So this book does get my automatic 1 star because of my rule about depiction of, and especially vivid depictions of animal cruelty in fiction.
You might be a genius writer and have some sort of excellent plot or story, but since I write the review I make the rule for it.
This book also doesn’t work for me. Culture-wise, phenomenon-wise, influencers and that sort of thing, getting them or becoming one, caring at all, fashionableness, I’m just not in that age bracket. (I’m very proud of mine, thanks for asking. Don’t feel missed out or old)
Ok so in this book our main character is Kylie.
We do not know her age at the exact beginning and I highlight that to highlight some hidden creepy themes I thought the book might be hiding, which, of course, could have added to the horror.
You could guess she is a teenager and, her teenage friend Erin post pictures to get likes, and the likes and comments come from older men who, shall we say, are perverts. There are other disturbing mind snapshots as well for sensationalist, horror value, example, the teens think about the Parkland Massacre and wish they could be survivors of something similar to bring them fame and attention. Even in the book, there are more rational teenagers, so these are of course not pictures of the mind of your normal teenager, even of today with all the influencer and social media phenomena. So, assuming 18 is the standard coming-of-age age in the whole world, I started wondering if these girls might be minors and this could also be a theme of this book?
Luckily not.
We learn they are just starting college.
Now even before the plot gets to the new app or the murder, we can already know Kylie has mental health issues. Not even getting to social media, she was thinking of committing suicide over a boy.
I also think it is fair to guess Kylie’s community is not rich America, but difficult to estimate how poor exactly? Maybe sort of middle class.
Her mom works long hours, so she’s alone a lot. She is also so young that she doesn’t understand the pure huge gulf between, for example, Katy Perry and herself, in that she really believes she can somehow relate to a rich celebrity through her music. Or is that just me? Because I know half the process songs go through to get put out there and for air-play, most music by big names is illusionary plastic, and is often just written for the album or attention. Very little is heart-felt. I mean, if you literally have billions of Dollars, your sad songs are probably not too real or authentic. I will grant you grief and death, but romantic love I am unwilling to even give you, since you move onto the next party and person on your arm so quickly. Plus the money and everything with it obviously shields you from normal people problems.
Anyway, like all teenagers mostly, Kylie is obsessed especially with one musician or band.
Now we get to the social media bit.
I was wanting to write that Kylie is vacuous, vapid and shallow and jealous, so unlikeable from the beginning, but this is what made me pause.
I did not grow up as a teenager under social media. How do those of us like me know or not whether we’d obsess about how many followers we had, or get jealous if people we knew had many more?
And, of course we had them, but very few and only on TV, we didn’t have the craze of influencers our age, let alone our friends or us ever being one.
On that subject, anyone remember Candice Hillebrand every afternoon on KTV after school? Or the other ones on Yo Tv? I forget their names.
So if you have read the book description you know Kylie joins a secret social networking app. It then becomes the more sinister horror bit.
Now here is the most stupid problem with this book.
If you are a human with ubuntu, you realize soon enough that Kylie is totally unlikeable.
So you are then left with a totally shit book because, you’re literally about a tenth of the way through the book and you like or care about absolutely nothing and no one.
A horror book shouldn’t do that?
The plot gets silly. The app in the story is rather nothing too special, rather crappy. Just a social media that isn’t censored and just brutal, cruel, disgusting shocking crap, the only difference between it and real-life social networks is that Monolife rewards and makes people achieve higher status by them performing worse and worse cruelties,but nothing that makes the book unique. For example a canabal woman. I’m sure in real life on hidden internet even vids of that can be circulating. He think he is unique, his devices and horror, it just isn’t, so the plot is not even fascinating. A normal survivor crime novel or real-life reality TV much better. Maybe imagine something like the dark web being open to idiots in our real world. If they could, you can bet that the people who censor everything else would try censor the dark web if they knew about it. Moms For Liberty and such would really try. The real world with social media and sensorship much more imaginative. Just really unimpressive with it and the story. Just cartoonish nasty rubbish, so the author’s point about social media also falls rather flat. Characters and everything just totally silly. I will say though that the book has good word paintings and descriptive scenes.
Ridiculous when paranormal character and event comes into play, I never have time for books with such nonsense.
We can comment that the author shows us the harm social media causes and the lengths users then go for attention-seeking and affirmation, also cults and so on, but do we already not see this in real-life anyway?
I will say though, I don’t think it is as bad as the author thinks. I mean, many teenagers just need education about dopamine and being responsible users of social media and screen-time.
What scares me often much more are the old people in their 60s and 70s who become addicts to social media and also do not understand how much fake content and news can be so professionally generated.
How do you think all this Q’Anon is going on?
Plus we have keyboard warriors who are basically dying of boredom, so they use their time to find outrage and oppress the younger people in vulnerable groups, example wanting books banned and organizing to prevent and take away rights of often YOUNG and distressed Lgbt people.
That is some real harm coming from social media in real life that is not noticed by many.
The narrator is very good.
The book?
Honestly it is mostly absolutely a shit boring story. Not interesting.
You won’t miss out if you don’t give it a read.
Disappointing as well. Wish could just tell you ending plot so could really persuade you not to waste your time.
The book description is more interesting than the story.
Book melo-drama bad soap opera.
The more I think about it, the more d-rate the book felt for me. Even it’s supposed satire and commentary about social media culture is really rather unsophisticated tackling this theme.