This debut poetry collection by Canadian broadcaster, Josie Balka, is organized into three thematic sections: loving, longing, and living. Of these, the loving and longing sections resonated with me the most. They offered moments of emotional reflection that felt sincere and relatable. In contrast, while there were a few strong pieces in the living section, I found it less compelling overall. The experimental shifts in poetic form and structure throughout this section often felt disjointed rather than dynamic, and the reflective content veered at times into territory that echoed the language of familiar self-help rather than fresh or insightful.
The collection's format also presented some challenges. The absence of formal breaks between poems gave the impression of a continuous stream of verse, which blurred the boundaries between individual pieces. While this may have been an intentional stylistic choice, it made it difficult at times to fully appreciate each poem on its own terms. Stylistically, the poet experiments with a wide range of forms and voices, a choice that both highlighted their versatility and revealed the unevenness of a writer still discovering their creative identity. The collection feels very much like a first book—ambitious and heartfelt, but occasionally disjointed. That said, there are definite gems scattered throughout, and moments where the poet's potential shines through.
Overall, this is a debut that shows promise, even as it grapples with questions of form, tone, and cohesion. I believe newer readers to poetry would greatly enjoy this collection as it offers an opportunity to explore familiar themes of love, nostalgia, and anxiety while also showcasing a variety of poetry styles. For longtime poetry readers though, this collection may leave you wanting more cohesion.
Thank you to the publisher, Simon Element, for an e-ARC of this book via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own!