I haven't read the precursor to this book (Roxton 1), which I think is the story of how Antonia, the current heroine, met her first husband, the Duke of Roxton. It is an unashamed tribute to Heyer's These Old Shades, the first of hers I ever read and for many years a favourite, which is a very brave thing to do. Even braver on Lucinda Brant's part was to write the sequal where Antonia, who was about 30 years younger than her beloved Monsigneur, is left a distraught widow, and three years after his death, has not moved on at all. I took quite a bit of persuading to read this story, but thank you to Wendy and to Caz, I'm really glad I did.
Antonia has lost the love of her life and with him her zest for life. She lives for her grandchildren, but has cut herself off from friends and to the rest of the world, her own two sons included, she's remote, cold and maybe even a bit mad with grief. Jonathon Strang is a widower with a 19 year old daughter, whose mother died in childbed. Jonathon is not so drowning in grief as Antonia, he's got on with his life, made his fortune in India, and raised his daughter, but like Antonia, he's lost the love of his life and never thinks that he'll find another. The early scenes between the two of them, where Jonathon recognises what Antonia is suffering, the fact that despite all, she thinks every time a door opens, her Monsigneur will walk into the room, moved me to tears - which is actually quite a rare thing with books these days.
So the burgeoning closeness between the two, the fact that Jonathon succeeds in getting under Antonia's skin when no-one else has, is entirely believable - and very moving. It seems inevitable that the two will fall in love - fated, just like they believed their first love to be - and I for one was rooting for them. The romance was mostly tender, but tempered with a very believable and sensual physical side that made the ages of the hero and heroine, and the age gap, entirely irrelevant. To the reader that is - of course it's a big issue with their respective families.
I loved the scenes between Jonathon and Antonia. I must confess though, that I got just a bit irritated at how slow Antonia was to catch on to both the fact that he loved her, and that he was behaving in an incredibly honourable way because he wanted to marry her, not simply have an affaire. However, on reflection I think this was right - that Antonia most likely would have been blind, and that the sudden revelation she has about her feelings, as if a curtain was lifted, was true to her character, even though I found it a bit that - sudden.
I also loved the fact that the Roxton family were woven beautifully into the story. I didn't enjoy the previous one (Book 2) so much, but seeing Deb and Julian (I think that was his name) some years down the line made me like them a lot more. I like that Ms Brant doesn't make her former heroes too perfect, and the troubled relationship with Antonia and her eldest son, the current duke was really well done.
The spying sub-plot was entertaining, but this was my grip. It got in the way of the ending - and in fact, the unravelling of it became the ending. While the secondary characters were great, and in the case of the epicurean spy, really funny, for me, they took up far too much stage room towards the end. I'd have liked the spy denouement to unfold before Antonia and Jonathon worked out the terms of their HEA, because the way it is (for me) detracted from the emotional impact of this. Antonia admits she loves Jonathon, but not to him, to her former maid. The issue of his title and an heir is resolved (and this bit I must admit I found a wee bit toe-curling) by the (surely remote) possibility of Antonia conceiving at the age of almost 50, when I'd have preferred them to simply agree that they were enough for one another. I know, that's not historically acceptable, Jonathon would have needed an heir, but that's what I'd have liked better!!!!! And as I said, I'd have liked the ending to have more focus on them finding each other, and less on the shenanigans of the other characters.
That said, I thoroughly enjoyed this book, and I applaud Ms Brant for having the guts to write about it. And I'm definitely going to be reading the rest of the series.