This is a very difficult memoir to like--Parvati Shallow's self-analysis matches her name. It's confusing and reveals that her thought process is extremely shallow.
What could have been an opportunity to apologize to the many people she hurt over her years on television and in life, instead she turns back on herself claiming she was "shamed" inappropriately, failing to see how evil her art of fawning really is. Parvati is a complete fake, she admits it, then wonders why people approach her saying how much they hate her--it's because television exposed her secret of being a fraud in order to try to control others to get them to like her!
The parts of her life story that are the most interesting are the ones that she devotes the least amount of space to. It's disappointing that she fails to come up with much to tell about her nine years in a cult, with her parents keeping ties to the weird female leader long after the family left the group. That alone should be a book-length case study on how raising a child in a repressed group can damage a child the rest of her life. And if you want to know much about her behind-the-scenes seasons on Survivor you'll be shocked how she barely glazes over what's she's best known for.
Instead Shallow brags about how she has turned out, using her body and charms to seduce those around her to like her. Her entire goal is to draw everyone in, then control and manipulate them. In high school she used some of that for good, but when she got on national television those same traits were exposed as being hurtful, harmful, and disgusting. Her "Black Widow Brigade" was named that way for a reason.
She writes that she was devastated by the negative public reaction--so of course she went on the show three more times to supposedly redeem herself and the negative feedback got worse each island visit! She is the one who caused her own pain by exposing her fraudulent self and to see her then proclaim that this was abuse by others or anti-female slut-shaming is absurd. She DID act like a slut since childhood, only stopping short of ever letting anyone sleep with her. She admits she used her seductive body language to get men AND women to trust her, then she could do what she wanted with them.
She admits that once she got all this negative response, she dove in even deeper! "To take the edge off I developed my own addiction to the allure of sex and power games in my romantic relationships." Claiming she felt "hideously ugly inside," she doubled down on the terrible false surface tactics that got her into her bad self-image.
She lacks a basic understanding of shame, it's purpose, and how it's not always negative. There's a reason we physically and mentally react in shame--sometimes it's our bodies or minds telling us to change things, while at other times it's a wakeup call to seeing an off-kilter relationship with someone or something. Alcoholics suffer a lot of shame, but that can be used to empower them to stop drinking and start healing.
In Parvati's case she continues to see shame as other people treating her poorly instead of that she has something that needs to be course-corrected. She brags about her ability to "fawn" over others (a unique chapter that few other books would have since fawning is rarely mentioned elsewhere) and says it's a way for women to fight power-wielding assertive men because "it can be safe to stay small, pleasing, nice and helpful. Fawning is especially useful in situations of domestic violence, kidnapping or sexual assault." HUH? So the answer to abuse is not standing up for yourself or stating the truth or removing yourself from the situation but to physically flirt and lie? Wow, is she misguided.
The latter part of the book is about her sleeping around, getting married to another Survivor guy (who she slams while expecting him to treat her like a goddess) and having a kid (blaming her bad parenting on “postpartum anxiety”), quitting any job that she finds “confining,” divorcing while her husband had stage 4 cancer, then finding a doctor who gave her sex "off the charts" and falling into her mold of wanting a high-powered man to conquer (she broke up with him after his sex play wasn’t kinky enough!). Bored when she lost control of him, Parvati meets a born female standup comic/actress that's a Survivor fan, they become lovers, and suddenly Shallow is no longer sexually binary. I took that to mean Parvati wanted to finally be the top in the relationship, including wearing a strap-on dildo (which she brags about in the book), and as of this review the two may no longer be together. The book’s ending is ambiguous.
Thankfully she manages to sneak in a few pages about her time on Traitors, but it doesn’t give much insight into the production. It does however remind us that there is one man that she was unable to manipulate through fawning and that was Peter from The Bachelor. He had enough experience with women flirting that he couldn’t be fooled by a fake seductress. And she hated him for it.
Parvati claims it's not about the sex and defends against claims that she's a slut but fails to see that to outsiders her traits are interpreted as sexually seductive and immoral. She needs to redefine her actions instead of standing by her warped views based on a childhood in a cult. She says she tries to do that but there's not a lot of evidence she's successful when continually bragging about her manipulative fawning abilities as her "power."
In the end Shallow is the problem--not the game, not the critics, certainly not the men or patriarchal society, not really even her female-worshipping upbringing. At some point an individual has to be responsible for her own adult actions. Here she tries--she gets into all sorts of self-help books to figure out how to change or deal with her obvious mental illness--but ultimately her self-perception throughout is that she's so attractive and can use it to diminish others that it worked to her advantage when she was young, so she's not going to stop. Saying she "claims her power" is a bizarre woke phrase that people often use to justify continuing to act selfishly instead of seeing how bad they hurt others or fail to find real solutions to their confusion.
Just watch what she did on Traitors or Deal or No Deal Island and you'll see that this woman has remained "shallow." She again wasn't very nice but she didn't win. Just like in this book.