Hard to know how to rate this, especially because, although absorbed, I did not much enjoy it. Re-reading my review of 'Sixteen horses', I see I wrote "Written in a somewhat twisty fashion with a clarity and seemingly effortless setting of place". The twistiness was there, (and the gruesome of it more or less as expected), but for me the clarity was missing; the characters hard to differentiate and the actions of each too easily forgotten or muddled, so I finished reading with little knowledge of who actually did what and a sense of being left adrift (which I recognise likely to be my lack as much as the book.) Not helped by the offer of short story ending having expired)