What do you think?
Rate this book
Whitby's Forgotten Victims #4
Forgotten Graves
Not every grave is blessed with flowers.
In the eerie silence of a forgotten silo, beneath the weight of bitter December snow, DCI Frank Black uncovers more than just bones. Over thirty years ago, Sarah Matthews vanished, dismissed as a troubled soul fleeing her demons. But as Frank digs deeper, he uncovers her true identity: a poet whose words still burn with life, her voice silenced too soon.
With the help of DS Gerry Carver—a detective with an uncanny gift for spotting patterns—Frank unravels a chilling truth: Sarah’s disappearance wasn’t a runaway act, but a calculated murder, buried by those with the power to keep secrets hidden.
To expose her killer, Frank and Gerry must infiltrate the highest circles of Whitby, where privilege and influence keep the dead buried and the guilty free. As Christmas lights flicker over the town, the two detectives must confront those who have walked among them for decades, guarding their dark secrets—and Sarah’s story—at all costs.
In the eerie silence of a forgotten silo, beneath the weight of bitter December snow, DCI Frank Black uncovers more than just bones. Over thirty years ago, Sarah Matthews vanished, dismissed as a troubled soul fleeing her demons. But as Frank digs deeper, he uncovers her true identity: a poet whose words still burn with life, her voice silenced too soon.
With the help of DS Gerry Carver—a detective with an uncanny gift for spotting patterns—Frank unravels a chilling truth: Sarah’s disappearance wasn’t a runaway act, but a calculated murder, buried by those with the power to keep secrets hidden.
To expose her killer, Frank and Gerry must infiltrate the highest circles of Whitby, where privilege and influence keep the dead buried and the guilty free. As Christmas lights flicker over the town, the two detectives must confront those who have walked among them for decades, guarding their dark secrets—and Sarah’s story—at all costs.
510 pages, Kindle Edition
Published March 3, 2025
918 people are currently reading
95 people want to read
About the author
Wes Markin
34 books242 followersBe sure to follow Wes on BookBub for the latest on sales: bit.ly/3tFWIHL
Wes Markin lives in Harrogate and is the bestselling author of the DCI Yorke crime novels set in Salisbury. He is also the author of the Jake Pettman series set in New England.
Wes Markin lives in Harrogate and is the bestselling author of the DCI Yorke crime novels set in Salisbury. He is also the author of the Jake Pettman series set in New England.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 72 reviews
February 21, 2025
This author can do no wrong! I am lucky enough to have read the ARC of this book, and I tell you, Wes Markin just excels!
The fourth book,in the Whitby series, and it is as good, if not better, than the first in the series.
I must say if you fancy reading this book, first go to book 1. Read them in order. The way Wes Markin develops his characters is so fabulous. The fact they feel like real people makes this one belter of a series.
The case of a body discovered after an accident unravels into something much more complex for Frank, Gerry, and the team. The fact that I was guessing for a lot of the story is proof that the twists, turns, and dead ends keep the reader on their toes. I was more than on my toes! I was seriously on the edge of my seat.
I love coming back to Frank and everyone. They almost feel like friends. Even Rylan, Gerry's dog is an integral part of the team for me now.
Amongst the gritty darkness of the storyline, there is still a little lightness with Frank and Gerry. Her neurodiversity always causes a little giggle because of how Frank and people around her sometimes react to her autistic way of being things.
It's great to see how the team is gelling together and the protectiveness they have over each other. Franks paternal streak being apparent with Gerry. His humour with Reggie. These small things just draw me into this world so easily.
I tried not to read it too quickly, and even then, when I got to the end, I didn't want to leave them all!
Thanks to the author for my ARC of the book to write my honest review.
The fourth book,in the Whitby series, and it is as good, if not better, than the first in the series.
I must say if you fancy reading this book, first go to book 1. Read them in order. The way Wes Markin develops his characters is so fabulous. The fact they feel like real people makes this one belter of a series.
The case of a body discovered after an accident unravels into something much more complex for Frank, Gerry, and the team. The fact that I was guessing for a lot of the story is proof that the twists, turns, and dead ends keep the reader on their toes. I was more than on my toes! I was seriously on the edge of my seat.
I love coming back to Frank and everyone. They almost feel like friends. Even Rylan, Gerry's dog is an integral part of the team for me now.
Amongst the gritty darkness of the storyline, there is still a little lightness with Frank and Gerry. Her neurodiversity always causes a little giggle because of how Frank and people around her sometimes react to her autistic way of being things.
It's great to see how the team is gelling together and the protectiveness they have over each other. Franks paternal streak being apparent with Gerry. His humour with Reggie. These small things just draw me into this world so easily.
I tried not to read it too quickly, and even then, when I got to the end, I didn't want to leave them all!
