This book is beautifully written. Complex ideas are clearly articulated, especially in the first two chapters.
I enjoyed the first half of the book far more thank the second. The authors argue that we must stop simply transferring the fundamentals of print genres into new mediums, such as video essays. They discuss the "excesses" of new media and encourage teachers to explore those potential spaces that don't exist in print. I expected that the second half of the book would explain what we should do instead. If we don't ask students to create video essays because the essay is a product of alphabetic text, then what do we do instead? I never found the answer to that question. The answer does not yet exist. It's easy enough to say that we should stop assigning the projects of the print world in our multimodal assignments, but it's a lot harder to actually apply that it the classroom. What will the assignment actually say? How will we grade? Will this result in poor course evaluations about teachers who write unclear assignments?
Nevertheless, the authors use a wealth of literature to make many good points about the alarm that teachers have always experienced as a result of technology, the way we always fall back on what we already know, perhaps out of fear, and how multimodal communication can occur through conversation in new mediums like video games--to name but a few. The last two chapters just didn't seem to fit with the first few though.