What do you think?
Rate this book
Heart Marks the Spot
A treasure hunter and the bestselling adventure novelist who broke her heart after one successful expedition reunite for a summer to search for lost riches.
Treasure hunter Stella Moore dreams of having it all—wealth, love, and a flourishing career—but knows she’ll never be that lucky. Every summer she and her childhood friends travel to search for hidden treasure, but she can barely manage her bills, let alone a relationship. Then, a chance encounter with alluring novelist Huck Sullivan during an expedition in Iceland has Stella thinking maybe her fortune has changed.
After his last book bombed, Huck hasn’t written a word. Joining Stella and her crew on an adventure seems like the perfect distraction from his problems, and when the crew finally uncovers hidden treasure, he is certain that he’s found more than just inspiration for his next novel. Huck and Stella’s undeniable connection gives way to an unforgettable night on a black sand beach.
After Huck disappears without a goodbye, Stella vows to put the heartbreak behind her—but that’s easier said than done when, a year later, every bookstore has a life-size cutout of her ex-lover next to stacks of his latest record-breaking bestseller. Good thing it’s time for another summer treasure hunt. Stella throws herself into mapping the path to a shipwreck off Key West, but the last thing she expects is an extra crew member showing up in search of material for a sequel and a second chance.
Stella and Huck are prepared for storms, sharks, sea sickness, even a tentative truce. But facing the feelings they buried and confronting the devastating truth about why Huck left is the only way to find what their hearts have been searching for all along.
Treasure hunter Stella Moore dreams of having it all—wealth, love, and a flourishing career—but knows she’ll never be that lucky. Every summer she and her childhood friends travel to search for hidden treasure, but she can barely manage her bills, let alone a relationship. Then, a chance encounter with alluring novelist Huck Sullivan during an expedition in Iceland has Stella thinking maybe her fortune has changed.
After his last book bombed, Huck hasn’t written a word. Joining Stella and her crew on an adventure seems like the perfect distraction from his problems, and when the crew finally uncovers hidden treasure, he is certain that he’s found more than just inspiration for his next novel. Huck and Stella’s undeniable connection gives way to an unforgettable night on a black sand beach.
After Huck disappears without a goodbye, Stella vows to put the heartbreak behind her—but that’s easier said than done when, a year later, every bookstore has a life-size cutout of her ex-lover next to stacks of his latest record-breaking bestseller. Good thing it’s time for another summer treasure hunt. Stella throws herself into mapping the path to a shipwreck off Key West, but the last thing she expects is an extra crew member showing up in search of material for a sequel and a second chance.
Stella and Huck are prepared for storms, sharks, sea sickness, even a tentative truce. But facing the feelings they buried and confronting the devastating truth about why Huck left is the only way to find what their hearts have been searching for all along.
384 pages, Paperback
First published July 22, 2025
36 people are currently reading
12244 people want to read
About the author
Libby Hubscher
5 books819 followersLibby Hubscher is an author and scientist. She studied biology at Bowdoin College in Brunswick, Maine and holds a doctor of philosophy in molecular toxicology from North Carolina State University. Her work has appeared online and in textbooks, scientific journals, and literary journals. Her short story “The Unwelcome Guest” was long-listed for the Wigleaf Top 50 in 2018. She lives in North Carolina with her husband, two young children, and a menagerie of pets.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 170 reviews
April 3, 2025
This book is a captivating blend of adventure, romance, and raw emotion that pulls you in from the very first page. It’s not just a treasure hunt—it’s a journey through love, loss, and the hope of second chances. Stella Moore, a fearless and passionate treasure hunter, lives for adventure alongside her tight-knit group of friends. But when Huck Sullivan, the famous novelist who once swept her off her feet and then vanished without a trace, suddenly reappears in her life, Stella’s world is turned upside down. Their first meeting on Iceland’s black sand beaches was unforgettable, but his abrupt departure left her heartbroken. Now, a year later, as Stella sets off on another daring expedition, Huck is back, ready to write a new book—and maybe, just maybe, rewrite their story.
What makes this novel truly stand out is its rich, immersive storytelling and characters that feel so real you’ll swear you know them. Stella is a force to be reckoned with—strong, independent, and fiercely loyal to her friends. Huck, despite his fame, is deeply human, wrestling with his own demons. The chemistry between them crackles with tension, and their slow-burn journey back to each other is as gripping as the treasure hunt itself. Beyond the romance, the story delves into themes of ambition, trust, and redemption, giving it a depth that lingers long after you’ve finished reading.