Thanks to the author for my ARC of the book to write my honest review.
March 11, 2025
Threads waving all over the place and Frank needs help to tie them all together. His team is willing to help.
From silos and cranes to love and passion, this book has it all.
A fabulous fourth book in the series. Blooming good!
From silos and cranes to love and passion, this book has it all.
A fabulous fourth book in the series. Blooming good!
December 19, 2025
Too many characters and story jumps around. Not one of his best.
August 15, 2025
3,5 estrellas. De 0 a 10: 6,5.
Pendidente de comentario.
Pendidente de comentario.
March 28, 2025
This is the 4th book in the series featuring Frank, Gerry and Rylan, so you know what I am going to say next. But you also know it makes sense to read a series in order as, well, that's kinda the point of them. And they've all been cracking books so...
In this book we start with the discovery of a set of bones. They appear to have been there a while, hidden in a silo, broken open when a pair of joyriders crashed into it. Initial thoughts include that they could belong to a person missing some 30 years. But Frank, Gerry and the rest of the team start their investigations with an open mind.
When they do identify the remains, those of a young girl called Sarah, who was presumed to have run away, they go back to that case and reopen it along with the fresh evidence, that of murder. This in turn takes them to a rather dark and sordid place and they have to tread very carefully indeed...
Oh my! I love this series. In fact I love all this author's series. Please do check them out if you haven't already. He writes brutal stuff, pulls no punches, but always stays clear of sensationalism. This book is no exception and, although harrowing, always remains balanced and objective.
In Gerry, the author has created the best and most novel character. Especially when you also include Rylan as part of the "package". Having a dog included in interviews also adds another dimension and often brings out a whole different side to people being talked to. As it does herein.
The investigation this time is a doozy and had me, alongside the detectives, running round chasing my tail all the way through. It's well plotted and said plot, expertly executed. Drip-feeding clues and reveals all the way through, with twists and turns aplenty, keeping me on my toes, before spitting me out at the end wholly satisfied.
All in all, another cracking addition to both a now well established series and a rather impressive back catalogue. Roll on next time!
In this book we start with the discovery of a set of bones. They appear to have been there a while, hidden in a silo, broken open when a pair of joyriders crashed into it. Initial thoughts include that they could belong to a person missing some 30 years. But Frank, Gerry and the rest of the team start their investigations with an open mind.
When they do identify the remains, those of a young girl called Sarah, who was presumed to have run away, they go back to that case and reopen it along with the fresh evidence, that of murder. This in turn takes them to a rather dark and sordid place and they have to tread very carefully indeed...
Oh my! I love this series. In fact I love all this author's series. Please do check them out if you haven't already. He writes brutal stuff, pulls no punches, but always stays clear of sensationalism. This book is no exception and, although harrowing, always remains balanced and objective.
In Gerry, the author has created the best and most novel character. Especially when you also include Rylan as part of the "package". Having a dog included in interviews also adds another dimension and often brings out a whole different side to people being talked to. As it does herein.
The investigation this time is a doozy and had me, alongside the detectives, running round chasing my tail all the way through. It's well plotted and said plot, expertly executed. Drip-feeding clues and reveals all the way through, with twists and turns aplenty, keeping me on my toes, before spitting me out at the end wholly satisfied.
All in all, another cracking addition to both a now well established series and a rather impressive back catalogue. Roll on next time!
October 10, 2025
Zwei Raser verursachen mitten in den Yorkshire Moors einen Unfall und zerstören dabei ein altes Silo. In den Trümmern wird die Leiche eines jungen Mädchens gefunden. Für DCI Frank Black ist dieser Fund besonders schwer, denn jedes Mädchen, das gefunden wird, erinnert ihn an seine Tochter Maddie.
Ich mag die Reihe um Frank Black und Gerry Carver. Es geht nicht nur um den Fall, sondern immer auch um die Ermittler. Nicht nur um Frank und den Verlust seiner Tochter, sondern auch um Gerry, die versucht, in einem ganz normalen Leben zurecht zu kommen. Wenn ich an die Teile der Reihe denke, die ich bis jetzt gelesen habe, kann ich mich tatsächlich mehr an das Privatleben von Gerry und Frank erinnern als an die Fälle selbst.
So geht es mir auch bei diesem Fall, bei dem mir nur noch einige Bruchstücke in Erinnerung sind: der Anstecker eines Reitturniers, mit dem man die Identität der Toten ermitteln konnte, ihre Beziehung zu falschen Männern und eine Verbindung zu den höchsten Kreisen in Whitby. Ein alter Mann, der seine fragwürdige Vergangenheit damit rechtfertigt, zum Besten von jungen Menschen gehandelt zu haben und seine Tochter, die nichts davon ahnte.
