Clara is accused on stealing while a ladies maid, because she spurns the advances of her lady’s new husband. She actually goes and steals his pocket watch in a fit of revenge. She is too scared to sell it, so she holds onto it. She marries a guy named John thinking he will protect her, but he turns out to be alcoholic with a gambling problem. He sells her to make some money, but promises to buy her back. The Duke, William, has recently inherited from a distance uncle. He sees the woman and feels bad for her. He buys her and brings her back to his estate. She is the only person he feels he can be himself with. Silas has returned from exile in France. He has to hide out in the Duke’s lodge as he is still wanted for murder. Clara becomes the servant William trusts to bring Silas food and watch out for him to avoid discovery. John shows up asking for more
money to pay his debtors. He threatens to tell the Duke about her theft, and embarrass the Duke if she tells him first. Clara confesses all (I liked this part, often you are screaming at the characters to just communicate, but Clara does the right thing at the right time). The Duke tells Clara he will meet John. When he does he gives John 50 pounds and tells him he will get the rest if he gives up alcohol and gambling. John doesn’t and is found dead one day. The Duke is trying to put his family’s need ahead of his own and that means marrying well, but the girl chosen by his steward at the house party wants to just give Silas money from afar instead of helping to clear his name. William’s female family members spot that he likes the maid. They dress her up to show William she can look the part of a Duchess. Once she is waiting for the Duke to get to the Lodge, she notices Silas is missing and chases after him trying to meet with the guy that framed him for murder, so he can talk reason with him (Silas must be a moron). The Duke finds them both missing but sees them on their return. He proposes to Clara and introduces her at the ball he is throwing as his fiancee. They get married, book ends with them expecting and giving permission for Silas to leave with them for London.
Liked that build up of feelings. Often this genre can make men seem very shallow, but the author develops practical things in addition to Clara’s beauty that attract William to her.
Disliked the unrealistic parts. I guess I’m not a big fan of the Cinderella story, but Keyes gives it a noble attempt suggesting he hates the nobles so he doesn’t care if he gets ostracized. It just seems super impractical: the whole family supported such a match, in that time, with the scandal. Seems very much like a modern age story dressed up in regency dresses. Keyes mentions in her note that it is loosely based on the Duke of Chandos. There are some pretty big differences between those stories, but it did make me feel like maybe I am overly judgmental on this. Also, Silas thinking he could convince a murder who framed him to come to an agreement so Silas can leave hiding. No, just no. Silas is an idiot and shouldn’t pass those genetics on to future generations. I get he was isolated and desperate, but not bringing any backup! Isn’t that how he got into this mess?
I could not root for an affair. Which meant most of the book was uncomfortable. I was uncomfortable with the kissing while Clara’s marriage was still valid. Vows mean something.