Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Willowweep Manor #2

The Nefarious Nights of Willowweep Manor

Rate this book
Haley must return to Willowweep to solve the mystery behind her friends vanishing in this hilarious sequel to the “well-paced and humorous…delightfully spirited” (Kirkus Reviews) young adult graphic novel The Dire Days of Willowweep Manor.

Haley is summoned back to the Willowweep pocket universe to deal with a huge another pocket universe is collapsing, and the survivors are seeking refuge in Willowweep. Haley and herfriends discover that the newcomers are from a mystery-themed universe complete with a blustery colonel, a sweet old spinster, and a butler.

But shortly after their arrival, strange things start happening to Willowweep…the once-Gothic pocket universe is transforming into a whodunit! As the tropes of a detective story start to multiply, a murder rocks Willowweep. And when she searches for the culprit, Haley begins to suspect that one of the newcomers is trying to eradicate Willowweep. One by one, all her friends disappear, and it’s up to Haley to get to the bottom of this mind-boggling mystery. Can she grow past her Gothic romance roots to become a new kind of heroine?

224 pages, Paperback

First published August 12, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Shaenon K. Garrity

63 books41 followers
Shaenon K. Garrity is a writer, artist, and editor specializing in comics and pop culture. As an editor, she has over a decade of experience working with comic books. As a freelance writer, she's written extensively on comics, animation, and other popular arts. She's advised companies on comics publishing and spearheaded their entry into the field. Her own comics and fiction have won awards and critical acclaim.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
68 (19%)
4 stars
191 (54%)
3 stars
83 (23%)
2 stars
6 (1%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 89 reviews
Profile Image for Kaia.
699 reviews
May 12, 2026
This sequel is as delightful as the first book. I laughed out loud many times, and I love how the dog and the chicken are incorporated into the story.
Profile Image for Lauren Stoolfire.
5,137 reviews310 followers
December 23, 2025
I think I preferred this sequel a little more than book one. It's sillier, but takes the whole thing up a couple of notches in my mind since it has now combined in an Agatha Christie Miss Marple style 1920s mystery.
Profile Image for Rod Brown.
8,003 reviews322 followers
September 7, 2025
It may be a half-step off the first volume, but this sequel still charms with its silliness and nonsense as it sends up murder mysteries. I might have liked it more if I were a fan of murder mysteries.
Profile Image for Jaida .
275 reviews50 followers
December 11, 2025
.ᨒ↟ 𖠰𖥧˚.ᨒ↟ 𖠰𖥧˚.ᨒ↟ 𖠰𖥧˚.ᨒ↟ 𖠰𖥧˚

This graphic novel duology is basically just a parody of gothic romance novels with every stereotype. It was kind of like Jane Eyre and an Agatha Christie novel had a baby (minus everything I hated from Jane Eyre)

“𝗔𝗱𝘃𝗲𝗻𝘁𝘂𝗿𝗲𝘀 𝗰𝘂𝘁 𝗶𝗻𝘁𝗼 𝗺𝘆 𝗯𝗿𝗼𝗼𝗱𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝘁𝗶𝗺𝗲.”

I liked the ending and I enjoyed this one more than I enjoyed the first one.

𝗧𝗵𝗲 𝗰𝗵𝗮𝗿𝗮𝗰𝘁𝗲𝗿𝘀
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Haley ~ I still liked her because she was funny. I think I might have liked her a little bit more in the first book when she was doing that Gothic heroine thing instead of whatever she's doing in this one LOL.

Montague ~ I like him. He was a little bit awkward though but other than that I liked him quite a bit and I do think that he's a good love interest for Haley.

Cuthbert ~ he was still hilarious like almost everything he said was just really funny and so I still really liked him. He was still probably my favorite character.

Laurence ~ he was okay he was just really brooding and a little boring but he was better in this one though.

Wilhelmina ~ she was really annoying. I did not like her.

Sybil ~ didn't like her at all.

Crickers ~ he was hilarious like Cuthbert and I liked their friendship.

Maybury ~ I liked the plot twist involving him. I really liked that I just can't say it because obviously it's a plot twist so obviously it's a spoiler.

Miss Meadowsweet ~ she was insanely weird.

Shotcroft ~ he didn't have much time actually on page so he was kind of boring. He didn't really have that many lines either so I don't really have much to say about him.

Miss Harewood ~ she was a little boring, kind of like shotcraft but she did have more page time than him. She was just still a little boring I don't know.

