A very solid four star rating for the collection as a whole. Underhill's writing reminds me of Hemingway, he likes to hint around a situation, let the characters sort of fumble their way through it, rarely giving a bigger outline or a clearer view. He uses allusion and subtlety to truly devastating effect. When I started reading these stories, I took notes so that I would be able to keep the stories straight and my impressions of them. I probably didn't need to. Every story is clearly defined, stands alone and makes an impression that stays with me. Overall, pretty much all of the stories reminded me of the sorts of critical thinking shorts I read in school--it's very reader-interactive. Since the reader is almost never just told what the *blank* is going on, they make them think, wonder, draw conclusions. They evoke images, worlds, thoughts, ideas and concepts that could be debated and argued and discussed in a group--and if anyone is wondering if that's a good thing, I would definitely say "very."
To story specifics, I don't usually do summaries in review, but I'll make an exception in this case:
"Ghost Writer" -- Three stars-- Horror: An author receives a quill that has a sinister history.: Interesting idea, but for me, this one felt like it would be better with a sister story to fill it out. I felt like there was more story to tell with this one, but what *is* told, is dark and haunting.
"Branded Faith" --Five stars-- Fantasy: Can he suffer through his gift, or will he revel in his curse?: I *loved* this short story. I didn't want it to end. If Underhill wrote a whole book in this world, I'd be begging for it. To create such a fleshed out world in such a short story, to make it feel like it could have been a side story of an epic or even a chapter beginning it... took my breath away. My favorite of the batch.
"Smile" --Three and a half stars-- Paranormal mystery: Someone takes the phrase "capturing a photo" to a whole new level.: This one gets the three and a half for just beautiful writing. This is one of the ones that least captured me, left me with too many questions, but the storytelling, the world-building was sublime, so real it could happen to anyone, anywhere.
"Time Trick" --Three stars-- Paranormal thriller: Is the time the trick or is the woman the trick?: There's a great play on words that may have inspired this idea and the concept is spectacular, extremely original, but the ending is rather abrupt. I would love to follow Claudia more, see more stories with her, but the main character just didn't capture me.
"Chartered Waters" --Three and a half stars-- Historical fantasy: How does a boat get stranded in the middle of the ocean?: This is the one I was most conflicted about. I was so confused while reading it that the twist at the end, the clarifying moment almost went right over my head. But when I got it--it was so *cool.* Just the idea of it was so clever that I can't hate it, no matter how crazy it made me while I was reading it. You definitely need to read and judge this one for yourself. It'll stay with you.
"Permanence" --Four stars-- post-apocalyptic/shipwrecked: I think the genre gives you the idea here. This was one of the best contained of the collection. While most of the stories in the collection felt like they could easily be part of a larger work, this one pretty well stood on it's own. I cared enough to wonder about the characters and what happens at the end (if they really make the right decision), but it stood so well on its own that I didn't need it. This was a very satisfying read.
"Splintered" --Five stars-- Sci-fi: The multiverse is collapsing... : I can't say too much without giving this one away, but the writing here, the descriptions of the worlds overlapping and blending into each other is beautiful. And the twist at the end, I read the last sentence, and went "no... wait..." went back and then just grinned and went "oh nice..." Just read this one.
"Low-limb High" --three stars-- paranormal mystery: Everyone keeps leaving Caroline, why?: This one was really interesting, the concept was so strong, but I kept getting tripped up because I just had no sense of time or age-relation in the story. It may not bother everyone, but it was really distracting for me. The descriptions and allusions, the way it was built was so well done, but that confusion really took away from settling in completely.
"Revision" --Five stars-- sci-fi/time travel: "The fact that you're reading this means you're a) literate, ... and b) dead.": This was the only one of the lot that made me chuckle. Really intriguing ideas, presented with a sort of morbid, quirky touch of humor. Probably the most *fun* read of the collection.
In conclusion, Underhill's writing presents a range of clever, intriguing and fascinating ideas. His writing in fluid, minimal, examples in showing rather than telling that are at times frustrating, but always leave you with an impression. Take a ride through his worlds, they're all worth at least a look-see.