cried and worried with our girl. The dynamic between her and Becker from the initial window knock at her car door to the end was felt in every word. Mistaken Identity of the Storytellers Cottage is a novella that has our girl Lenny starting a new chapter in her life and I am all for it.
I loved this story from the beginning. Lenny just had an energy about her that you never expected what came out of her mouth. She is getting out of a relationship in which her fiance cheated on her and what did she do? She started driving with no destination in mind somewhere in Kansas she comes upon an ad in for a bakery that is for sale in Avonbury, Massachusetts and just decides to wing it and buy it. Becker is the sheriff of this small town.
From her “arrest” to everything that followed I laughed, cried and worried with our girl. The dynamic between her and Becker from the initial window knock at her car door to the end was felt in every word. Mistaken Identity of the Storytellers Cottage is a novella that has our girl Lenny starting a new chapter in her life and I am all for it.
December 5, 2024
This has been such an amazing, cute and entertaining novella read. It was packed with the right amounts of fun, romance, spice and Magic. The instant attraction between Becker and Lenny was quite cute to read, and you'll fall in love with them right from chapter 1.
I love how brave and independent Lenny was, to even start a new chapter of her life on her own. But she is stubborn as well which is actually funny and cute.
Becker is such a kind yet amazing sheriff. And it was cute to see how even when he tried to be away from Lenny, he was utterly defeated by his own heart. It was quite cute to see him talking to his angel and demon, which was completely funny no matter how many times I read them.
The cottage sure is absolute magic, the journey and entries just increased the charm of the place. Overall, it's such a beautiful perfect novella for the Christmas season 🎄 Highly Recommended.
I love how brave and independent Lenny was, to even start a new chapter of her life on her own. But she is stubborn as well which is actually funny and cute.
Becker is such a kind yet amazing sheriff. And it was cute to see how even when he tried to be away from Lenny, he was utterly defeated by his own heart. It was quite cute to see him talking to his angel and demon, which was completely funny no matter how many times I read them.
The cottage sure is absolute magic, the journey and entries just increased the charm of the place. Overall, it's such a beautiful perfect novella for the Christmas season 🎄 Highly Recommended.
December 10, 2024
Mistaken Identity at The Storyteller’s Cottage by Nalani Titcome
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Tropes:
🎄Novella
🎁Christmas Romance
🎄Forced Proximity
🎁One Bed
🎄Small Town
🎁Banter
Sheriff Becker Quinn responded to the call of a suspicious vehicle, the last thing he expected to find was a feisty woman sleeping in her car. Lenny Heckman purchased the small-town bakery in Avonbury, sight unseen, she hadn’t expected her introduction to the cozy little town to be spent behind bars. It didn’t help matters that the grumpy, sexy Sheriff had the appearance of a smoldering, untamed mountain man and the banter between Lanny and Becker will keep you smiling. When Lenny falls deliriously sick, it's Becker who comes to her rescue. The gentleness he exudes is something Lenny's not familiar with, and quickly doesn't want to let go of. This is a great cozy sweet novella.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Tropes:
🎄Novella
🎁Christmas Romance
🎄Forced Proximity
🎁One Bed
🎄Small Town
🎁Banter
Sheriff Becker Quinn responded to the call of a suspicious vehicle, the last thing he expected to find was a feisty woman sleeping in her car. Lenny Heckman purchased the small-town bakery in Avonbury, sight unseen, she hadn’t expected her introduction to the cozy little town to be spent behind bars. It didn’t help matters that the grumpy, sexy Sheriff had the appearance of a smoldering, untamed mountain man and the banter between Lanny and Becker will keep you smiling. When Lenny falls deliriously sick, it's Becker who comes to her rescue. The gentleness he exudes is something Lenny's not familiar with, and quickly doesn't want to let go of. This is a great cozy sweet novella.
December 12, 2024
After going through a breakup, Lenny travels across the United States with no destination in mind. However, half way across the country, an advertisement catches her eye. She sets her sites on this small town that promises owning her own bakery. The only thing getting in the way? The dang "Hot Dad", Sherriff Becker.
I will be the first to tell you that I am not usually a novella reader because I often feel like the story is rushed and missing key components. That is so NOT the case for Mistaken Identity at the Storyteller's Cottage. The amount of banter was *chefs kiss* for the time it took the relationship to bloom.
Definitely recommend this short story if you're looking for a snowy/Christmassy setting, small town, or even one bed type tropes. My only wish? That this would be longer! I could have easily been just as in love with Lenny and Becker in a full-length novel!
I will be the first to tell you that I am not usually a novella reader because I often feel like the story is rushed and missing key components. That is so NOT the case for Mistaken Identity at the Storyteller's Cottage. The amount of banter was *chefs kiss* for the time it took the relationship to bloom.
Definitely recommend this short story if you're looking for a snowy/Christmassy setting, small town, or even one bed type tropes. My only wish? That this would be longer! I could have easily been just as in love with Lenny and Becker in a full-length novel!
December 19, 2024
After driving across the country, Lenny parks on the side of the road to catch a quick nap… or what should have been a nice nap. Instead, she is awoken by a gorgeous police officer, I mean Sheriff, at her window who promptly detains her! The story unfolds here, and many laughs and sweet moments are had. This book was such an unexpectedly sweet and wonderful read.
Becker is so protective and caring - he certainly goes above and beyond his sheriff duties!
The banter of this book is one of the best parts. You can learn so much about the characters through their humor and common interactions. Add in the spicey times, and it was a no-brainer for a recommended read.
⭐️Christmas time novella
⭐️Small town
⭐️Forced proximity
⭐️Starting over
Thank you to Nalani Titcomb and Happily Booked PR for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review!
Becker is so protective and caring - he certainly goes above and beyond his sheriff duties!
The banter of this book is one of the best parts. You can learn so much about the characters through their humor and common interactions. Add in the spicey times, and it was a no-brainer for a recommended read.
⭐️Christmas time novella
⭐️Small town
⭐️Forced proximity
⭐️Starting over
Thank you to Nalani Titcomb and Happily Booked PR for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review!
November 26, 2024
⭐⭐⭐⭐️⭐ - 5 stars
🌶️🌶️🫑- 2.5 spice level
What to expect:
❄️Novella
❄️Christmas Romance
❄️Forced Proximity
❄️One Bed
❄️Small Town
❄️Starting Over
❄️Hilarious Meet Cute
🔥My Thoughts: This was such a cute story! I loved it. It was fast paced but not rushed and I finished it in one sitting. The chemistry between Lenny and Becker was on fire and I loved that he was the grumpy small town sheriff and she was moving to the small town to start over. It is set during the holidays but the focus is on the “magical” legendary cabin. When Lenny gets sick and Beck comes to help, that is when their defenses fall and the real “magic” begins. It’s a perfectly written holiday romance that screams Hallmark movie in the making. Do yourself a favor and check it out!
🌶️🌶️🫑- 2.5 spice level
What to expect:
❄️Novella
❄️Christmas Romance
❄️Forced Proximity
❄️One Bed
❄️Small Town
❄️Starting Over
❄️Hilarious Meet Cute
🔥My Thoughts: This was such a cute story! I loved it. It was fast paced but not rushed and I finished it in one sitting. The chemistry between Lenny and Becker was on fire and I loved that he was the grumpy small town sheriff and she was moving to the small town to start over. It is set during the holidays but the focus is on the “magical” legendary cabin. When Lenny gets sick and Beck comes to help, that is when their defenses fall and the real “magic” begins. It’s a perfectly written holiday romance that screams Hallmark movie in the making. Do yourself a favor and check it out!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 127 reviews