2/5 Stars
TL;DR - A slow, bleak story of two women connected through time by the house they have little choice to live in. Not horror, barely supernatural, wholly not what I was expecting in a disappointing way. Might be enjoyable if you like historical fiction, but definitely not a good time for me.
Big thanks to Penguin Viking and NetGalley for providing the ARC for this book in exchange for an honest review!
***Trigger Warnings for: death of a parent, death of a sibling, death of an infant, racism, mental illness, attempted suicide, child neglect, suicidal ideation, child endangerment, and suicide.***
‘The Djinn Waits a Hundred Years’ by Shubnum Khan is a historical fiction book set in South Africa, told in dual timelines, one mainly in 1932 that follows the Khan family and their struggles, and one in 2014, following 15 year old Sana Malek as she moves into a grand and decaying mansion by the sea. Something else lives in the house, watching and remembering, and Sana’s life takes an unexpected turn when she finds the diaries of Meena Begum, the second wife of the man who built the house in which she now lives.
I don’t have much to say about this book, other than it’s depressing as fuck and decidedly NOT horror. I struggle to even call this magical realism, because the titular djinn is barely a player in the story. It’s 99.9% semi-historical literary fiction and 0.1% supernatural - which is all well and good, but I requested the ARC because it was shelved as horror on NetGalley and the blurb strongly suggested it was. It’s not, and I’m disappointed.
(And, being pedantic, the djinn doesn't even wait a hundred years - the math ain't mathing.)
The pacing is slow, and there’s really not a cohesive plot. I can’t even say it’s character-driven, because we really don’t see characters shaping the plot, just sort of floating along with it. I was bored and considered DNF’ing quite often, but I just kept holding out hope that the so-called “horror” would show up, but nope, never did.
The prose jumps all over the place, headhopping a lot without scene breaks, so I was very confused to be reading about the inner workings of one character, only to be inside another’s head in the next few paragraphs. The prose itself is fine, nothing spectacular, and I think I only highlighted two passages in the whole book for standing out. That’s not to say it’s badly-written, it’s just average in terms of depth and craft in my opinion. It’s also written in a way that distances you from the things going on, and I can see an argument for how this may have been intentional due to what I discuss below, but I just felt too far away from the characters and their struggles because of it.
The characters are solidly mid. They have passingly interesting personalities, but no real emotion or depth. Sana is pretty much just there for the whole book, as is Meena, and no one really had any impact on me emotionally. I didn’t care what happened to them, and the inevitable depressing outcomes didn’t really faze me. That said, the whole book is a huge bummer in that everyone in the past timeline is awful or treated awfully, and everyone in the present is broken and depressed. If that’s your jam, you’re in for a treat, but I was straight up not having a good time, and now I need to go pet my dog and watch a comedy because this book is bleak.
However, there is one aspect I did really enjoy - the house itself is a character and entity, and we get interspersed POVs from it, about how the ceiling beams and furniture and even smells are animate and have opinions and memories, and I found that really interesting. I think maybe that the house itself might be the narrator, which would explain the distance and the omniscience/headhopping, and if so, that’s really cool. Or I’m overthinking it and the author just a weak grasp on POV. 50/50. Either way, I did like hearing what the house had to think about things, however brief those sections were.
Overall, though, I’m really disappointed. I feel like the djinn was under-utilized at best, and at worst, unnecessary for how little of an impact it had on the story. I’m definitely salty this was shelved under horror, and billed as such in the blurb.
Final Thoughts:
If you like semi-historical literary fiction that's depressing and not much else, you’ll probably enjoy it. I, however, did not. The book isn’t bad, it’s fully an issue of this not being to my personal tastes, at all, in any way. Will not be purchasing a physical copy.