What do you think?
Rate this book
Dangerous Girls
An atmospheric, heart‑racing gothic fantasy romance for
fans of Ninth House, The Power and Wilder
Girls.
Imogen Brine is undeniably strange. Some would even say
dangerous.
She can make poisonous flowers grow from her fingertips and her
"gift" is becoming harder to control. When she is invited to a
secret island to be with other girls – girls with dangerous
gifts of their own – it feels like the chance to finally be
herself. Somewhere she will fit in. However, not long after her
arrival, a deer is found dead with poisonous flowers growing from
its corpse. And all eyes are on Imogen.
Imogen knows she's been set up. Something on the island feels
wrong – and it isn't just the friction with the other girls
or the growing tension between her and the son of the island's head
of security, Jack. As strange occurrences continue to rock the
island, some more dangerous than others, Imogen realizes she will
have to work quickly to learn what's causing them.
Because things are about to turn deadly. And not all dangerous
girls want to be friends.
Part dark and addictive fantasy, part murder mystery:
this story features a compelling cast of girls with unique
gifts and chilling secrets
Atmospheric and beautifully written, it's filled with gorgeous,
slow-burn romantic tension
Perfect for fans of Leigh Bardugo with shades of Netflix's Wednesday
fans of Ninth House, The Power and Wilder
Girls.
Imogen Brine is undeniably strange. Some would even say
dangerous.
She can make poisonous flowers grow from her fingertips and her
"gift" is becoming harder to control. When she is invited to a
secret island to be with other girls – girls with dangerous
gifts of their own – it feels like the chance to finally be
herself. Somewhere she will fit in. However, not long after her
arrival, a deer is found dead with poisonous flowers growing from
its corpse. And all eyes are on Imogen.
Imogen knows she's been set up. Something on the island feels
wrong – and it isn't just the friction with the other girls
or the growing tension between her and the son of the island's head
of security, Jack. As strange occurrences continue to rock the
island, some more dangerous than others, Imogen realizes she will
have to work quickly to learn what's causing them.
Because things are about to turn deadly. And not all dangerous
girls want to be friends.
Part dark and addictive fantasy, part murder mystery:
this story features a compelling cast of girls with unique
gifts and chilling secrets
Atmospheric and beautifully written, it's filled with gorgeous,
slow-burn romantic tension
Perfect for fans of Leigh Bardugo with shades of Netflix's Wednesday
320 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 11, 2025
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 54 reviews
September 21, 2025
not what i was expecting at all tbh...netflix's wednesday meets miss peregrines home for peculiar children
March 4, 2026
Rating- 5 Stars
(Physical Book)
What a amazing gem of a book. I got this book for Christmas off my mum who knows my tastes quite well. This did not disappoint and was a stunning debut YA novel off the author.
This followed Imogen Brine who has the ability to grow poisonous flowers from her fingertips. She starts finding it hard to control and is invited to a secret island where there is other girls who needs help to control their gifts. There are mutiple different gifts on the island. But not soon after she arrives, a deer is found dead with poisonous flowers growing from the deer. Imogen knows she has not done it and is being set up. Other occurrences start and she has to work with the help of Jack on whats causing them.
This was amazing. I was unable to put this book down. There were moments where this book made you doubt everyone. At one point you would think that you knew the culprit before it would change your mind competely where faced with other clues. It was fast paced and the characters were full of personality. It was interesting to see the other different girls gifts. I especially liked the way other generations were also mentioned and the history of the island. The references to witchcraft too.
I am really looking forward to seeing what else this author will do because I will definitely be reading more of her books. Please check this book out- this will definitely not disappoint you.
(Physical Book)
What a amazing gem of a book. I got this book for Christmas off my mum who knows my tastes quite well. This did not disappoint and was a stunning debut YA novel off the author.
This followed Imogen Brine who has the ability to grow poisonous flowers from her fingertips. She starts finding it hard to control and is invited to a secret island where there is other girls who needs help to control their gifts. There are mutiple different gifts on the island. But not soon after she arrives, a deer is found dead with poisonous flowers growing from the deer. Imogen knows she has not done it and is being set up. Other occurrences start and she has to work with the help of Jack on whats causing them.
This was amazing. I was unable to put this book down. There were moments where this book made you doubt everyone. At one point you would think that you knew the culprit before it would change your mind competely where faced with other clues. It was fast paced and the characters were full of personality. It was interesting to see the other different girls gifts. I especially liked the way other generations were also mentioned and the history of the island. The references to witchcraft too.
I am really looking forward to seeing what else this author will do because I will definitely be reading more of her books. Please check this book out- this will definitely not disappoint you.
September 10, 2025
Mostly I already pre-order books and then discover I can request a digital review copy through Netgalley. Sometimes I discover books through Netgalley. This book had not been on my radar, but the cover and the blurb made me curious and Scholastic UK granted me a review copy.
It's clearly been a while since I read a true YA. I had to get used to the writing, a little easier to read and a little simpler than what I currently read mostly. However, I'm glad that I stumbled upon a true YA again. I'm glad they're still there. Books younger teenagers can lose themselves in, can see themselves in and can read without being confronted with all kinds of graphic and gruesome scenes they're not yet into.
What I love about this book is the friendships and the way these characters eventually show they trust each other. We get to meet all these girls, and one boy, and they are all different. They each have their own personality, their own challenges and their own talents. It's clear that not all of those girls will mix well. And yet, in the end, when things get important and dangerous, they pick the right side: each other's and it was really touching.
I also loved how this book, even though there are some dangerous and action packed moments, focusses on the good and the positive. I don't want to give everything away, but the heroine of the story is amazing when it comes to being empathic, caring and believing in people being inherently good. She was therefore easy to like and easy to believe. It was therefore also easy to root for her, her friends and their safe haven on the Isle.
It's clearly been a while since I read a true YA. I had to get used to the writing, a little easier to read and a little simpler than what I currently read mostly. However, I'm glad that I stumbled upon a true YA again. I'm glad they're still there. Books younger teenagers can lose themselves in, can see themselves in and can read without being confronted with all kinds of graphic and gruesome scenes they're not yet into.
What I love about this book is the friendships and the way these characters eventually show they trust each other. We get to meet all these girls, and one boy, and they are all different. They each have their own personality, their own challenges and their own talents. It's clear that not all of those girls will mix well. And yet, in the end, when things get important and dangerous, they pick the right side: each other's and it was really touching.
I also loved how this book, even though there are some dangerous and action packed moments, focusses on the good and the positive. I don't want to give everything away, but the heroine of the story is amazing when it comes to being empathic, caring and believing in people being inherently good. She was therefore easy to like and easy to believe. It was therefore also easy to root for her, her friends and their safe haven on the Isle.
