I don't know, it was good at times but I feel this one could have benefitted from being a series. Like 3-4 volumes instead of everything crammed into one 200 page volume. I noticed myself just slipping away, my ADHD longing for other books and other things to do. In the end I continued, and yes, I love the magical aspect, I love the way the mental health/suicide is handled and could feel it all, the characters are fab. But I just wish it had been more.