With a semi-detailed knowledge of the Kennedy family, I was eager to see what The Kennedys at Cape Cod, 1944’s take would be regarding their political dynasty and the assumed curse that plagued not only the Kennedy siblings, but continued with their children, nieces/nephews, and grandchildren. While JFK’s reputation now may be a bit more more marred by his philandering escapades and the family’s presence and influence are weakening with every passing year, there are still many who are fascinated by their history and the trajectory of their political rise.
Straw presents a narrative that weaves together facts, continual anecdotes/quotes from the Kennedys and contemporaries close to them, and speculation about information never revealed in order to make a case that JFK’s presidency may not have, in fact, been the climax of the family’s life and legacy. Rather, it was the summer of 1944, for everything that followed was simply a product of or dedication to the impenetrable bond forged at 50 Marchant Avenue.
The book was well written, though not without its issues. From around the point at which Joe Jr., Jack, and Kick’s involvement in World War II was described, Straw consistently reiterated details that had already been mentioned, particularly with respect to the matriarch’s, Rose, attitude towards her faith. The focal point of the entire book (the role Hyannis Port played in maintaining the family’s connection), moreover, was described in great detail, but in a rather impersonal manner. Yes, Straw was able to convey the emotional depth of the family’s time there, but I didn’t feel as affected as I normally would when reading about those moments. Perhaps it was a purposeful stylistic choice to not give the reader a first-person perspective of their days on Cape Cod. It is more likely that such a choice would have required permission from the remaining members of the family, biographers, and even more extensive research. The biggest shortcoming of the work, however, is the choppiness of the time jumps and focus on each member’s story. The narrative frequently loses its flow. After relaying the context of and reaction to Kick’s passing, the book immediately jumps to JFK’s presidency, leaving over a decade of the family’s lives out of the story. For readers who are knowledgeable about their goings on, the jump may seem trivial. However, it is not for someone whose first deep dive into their dynasty is The Kennedys at Cape Cod, 1944. Therefore, I have an inkling this book was written more for people with a quasi investigative understanding of the family and not for the average reader.
Regardless of my opinions, The Kennedys at Cape Cod, 1944 should be read by anyone who is interested in gaining more insight into the family. It was a very quick read for me and held my attention with little difficulty.
Thank you to Bloomsbury Academic and NetGalley for the ARC!