August 24, 2025
This was dark, fun and fast paced. I read this in one sitting. I did guess the twist but that didn't stop it from being enjoyable and thrilling. It's gothic, dark murder mystery mixed with fantasy. It's giving Wednesday meets Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children and The House on the Cerulean Sea.
Loved the characters, the plot was great, the setting was cosy and dark. Loved that all the girls had unique, dark abilities, some that I've never/rarely read in books. There's a bit of romance in there too. Very enjoyable. So perfect for the weather turning colder and autumn/spooky season vibes.
[Thank you Scholastic for the ARC - all opinions are honest and my own]
Loved the characters, the plot was great, the setting was cosy and dark. Loved that all the girls had unique, dark abilities, some that I've never/rarely read in books. There's a bit of romance in there too. Very enjoyable. So perfect for the weather turning colder and autumn/spooky season vibes.
[Thank you Scholastic for the ARC - all opinions are honest and my own]
July 17, 2025
4.5 Stars
An atmospherically gothic YA fantasy with an eerie murder mystery at its core! Dangerous Girls felt like the slow burn (and deliciously creepy) sister to Wilder Girls, Miss Peregrine’s Home For Peculiar Children and Belladonna. And I thoroughly devoured it!
The chilling feeling of isolation at our setting Marshwood House, a school for girls with “dangerous” gifts (located on a secret, remote Scottish island), and the suffocatingly hostile wilderness that surrounds it was soo well done.
I’m an absolute sucker for eerie, uncanny vibes so the tension that encircles the girls as the story unfolds (and the suspicion and paranoia took hold) has me on utterly hooked and ready to play armchair detective. Though trying to work out the identity of the murderer was next to impossible (especially when their unique gifts were revealed.)
Seriously, I was on the edge of my seat and suspicious of literally everyone. Teachers, staff, the wildlife— everyone came under scrutiny, and like Imogen I just couldn’t work out who to trust!
I will say, I liked Imogen from the very start, and found her journey to self acceptance and belonging such a lovely if emotional experience. Her power to create poisonous flowers was pretty fascinating too and really added to the gorgeously lush, Belladonna-esque gothic tone.
The romance was good too (subtle and beautifully slow-burn) though does take a back seat to the mystery.
I found the other girls and their powers (control of birds, talking to the dead, influence over insects,etc) equally as intriguing, and enjoyed exploring how they each ended up at Marshwood. We don’t delve nearly as deep as I would’ve liked, but what we do explore was interesting.
There’s soo much I want to say but I can’t as it involves spoilers. What I can say however, is this was a wonderfully dark gothic YA fantasy with psychological horror-esque elements (that had me completely on edge until the very last page.) I absolutely loved it!
Also, thanks to Insta Book Tours & Scholastic UK for the proof & spot on the tour.
An atmospherically gothic YA fantasy with an eerie murder mystery at its core! Dangerous Girls felt like the slow burn (and deliciously creepy) sister to Wilder Girls, Miss Peregrine’s Home For Peculiar Children and Belladonna. And I thoroughly devoured it!
The chilling feeling of isolation at our setting Marshwood House, a school for girls with “dangerous” gifts (located on a secret, remote Scottish island), and the suffocatingly hostile wilderness that surrounds it was soo well done.
I’m an absolute sucker for eerie, uncanny vibes so the tension that encircles the girls as the story unfolds (and the suspicion and paranoia took hold) has me on utterly hooked and ready to play armchair detective. Though trying to work out the identity of the murderer was next to impossible (especially when their unique gifts were revealed.)
Seriously, I was on the edge of my seat and suspicious of literally everyone. Teachers, staff, the wildlife— everyone came under scrutiny, and like Imogen I just couldn’t work out who to trust!
I will say, I liked Imogen from the very start, and found her journey to self acceptance and belonging such a lovely if emotional experience. Her power to create poisonous flowers was pretty fascinating too and really added to the gorgeously lush, Belladonna-esque gothic tone.
The romance was good too (subtle and beautifully slow-burn) though does take a back seat to the mystery.
I found the other girls and their powers (control of birds, talking to the dead, influence over insects,etc) equally as intriguing, and enjoyed exploring how they each ended up at Marshwood. We don’t delve nearly as deep as I would’ve liked, but what we do explore was interesting.
There’s soo much I want to say but I can’t as it involves spoilers. What I can say however, is this was a wonderfully dark gothic YA fantasy with psychological horror-esque elements (that had me completely on edge until the very last page.) I absolutely loved it!
Also, thanks to Insta Book Tours & Scholastic UK for the proof & spot on the tour.
May 3, 2025
ad | thank you Scholastic Uk for gifting this copy.
Dangerous Girls is a YA novel set at Marshwood House - a secluded estate on a remote Scottish island. The story follows Imogen, a young girl sent to the house alongside others like her - all of them possess mysterious magical gifts. Whilst the house is meant to be there as a safe place for the girls to learn to control their magic, it quickly becomes unsettling when sinister and dangerous occurrences start happening. We follow Imogen as she races to uncover the truth before it’s too late.
I absolutely flew through this book - its gripping narrative made it an easy read. It has a blend of ghostly themes with a spooky atmosphere that I enjoyed. While I would have loved a bit more depth in the world-building, I found that the concise storytelling is well suited for a YA audience, especially those dipping their toes into suspenseful or thriller genres for the first time. I particularly enjoyed the fast pace of the latter third of the book where the story really begins to unravel.
The novel’s eerie tone makes it an ideal read for the spooky season - so its September release is perfect. If you’re looking for a captivating and slightly creepy YA read with a mix of magic and mystery then Dangerous Girls is a solid choice.
Dangerous Girls is a YA novel set at Marshwood House - a secluded estate on a remote Scottish island. The story follows Imogen, a young girl sent to the house alongside others like her - all of them possess mysterious magical gifts. Whilst the house is meant to be there as a safe place for the girls to learn to control their magic, it quickly becomes unsettling when sinister and dangerous occurrences start happening. We follow Imogen as she races to uncover the truth before it’s too late.
I absolutely flew through this book - its gripping narrative made it an easy read. It has a blend of ghostly themes with a spooky atmosphere that I enjoyed. While I would have loved a bit more depth in the world-building, I found that the concise storytelling is well suited for a YA audience, especially those dipping their toes into suspenseful or thriller genres for the first time. I particularly enjoyed the fast pace of the latter third of the book where the story really begins to unravel.
The novel’s eerie tone makes it an ideal read for the spooky season - so its September release is perfect. If you’re looking for a captivating and slightly creepy YA read with a mix of magic and mystery then Dangerous Girls is a solid choice.
August 28, 2025
In Dangerous Girls we are taken to a remote Scottish island which serves as home for a group of teenage girls that each have a unique gift, one which they need to learn to manage if they are not going to be seen as a danger to society.