The adventure is just as thrilling as the emotional stakes. From vividly painted settings to high-seas escapades, the book keeps you on the edge of your seat. The bond between Stella and her friends is so genuine and heartwarming, it feels like you’re part of their found family. Sure, some plot twists might feel predictable, but the ride is so enjoyable that it doesn’t matter. The story balances action-packed moments with tender, heartfelt scenes, and while the ending ties things up a little too neatly for some, it’s still deeply satisfying, giving the characters the growth and closure they deserve.
In the end, this book is a perfect escape—a mix of pulse-pounding adventure and a touching second-chance romance. If you love treasure hunts, emotional depth, and love stories that weather even the stormiest seas, this one’s for you. It’s a ride you won’t want to miss.
A very huge thanks to NetGalley and Berkley Publishing Group for providing me this heartfelt and entertaining novel's digital reviewer copy in exchange for my honest opinions.
Follow me on medium.com to read my articles about books, movies, streaming series, astrology:
medium blog
instagram
facebook
twitter
What makes this novel truly stand out is its rich, immersive storytelling and characters that feel so real you’ll swear you know them. Stella is a force to be reckoned with—strong, independent, and fiercely loyal to her friends. Huck, despite his fame, is deeply human, wrestling with his own demons. The chemistry between them crackles with tension, and their slow-burn journey back to each other is as gripping as the treasure hunt itself. Beyond the romance, the story delves into themes of ambition, trust, and redemption, giving it a depth that lingers long after you’ve finished reading.
The adventure is just as thrilling as the emotional stakes. From vividly painted settings to high-seas escapades, the book keeps you on the edge of your seat. The bond between Stella and her friends is so genuine and heartwarming, it feels like you’re part of their found family. Sure, some plot twists might feel predictable, but the ride is so enjoyable that it doesn’t matter. The story balances action-packed moments with tender, heartfelt scenes, and while the ending ties things up a little too neatly for some, it’s still deeply satisfying, giving the characters the growth and closure they deserve.
In the end, this book is a perfect escape—a mix of pulse-pounding adventure and a touching second-chance romance. If you love treasure hunts, emotional depth, and love stories that weather even the stormiest seas, this one’s for you. It’s a ride you won’t want to miss.
A very huge thanks to NetGalley and Berkley Publishing Group for providing me this heartfelt and entertaining novel's digital reviewer copy in exchange for my honest opinions.
Follow me on medium.com to read my articles about books, movies, streaming series, astrology:
medium blog
July 9, 2025
Bare with me. You know those books that are so hard to review because it feels impossible to summarize everything you loved about them? This was a super soft but adventurous second chance romance following Stella, a determined treasure hunter who is reunited with Huck, the bestselling author who broke her heart after one perfect expedition together.
Divided into two parts, I absolutely loved the use of dual timelines here. It sort of felt like two stories in one. You'll see! The initial feelings between Stella and Huck are definitely fast and intense, but the time jump really adds some emotional weight. And besides, there’s just something about high-stakes adventure that makes heightened emotions feel totally believable!
Stella was such a brave, hyper-focused person, driven by a lifetime of abandonment and a relentless obsession with the treasure that consumed her parents. I loved the mix of her strength and vulnerability! Both she and Huck carry pain from people who made them feel unworthy, and I loved how their need to prove themselves played out in such different but meaningful ways.
The adventure itself with its deep sea dives and explorations was so vivid and fun while still feeling realistic. And the treasure-hunting friend group was such a highlight. I especially loved Teddy, the mischievous charmer who brought a lot of chaos, humour, and conflict. Honestly, I was a little saddened by the finality in the epilogue because I was so hopeful he’d get his own book. I’m just not ready to leave these characters!
(heat level: 3 open-door scenes, mild details)
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Divided into two parts, I absolutely loved the use of dual timelines here. It sort of felt like two stories in one. You'll see! The initial feelings between Stella and Huck are definitely fast and intense, but the time jump really adds some emotional weight. And besides, there’s just something about high-stakes adventure that makes heightened emotions feel totally believable!
Stella was such a brave, hyper-focused person, driven by a lifetime of abandonment and a relentless obsession with the treasure that consumed her parents. I loved the mix of her strength and vulnerability! Both she and Huck carry pain from people who made them feel unworthy, and I loved how their need to prove themselves played out in such different but meaningful ways.