Tatsächlich kann ich mich besser daran erinnern, dass Gerry einen Heiratsantrag bekommen hat, der ihr Leben auf den Kopf stellt und dass Frank endlich wieder eine Spur zu seiner Tochter zu haben scheint.
Damit will ich nicht sagen, dass mir die Lektüre nicht gefallen hat. Aber die Fälle ähneln sich zu sehr, als dass sie mir einzeln lange im Gedächtnis bleiben. Den nächsten Teil der Reihe werde ich trotzdem lesen, weil ich hoffe, für Frank ein gutes Ende zu lesen.
Ich mag die Reihe um Frank Black und Gerry Carver. Es geht nicht nur um den Fall, sondern immer auch um die Ermittler. Nicht nur um Frank und den Verlust seiner Tochter, sondern auch um Gerry, die versucht, in einem ganz normalen Leben zurecht zu kommen. Wenn ich an die Teile der Reihe denke, die ich bis jetzt gelesen habe, kann ich mich tatsächlich mehr an das Privatleben von Gerry und Frank erinnern als an die Fälle selbst.
So geht es mir auch bei diesem Fall, bei dem mir nur noch einige Bruchstücke in Erinnerung sind: der Anstecker eines Reitturniers, mit dem man die Identität der Toten ermitteln konnte, ihre Beziehung zu falschen Männern und eine Verbindung zu den höchsten Kreisen in Whitby. Ein alter Mann, der seine fragwürdige Vergangenheit damit rechtfertigt, zum Besten von jungen Menschen gehandelt zu haben und seine Tochter, die nichts davon ahnte.
Tatsächlich kann ich mich besser daran erinnern, dass Gerry einen Heiratsantrag bekommen hat, der ihr Leben auf den Kopf stellt und dass Frank endlich wieder eine Spur zu seiner Tochter zu haben scheint.
Damit will ich nicht sagen, dass mir die Lektüre nicht gefallen hat. Aber die Fälle ähneln sich zu sehr, als dass sie mir einzeln lange im Gedächtnis bleiben. Den nächsten Teil der Reihe werde ich trotzdem lesen, weil ich hoffe, für Frank ein gutes Ende zu lesen.
March 20, 2025
This is book four in the series set around Whitby, North Yorkshire, and features all the familiar and popular characters, including Gerry, her boyfriend, and Rylan, her faithful assistance dog. Frank is still missing his wife but is now striking up a friendship with the wife of the man who his wife went off with and lost their lives together many years ago.
This story centres around two teenage joyriders who whilst speeding along the road on a snowy day, crash into a disused farm silo, the impact of the collision uncovers more than years of dirt and dust, a body of a young woman, dressed in riding gear. This starts a search to find out exactly who she was, what she was doing there, and did she have a criminal background?
Very soon, Frank and his team are digging deeply into this case and discovering secrets along the way. Many people are thought to be suspects, but it's not all plain sailing, and it wasn't who I thought it was who committed this crime many years ago deep in the Yorkshire Moors.
Fans of the tv drama Silent Witness will love this and the other books in the series.
A compelling and unputdownable novel which kept me engrossed from the very beginning and which I absolutely loved as much as the previous books in this series, I loved meeting all the familiar characters again and look forward to reading more in this series and hoping that there are many more to come.
A well-deserved five-star read.
#WesMarkin
#ForgottenGraves
This story centres around two teenage joyriders who whilst speeding along the road on a snowy day, crash into a disused farm silo, the impact of the collision uncovers more than years of dirt and dust, a body of a young woman, dressed in riding gear. This starts a search to find out exactly who she was, what she was doing there, and did she have a criminal background?
Very soon, Frank and his team are digging deeply into this case and discovering secrets along the way. Many people are thought to be suspects, but it's not all plain sailing, and it wasn't who I thought it was who committed this crime many years ago deep in the Yorkshire Moors.
Fans of the tv drama Silent Witness will love this and the other books in the series.
A compelling and unputdownable novel which kept me engrossed from the very beginning and which I absolutely loved as much as the previous books in this series, I loved meeting all the familiar characters again and look forward to reading more in this series and hoping that there are many more to come.
A well-deserved five-star read.
#WesMarkin
#ForgottenGraves
March 21, 2025
This is the second book I’ve read in the Whitby series, and while you can absolutely read them as standalones, I’m glad I read book one first. Having that prior knowledge of the main characters and their backstories added an extra layer of depth to my experience.
I’ll admit, Forgotten Graves took a little while to pull me in. It wasn’t an instant-grab-from-page-one kind of read, but I suspect that’s just Wes Markin’s style—slowly building the tension before hitting full throttle. And that’s exactly what happened! Around the 30% mark, I was completely hooked and found myself unable to put it down.