Imogen is the newest arrival. Nervous about what she will face her arrival on the island does not quite go as well as she’d hoped when her gift - the ability to produce poisonous flowers - ends up killing a magpie belonging to one of the other girls. In the days following this, strange events occur and, each time, it seems to be one of the girls responsible although they are each adamant they’re not involved.
We follow the events through Imogen. As the outsider she is under suspicion, but we are aware that she seems to understand things are not what they appear to be. She has to learn who she can trust, and how much she is prepared to do to save herself and her new home.
While we never learn how the girls get their gifts it was interesting to see the changing dynamics between them. The setting was suitably atmospheric and though the explanation for what is taking place is quite unpleasant, it’s hard not to feel sympathy for all involved.
Thanks to NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read and review this before publication.
Imogen is the newest arrival. Nervous about what she will face her arrival on the island does not quite go as well as she’d hoped when her gift - the ability to produce poisonous flowers - ends up killing a magpie belonging to one of the other girls. In the days following this, strange events occur and, each time, it seems to be one of the girls responsible although they are each adamant they’re not involved.
We follow the events through Imogen. As the outsider she is under suspicion, but we are aware that she seems to understand things are not what they appear to be. She has to learn who she can trust, and how much she is prepared to do to save herself and her new home.
While we never learn how the girls get their gifts it was interesting to see the changing dynamics between them. The setting was suitably atmospheric and though the explanation for what is taking place is quite unpleasant, it’s hard not to feel sympathy for all involved.
Thanks to NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read and review this before publication.
July 10, 2025
3.5 ⭐️
This was a surprisingly fun and fast-paced read. I absolutely flew through it. Think Wednesday meets Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children with a gothic fantasy twist and a touch of murder mystery.
I really enjoyed the concept. Girls with dangerous magical gifts brought to a mysterious island? It had me hooked. Imogen’s ability to grow poisonous flowers was so intriguing, and the setting was creepy in the best way… although I wish the WHY behind this was explored a little more?! The tension builds nicely, there are some great twists and the slow-burn romance added a little extra something.
Perfect if you’re after something that’s dark, magical and just a little bit different.
This was a surprisingly fun and fast-paced read. I absolutely flew through it. Think Wednesday meets Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children with a gothic fantasy twist and a touch of murder mystery.
I really enjoyed the concept. Girls with dangerous magical gifts brought to a mysterious island? It had me hooked. Imogen’s ability to grow poisonous flowers was so intriguing, and the setting was creepy in the best way… although I wish the WHY behind this was explored a little more?! The tension builds nicely, there are some great twists and the slow-burn romance added a little extra something.
Perfect if you’re after something that’s dark, magical and just a little bit different.
September 12, 2025
“Colour me furious” p 301 was iconic.
And also the qoute at the start of the book’ for all the women killed as witches’🤌🏻
That plus the school being an only girls school made the book even better for me tbh.
I loved this book. It was twisted and dark but never too much and i didnt see the main plot comming. If u love the harry potter series like me u need to read this. It gives u the ‘magic school vibes’ as in the series but in a completly different atmospere. This book reminded me a little of Gallant by V.e Schwab. I also bought this book in waterstones while i was in Londen recently on vacation and got a singed version too, so that marks my first singed book ever! Thank you Lisa M. Sylvan! :)
And also the qoute at the start of the book’ for all the women killed as witches’🤌🏻
That plus the school being an only girls school made the book even better for me tbh.
I loved this book. It was twisted and dark but never too much and i didnt see the main plot comming. If u love the harry potter series like me u need to read this. It gives u the ‘magic school vibes’ as in the series but in a completly different atmospere. This book reminded me a little of Gallant by V.e Schwab. I also bought this book in waterstones while i was in Londen recently on vacation and got a singed version too, so that marks my first singed book ever! Thank you Lisa M. Sylvan! :)
September 30, 2025
An autumnal, witchy murder mystery perfect for spooky season.
This was very atmospheric, I liked the island setting and the X-Men/ witchy powers that distinguished each of the characters. The twist was fun and exciting with a confrontation scene I really enjoyed. The romance was sweet and a nice B plot that didn't impede on the main plot.
This story is about togetherness and acceptance and I really enjoyed it. Thank you to the publishers for the ARC (via the mess that was Waterstones Bookfest)
This was very atmospheric, I liked the island setting and the X-Men/ witchy powers that distinguished each of the characters. The twist was fun and exciting with a confrontation scene I really enjoyed. The romance was sweet and a nice B plot that didn't impede on the main plot.
This story is about togetherness and acceptance and I really enjoyed it. Thank you to the publishers for the ARC (via the mess that was Waterstones Bookfest)
October 8, 2025
Okay so I’m actually in love with this book.🤭
I NEED MORE😂
I picked it up on a whim and I’m so glad I did. The plot and the characters were outstanding, instantly falling in love with all of them. So much that I finished this book in 2 days (which I don’t not do very often)
And that plot twist left me screaming🤭
I NEED MORE😂
I picked it up on a whim and I’m so glad I did. The plot and the characters were outstanding, instantly falling in love with all of them. So much that I finished this book in 2 days (which I don’t not do very often)
And that plot twist left me screaming🤭
August 29, 2025
not my usual sort of book so didn’t love it but it was well written and definitely kept me on edge! not a massive fan of the ending though didn’t really feel finished / resolved to me tbh
January 6, 2026
Imogen Brine od zawsze była inna. Jej niezwykły dar, zdolność sprawiania, że spod jej palców wyrastają trujące kwiaty, jest czymś, nad czym nie potrafi zapanować. To moc, która jednocześnie fascynuje i przeraża, przez co Imogen przez całe życie doświadcza odrzucenia. Gdy otrzymuje zaproszenie na odludną szkocką wyspę, do Marshwood House, wierzy, że wreszcie trafiła do miejsca, w którym nie będzie musiała się ukrywać ani udawać kogoś innego.
Marshwood House ma być przestrzenią nauki akceptacji, siebie nawzajem i własnych zdolności. Trafiają tam dziewczęta obdarzone niezwykłymi, często niebezpiecznymi mocami, których świat się boi. Choć idea tego miejsca opiera się na zrozumieniu i wsparciu, rzeczywistość szybko okazuje się znacznie bardziej skomplikowana. Relacje między dziewczętami są trudne, pełne napięć, rywalizacji i lęku. Każda z nich niesie własne traumy, potrzebę przynależności i strach przed kolejnym odrzuceniem.
Fabuła rozwija się powoli, momentami wręcz leniwie, jednak nie jest to wada, lecz świadomy wybór autorki. Zamiast dynamicznej akcji stawia ona na gęstą, niepokojącą atmosferę. Każdy kolejny rozdział dokłada cegiełkę do narastającego poczucia klaustrofobii, zamknięta przestrzeń Marshwood House potęguje emocje, a napięcia między dziewczętami stopniowo narastają.
