Atmospheric, raw, and deeply thought-provoking, The Stranger in Room Six was a hard-hitting family drama with a suspense-laden edge. Exploring the themes of love, forgiveness, trust, and revenge, the dual timelines and multiple POVs interwove into a startlingly haunting yet relevant story that I won’t be forgetting anytime soon. After all, packed full of multifaceted women hiding dark secrets, the slow reveal of their pasts made me fly through the pages. That wasn’t the only thing that had me utterly spellbound, however. You see, the WWII-era plot line had a serious message that was as provocative as it was timely. For this reason alone, I think it would be the perfect book club selection.
There were only two minor flaws. With a few plot points that required a definite need to suspend all disbelief, I felt myself jolted out of the story once or twice. You see, several times the turn in the plot went just a step too far into the melodramatic given the historical setting and overriding feel. The only other issue I had was the slow-boiling pace of the plot. Sadly, thanks to the synopsis, I went into this novel expecting a thriller—which it most definitely was not. That’s not to say that I didn’t love every minute of what I saw as an immersive family saga. After all, as these two flawed women exchanged their stories, I became just as invested in learning both of their truths as they were themselves.
All said and done, with an original format on top of short chapters full of drool-worthy cliffhangers, Ms. Corry certainly delivered in spades. After all, I loved how the entire plot was essentially a conversation between Belinda and Mabel, both of whom had plenty to hide. But it was the ever-present sense of angst and layers of secrets that kept my fingers flying at speed. Gritty and tense but also heartfelt and poignant, the author nimbly crossed the divide between drama and mystery with ease. A back-and-forth story of resilience and redemption, there was much to unpack and relish in this unputdownable tale, so you really should order it now. Go ahead. I’m waiting… Rating of 4.5 stars.
SYNOPSIS:
It's been fifteen years since Belinda was convicted of her husband's murder. Now that she’s free, she’s ready for a fresh start. So, when she gets a job at Sunnyside Home for the Young at Heart, she’s dead set on making sure no one learns about her awful past.
Mabel has spent her life at Sunnyside—first as an evacuee during the Blitz, and now as the home’s oldest resident. She’s held the secrets of this house for as long as she can remember. Secrets that, in the wrong hands, could kill.
But history won’t stay hidden forever, because someone is onto both Belinda and Mabel, watching and listening from Room Six. And they’ll stop at nothing to find out the truth.
Thank you to Jane Corry and Penguin Random House Canada for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
PUB DATE: October 7, 2025
Content warning: infidelity, imprisonment, knife and gun violence, political beliefs, death of a parent, pregnancy, forced adoption, dementia