The mystery itself is brilliantly crafted. With so many potential suspects, I was kept on my toes, constantly second-guessing who the murderer might be. The twists and turns kept coming, and I tore through the pages eager to uncover the truth.
Frank and Gerry are such a fantastic duo. Their dynamic—both as working partners and friends—is one of my favorite aspects of the book. They bring warmth and depth to the story, and I can’t wait to continue the series just to spend more time with them.
I’m so grateful to have received an ARC in exchange for an honest review because I truly loved this book. If you enjoy a well-plotted thriller with great characters and plenty of suspense, I highly recommend this one!
I’ll admit, Forgotten Graves took a little while to pull me in. It wasn’t an instant-grab-from-page-one kind of read, but I suspect that’s just Wes Markin’s style—slowly building the tension before hitting full throttle. And that’s exactly what happened! Around the 30% mark, I was completely hooked and found myself unable to put it down.
The mystery itself is brilliantly crafted. With so many potential suspects, I was kept on my toes, constantly second-guessing who the murderer might be. The twists and turns kept coming, and I tore through the pages eager to uncover the truth.
Frank and Gerry are such a fantastic duo. Their dynamic—both as working partners and friends—is one of my favorite aspects of the book. They bring warmth and depth to the story, and I can’t wait to continue the series just to spend more time with them.
I’m so grateful to have received an ARC in exchange for an honest review because I truly loved this book. If you enjoy a well-plotted thriller with great characters and plenty of suspense, I highly recommend this one!
February 21, 2025
Sheesh what a story. An emotional roller coaster. Twisting and turning you all over the place.
Starting simply enough, 2 idiot joyriders crash into an old silo and accidentally unearth a body. The question is who is it and how long have they been there ?
Frank, newly slimmed down and teetotal, after the nagging of his partner Gerrie sinks in, and his team, set out to investigate.
What they uncover reveals so many issues from the early to late eighties. How girls and women were treated differently, how accusations were treated.
There is a real look at family, utter devotion, stifling love, resentful love, hidden love.
So many issues are explored in some at times heart rending subplots.
Perhaps my favourite of all is Peter. What a time he has. The most disgusting without question was Honey.
All of this is set against a backdrop of winter, the bleakness and the heavy snowfall becoming a character of its own and really adding something that brings this up another level.
I truly believe Wes is one of our finest and most underappreciated writers around. Another truly stunning read that will stay with me and easily a contender for book of 2025.
Starting simply enough, 2 idiot joyriders crash into an old silo and accidentally unearth a body. The question is who is it and how long have they been there ?
Frank, newly slimmed down and teetotal, after the nagging of his partner Gerrie sinks in, and his team, set out to investigate.
What they uncover reveals so many issues from the early to late eighties. How girls and women were treated differently, how accusations were treated.
There is a real look at family, utter devotion, stifling love, resentful love, hidden love.
So many issues are explored in some at times heart rending subplots.
Perhaps my favourite of all is Peter. What a time he has. The most disgusting without question was Honey.
All of this is set against a backdrop of winter, the bleakness and the heavy snowfall becoming a character of its own and really adding something that brings this up another level.
I truly believe Wes is one of our finest and most underappreciated writers around. Another truly stunning read that will stay with me and easily a contender for book of 2025.
March 10, 2025
Goodness me what an emotional roller coaster I have been taken on in book 4 in Wes Markin’s Whitby’s Forgotten Victims series.
This one, along with all books in the series, should absolutely come with a health warning to highlight the mood swings that only a great author, who is completely on top of the game in crime fiction writing, can induce.
There’s laughter: DCI Frank Black’s ironic humour is pitched perfect.
Tears: once again, we see that outwardly irascible Frank let us into his true compassionate self as he investigates, with his usual unerring dedicated focus and determination, the discover of human bones which had been buried some 30 years previously.
Anger: The distressing cruelty inflicted on the victim’s life which is revealed as Frank and his sidekick, and friend, DS Gerry Carver, slowly uncover the truth
Heart wrenching disappointment: you know, that pain that always comes when you turn that final page and realise it is all over.
This is very much a standalone book but if you do experience the pain of an ending, then you’ll be pleased to know there are 3 more to absorb you in the series.
This one, along with all books in the series, should absolutely come with a health warning to highlight the mood swings that only a great author, who is completely on top of the game in crime fiction writing, can induce.
There’s laughter: DCI Frank Black’s ironic humour is pitched perfect.
Tears: once again, we see that outwardly irascible Frank let us into his true compassionate self as he investigates, with his usual unerring dedicated focus and determination, the discover of human bones which had been buried some 30 years previously.