Poczucie zagrożenia nie wynika tu ze spektakularnych wydarzeń, lecz z ciągłej emocjonalnej niepewności. Dzieją się rzeczy dziwne i trudne do wyjaśnienia, a atmosfera podejrzeń gęstnieje. Ktoś wyraźnie manipuluje sytuacją, sprawiając, że kolejne dziewczęta zaczynają postrzegać siebie nawzajem jako zagrożenie. Ta gra niedomówień, lęków i narastającej paranoi buduje napięcie powoli, lecz konsekwentnie.
„Dangerous Girls. Niebezpieczne dziewczęta” nie jest powieścią idealną. Momentami gubi tempo, innym razem zbyt mocno koncentruje się na nastroju kosztem rozwoju fabuły. Nie są to jednak wady, które odbierają jej sens, raczej elementy stylu, na który czytelnik musi się świadomie zgodzić.
To opowieść o dorastaniu w świecie, który nie chce zaakceptować inności. O strachu przed własną naturą i przed tym, jak zostanie ona odebrana przez innych. O dziewczętach, które nie mieszczą się w normach, i o świecie, który próbuje je naprawić, zamiast zrozumieć. O byciu „niebezpieczną” dziewczyną, co często oznacza po prostu bycie dziewczyną niewygodną, taką, która nie chce spełniać cudzych oczekiwań.
Autorka znakomicie oddaje dynamikę zamkniętej grupy młodych osób, pełnych lęku, gniewu i potrzeby bliskości. To historia o tym, jak dziewczęta potrafią być dla siebie wsparciem i jak szybko mogą stać się dla siebie zagrożeniem.
Jeśli szukasz mrocznej, emocjonalnej historii młodzieżowej z mroczną atmosferą, ta książka powinna Ci się spodobać.
Marshwood House ma być przestrzenią nauki akceptacji, siebie nawzajem i własnych zdolności. Trafiają tam dziewczęta obdarzone niezwykłymi, często niebezpiecznymi mocami, których świat się boi. Choć idea tego miejsca opiera się na zrozumieniu i wsparciu, rzeczywistość szybko okazuje się znacznie bardziej skomplikowana. Relacje między dziewczętami są trudne, pełne napięć, rywalizacji i lęku. Każda z nich niesie własne traumy, potrzebę przynależności i strach przed kolejnym odrzuceniem.
Fabuła rozwija się powoli, momentami wręcz leniwie, jednak nie jest to wada, lecz świadomy wybór autorki. Zamiast dynamicznej akcji stawia ona na gęstą, niepokojącą atmosferę. Każdy kolejny rozdział dokłada cegiełkę do narastającego poczucia klaustrofobii, zamknięta przestrzeń Marshwood House potęguje emocje, a napięcia między dziewczętami stopniowo narastają.
Poczucie zagrożenia nie wynika tu ze spektakularnych wydarzeń, lecz z ciągłej emocjonalnej niepewności. Dzieją się rzeczy dziwne i trudne do wyjaśnienia, a atmosfera podejrzeń gęstnieje. Ktoś wyraźnie manipuluje sytuacją, sprawiając, że kolejne dziewczęta zaczynają postrzegać siebie nawzajem jako zagrożenie. Ta gra niedomówień, lęków i narastającej paranoi buduje napięcie powoli, lecz konsekwentnie.
„Dangerous Girls. Niebezpieczne dziewczęta” nie jest powieścią idealną. Momentami gubi tempo, innym razem zbyt mocno koncentruje się na nastroju kosztem rozwoju fabuły. Nie są to jednak wady, które odbierają jej sens, raczej elementy stylu, na który czytelnik musi się świadomie zgodzić.
To opowieść o dorastaniu w świecie, który nie chce zaakceptować inności. O strachu przed własną naturą i przed tym, jak zostanie ona odebrana przez innych. O dziewczętach, które nie mieszczą się w normach, i o świecie, który próbuje je naprawić, zamiast zrozumieć. O byciu „niebezpieczną” dziewczyną, co często oznacza po prostu bycie dziewczyną niewygodną, taką, która nie chce spełniać cudzych oczekiwań.
Autorka znakomicie oddaje dynamikę zamkniętej grupy młodych osób, pełnych lęku, gniewu i potrzeby bliskości. To historia o tym, jak dziewczęta potrafią być dla siebie wsparciem i jak szybko mogą stać się dla siebie zagrożeniem.
Jeśli szukasz mrocznej, emocjonalnej historii młodzieżowej z mroczną atmosferą, ta książka powinna Ci się spodobać.
July 20, 2025
There were several things that I liked about this book, but I didn't quite love it.
Imogen has the power to grow poisonous flowers from her hands and is send to an island where girls with dangerous powers live and are tought to control their powers.
Immediately after her arrival an accident happens that makes the other girls weary of her, and a deer is found dead, killed by poisonous flowers. Someone is trying to frame Imogen...
The mistery plot was done very well and the gotic atmosphere was my favorite aspect of the book.
I would have liked a bit more depth in the characterization of the other girls but their voices felt different enough so that was not too bad.
The world building was a bit confusing. There is no real explanation of the girls' powers and why they have them. But also, the story is supposedly taking place now but doesn't feel like it. The Island feels outside of time and none of the girls act or speak like 21st century's young adults (is not even clear how old they are supposed to be). Which is not a bad thing per se, because it works very well with the gothic atmosphere. However every now and then there is a clear reference to technology, or Google is mentioned, bringing the reader back to the 21st century which is quite jarring.
However my main problem was with the "romance". Tepid, born out of nowhere, it felt completely forced and out of place. This story would have worked so much better with a stronger and clearer focus on the group of girls and their friendship, but I feel like the author felt forced to introduce the romantic element because that is what sells now.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for sending me this arc in exchange for my honest review
Imogen has the power to grow poisonous flowers from her hands and is send to an island where girls with dangerous powers live and are tought to control their powers.
Immediately after her arrival an accident happens that makes the other girls weary of her, and a deer is found dead, killed by poisonous flowers. Someone is trying to frame Imogen...
The mistery plot was done very well and the gotic atmosphere was my favorite aspect of the book.
I would have liked a bit more depth in the characterization of the other girls but their voices felt different enough so that was not too bad.
The world building was a bit confusing. There is no real explanation of the girls' powers and why they have them. But also, the story is supposedly taking place now but doesn't feel like it. The Island feels outside of time and none of the girls act or speak like 21st century's young adults (is not even clear how old they are supposed to be). Which is not a bad thing per se, because it works very well with the gothic atmosphere. However every now and then there is a clear reference to technology, or Google is mentioned, bringing the reader back to the 21st century which is quite jarring.
