OOn the positive side, An Inside job was well-written, as Daniel Silva's novels always are. On the whole, it was disappointing. The novel describes how Gabriel Allon discovers and solves an art theft. This is a common theme in recent Silva novels. As he has done in the past, Allon paints a fake painting, and plants it to lure the criminals out.
The minor flaws are the usual. Allon is the very best at everything he does. The best artist. The best restorer. The best investigator. So are his associates. Ingrid Johansen is the best thief and the best hacker ever. Christiopher Keller has a minor role here, but was the best asssssin in the world. The children are brilliant and precocious
The main problem with the book is more serious. It has a moral component that detracts from the relevance of the Allon character, and from the appeal of the Gabriel Allon series. Allon and his family have undergone a complete transformation. There is nothing Jewish or Israeli about them anymore. Silva mentions several times that Allon was in a government's secret service, but doesn't say which one. Indeed, the word "Israel" appears nowhere in the book. Allon knows a lot about Catholicism, and would seem to be an Italian Catholic, except for his name. The only reference to his being Jewish is an offhand exchange of banter with Allon's friend, the Pope, about Italian and Jewish mothers.
Gabriel's wife, Chiara, of course, has an Italian name, is a Venetian native, and is a fabulous cook, whose dishes are all Italian. You would not know from this novel that she is Jewish, comes from a long line of rabbis, and that she, like Allon, worked for the Israeli secret service and is an Israeli citizen. She and Gabriel now run an elite art restoration service. After all, Gabriel is the best art restorer around. He seems to make a lot of money doing this; they live a luxurious lifestyle that they never enjoyed as Israeli agents. The children go to a fancy private school, and have liberal secular beliefs, it seems, as do Gabriel and Chiara. His daughter’s preoccupation is with climate change. I wonder if they ever speak Hebrew at home. I wonder whether the kids are going to have Bar and Bat Mitzvahs, or are even aware of their background, or care about it. It seems that Gabriel and Chiara have just shed their lifelong ideological and personal commitments like last season's clothing, and have taken the children along for the ride.
The perpetrators of the art theft have nothing to do with international politics.
Gabriel Allon's ongoing coterie of Israli comrades have disappeared. So does his invalid former wife, a victim of a bombing that made her severely and permanently demented. He used to visit her regularly in Jerusalem. The only continuing characters from previous novels are non-Jewish. Christopher Keller and his wife, Ingrid Johansen (the Danish thief), and some Italian cops with whom he has collaborated in the past. And the Pope.
Gabriel Allon's character was previously filled out by his heritage. Holocuast survivor. Defender of his beleaguered nation. Ambivalence about his status as an assassin. The sense of mission he shared with his team. The relationship with his substitute father figure, Ari Shomron. They all have disappeared. What we have now is an affluent would-be upper-class Italian couple who have abandoned their former selves without looking back. A couple that schmoozes with cardinals and Popes, but has no relationship with Jews, the Jewish religion, or the Jewish community.
Daniel Silva has turned into a would-be Donna Leon (who is very good, and a long-time Venice resident). Allon has turned into a superhero Guido Brunetti. Both are good writers. Donna Leon is more credible, and her character hasn't run away from his roots without a bit of ambivalence or guilt.