Anger: The distressing cruelty inflicted on the victim’s life which is revealed as Frank and his sidekick, and friend, DS Gerry Carver, slowly uncover the truth
Heart wrenching disappointment: you know, that pain that always comes when you turn that final page and realise it is all over.
This is very much a standalone book but if you do experience the pain of an ending, then you’ll be pleased to know there are 3 more to absorb you in the series.
April 4, 2025
Oh how I have missed my favourite police team! Firstly this is a series, the books could definitely be enjoyed as standalone, however, I would highly recommend reading the other three books first as we really get to know the characters personalities and quirks as their lives progress through the books.
DCI Frank Black and his somewhat misfit team are back to tackle another cold case. When two teenagers crash into an old silo and make a gruesome discovery the team are determined to get justice for a young woman who it transpires disappeared many years ago. Forgotten Graves is as always full of unsavoury characters, hidden family secrets and twisted webs of lies and deception.
For me the star of the book is Gerry, Frank's neurodivergent prodigy who comes up against her own dilemma in this book. I loved to see how she has flourished under Frank's guidance.
I was really hoping this would be the book that would be more about Frank's own daughter but can't be disappointed as I know it's definitely got to be on the way.
Another fantastic book in the Whitby's Forgotten Victims series. In my opinion the books just keep getting better with this being my favourite so far.
DCI Frank Black and his somewhat misfit team are back to tackle another cold case. When two teenagers crash into an old silo and make a gruesome discovery the team are determined to get justice for a young woman who it transpires disappeared many years ago. Forgotten Graves is as always full of unsavoury characters, hidden family secrets and twisted webs of lies and deception.
For me the star of the book is Gerry, Frank's neurodivergent prodigy who comes up against her own dilemma in this book. I loved to see how she has flourished under Frank's guidance.
I was really hoping this would be the book that would be more about Frank's own daughter but can't be disappointed as I know it's definitely got to be on the way.
Another fantastic book in the Whitby's Forgotten Victims series. In my opinion the books just keep getting better with this being my favourite so far.
March 11, 2025
A seriously good read, so twisty I didn’t know who to believe and changed my mind with the wind and, as it turns out I’m probably not such a good judge of character.
I love that this series is set in Whitby, an area very important and special to me, the atmosphere and backdrop is stunning even if you don’t know the area, however, a great choice.
The very human topics of secrets and tragedy from the past provide an emotional and evocative ride and I certainly shed a few tears on the way. The questions of how we parent or teach and the influence we have on a younger generation are also very much under the microscope as are the long reaching ripples they can create.
I love, love, love the main characters and their dynamics with each other and own personal quirks and backstories, there were plenty of chuckles to balance the tears. Honestly can’t get enough of these books, they’re so enjoyable and utterly compelling. Thank you.
I love that this series is set in Whitby, an area very important and special to me, the atmosphere and backdrop is stunning even if you don’t know the area, however, a great choice.
The very human topics of secrets and tragedy from the past provide an emotional and evocative ride and I certainly shed a few tears on the way. The questions of how we parent or teach and the influence we have on a younger generation are also very much under the microscope as are the long reaching ripples they can create.
I love, love, love the main characters and their dynamics with each other and own personal quirks and backstories, there were plenty of chuckles to balance the tears. Honestly can’t get enough of these books, they’re so enjoyable and utterly compelling. Thank you.
March 12, 2025
I love this series. It was good to get more of an insight into Gerry’s life too and her relationship with Tom. Frank and Gerry have developed a great bond and I like that she’s now asking Frank for advice.
DCI Frank Black and his team are called to the discovery of a body. Two joyriders crashed into an old silo which toppled on the car and uncovered a body. The team pulled together and tasks were assigned. DS Gerry Carver worked tirelessly to establish who the victim was.
They discovered that the body was Sarah Matthews who had gone missing years previously. A witness had seen Sarah getting into a red fiesta with an older man. As the case progressed there were a number of suspects who fitted that description.
Frank was determined to solve the case for Sarah and her mum. He still hadn’t heard from his own daughter and the case brought back lots of memories for him.
I’ve seen that the next book is coming soon and I can’t wait to read it.
DCI Frank Black and his team are called to the discovery of a body. Two joyriders crashed into an old silo which toppled on the car and uncovered a body. The team pulled together and tasks were assigned. DS Gerry Carver worked tirelessly to establish who the victim was.
They discovered that the body was Sarah Matthews who had gone missing years previously. A witness had seen Sarah getting into a red fiesta with an older man. As the case progressed there were a number of suspects who fitted that description.
Frank was determined to solve the case for Sarah and her mum. He still hadn’t heard from his own daughter and the case brought back lots of memories for him.
I’ve seen that the next book is coming soon and I can’t wait to read it.