However my main problem was with the "romance". Tepid, born out of nowhere, it felt completely forced and out of place. This story would have worked so much better with a stronger and clearer focus on the group of girls and their friendship, but I feel like the author felt forced to introduce the romantic element because that is what sells now.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for sending me this arc in exchange for my honest review
July 28, 2025
I read an eARC of this book on NetGalley so thank you to the author and the publisher.
This was an atmospheric book with a great premise. We have a girl with uncontrollable powers sent to a school/home on a remote island in Scotland that can cater to the education she needs to manager her power. Imogen’s power itself was really fascinating. She can grow Oleander, a poisonous plant from her fingertips, but only that specific plant. When this was introduced I thought this was really cool. I wanted to see a lot more of this. I also wanted to know, why Oleander? I thought this likely had a fascinating backstory or explanation so I would have loved to have seen this explored further. All the girls we meet at the school have interesting powers. We did get to see a decent bit of this at the start, but it tailed off and this was a shame as I’d have loved more focus on the magic. The author had some really interesting ideas on this space, we just needed more detail. I liked the school location and how this helped with Imogen’s sense of self. Despite the danger she faces here, she starts to feel more confident and comfortable in her own skin, not feeling like she has to hide because of her kinship with her fellow students that blossoms throughout the book.
The setting was great, an isolated Scottish island. Elements of this were used really well, particularly around water. This really added to the atmosphere of the book.
The storyline that positions the mystery and the growing menace was intriguing. I liked how this built up on the girl’s different powers, giving us more depth around what they can do whilst adding suspense. I felt I wanted more of this. The romance felt quite unnecessary and didn’t add anything to the book. It could have just been friendship and given us more space for the mystery.
Some great elements to this book, I would have just liked them explored in more detail and for it to have been a bit longer. Certainly memorable and worth a read for the mystery and atmosphere.
This was an atmospheric book with a great premise. We have a girl with uncontrollable powers sent to a school/home on a remote island in Scotland that can cater to the education she needs to manager her power. Imogen’s power itself was really fascinating. She can grow Oleander, a poisonous plant from her fingertips, but only that specific plant. When this was introduced I thought this was really cool. I wanted to see a lot more of this. I also wanted to know, why Oleander? I thought this likely had a fascinating backstory or explanation so I would have loved to have seen this explored further. All the girls we meet at the school have interesting powers. We did get to see a decent bit of this at the start, but it tailed off and this was a shame as I’d have loved more focus on the magic. The author had some really interesting ideas on this space, we just needed more detail. I liked the school location and how this helped with Imogen’s sense of self. Despite the danger she faces here, she starts to feel more confident and comfortable in her own skin, not feeling like she has to hide because of her kinship with her fellow students that blossoms throughout the book.
The setting was great, an isolated Scottish island. Elements of this were used really well, particularly around water. This really added to the atmosphere of the book.
The storyline that positions the mystery and the growing menace was intriguing. I liked how this built up on the girl’s different powers, giving us more depth around what they can do whilst adding suspense. I felt I wanted more of this. The romance felt quite unnecessary and didn’t add anything to the book. It could have just been friendship and given us more space for the mystery.
Some great elements to this book, I would have just liked them explored in more detail and for it to have been a bit longer. Certainly memorable and worth a read for the mystery and atmosphere.
August 6, 2025
Okay, you need to read Dangerous Girls, seriously, I devoured it in like two sittings. If you’re into gothic fantasy with a hint of dark mystery and just the right amount of romance, this one’s for you. It gave me total Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children vibes, but with its own unique, haunting twist.
So, the main character, Imogen Brine, is not your average teenage girl. She can literally grow poisonous flowers from her fingertips (yes, really). Because of this strange and slightly terrifying gift, she’s invited to this secret island where girls like her are able to learn how to control their powers. Sounds cool, right? But of course, things don’t go smoothly. Weird stuff starts happening as she arrives, and suddenly everyone’s looking at her like she’s the problem.
What I loved is that it wasn’t just spooky for the sake of being spooky. There’s mystery, tension, and this creepy sense of “something’s not right” that keeps you flipping pages. Plus, the powers the other girls have? Wild. Think summoning swarms of insects, starting fires with a glance, even turning into a mermaid. It's like X-Men meets dark fairy tale.
There’s also a sweet romance woven in, not overpowering, not cheesy, just the right amount to make you smile a bit while still letting the mystery take the spotlight. And the found family element? Ugh, so good. These girls are messy and powerful and trying to figure themselves out, and you can’t help but root for them all.
All in all, it’s a fast, eerie, magical ride that hits all the right YA notes. If you love gothic fantasy with heart and atmosphere, you need to add this to your TBR ASAP.
So, the main character, Imogen Brine, is not your average teenage girl. She can literally grow poisonous flowers from her fingertips (yes, really). Because of this strange and slightly terrifying gift, she’s invited to this secret island where girls like her are able to learn how to control their powers. Sounds cool, right? But of course, things don’t go smoothly. Weird stuff starts happening as she arrives, and suddenly everyone’s looking at her like she’s the problem.
What I loved is that it wasn’t just spooky for the sake of being spooky. There’s mystery, tension, and this creepy sense of “something’s not right” that keeps you flipping pages. Plus, the powers the other girls have? Wild. Think summoning swarms of insects, starting fires with a glance, even turning into a mermaid. It's like X-Men meets dark fairy tale.
There’s also a sweet romance woven in, not overpowering, not cheesy, just the right amount to make you smile a bit while still letting the mystery take the spotlight. And the found family element? Ugh, so good. These girls are messy and powerful and trying to figure themselves out, and you can’t help but root for them all.
All in all, it’s a fast, eerie, magical ride that hits all the right YA notes. If you love gothic fantasy with heart and atmosphere, you need to add this to your TBR ASAP.
August 6, 2025
Dangerous Girls by @lisamsylvan
@scholastic_uk + @instabooktours blog tour
________________________
"Not all dangerous girls want to be friends."
Our tale follows Imogen Brine, a young girl with a mysterious gift (curse?) for making poisonous flowers grow from her hands...🌸🌺🌸🌺
When her talents begin to get out of control she receives an invitation from Marshwood House, a secret school hidden away on a remote Scottish island.
🌊🏰🌊🏰
This YA gothic fantasy was unputdownable! I read it in one sitting, barely taking my eyes off the pages! The storytelling was simple but vibrant and the pacing was consistently upbeat throughout.
This book reminded me strongly of the Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children movie (I need to read the books!!) especially when we began to discover each girls' gift. The dynamics between the girls at the school were very interesting, particularly the set up of Imogen and Ailith as clear rivals. Their complex relationship lent much to the story and I liked that Imogen was feisty enough to stand her ground and not shrink from a challenge.
This is definitely a darker YA story which touches on stronger themes. I know I would've been particularly obsessed with this as a teenager. It never shies away from showing how dangerous the girls' powers can be and at times the plot was downright eerie.
"Everyone loves a fairy tale until they realize they're the villain."
