Adam Morgan’s A Danger to the Minds of Young Girls is a spirited, earnest effort to resurrect the life and legacy of a critical yet little-known figure in early twentieth-century literature: the editor and publisher Margaret C. Anderson. At its core, the book seeks to situate Anderson — founder of The Little Review — at the intersection of modernism, queer history, and the early battles over censorship in the United States. The Little Review championed voices on the fringe of accepted literary norms, from T. S. Eliot and Ezra Pound to, most famously, James Joyce’s Ulysses, excerpts of which Anderson serialized and for which she would face obscenity charges in 1921.
Morgan’s account is meticulously researched, packed with details about Anderson’s early life, the evolution of her magazine, and the wider cultural and legal battles she waged. The narrative is often enlivened by colorful depictions of influential figures passing through Anderson’s orbit — intellectuals, radicals, writers, and artists who populated Chicago, New York, and later Paris. Such vignettes underscore the vibrancy of the modernist milieu she helped cultivate, and they reveal the stakes of publishing material deemed obscene or dangerously avant-garde in an era steeped in social conservatism.
Themes and Scope
One of the book’s central themes is censorship versus artistic freedom. Morgan frames Anderson’s prosecution not merely as a historical curiosity but as an early flashpoint in the ongoing struggle between progressive artistic expression and reactionary cultural forces. The subtitle — Book Bans and the Fight to Modernize Literature — gestures at this broader battle, and for readers interested in censorship and the politics of publishing, the book delivers compelling context and parallels to contemporary debates.
Closely tied to this is the theme of gender and sexual politics. Anderson’s identity as a queer woman operating in predominantly male literary circles complicates orthodox narratives of modernism; her relationships with other women and her broader social milieu are interwoven with her editorial work. The biography echoes through with the sense that Anderson’s life itself was an act of defiance against rigid norms — both literary and societal.
Morgan also foregrounds the power of community and artistic networks. The Little Review was not just a publication but a nexus for like-minded radicals and innovators. In chronicling how Anderson nurtured and supported then-unknown writers (some of whom would go on to shape the canon), the book highlights how avant-garde movements often emerge through collective effort rather than solitary genius.
Margaret C. Anderson: A Portrait
What emerges from Morgan’s biography is a portrait of Anderson as a complex and fiercely independent figure. Raised in the Midwest, she gravitated toward improvisational and intellectual circles in Chicago before moving east and then abroad in search of broader horizons. She was audacious enough to publish work considered obscene — especially Joyce’s Ulysses — and she understood the symbolic power of her editorial choices not just as literary curation, but as cultural provocations.
Anderson’s relationships — romantic, professional, and intellectual — further illuminate her personality and ambitions. Morgan depicts a woman who both shaped and was shaped by the avant-garde circles she inhabited: passionate, sometimes reckless, and often ahead of her time. Yet these very traits that make her compelling also highlight one of the book’s key challenges: the difficulty of sustaining narrative momentum across hundreds of pages when the subject’s life, while fascinating, lacks dramatic escalations typical of traditional biographies.
Strengths and Limitations
Strengths:
Rich Context: Morgan’s detailing of The Little Review’s significance within American letters and the broader modernist movement is among the book’s greatest assets.
Research and Voices: The book weaves in contemporary reviews and perspectives, including reactions from peers and institutions, giving readers a textured sense of the period.
Political Resonance: The parallels between Anderson’s battles and current controversies around censorship provide timely relevance.
Limitations:
Narrative Density: For some readers — as reflected in early reader responses — the story meanders at times, veering deeply into ancillary figures and episodes that, while interesting, do not always serve the central arc of Anderson’s life.
Scale vs. Depth: Because Anderson’s “public battles” were concentrated primarily around Ulysses and issues of censorship, the book occasionally feels stretched to fill its 288 pages. A long, focused article or essay might have captured the essence more sharply without padding.
Verdict
In the end, A Danger to the Minds of Young Girls succeeds as a cultural biography and historical document, offering readers an accessible gateway into the intertwined worlds of modernism, censorship, and queer history. It honors Anderson’s legacy and frames her work within the broader currents of early twentieth-century upheaval. At the same time, the book’s breadth occasionally diffuses its focus, supporting your sense that the material might have read more crisply as a long article or extended essay.
For readers curious about the history of literary censorship, the birth of American modernism, or the contributions of overlooked women in cultural history, Morgan���s book is rewarding. But for those seeking a tighter, more focused narrative arc, the biography sometimes feels more generous in length than strictly necessary.