March 26, 2025
2 young joyriders lose control & bring down an ancient silo, inside is the skeleton of a young woman bound up.
Frank Black & his unlikely team have to solve this crime 34 years after the victim was reported missing.
What follows takes us on a journey , joining up the connections between 4 men and Sarah to see who was responsible for her horrific end, left to die in that lonely place. The retired headmaster , a pillar of the community, Peter the lonely , bitter recluse, John the dying businessman with a son who has hated him since he was 10 years old or Clive the religious gardener who died in a gas explosion with his employer soon after Sarah went missing.
The twists and turns in this book and the way these connections are revealed slowly throughout leading to a truly unexpected Finale will keep you awake half the night to finish this brilliant book. Wes Markin is a master of his craft.
Frank Black & his unlikely team have to solve this crime 34 years after the victim was reported missing.
What follows takes us on a journey , joining up the connections between 4 men and Sarah to see who was responsible for her horrific end, left to die in that lonely place. The retired headmaster , a pillar of the community, Peter the lonely , bitter recluse, John the dying businessman with a son who has hated him since he was 10 years old or Clive the religious gardener who died in a gas explosion with his employer soon after Sarah went missing.
The twists and turns in this book and the way these connections are revealed slowly throughout leading to a truly unexpected Finale will keep you awake half the night to finish this brilliant book. Wes Markin is a master of his craft.
April 1, 2025
In book 4, DCI Frank Black and DS Gerry Carver (and faithful Rylan) are investigating the murder of a missing woman from 1989, Sarah, who was found after joyriders crashed into the old silo, which was her last resting place. As with all the Whitby Forgotten Victims books, there are lots of interwoven characters that form the plot lines.
Whilst I really enjoyed this book, all of them are excellent, I felt this book was a little different. There's less of Gerry and the other coppers on Frank's team and more of Frank (which is great) also, I felt the characters were not as deep as the previous books. Some were not really relevant to the story, like Peter and Donna. I guessed who was the culprit quite early on, which hasn't happened before in these books, and the ending left me a little unsatisfied. Don't let that put you off, its still an immense read.
Thanks to the TBC Reviewers Book Club on Facebook for the opportunity to read this!
Whilst I really enjoyed this book, all of them are excellent, I felt this book was a little different. There's less of Gerry and the other coppers on Frank's team and more of Frank (which is great) also, I felt the characters were not as deep as the previous books. Some were not really relevant to the story, like Peter and Donna. I guessed who was the culprit quite early on, which hasn't happened before in these books, and the ending left me a little unsatisfied. Don't let that put you off, its still an immense read.
Thanks to the TBC Reviewers Book Club on Facebook for the opportunity to read this!
March 6, 2025
Complex and riveting
Just like Whitby itself this book twists round sharp corners sending you off in directions you had not expected to be taking.
You are halfway up the Abbey steps knowing Dracula is waiting for you when the snow starts whirling around turning you back to look at another direction, a different way, a suspect who just showed up to confuse you further.
Wes Markin's latest book, far from being bogged down in Whitby's snow, glides like a dancer on black ice; occasionally deliberately landing on one knew to have another look behind in case something has been missed.
Who did it? And what did they actually do?
I have some questions for the author such as where are the rest of the bones? How did the body get there? But this is not an anatomy text book or a How to Hide a Body manual so I will forgive Wes for leaving me thinking.
Especially as I did work out the main baddy.
Another excellent read with the next on order.
Just like Whitby itself this book twists round sharp corners sending you off in directions you had not expected to be taking.
You are halfway up the Abbey steps knowing Dracula is waiting for you when the snow starts whirling around turning you back to look at another direction, a different way, a suspect who just showed up to confuse you further.
Wes Markin's latest book, far from being bogged down in Whitby's snow, glides like a dancer on black ice; occasionally deliberately landing on one knew to have another look behind in case something has been missed.
Who did it? And what did they actually do?
I have some questions for the author such as where are the rest of the bones? How did the body get there? But this is not an anatomy text book or a How to Hide a Body manual so I will forgive Wes for leaving me thinking.
Especially as I did work out the main baddy.
Another excellent read with the next on order.
April 6, 2025
Another thrilling addition to The Forgotten Lives Series, Wes Markin has an amazing talent in his writing, he brings the characters to life, no matter how long they may have lain in the darkness of death, he makes sure they will not be forgotten, as he delves into the past life of Sarah Matthew’s it soon becomes apparent powerful people from the area could be involved with her disappearance, people who have used their influence in Whitby to hide dark and chilling secrets of the past. Wonderful to see Frank, Gerry and the team together, all bringing their individual characters into the mix, and who doesn’t love Rylan Gerry’s dog, a great role in the series!. I could say so much more, but just a recommendation that you really should invest in this series, you will not regret it.