__________________________
@scholastic_uk + @instabooktours blog tour
________________________
"Not all dangerous girls want to be friends."
Our tale follows Imogen Brine, a young girl with a mysterious gift (curse?) for making poisonous flowers grow from her hands...🌸🌺🌸🌺
When her talents begin to get out of control she receives an invitation from Marshwood House, a secret school hidden away on a remote Scottish island.
🌊🏰🌊🏰
This YA gothic fantasy was unputdownable! I read it in one sitting, barely taking my eyes off the pages! The storytelling was simple but vibrant and the pacing was consistently upbeat throughout.
This book reminded me strongly of the Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children movie (I need to read the books!!) especially when we began to discover each girls' gift. The dynamics between the girls at the school were very interesting, particularly the set up of Imogen and Ailith as clear rivals. Their complex relationship lent much to the story and I liked that Imogen was feisty enough to stand her ground and not shrink from a challenge.
This is definitely a darker YA story which touches on stronger themes. I know I would've been particularly obsessed with this as a teenager. It never shies away from showing how dangerous the girls' powers can be and at times the plot was downright eerie.
"Everyone loves a fairy tale until they realize they're the villain."
__________________________
August 14, 2025
I was really intrigued by this story as it was described as an "atmospheric, heart-racing gothic fantasy romance" and for me it delivered that and more. It really, really reminded me of Miss Peregrine which absolutely kept me reading as I adored MP and the whole gifted children theme.
The setting is undeniably beautiful, set in an eerie, isolating remote school for girls with dangerous gifts and the quiet chill through the school halls can be felt seeping out of the pages. The gifts the girl posses are interesting and on the surface feel quite fun and fresh until you start to see the more sinister side of their powers coming to light, especially when the elements of their powers start appearing in settings of more malicious behaviour...
The fast-paced nature really helped drive the spooky tension and mystery and there were many moments where something just didn't "feel right" and I absolutely couldn't get enough of it.
Imogen was a stand out character for me, I loved her development, I loved her growth in both confidence and acceptance as the story progresses and I thought her inner dialogue with regards to her poison power was really powerful. The romance sub-plot is sweet, really well placed and felt natural to how teenagers deal with new emotions and navigating romance.
A truly great quick little read, ideal for spooky seasons.
Thank you to Scholastic and instabooktours for having me on the tour and sending a proof copy.
The setting is undeniably beautiful, set in an eerie, isolating remote school for girls with dangerous gifts and the quiet chill through the school halls can be felt seeping out of the pages. The gifts the girl posses are interesting and on the surface feel quite fun and fresh until you start to see the more sinister side of their powers coming to light, especially when the elements of their powers start appearing in settings of more malicious behaviour...
The fast-paced nature really helped drive the spooky tension and mystery and there were many moments where something just didn't "feel right" and I absolutely couldn't get enough of it.
Imogen was a stand out character for me, I loved her development, I loved her growth in both confidence and acceptance as the story progresses and I thought her inner dialogue with regards to her poison power was really powerful. The romance sub-plot is sweet, really well placed and felt natural to how teenagers deal with new emotions and navigating romance.
A truly great quick little read, ideal for spooky seasons.
Thank you to Scholastic and instabooktours for having me on the tour and sending a proof copy.
September 19, 2025
Dangerous Girls by Lisa M. Sylvan ended up surprising me. Personally, I’d put it at three stars, but for its genuine YA audience—especially younger YA or even upper middle grade readers—I think it easily deserves closer to four or four and a half.
The premise is sharp and engaging: an island school where strange powers are acknowledged but not fully explained, and a group of girls who find themselves banding together as outsiders. The message of “outcasts together” really comes through, and I loved that sense of solidarity. The atmosphere was another highlight for me—suspicious, hazy weather in a remote wilderness setting that makes you feel like the landscape itself is keeping secrets.
That said, the pacing felt caught between two versions of itself. It could have been a really tight novella—50 pages shorter and razor-sharp—or a longer, more fleshed-out novel that built up the world, the history of the island, and the supporting cast. As it stands, it leaves you wishing for either more depth or more restraint.
Still, I enjoyed it more than I expected. The intriguing concepts, moody setting, and themes of belonging make this a compelling read for the right audience. I’m also very interested in what Lisa M. Sylvan writes next—I think it will be promising.
Thank you to NetGalley and Scholastic UK for providing a copy in exchange for an honest review!
The premise is sharp and engaging: an island school where strange powers are acknowledged but not fully explained, and a group of girls who find themselves banding together as outsiders. The message of “outcasts together” really comes through, and I loved that sense of solidarity. The atmosphere was another highlight for me—suspicious, hazy weather in a remote wilderness setting that makes you feel like the landscape itself is keeping secrets.
That said, the pacing felt caught between two versions of itself. It could have been a really tight novella—50 pages shorter and razor-sharp—or a longer, more fleshed-out novel that built up the world, the history of the island, and the supporting cast. As it stands, it leaves you wishing for either more depth or more restraint.
Still, I enjoyed it more than I expected. The intriguing concepts, moody setting, and themes of belonging make this a compelling read for the right audience. I’m also very interested in what Lisa M. Sylvan writes next—I think it will be promising.
Thank you to NetGalley and Scholastic UK for providing a copy in exchange for an honest review!
April 12, 2026
This book was amazing, I picked it up off a whim and was quickly hooked into the storyline, reading it all in one sitting. The characters were well written and interesting, most of them had distinct backgrounds and personalities. I loved the gothic academia setting in a recluded island, and the storyline kept me enraptured. Imogen was very likeable and I enjoyed seeing her character growth. Imogen, Bianca, Jack and Kinsley were probably my favourite characters. I loved reading about the girls’ gifts and how they all came from different countries. I loved learning about the past of the island and I think the tone was very fitting.
I think I would have liked to see more of the students’ cultures and languages, many of them didn’t come from English speaking countries so I think Lisa M. Sylvan could have played into they’re accents and cultural differences. Similarly, I think more world building would have been beneficial. If these details were added the book would have ended up being significantly longer which I don’t think is a problem. I could see this as a trilogy but I do think she tied up loose strands quite well at the end of the book.
Would definitely recommend and I am looking forward to reading more of this author’s work.
I think I would have liked to see more of the students’ cultures and languages, many of them didn’t come from English speaking countries so I think Lisa M. Sylvan could have played into they’re accents and cultural differences. Similarly, I think more world building would have been beneficial. If these details were added the book would have ended up being significantly longer which I don’t think is a problem. I could see this as a trilogy but I do think she tied up loose strands quite well at the end of the book.
Would definitely recommend and I am looking forward to reading more of this author’s work.