𝗪𝗵𝗮𝘁 𝘁𝗼 𝗲𝘅𝗽𝗲𝗰𝘁
🪞 Gothic Romance Parody
🪞 Graphic Novel
🪞 Murder Mystery
🪞 Romance
🪞 Sci-fi

𝗤𝘂𝗼𝘁𝗲𝘀
~~~~~~~
“Back in my village, I recall, there was a young man who never got to sleep in a proper hour. One of those modern types. That wasn't good for his health, not one bit, before long he didn't know night from day or a raven from a writing desk. Naturally, he snapped and went on a killing spree. And 𝘁𝗵𝗮𝘁'𝘀 why you always get a good night's sleep.”

𝗖𝗼𝗻𝘁𝗲𝗻𝘁
~~~~~~~
❤️‍🔥𝗥𝗼𝗺𝗮𝗻𝗰𝗲| two kisses,

🤬𝗟𝗮𝗻𝗴𝘂𝗮𝗴𝗲| B-stard, blast,

🗡️𝗩𝗶𝗼𝗹𝗲𝗻𝗰𝗲| Murder, Stabbing, fighting,

🏳️‍🌈𝗟𝗚𝗕𝗧𝗤| Wilhelmina and Sybil are dating or something and they kiss once

✝️ 𝗥𝗲𝗹𝗶𝗴𝗶𝗼𝗻/𝘀𝗽𝗶𝗿𝗶𝘁𝘂𝗮𝗹𝗶𝘁𝘆| ghosts,

⚠️𝗢𝘁𝗵𝗲𝗿| Blood, drugging
Profile Image for Mehsi.
16.2k reviews479 followers
May 26, 2026
The second book in the series and this time a mystery universe along with some extra dangers is added to the universe of gothic nature. Which leads to several delightful moments, murders, a cute dog with a disgusting habit, we learn more about Willowweep and what makes it tick, there is someone doing some erasing, our MC tries to be more detectivey but really gets outdone by Crickers and the other idiot from this universe, there is a chicken, and there is lots of mystery and some dangerous moments. I loved every moment of it!

Maybe I will write a longer review, for now *sleeps*.
Profile Image for Mai.
466 reviews6 followers
December 8, 2025
The first graphic novel in this series parodied the genre of Gothic romance. This one parodies the genres of both Gothic romance and murder mystery. For even more fun, Shaenon Garrity lifts a supporting cast of characters from the Clue franchise. I found myself laughing out loud in parts. This story is a really fun, sometimes absurd, wholly entertaining read.
Profile Image for Kat.
415 reviews1 follower
September 23, 2026
This was a laugh-out-loud romp that lovingly satirizes golden age mysteries
Profile Image for Megan Mann.
1,456 reviews32 followers
September 19, 2025
Oh my god. This was so much fun. I loved the first one, but this one was equally as fun. It played on the mystery genre this time and mixed it with gothic literature. It was just so fun.
Profile Image for TheNextGenLibrarian.
3,318 reviews130 followers
March 23, 2025
The highly-anticipated sequel to the Willowweep Manor YA graphic novel.
🐶
Haley hates living in the real world after being able to travel to a pocket universe. When she gets the chance to go back, she’s thrilled. This time another pocket universe is collapsing and the survivors are seeking refuge in Willowweep. They’re from a mystery-themed universe so automatically upon their arrival there’s a murder and the new and old cast of characters must solve the crime!
🔪
I got such Clue vibes from this book, which made me love it as much as Haley’s gothic romance world. Outlandish, hilarious and over-the-top events make this an unforgettable novel. The Maverick reading list committee added the 1st in the series when I was Chair so I’ll always have a soft spot for these titles. Nefarious Nights releases August 12!

CW: murder, blood, death
Profile Image for Cristy (Quinnbook).
236 reviews10 followers
May 2, 2025
I absolutely loved this sequel, from beginning to end you’ll cheer for our protagonist and the inhabitants of Willowweep Manor. Haley is back at school and delivers a fantastic oral report about her previous adventures. Unfortunately nobody seems to take her seriously. As she leaves school she is meet with Montague, one of the Willowweep inhabitants.

