What do you think?
Rate this book
Winter Pride
Janet Hamilton, the minister's daughter, betrothed to the Laird's son, goes to dine with her fiance's family, little reckoning that this is the last evening of peace and security which she is destined to know. Already she feels anxious about her wild young brother Andy, and certain happenings that same night bring Andy into deadly peril and threaten to ruin Janet's happiness. In the grim struggle for Andy's life which follows, Janet is willing to sacrifice her all, and cannot understand the attitude of her father, the cold remorseless, self-righteous minister, towards his only son. This is an absorbing tale of pride and folly set against the dour background of a remote village and the charms of 1860's Edinburgh
282 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 1952
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 of 1 review
January 30, 2026
I went into Winter Pride knowing almost nothing about the book or its author, and I’m glad I took the chance. I was quickly absorbed in the story and really enjoyed Winifred Duke’s writing style.
The Plot
Set in a remote Scottish village in the 1860s, the novel follows Janet Hamilton, the local minister’s daughter, who is engaged to Archibald Erskine, the eldest son of the local Laird. One Sunday evening, Janet dines at the Laird’s manor, and when she returns home she discovers that her brother Andy has been injured while poaching on the Laird’s land. That same night, the Laird’s groundskeeper is found murdered, and suspicion soon falls on Andy and his companions. With both her father and her fiancé’s family seemingly convinced of Andy’s guilt, it falls to Janet to fight for her brother, no matter the cost to her reputation and her future.
My Thoughts
This novel is well-written, the characters are engaging, and the plot moves at a satisfying pace. Although there is a mystery at the heart of the story, the novel is less about solving the crime and more about exploring how the murder and its aftermath shape the characters’ lives. It is an emotional, character-driven story, rather than a traditional whodunit, but readers are given a resolution to the mystery in the end.
I especially liked the world Duke creates. Her descriptions are beautiful, and I could easily picture all of the settings, from the Laird’s countryside manor to the area around the church (kirk) and the minister’s house (manse), and even the Edinburgh schoolhouse where Janet spends some time as a teacher.
The cast of characters is varied and believable. No one is unrealistically cheerful or flawless, and everyone, including Janet, has their own weaknesses and less admirable moments. This made them feel more real, even if it sometimes made them less likeable.
This novel contains a lot of Scottish dialect, particularly in the villagers’ dialogue. This was challenging at first, but I soon fell into its rhythm and was able to follow everything the characters were saying (though I did have to look up a few unfamiliar terms).
I’d recommend Winter Pride to readers who enjoy historical fiction and classic literature. I’m looking forward to exploring more of Winifred Duke’s work.
The Plot
Set in a remote Scottish village in the 1860s, the novel follows Janet Hamilton, the local minister’s daughter, who is engaged to Archibald Erskine, the eldest son of the local Laird. One Sunday evening, Janet dines at the Laird’s manor, and when she returns home she discovers that her brother Andy has been injured while poaching on the Laird’s land. That same night, the Laird’s groundskeeper is found murdered, and suspicion soon falls on Andy and his companions. With both her father and her fiancé’s family seemingly convinced of Andy’s guilt, it falls to Janet to fight for her brother, no matter the cost to her reputation and her future.
My Thoughts
This novel is well-written, the characters are engaging, and the plot moves at a satisfying pace. Although there is a mystery at the heart of the story, the novel is less about solving the crime and more about exploring how the murder and its aftermath shape the characters’ lives. It is an emotional, character-driven story, rather than a traditional whodunit, but readers are given a resolution to the mystery in the end.
I especially liked the world Duke creates. Her descriptions are beautiful, and I could easily picture all of the settings, from the Laird’s countryside manor to the area around the church (kirk) and the minister’s house (manse), and even the Edinburgh schoolhouse where Janet spends some time as a teacher.
The cast of characters is varied and believable. No one is unrealistically cheerful or flawless, and everyone, including Janet, has their own weaknesses and less admirable moments. This made them feel more real, even if it sometimes made them less likeable.
This novel contains a lot of Scottish dialect, particularly in the villagers’ dialogue. This was challenging at first, but I soon fell into its rhythm and was able to follow everything the characters were saying (though I did have to look up a few unfamiliar terms).
I’d recommend Winter Pride to readers who enjoy historical fiction and classic literature. I’m looking forward to exploring more of Winifred Duke’s work.
Displaying 1 of 1 review