The adventure itself with its deep sea dives and explorations was so vivid and fun while still feeling realistic. And the treasure-hunting friend group was such a highlight. I especially loved Teddy, the mischievous charmer who brought a lot of chaos, humour, and conflict. Honestly, I was a little saddened by the finality in the epilogue because I was so hopeful he’d get his own book. I’m just not ready to leave these characters!
(heat level: 3 open-door scenes, mild details)
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
November 3, 2025
time of dnf: 21%
unfortunately despite how badly I wanted to like this based on the premise, I don’t think it’s for me specifically at all (African), my final straw was the joking mention of “the racism in Peter Pan” from a MC whose lifelong dream is to find an African diamond and yet never mentions what they plan to do with it (like maybe …give it back???) idk the randomly colonial vibes of their treasure hunt really took me aback personally
I did like Huck (and Zoe and Gus) but Stella and Teddy’s characterization seemed a bit messy in a way I was not going to enjoy reading so I decided to quit while ahead 😔
this is also one of my first time reading this author so I am bummed about this outcome but will try again with another of their works!
thank you so much to netgalley and berkeley for this arc to review nonetheless 💗
unfortunately despite how badly I wanted to like this based on the premise, I don’t think it’s for me specifically at all (African), my final straw was the joking mention of “the racism in Peter Pan” from a MC whose lifelong dream is to find an African diamond and yet never mentions what they plan to do with it (like maybe …give it back???) idk the randomly colonial vibes of their treasure hunt really took me aback personally
I did like Huck (and Zoe and Gus) but Stella and Teddy’s characterization seemed a bit messy in a way I was not going to enjoy reading so I decided to quit while ahead 😔
this is also one of my first time reading this author so I am bummed about this outcome but will try again with another of their works!
thank you so much to netgalley and berkeley for this arc to review nonetheless 💗
July 22, 2025
Thanks to Netgalley & Berkley Publishing Group for the arc! So cute! Loved the characters & the themes. Fun romance too. Perfect summer read! Will read more from this author.
July 4, 2025
♡ Treasure hunt
♡ Writer MMC
♡ Dual timeline
♡ Right person wrong time
♡ Second chance
I admit I expected more drama or intensity in this book, but this was pretty much soft and lowkey. I found myself very interested in the treasure hunt plot since it was important but not overbearing. There have been a lot of romances like this lately, but sometimes the adventure part is a bit too much and I lose interest. It wasn’t the case here because it was perfectly balanced with the romance!
The book is divided into “then” and “now”, splitting the story into two timelines and a second chance. In both parts I thought they were a perfect match, and I could smell the big revelation coming from chapters away. It was really good, but in my opinion it happened too late in the book. I kind of wanted more drama, but it just follows the gentle tone of the book.
I’d say this was a hit for me! I’ve loved almost all of Libby’s books, and I’m excited for more!
Rating: 4/5
Steam level: Closed door, a very low-detail open door scene
ARC provided by Berkley and NetGalley. Opinions are my own!
♡ Writer MMC
♡ Dual timeline
♡ Right person wrong time
♡ Second chance
I admit I expected more drama or intensity in this book, but this was pretty much soft and lowkey. I found myself very interested in the treasure hunt plot since it was important but not overbearing. There have been a lot of romances like this lately, but sometimes the adventure part is a bit too much and I lose interest. It wasn’t the case here because it was perfectly balanced with the romance!
The book is divided into “then” and “now”, splitting the story into two timelines and a second chance. In both parts I thought they were a perfect match, and I could smell the big revelation coming from chapters away. It was really good, but in my opinion it happened too late in the book. I kind of wanted more drama, but it just follows the gentle tone of the book.
I’d say this was a hit for me! I’ve loved almost all of Libby’s books, and I’m excited for more!
Rating: 4/5
Steam level: Closed door, a very low-detail open door scene
ARC provided by Berkley and NetGalley. Opinions are my own!
February 1, 2025
This was such a fun read!
Treasure hunter and writer, kinda a match made in heaven!
I’m normally not a huge of second chance romance but I liked this one (though I can’t say more without giving things away)
I would say the book is plot heavy but relatively low stakes. It’s an adventure book but not action adventure.
You’ll love the side characters and wish they had their own stories! Hell, I wish we had more of them in the book and got to see more of their dynamic.
The best part for me was the little tidbits about the locations!
I grew up in Virginia Beach and spent summers in OBX, I’ve been to Iceland, and now I live in Miami and go to the Keys!
Plus my husband was a seal and one of his specialties was diving so I know way more about it despite never doing it than I could ever want!
I really appreciated the author doing the homework to get the factoids right! That’s what makes a fun book great.
Treasure hunter and writer, kinda a match made in heaven!
