3.5 stars
The third book in this series is a welcome return to the Derbyshire area and Violet Brewster. Once more, Jane Bettany proves that she can write an engaging protagonist who is fallible, personable and, above all else, genuine. I always feel that a cosy mystery in a small town/village setting requires strong characters, because the settings are usually quiet. And this book has many strong characters. And one thing I think many cosy mystery series do well is return to characters, even if it's to tie them to the new mystery briefly, and this book does just that. Reading this, I was reminded of the first book in the series, and how much fun it was when Violet interviewed the residents of the village about their memories.
Some of the new characters we meet in this book are what I think of as a delightful trope, a group of active, clever, and fun elderly woman. They all reside in a retirement community and they are wonderful in this story. And it's the contrast of the dark nature of the mystery against their vibrancy at, and times, vulnerability that make this mystery more engaging.
While I enjoyed the setup of this mystery and much of the investigation, I have to say the conclusion let me down. Not the reveal of the culprit, which I found surprising and clever, but the drawn out moments of explanation and the scenes where Violet faces the culprit. It felt too removed from the rest of the story and almost caperish, which is not the tone I've come to enjoy in this series so far.
Thank you to the author, the publisher, and Netgalley for providing a copy of this book for an honest review.