When they finally pass the portal together they are meet with everyone and now they’ll have more unexpected visitors. One thing I love about books is all the different genres and especially when those genres are combined in a unique way. This sequel had so many funny and tragic moments that it was like watching a detective movie unfold its secrets. Can’t wait to continue this amazing saga and follow along our heroine Haley as she becomes an expert in everything bookish.
Profile Image for Vanessa.
208 reviews
June 17, 2025
what a fun adventure off into the land of mystery. enjoyed this way more than the first one. Gothic romance is not my preferred read although for a graphic novel it wasn't horrible. returning to willowweep this time where the brothers make new friends that flee their universe because it was being erased. gone for eternity no where for them to go. new rooms appear. old ones disappear. of course cannot have a good mystery without a good old who done it murder. I would say there is sort of 2 stories going on at once but very easy to follow and they do intertwine nicely. some laughs, quite a few chuckles and still a rather happy ending. if there is a book 3 I'll definitely be reading it.
Profile Image for Elizabeth.
2,270 reviews70 followers
November 17, 2025
I originally read The Dire Days of Willowweep Manor in 2021, just months after it had been released. I loved it, and it has been one I remembered very fondly ever since. I have been so incredibly excited since I heard that four years later, we were finally getting a sequel. I reread the first book in preparation, and now that I have the library copy of the Nefarious Nights of Willowweep Manor (I intend to own both eventually, but books are expensive and I am poor) I had to read it immediately.

It was so fun! The characters continue to be a delight, with some fun new characters introduced. I love the way it continues to play with gothic story tropes, and I thought adding murder mystery tropes to the mix was such a fun way to continue the story without getting too repetitive. The mystery itself had some really fun twists and turns too. I love that it leaves off with another open enough ending for another book, and I hope we get another (ideally sooner than four years from now, but I'm prepared to wait!).

It's just such a blast of a story, and I'm so glad to have read it. I would recommend it for sure, but be sure to check out the first book first.
Profile Image for Samantha.
3,008 reviews207 followers
March 25, 2026
These are my absolute favorite graphic novels.

I was curious where the second installment of the story would go, and I love that Willowweep, formerly Gothikana manor extraordinaire, has now adapted itself to a classic mystery setting.

Fear not, all the Gothic design and tropes (and jokes!) are still there, but Garrity and Baldwin have added another layer to the story and it worked incredibly well.

The humor (both written and illustrated) remains absolutely elite in these, and the plot here is as clever as it was in the first book. These have some of the best sense of place and immersive atmosphere that I’ve run across in a graphic novel, and it comes through both in the text and in the art. More, please!

*I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.*
Profile Image for piper monarchsandmyths.
670 reviews68 followers
November 7, 2025
this series is super fun and charming! i liked seeing how they took on murder mystery tropes and combined them with the gothic elements already in-universe. also okay setup for more books in the future, i’m here for it!!
Profile Image for Donna Callaghan.
978 reviews1 follower
October 14, 2025
4.5 this was just as good as the first one! I love the quirky characters and the story was really good.
Profile Image for Kara.
Author 29 books99 followers
October 6, 2025

After a thorough deconstruction of the Gothic novel in the first book in the Willowweep Manor series, Haley is back at the manor, ready for more adventure. This time, we get a hilarious deconstruction of all the tropes of the Mystery novel, with Haley frankly admitting how out of her depth she is.

There is both a satisfying ending as well as plenty of plot threads left dangling for more of this universe (and others) and I look forward to more of this series.
Profile Image for Renee.
988 reviews1 follower
October 25, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐✨
5.5 stars

The Nefarious Nights of Willowweep Manor by Shaenon K. Garrity

Haley's adventures in the strange world of Willowweep Manor continue when a distress signal arrives from another pocket universe. With entire worlds beginning to collapse, Haley and the inhabitants of Willowweep Manor find themselves dealing with visitors from a very different literary genre: the classic murder mystery. And naturally, wherever murder-mystery characters go, suspicious deaths, elaborate clues and increasingly peculiar circumstances are never far behind.

I absolutely adored the first book, The Dire Days of Willowweep Manor, and somehow this one was even better. Which presents something of a problem, considering I gave the first book five stars. Goodreads might not allow more than five, but it's my review and I can do what I like. So, five and a half stars it is!

Haley remains a fantastic protagonist. She's clever, resourceful, determined and wonderfully unimpressed by the idea that she should behave according to the conventions of whichever fictional genre she happens to find herself in. But this time, she finds herself at something of a disadvantage. Gothic romances are her speciality, and she quickly discovers that her knowledge of murder mysteries is nowhere near as comprehensive. I really enjoyed watching her grapple with an unfamiliar set of literary conventions, gradually learning the rules and working alongside Miss Harewood, the wonderfully capable young woman from the murder-mystery world. It's a lovely development of her character, and I appreciated that her success comes from curiosity, resourcefulness and a willingness to learn rather than simply knowing all the answers.