March 16, 2025
Wes Markin books just keep getting better and better this one had me gripped there is so much going on. This is the fourth book in the series and it doesn't disappoint.
Two joyriders skid in the snow and crash into a silo upon which they discover a body now it's down to Frank and his team to solve the case but the body a young girl has been there for years. And there are loads of suspects to interview. Highly recommend reading the books in order to get a feel for the main characters especially the relationship between DCI Frank Black and DS Gerry Carver I can't wait for the next book to see what happens next especially with Frank's daughter.
Two joyriders skid in the snow and crash into a silo upon which they discover a body now it's down to Frank and his team to solve the case but the body a young girl has been there for years. And there are loads of suspects to interview. Highly recommend reading the books in order to get a feel for the main characters especially the relationship between DCI Frank Black and DS Gerry Carver I can't wait for the next book to see what happens next especially with Frank's daughter.
March 17, 2025
This is one of those books. Once you start reading, you are captured into the twists and turns of a gripping storyline and plot.
There are strong characters, and I like the way the main characters, Frank and Gerry, work well and get along with each other.
I particularly like the author's descriptive, which brings the settings, characters, and storyline to life in your minds eye.
Although part of a series, this book can be read as a standalone in its own right and is well worth reading.
I look forward to the next book.
My thanks to the author for the advanced copy.
This is my honest and unbiased review.
There are strong characters, and I like the way the main characters, Frank and Gerry, work well and get along with each other.
I particularly like the author's descriptive, which brings the settings, characters, and storyline to life in your minds eye.
Although part of a series, this book can be read as a standalone in its own right and is well worth reading.
I look forward to the next book.
My thanks to the author for the advanced copy.
This is my honest and unbiased review.
April 6, 2025
DCI Frank Black returns, along with Gerry and Rylan. This book can be read as a standalone or as part of the series. What can I say? It truly didn’t disappoint and kept me on my toes right till the end!
It begins when a couple of hapless young lads joyride and crash into a silo. This unearths some bones which are related to the disappearance of a young local girl some 30 years ago. I love how the various characters stories intertwine. This particular book is all about how lies and secrets destroy families. It’s also about lost opportunities, and fractured families and relationships. This is a must read for crime fiction lovers. I cannot wait for the next instalment.
It begins when a couple of hapless young lads joyride and crash into a silo. This unearths some bones which are related to the disappearance of a young local girl some 30 years ago. I love how the various characters stories intertwine. This particular book is all about how lies and secrets destroy families. It’s also about lost opportunities, and fractured families and relationships. This is a must read for crime fiction lovers. I cannot wait for the next instalment.
March 11, 2025
This is the fourth book in the series and my favourite so far. I’ve really settled in to this series now. The characters particularly Frank, Gerry and Rylan are fabulous but it’s the rest as well. The whole team yes even Reggie and his tash. Well not so much the tash.
So here we have a great setting, story and characters. It keeps you guessing and there’s a good feel to this one. British crime isn’t my genre and I struggled particularly with the first book. But this is good and I’m feeling good about it going forwards.
So here we have a great setting, story and characters. It keeps you guessing and there’s a good feel to this one. British crime isn’t my genre and I struggled particularly with the first book. But this is good and I’m feeling good about it going forwards.
March 20, 2025
Absolutely loved this book. Frank Black one of my favourite detectives. A couple of joyriders have crashed into a silo and dislodged a body which has been hidden in there for over 30 years. Frank and his team have to find out who, when and why. There is a lot going on in this story, lots of hidden secrets to uncover. Whilst all this is going on not one but two women have set their caps at Frank and Gerry has received a marriage proposal. All loose ends are tied up at the end and I can’t wait for the next instalment.
April 3, 2025
I absolutely loved this book was great to catch up with frank Gerry and the team. I enjoyed how the author introduced new characters in new chapters throughout the book and the twist at the end was so unexpected. I enjoyed how Wes markin interweaves the personal lives of all the main characters throughout the story and we are still left in wonder as to what has become of franks daughter. This story had my emotions all over the place and I can’t wait till the next book to find out what more is happening in the lives of Gerry frank and the team
April 19, 2025
Never a miss, always a hit from Wes Markin. I’m fully invested in Frank’s team and their eclectic personalities.
An explosive start leads to the unravelling of a web of lies and past indiscretions. Lives, carefully crafted to conceal are explored and hideous secrets that have been hidden for decades are discovered.
We learn more not only about the ‘forgotten’, but what’s developing in Frank and Gerry’s lives. When you are invested in the characters, you always come back for more. Looking forward to the next one.
An explosive start leads to the unravelling of a web of lies and past indiscretions. Lives, carefully crafted to conceal are explored and hideous secrets that have been hidden for decades are discovered.