May 5, 2026
✨ Dark. Witchy. Slightly unhinged (in the best way). ✨
I went into this expecting spooky vibes… and got full-on eerie girl power with a bite 🖤🔥
This book has that haunting forest, secrets in the dark, don’t-trust-anyone energy that just pulls you in and refuses to let go. The atmosphere?? IMMACULATE. It’s giving:
creepy magic 🌙
girls who are not to be messed with 👀
slow-burning tension that keeps building
The characters feel off in a way that’s so intentional—you’re constantly questioning motives, loyalties, and what’s actually real. And honestly? That’s what makes it addictive. You’re not just reading, you’re trying to figure it out the whole time.
🔥 Things I loved:
The dark, almost gothic vibe
The mystery that keeps twisting
That underlying “something is wrong here” feeling
⚠️ Just a heads up: It leans more eerie and unsettling than fast-paced action, so if you love vibes > plot speed, this will hit.
💭 Overall: If you like books that feel like a beautifully dangerous fever dream, this is 100% for you.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Would I trust these girls? Absolutely not.
Would I read again? Also yes.
I went into this expecting spooky vibes… and got full-on eerie girl power with a bite 🖤🔥
This book has that haunting forest, secrets in the dark, don’t-trust-anyone energy that just pulls you in and refuses to let go. The atmosphere?? IMMACULATE. It’s giving:
creepy magic 🌙
girls who are not to be messed with 👀
slow-burning tension that keeps building
The characters feel off in a way that’s so intentional—you’re constantly questioning motives, loyalties, and what’s actually real. And honestly? That’s what makes it addictive. You’re not just reading, you’re trying to figure it out the whole time.
🔥 Things I loved:
The dark, almost gothic vibe
The mystery that keeps twisting
That underlying “something is wrong here” feeling
⚠️ Just a heads up: It leans more eerie and unsettling than fast-paced action, so if you love vibes > plot speed, this will hit.
💭 Overall: If you like books that feel like a beautifully dangerous fever dream, this is 100% for you.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Would I trust these girls? Absolutely not.
Would I read again? Also yes.
August 4, 2025
Firstly a huge thank you to Insta Book Tours and Scholastic UK for having me on the tour and sending me a proof copy of Dangerous Girls to read and review!
Dangerous Girls is a lush gothic YA fantasy read, with great pacing and a gorgeous Scottish Island setting. I really enjoyed the book and I thought the mystery and tension built up really well to keep the reader engaged - the author really utilised the imagery and scene setting of the isolated Scottish Island to help with this and it worked!
I loved the concept of Imogen's powers; she can grow plants from her fingertips, but only one specific poisonous plant. The other girls in the school all have different and unique powers and I loved watching Imogen become more confident and accepting of who she was as her friendships developed with some of the other girls.
Overall a great fantasy read with an atmospheric setting, a well paced plot line, plenty of suspense, and whole load of magic!
Dangerous Girls is a lush gothic YA fantasy read, with great pacing and a gorgeous Scottish Island setting. I really enjoyed the book and I thought the mystery and tension built up really well to keep the reader engaged - the author really utilised the imagery and scene setting of the isolated Scottish Island to help with this and it worked!
I loved the concept of Imogen's powers; she can grow plants from her fingertips, but only one specific poisonous plant. The other girls in the school all have different and unique powers and I loved watching Imogen become more confident and accepting of who she was as her friendships developed with some of the other girls.
Overall a great fantasy read with an atmospheric setting, a well paced plot line, plenty of suspense, and whole load of magic!
October 6, 2025
Dangerous Girls is both beautifully atmospheric and deeply unsettling at the same time. There were moments when I actually had to stop reading and glance around my room because it felt like the story was creeping beyond the pages, making my mind play tricks on me.
The island setting that the story primarily takes place in is so vividly described it almost becomes a character itself: isolated, eerie, and dripping with secrets.
The murder mystery element adds another layer of intrigue, and I loved how Sylvan weaves it through the dark fantasy world. By the end, I was completely invested. The twists kept me guessing, and the conclusion was both satisfying and haunting. In short, Dangerous Girls is a dark, addictive blend of fantasy and mystery with a heavy dose of gothic atmosphere. It’s beautiful, creepy, and full of secrets. A perfect read if you like stories that blur the line between power and danger.
The island setting that the story primarily takes place in is so vividly described it almost becomes a character itself: isolated, eerie, and dripping with secrets.
The murder mystery element adds another layer of intrigue, and I loved how Sylvan weaves it through the dark fantasy world. By the end, I was completely invested. The twists kept me guessing, and the conclusion was both satisfying and haunting. In short, Dangerous Girls is a dark, addictive blend of fantasy and mystery with a heavy dose of gothic atmosphere. It’s beautiful, creepy, and full of secrets. A perfect read if you like stories that blur the line between power and danger.
June 1, 2025
‘Everyone loves a fairy tale until they realise they’re the villain’
-
What a joy it was to read Dangerous Girls, a huge thank you to Scholastic UK for sending me an early copy of one of my most anticipated reads of 2025!
Set on the isolated island of Innis Súil just off the coast of Scotland lies Marshwood House, a home full of girls with dangerous gifts. We follow our protagonist Imogen as she learns to master her unusual powers, and as she navigates the mysterious reckonings following her arrival.
Dangerous Girls is fast paced, deliciously gothic, full of absolutely beautiful writing, with wickedly wonderful twists and turns, and is so very riveting! I cannot recommend Dangerous Girls enough.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Dangerous Girls is released on 11th September, and is just the most perfect read for spooky season!
-
What a joy it was to read Dangerous Girls, a huge thank you to Scholastic UK for sending me an early copy of one of my most anticipated reads of 2025!
Set on the isolated island of Innis Súil just off the coast of Scotland lies Marshwood House, a home full of girls with dangerous gifts. We follow our protagonist Imogen as she learns to master her unusual powers, and as she navigates the mysterious reckonings following her arrival.
Dangerous Girls is fast paced, deliciously gothic, full of absolutely beautiful writing, with wickedly wonderful twists and turns, and is so very riveting! I cannot recommend Dangerous Girls enough.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Dangerous Girls is released on 11th September, and is just the most perfect read for spooky season!
July 1, 2025
If you like dark, creepy, gothic YA fantasy, this book is for you. It’s beautifully atmospheric, and it felt so nostalgic to me. It feels like so many of my favourite YA books I read when I was a teenager. Whilst I enjoyed this book as an adult, it simply would have changed my brain chemistry as a teenager. I would have been completely OBSESSED with it. There were parts of this book that were super creepy and I loved those parts. It’s super fast paced and mysterious.
I’m a little sad that we don’t get to see an epilogue of the future of Imogen. Some of Imogen’s actions/thoughts, along with her relationships feel a little off and juvenile (this kind of makes sense, as she is a teenager), but made the character feel a little disjointed for me and her motivations didn’t seem realistic.
Overall I enjoyed it but I know teenage me would’ve made this book my whole personality.