The three brothers are every bit as entertaining as before. Laurence remains the wonderfully stoic, perpetually serious eldest brother, Montague is still the handsome, poetic romantic, and Cuthbert continues to be gloriously dim and delightfully ridiculous. There are also some rather interesting developments in Haley and Montague's relationship, which I thoroughly enjoyed. But I think my new favourite character might actually be a chicken. Yes, a chicken.

Cuthbert's friendship with Crickers, one of the newcomers from the murder-mystery universe, is absolutely hilarious. The two become inseparable, proudly declaring themselves people best friends, because naturally their actual best friends are Crickers' dog, Jerome, and Cuthbert's chicken. I'm laughing again just thinking about them, which probably tells you everything you need to know about how much I enjoyed this book.

When Crickers takes Jerome for walks, Cuthbert decides he needs a companion of his own, so naturally he acquires a chicken and puts it on a lead. The two then venture into the real world to visit a public library, dressed in their wonderfully outdated clothing, one walking a dog and the other a chicken. The whole thing is gloriously absurd, made even better by the fact that their research into murder-mystery conventions turns out to be genuinely useful. I loved that two characters who are initially sent off to keep them out of the way end up making a meaningful contribution. And the chicken herself proves to be considerably more capable than anyone might expect. Honestly, I think she deserves her own book.

But the humour doesn't stop there. Garrity has such a brilliant understanding of literary conventions, and the way she pokes fun at them is genuinely hilarious. This time, the gloomy Gothic atmosphere of Willowweep Manor collides with the familiar characters and settings of an old-fashioned murder mystery. There's Colonel Shotcroft, Miss Meadowsweet, the wonderfully capable Miss Harewood, the delightfully foppish Crickers and Maybury, the seemingly unflappable butler whose talents extend considerably beyond serving breakfast. Even the manor itself starts accommodating the newcomers, producing a conservatory, crypt, study and other rooms that belong in their particular sort of story.

I also loved Maybury, whose unexpected talents provide some wonderfully ridiculous moments. His impromptu attempt to psychoanalyse the perpetually serious Laurence was hilarious, particularly when Laurence had absolutely no idea what an alienist or a psychiatrist was. It's another perfect example of the humour that comes from bringing characters from completely different literary traditions together and expecting them to understand one another.

Some of the jokes are so unexpectedly perfect that I found myself laughing out loud. I particularly loved the way the characters are bound by the rules of their genres, even when those rules are completely ridiculous. It's the sort of humour that becomes even funnier when you recognise exactly which literary convention is being skewered. There were moments when I had to stop reading just to appreciate the sheer absurdity of what was happening.

And just like the first book, there's far more going on beneath the comedy than you might initially expect. The mythology surrounding these strange little universes continues to expand, and the mystery introduces some genuinely intriguing developments. I loved watching the different genres collide while Haley worked to make sense of what was happening. There's plenty of cleverness in the plotting, and the story manages to be both wonderfully silly and surprisingly compelling. The mystery itself was entertaining, with some satisfying surprises along the way.

The artwork is once again gorgeous. I loved the atmospheric Gothic setting in the first book, and the illustrations here are every bit as engaging. The visual details add so much to the humour, particularly as the different literary worlds begin to overlap. The expressions, settings and little background touches make the whole thing an absolute pleasure to read. Once again, I became so absorbed in the story that I stopped noticing I was reading a graphic novel and simply felt immersed in its wonderfully strange world.

What I appreciate most about these books is that they never feel as though they're talking down to their audience. The literary references are clever, the characters are engaging, and the humour works on multiple levels. They're accessible to younger readers, but there's so much here for adults who recognise the genres being lovingly dismantled. I think having some familiarity with Gothic romances and traditional murder mysteries makes the jokes even more enjoyable, although there's plenty to appreciate regardless.

I genuinely didn't want this one to end. I loved the characters, the mystery, the developing relationships, the increasingly elaborate worldbuilding and, above all, the humour. It's rare that a book makes me laugh quite this consistently, and rarer still that I find myself laughing again just remembering particular scenes afterward.