We learn more not only about the ‘forgotten’, but what’s developing in Frank and Gerry’s lives. When you are invested in the characters, you always come back for more. Looking forward to the next one.
April 25, 2025
Forgotten Graves did not disappoint.
I am quite invested in the characters, Frank and Gerry in particular. Their relationships has developed into a friendship to envy.
A case not for the light hearted, with minimal evidence and a body that had been missing for many years.
There are a lot of characters involved, piecing together the life that was once led.
A complicated investigation for the team to unravel with aging witnesses and minimal facts.
Well written and enjoyable to read as always, Wes Markin is a firm favourite.
I am quite invested in the characters, Frank and Gerry in particular. Their relationships has developed into a friendship to envy.
A case not for the light hearted, with minimal evidence and a body that had been missing for many years.
There are a lot of characters involved, piecing together the life that was once led.
A complicated investigation for the team to unravel with aging witnesses and minimal facts.
Well written and enjoyable to read as always, Wes Markin is a firm favourite.
May 8, 2025
I will remember.
Another emotional cracker. An old silo collapses when a car crashes into it in the winter. A body falls out and Frank and Gerry and the rest of the team move on to solve the mystery. In this story there are some memorable characters who knew the deceased. Gerry's relationship with Tom wavers. Frank finds he has two female admirers. A grief bound elderly man finds a new reason for living. And I cried. Again. Wes Markin has the ability to evoke tears for his characters, no strike that, for his people. Loved it. Highly recommended.
Another emotional cracker. An old silo collapses when a car crashes into it in the winter. A body falls out and Frank and Gerry and the rest of the team move on to solve the mystery. In this story there are some memorable characters who knew the deceased. Gerry's relationship with Tom wavers. Frank finds he has two female admirers. A grief bound elderly man finds a new reason for living. And I cried. Again. Wes Markin has the ability to evoke tears for his characters, no strike that, for his people. Loved it. Highly recommended.
March 3, 2025
Fabulous storytelling! It's a great big mystery thriller with plenty of intrigue, twists and turns. A few threads are intricately woven into the storyline which make it a compelling read.
Frank, Gerry and the team have a killer to find but are they still alive? The mystery goes back to the 1980's and there are many avenues to investigate. I love all the lies and deceit, the secrets and the passion. An emotional ride for many of the characters. Frank feels that time is running out because people move on, evidence can be lost, memories are vague and the truth is easy to forget, especially if it will cause heartache.
A complex jigsaw puzzle with the missing pieces slowly slotting together to a thrilling and increasingly dark and exciting end.
This series is seriously addictive and a firm favourite of mine. Such likable and creative characters, always a splash of humour, great plotting and lots of suspense.
Looking forward to the next book.
Frank, Gerry and the team have a killer to find but are they still alive? The mystery goes back to the 1980's and there are many avenues to investigate. I love all the lies and deceit, the secrets and the passion. An emotional ride for many of the characters. Frank feels that time is running out because people move on, evidence can be lost, memories are vague and the truth is easy to forget, especially if it will cause heartache.
A complex jigsaw puzzle with the missing pieces slowly slotting together to a thrilling and increasingly dark and exciting end.
This series is seriously addictive and a firm favourite of mine. Such likable and creative characters, always a splash of humour, great plotting and lots of suspense.
Looking forward to the next book.
February 28, 2025
What a story! It was a totally emotional read and is hands down the best so far and the standard was unbelievably high already. I love how the author seems to have several different threads on the go at the same time and you are left wondering how these will somehow link together and then bam, you're in the middle of it all as everything gets revealed.
Even when you think things are done, there's more twists to come.Totally incredible. Can't wait to see how he can top this.
Even when you think things are done, there's more twists to come.Totally incredible. Can't wait to see how he can top this.
March 5, 2025
This the best book yet in this series. The plot is much more interesting than in previous books and takes many more twists, saving the final twist for the very end. The characters are developing into a unique crime investigation unit each with their own strengths and weaknesses. It is important to read in order as the progression of the characters is vital in understanding how they plot winds it way to conclusion.
March 11, 2025
This was a really great plot and written as usual in a way that draws you in immediately
Frank Black is such an attractive character and I enjoyed the way he views life. His team are fascinating with such diverse characters. Although this book is in a series it can be read as a standalone although you’ll miss the other great plots. The twists and turns were great and I can’t wait for the next one!!! Thoroughly recommended
Frank Black is such an attractive character and I enjoyed the way he views life. His team are fascinating with such diverse characters. Although this book is in a series it can be read as a standalone although you’ll miss the other great plots. The twists and turns were great and I can’t wait for the next one!!! Thoroughly recommended
Displaying 1 - 30 of 72 reviews