I’m a little sad that we don’t get to see an epilogue of the future of Imogen. Some of Imogen’s actions/thoughts, along with her relationships feel a little off and juvenile (this kind of makes sense, as she is a teenager), but made the character feel a little disjointed for me and her motivations didn’t seem realistic.
Overall I enjoyed it but I know teenage me would’ve made this book my whole personality.
August 13, 2025
3.5 stars!
This book sounded right up my alley - and I was right! I really loved the setting - a remote island in Scotland - and the gothic atmosphere. The constant feeling of ‘something is just not right here‘ made this such a fast-paced read, as I needed to know what was going on! I ended up reading the majority of this in one sitting.
I also thought the mystery plot was done well and I enjoyed all the twist and turns.
I just would have liked a bit more background on the girls’ gifts (where do they come from? Why do they have them?) and I think the 'love story‘ could have been left out as I don’t think it added much!
But definitely check this one out of you like the sound of a gothic fantasy full of mystery, secrets and magic!
Thanks to the publisher and Insta Book Tours for sending me a gifted copy in exchange for an honest review!
This book sounded right up my alley - and I was right! I really loved the setting - a remote island in Scotland - and the gothic atmosphere. The constant feeling of ‘something is just not right here‘ made this such a fast-paced read, as I needed to know what was going on! I ended up reading the majority of this in one sitting.
I also thought the mystery plot was done well and I enjoyed all the twist and turns.
I just would have liked a bit more background on the girls’ gifts (where do they come from? Why do they have them?) and I think the 'love story‘ could have been left out as I don’t think it added much!
But definitely check this one out of you like the sound of a gothic fantasy full of mystery, secrets and magic!
Thanks to the publisher and Insta Book Tours for sending me a gifted copy in exchange for an honest review!
August 28, 2025
I flew through this book and was absolutely absorbed into the eerie and engaging story of Dangerous Girls!
Miss Peregrines Home for Peculiar Children meets Pretty Little Liars in this atmospheric adventure set on a secluded, Scottish island.
I loved all of the unique powers each of the girls had, kinda gave me x-men vibes which I loved! I also really got into the murder mystery element of the book and was constantly suspicious of everyone!! (This is why the book reminds me of PLL IYKYK)
Also wanted to mention I loved the slow burn romance in this too, it takes abit of a back seat but its done so well 🥰🥰
If you're in the mood for a fast paced read filled with magic, mayhem and mystery then look no further!
Thank you so much to the publisher for sending me a proof copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Miss Peregrines Home for Peculiar Children meets Pretty Little Liars in this atmospheric adventure set on a secluded, Scottish island.
I loved all of the unique powers each of the girls had, kinda gave me x-men vibes which I loved! I also really got into the murder mystery element of the book and was constantly suspicious of everyone!! (This is why the book reminds me of PLL IYKYK)
Also wanted to mention I loved the slow burn romance in this too, it takes abit of a back seat but its done so well 🥰🥰
If you're in the mood for a fast paced read filled with magic, mayhem and mystery then look no further!
Thank you so much to the publisher for sending me a proof copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
August 30, 2025
This was so good! I was constantly on edge, but I also felt to comfort in this of finally finding people that accept you and that you fit in with despite your differences.
This genuinely creeped me out to the point I had to put it down and take a break from reading it. The idea of never knowing if you are talking to the person you think you are is actually terrifying! I don’t usually read horror, but I think this could definitely convince me, this mysterious gothic atmosphere was compelling.
There was a very light romance in here, and was very very slow, and was mainly in the background. The romance also helped with this element of mistrust, because Imogen couldn’t be sure that she was ever really talking to the person she thought she was, and whether they were on the same page.
Thank you Scholastic UK for sending me an advanced copy of this book.
This genuinely creeped me out to the point I had to put it down and take a break from reading it. The idea of never knowing if you are talking to the person you think you are is actually terrifying! I don’t usually read horror, but I think this could definitely convince me, this mysterious gothic atmosphere was compelling.
There was a very light romance in here, and was very very slow, and was mainly in the background. The romance also helped with this element of mistrust, because Imogen couldn’t be sure that she was ever really talking to the person she thought she was, and whether they were on the same page.
Thank you Scholastic UK for sending me an advanced copy of this book.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 6, 2025
Very rarely, a girl is born with a gift. Not traditional magic. No wands, cauldrons or chants but a gift as unique as the girl itself. Some are useful, some aren't, but all can be dangerous.
When this gift awakens, the girls go to Marshwood House to learn to manage their gifts, but when Imogen arrives, things start happening, and all eyes are on her.
I really enjoyed this story. Set on a remote island off the Scottish Coast, the atmosphere is dark and mystical. The island has long been used as a way to manage girls with powers. From burnings to rehabilitation, the island and its spirits have seen it all.
The story has rivals, intrigue, mystery, a sweet YA romance, and a couple of twists to see you through to the end.
This is one of those books you could happily spend a rainy afternoon reading.
Perfect for spooky season. It's almost like dark academy meets cosy fantasy.
When this gift awakens, the girls go to Marshwood House to learn to manage their gifts, but when Imogen arrives, things start happening, and all eyes are on her.
I really enjoyed this story. Set on a remote island off the Scottish Coast, the atmosphere is dark and mystical. The island has long been used as a way to manage girls with powers. From burnings to rehabilitation, the island and its spirits have seen it all.
The story has rivals, intrigue, mystery, a sweet YA romance, and a couple of twists to see you through to the end.
This is one of those books you could happily spend a rainy afternoon reading.
Perfect for spooky season. It's almost like dark academy meets cosy fantasy.
August 29, 2025
3.5 stars
This was a fast paced read that will be really well suited to young adult readers, especially those trying out gothic fantasy or mystery/thriller for the first time. The writing style was easy to read, and I flew through the last third of the book which was by far my favourite part.
The eerie Scottish setting gave the story a creepy but beautiful gothic feel. I also really enjoyed the variation in the girls’ gifts. Some of them felt unique compared to what you usually find in fantasy. The little bit of romance added variety to the plot without overwhelming the main story and mystery that unfolded.
Imogen was a great main character. She had confidence right from the start, but I loved watching her growth as she learned to truly accept herself and her gift.
This was a fast paced read that will be really well suited to young adult readers, especially those trying out gothic fantasy or mystery/thriller for the first time. The writing style was easy to read, and I flew through the last third of the book which was by far my favourite part.
The eerie Scottish setting gave the story a creepy but beautiful gothic feel. I also really enjoyed the variation in the girls’ gifts. Some of them felt unique compared to what you usually find in fantasy. The little bit of romance added variety to the plot without overwhelming the main story and mystery that unfolded.
Imogen was a great main character. She had confidence right from the start, but I loved watching her growth as she learned to truly accept herself and her gift.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 54 reviews