William believes he has lost his soul mate when his wife, Sara, dies suddenly. Five years later he meets Annie who is the only woman since Sara who has attracted him. She’s very different to his wife, but Annie has her unusual blue-green eyes. Annie doesn’t believe in soul mates, but William turns out to be the man of her dreams (literally). William and Annie do a lot of soul searching to discover whether they have been brought together by chance or destiny, or maybe they are fulfilling Sara’s promise.
The combination of a love story with hints of the paranormal attracted me to this book, but it is the characters and their relationships that make the bigger impression. Annie is a lively, independent, attractive woman, who is putting the difficulties of her childhood behind her in order to make a success of her life. Outwardly down to earth, she is unnerved by her colourful, lyrical dreams and other strange coincidences that keep occurring. William and his family are so vulnerable; it feels natural that Annie is drawn to them and plays a vital role in their healing process. I like the creative way in which Annie gradually helps William’s daughter to work through her guilt, and how Annie’s relationship with William’s son is gently handled. Annie and William’s nigh-on instant rapport is lovely, and his guilt about Sara’s death and his struggle to love Annie for herself add depth to his character. William’s good looks make him irresistible to Annie, and this reader.
While the characterisation is good, I’d have preferred the handling of the paranormal aspect to be left more open. I enjoyed the coincidences, especially the subtle, slightly disquieting things that happen when Annie first visits William’s house, but as the story progresses I found there was just a bit too much explanation and repetition. That said, Sara’s influence adds a level of intrigue and enhances the will-they won’t-they love story.