Kto przeleje krew

Noah #4

by Darren Aronofsky, Ari Handel, Niko Henrichon

Le créateur dit alors : "J'exterminerai de la face de la Terre l'homme que j'ai créé". Genèse 6:7

Genres: Comics, Graphic Novels, Graphic Novels Comics

56 pages, Hardcover

First published January 1, 2014

About the author

Darren S. Aronofsky (born February 12, 1969) is an American film director, screenwriter and film producer. He attended Harvard University and AFI to study both live-action and animation film theory, where he met long-time collaborator Matthew Libatique. He won several film awards after completing his senior thesis film, "Supermarket Sweep", starring Sean Gullette, which went on to become a National Student Academy Award finalist.

Aronofsky did not make a feature film until five years later, creating the concept for his debut feature, π, in February 1996. The low-budget, $60,000 production, starring Sean Gullette, was sold to Artisan Entertainment for $1 million, and grossed over $3 million; it won both a Sundance Film Festival award and an Independent Spirit Award. Aronofsky's followup, Requiem for a Dream, was based on the novel of the same name written by Hubert Selby, Jr. The film received an Academy Award nomination for Ellen Burstyn's performance. After turning down an opportunity to direct Batman Begins, Aronofsky began production on his third film, The Fountain. The film was released to mixed reviews and poor box office results.

However, his next film, The Wrestler, rebounded with positive reviews and healthy box office. Both of the film's stars, Mickey Rourke and Marisa Tomei, received Academy Award nominations. Rourke also won a Golden Globe for Best Actor and Bruce Springsteen won for Best Original Song for his title song. Aronofsky's next film, Black Swan, received further critical acclaim and many accolades, being nominated for five Academy Awards including Best Picture and Best Director, four Golden Globes including Best Motion Picture – Drama and Best Director, three Screen Actors Guild Awards, a record 12 BFCA nominations and a DGA nomination.

Reviews

[Kristijan · Rating 4 out of 5]

Nakon čitanja sva četiri nastavka i ukupno 2 (slovima:dva) gledanja filma ostajem pri svojim ocenama: 5-5-5-4.
Ono što me u celini, u svim nastavcima oduševilo jesu grafika, boje i sitni detalji. Bukvalno sam provodio minute analizirajući slike, što je znak da je grafička novela više nego uspešno odrađena.
Generalno gledano ovo je interesantna verzija dobro poznate biblijske priče, ali prikazana na malo blasfemičan i drugačiji način.
Kada uporedimo sa filmom postoje momenti koji su bolje odrađeni u ovim novelama, ali postoji i ono što je bolje realizovano u filmu.
Zašto je poslednji deo dobio 4 zvezdice? Ima dva razloga - tempo poslednjeg nastavka je malo sporiji od prethodnika pa deluje nekako neujednačeno, i smatram da je situacija kada Noa sazna za svoje unuke ipak bolje rešena u filmu nego u noveli.
Možda sam subjektivan kada je Aronofski u pitanju, ali meni je ova grafička novela totalno legla!

[Petar Vučković · Rating 1 out of 5]

This is part 4 (and the last part) of Noah, graphic novel.

I am so angry right now. Fuck the art, this was a terrible story. Noah is a terrible person. He couldn't kill one last time, yet he could have killed millions of people, his son's wife and many others. These were the stories in the Bible that made me be a unbeliever.

This did nothing for me then make me feel bad. And they forgave him? I need to calm down... I can talk about the Bible right now (had some funny things to say about its inaccuracies) but I won't. Because that wouldn't be fair to people who are Christian. But read between the lines people. 1 star, regret reading it.

[Sven · Rating 4 out of 5]

Het afsluitende deel van de Noach reeks. Het deel waarin Noach in conflict komt met zichzelf. Ik zou niet graag in zijn plaats staan om beslissingen te nemen op leven of dood.

Engels
The closing part of the Noah series. The part where Noah comes into conflict with himself. I wouldn't like to be in his place to make life or death decisions.

[BozCitac · Rating 3 out of 5]

Although full of beautiful drawings, this is a rather disappointing and hasty conclusion to an unusual deconstruction of the famous Bible story.

[Quiver · Rating 2 out of 5]

Poznati kraj bez nekog posebnog iznenađena. Lep provod za po desetak minuta po knjizi.

[Markus Pfeffer · Rating 3 out of 5]

Das dramatische Finale - ein Akt des Verzeihens macht diesen letzten Band ein bisschen weniger berechenbar. Am Ende Ende ist jedoch klar, dass man allein schon durch die Vorlage weiß, wie die Geschichte ausgeht. Da istnicht viel Platz für Überraschungen, und so ist der Schluss dann auch etwas ruhiger und vorhersehbarer, als man sich das gewünscht hätte. Und leider auch optisch kein Vergleich zu dem fantastischen dritten Teil.

[G-E · Rating 2 out of 5]

Les choix de Noé sont discutables, il est complètement détaché de sa famille. Le côté religieux est plus présent dans cet album, ce que j’ai moins aimé. Moins d’action dans celui-ci et une fin sans éclat.

[William · Rating 4 out of 5]

Mooie ballonstrip

[Stephanie Racette · Rating 3 out of 5]

Juillet 2021. J’ai failli mettre un 2. Les dessins rachètent le tout.