Rating: 3 stars for the book | 4 stars for the audiobook
Huge thanks to St. Martin’s Press for the eARC via NetGalley 💌
So I tandem-read The Love Haters—earc in one hand, audiobook in the other—and let’s just say: this book and I had a complicated situationship.
This was my first book by Katherine Center, and no hate at all, but… it didn’t hit like I hoped. Somewhere between the coastal vibes, rescue swimmer energy, and fake-it-til-you-make-it plot, I got caught in a current of mid-feelings.
Okay, here’s the setup:
Katie’s about to get laid off unless she takes a risky assignment—interview a Coast Guard rescue swimmer. The catch? She can’t swim. The other catch? The swimmer, Hutch, is her boss's estranged brother. And somehow she’s in Key West, tangled in family drama, pretending she can float, surrounded by strangers and secrets.
Sounds like chaos, right? It was.
Let me just say it:
The plot was fine. The setting was cute. The vibes were summer. But Katie's constant insecurity wore me out. I get body image struggles—I really do—but this felt like it was being replayed on a loop. I wanted to root for her, but after the 5th self-hating monologue and the 9th “omg I'm awkward” moment, I just needed her to grow already.
Hutch? Yeah, he was hot. Rescuer type, emotionally stunted, very “I don’t do love” until suddenly he does. But their chemistry? More lukewarm than sizzling. I was waiting for that magnetic pull, the tension, something that made me feel like yes, THIS is why they’re meant to fall in love. Never really happened. The banter felt manufactured sometimes, like dialogue trying too hard.
Also—I swear the rom in this rom-com was hiding. The chemistry between Katie and Hutch? Mid. I needed banter, longing, some fire, but instead, it was giving slow-burn that never fully lit up. I felt more emotional connection to Hutch’s dog, George Bailey (aka the MVP).
Aunt Rue and the “Gals” were the scene stealers. They were vibrant and warm, and honestly, I would’ve read a whole book about Rue running her inn and match-making on the side.
Now Cole... don’t even get me started. He gave manipulative snake. And Beanie, Katie’s best friend? Useless. No real backbone or support.
Also, can we talk about how over-the-top some moments got? The conga line? The hurricanes? The treasure hunt? It went from rom-com to cartoon real quick. Like, I signed up for cute chaos, not full-blown sitcom absurdity. The plot also dipped into full-on chaos toward the end. It was like the book remembered it had to wrap up 15 storylines in 50 pages.
BUT.
Katie learning to accept her body was probably the most powerful part of the book. Even if the journey was messy, even if it was too dragged out, it’s still something important. I just wish it had more balance.
So yeah—not a total miss, but not the hit I hoped for either.
Would I still try another Katherine Center book? Yep.
Would I recommend this one? Only in audio.
Final thoughts:
– Best format: audiobook, 100%
– Tropes: grumpy x sunshine, enemies-ish to lovers, forced proximity, fake it till you make it, self-love journey
– Standout: the dang dog and Aunt Rue
– What dragged: repetitive body image dialogue, weak side characters, low romantic spark
Not my fav, but not a flop. Just... in between.