5.5 stars. I'm making an executive decision that the rating scale needed expanding.
Profile Image for Hannah Rowan.
437 reviews
May 18, 2025
The Dire Days of Willowweep Manor is one of my all time favorite graphic novels. When I found out there was going to be a sequel, I was beyond excited. I was even more excited when I was approved for the ARC! Being back in the bizarre world of Willowweep was such a delight. I didn’t think the story could get much better, but it was expanded upon wonderfully. All of our favorite characters are back with new side characters that are just as lovable. I loved the commentary on cross genre stories. The author took all the tropes of a gothic story and paired it brilliantly with the tropes of a classic mystery novel. As always, this book made me laugh out loud. It was such a good time. I really hope the series continues. I would love to see the story cross over with the fantasy genre. There’s so much potential for more tales in this series. I adored this. Immediately preordered and added to my all time favorites shelf!

*Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for my honest review!*
Profile Image for Lindsey.
1,368 reviews56 followers
August 10, 2025
✨ Review ✨ The Nefarious Nights of Willowweep Manor by Shaenon K. Garrity, Illustrated by Christopher Baldwin

Thanks to Simon and Schuster Children's Publishing, Margaret K. McElderry Books and #netgalley for the gifted advanced copy/ies of this book!

Welp, I didn't realize this was the second book in the series so it sort of starts at a run, but I feel like I more or less caught up quickly. The main character heads off to a pocket universe, Willowweep, that she's apparently already saved once in the first book. This gothic universe collides with newcomers from a mystery-themed universe and a classic whodunit commences.

This was lots of fun and makes me want to go back and read the first one! I loved how it played with genre in a sort of chaotic don't-let-the-universe-collapse sort of way. :)

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Genre: mystery meets gothic YA graphic novel
Setting: Willowweep pocket universe
Pub Date: August 12, 2025

Read this if you like:
⭕️ YA graphic novels
⭕️ mystery and gothic styles
⭕️ chaos
Profile Image for Abigail Pankau.
2,187 reviews22 followers
September 8, 2025
Haley is still studying how pocket universes work with the assistance of Willowweep residents, when they receive a message from another universe. That pocket universe is disappearing, and the survivors are seeking refuge. Haley figures out they are from a murder mystery genre universe when one of them is found murdered, but Haley has no experience with mystery novels and can't solve this mystery on her own. When Willowweep residents start disappearing, she realizes that this pocket universe is now threatened. Can she figure out who's behind it all and stop them before it's too late?

A very fun YA graphic novel that’s a fully self-aware parody of mystery novels, with a slight gothic twist. It is nice to world-building and the ideas of the pocket universes expand. Very fun. Hope there will be more in this series.
Profile Image for Ashley.
1,245 reviews28 followers
May 1, 2025
Mysteries abound when Willowweep, a gothic pocket universe, takes in a group of refugees from a disappearing mystery universe. But when parts of Willowweep start to disappear as well, it's up to heroine Haley and romantic hero Montague to solve the mystery...if only they knew how mysteries worked. I love the Willowweep Universe so much. Especially Cuthbert and his new best person friend, Crickers (they're the same person and must be protected at all costs) and the dog Jerome and his sticky spot. This book was so delightful - just like it's predecessor. I can't wait for more! (Fingers crossed there will be more, someday!)
Profile Image for Katherine.
199 reviews8 followers
July 14, 2025
Adored how creative the premise was and this narrative is ripe for many, many installments! The cast of characters is so diverse, leaning into genre stereotypes yet never feeling boring. There's so many different personalities and dynamics at play here. I did find it a bit difficult to keep track of them all once the other universe's cast joined theirs, though. There's a perfect blend of mystery and comedy that keeps you engaged throughout. A genuinely fun narrative coupled with an inviting art style that will keep readers wanting more from this universe.

Thanks to NetGalley and Simon and Schuster Children's Publishing for the arc!
Profile Image for Sesana.
6,688 reviews326 followers
September 22, 2025
Not quite as much fun as the first entry in this series. This is probably because I have more of a fondness for the gothic tropes that the first book was gently mocking than the mystery genre that intrudes here. Specifically, golden age detective mysteries. I did think the mystery was fairly well written, and that an astute reader could figure out the solution on their own. That's essential to be a true homage to this type of story. The ending is just open enough to make me think more books, skewering other genres, are on the way, and I'm here for that.
Profile Image for Badger.
86 reviews4 followers
August 3, 2025
This was a dang delight. Even better then the first volume and absolutely sold me on a third. Our heroine Haley return to her beloved Willowweep Manor and soon finds herself in an unexpected genre: murder mystery. Hi-jinks ensue, new best friends are made, and secrets are revealed. I loved the silliness and and the whole-hardheartedness of every character's personalty. Truly so, so fun.

My thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the advanced digital review copy.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 89 reviews