I’m normally not a huge of second chance romance but I liked this one (though I can’t say more without giving things away)
I would say the book is plot heavy but relatively low stakes. It’s an adventure book but not action adventure.
You’ll love the side characters and wish they had their own stories! Hell, I wish we had more of them in the book and got to see more of their dynamic.
The best part for me was the little tidbits about the locations!
I grew up in Virginia Beach and spent summers in OBX, I’ve been to Iceland, and now I live in Miami and go to the Keys!
Plus my husband was a seal and one of his specialties was diving so I know way more about it despite never doing it than I could ever want!
I really appreciated the author doing the homework to get the factoids right! That’s what makes a fun book great.
July 24, 2025
I will say that the premise is fun (I love a good treasure hunting romance). Huck and Stella are cute together, and I enjoyed their writer/muse dynamic (it felt like a spin on Castle which I adore). Their relationship was pretty insta-lovey, and that is hurt by the way the book is structured. The story would have been better served if their history was told in flashbacks (it's a tried and true method of doing the second chance romance for a reason). But at the same time, I was invested in seeing the pair reunite, and I loved being able to read excerpts of his book along with Stella. (And I was able to picture David Corenswet as Huck and that’s always a win)
The other bright point of this book was Zoe. I loved how she was a sounding board for both Stella and Huck. She told it the way she saw it, and didn't hesitate to call either character out on the feelings they were ignoring. I would have liked to see her take on the full context of Stella and Teddy's confrontation. All she says is that she knows there was an argument, but it shouldn't negate a decade of their friendship, but I would have preferred if either Stella or Huck went to her and told her the whole story, and if Zoe reinforced that, while the friendship may be repairable, Teddy's behavior was *not* okay.
Now, to the main issue of the book... Teddy.
I would have loved the found family dynamic were it not for Teddy obviously having unrequited feelings for Stella. It isn't revealed until later in the story, but I saw the writing on the wall from the beginning, and as much I was hoping the story wouldn't fall into the cliche of "men and women can't be friends without one catching feelings" it unfortunately went that route. I will admit his storyline is a trigger for me, but the way his "love" for Stella borders on emotional manipulation should have been addressed as a content warning at the start of the book. His not-so-subtle digs, how he uses his words to hurt Huck, and how he uses money as a thinly veiled form of control, I could go ON AND ON. And don't even get me started on how quickly he earns forgiveness. I'm not against a redemption arc, he just needed to earn it. Maybe I’m jaded, but with how intentional he is with his words, using them to get what he wants, it felt disingenuous for him to make a complete 180 and apologize the way he did (it ends up feeling like he’s just saying it to get what he wants). It would have been so much more satisfying if some time had passed, giving the readers the chance to see the real actions Teddy took to show his development (like the AA meetings and finding someone better suited to him), before seeing him and Stella and Huck rekindle their friendship. To forgive his character so quickly sends the message that his behavior and manipulation is somehow okay (which it's NOT). He broke Stella’s trust, and downright disrespected her and Huck, and I would have liked the author take the time to show that trust rebuilt.
In short, I had high hopes for this, but it ultimately left me disappointed.
The other bright point of this book was Zoe. I loved how she was a sounding board for both Stella and Huck. She told it the way she saw it, and didn't hesitate to call either character out on the feelings they were ignoring. I would have liked to see her take on the full context of Stella and Teddy's confrontation. All she says is that she knows there was an argument, but it shouldn't negate a decade of their friendship, but I would have preferred if either Stella or Huck went to her and told her the whole story, and if Zoe reinforced that, while the friendship may be repairable, Teddy's behavior was *not* okay.
Now, to the main issue of the book... Teddy.
I would have loved the found family dynamic were it not for Teddy obviously having unrequited feelings for Stella. It isn't revealed until later in the story, but I saw the writing on the wall from the beginning, and as much I was hoping the story wouldn't fall into the cliche of "men and women can't be friends without one catching feelings" it unfortunately went that route. I will admit his storyline is a trigger for me, but the way his "love" for Stella borders on emotional manipulation should have been addressed as a content warning at the start of the book. His not-so-subtle digs, how he uses his words to hurt Huck, and how he uses money as a thinly veiled form of control, I could go ON AND ON. And don't even get me started on how quickly he earns forgiveness. I'm not against a redemption arc, he just needed to earn it. Maybe I’m jaded, but with how intentional he is with his words, using them to get what he wants, it felt disingenuous for him to make a complete 180 and apologize the way he did (it ends up feeling like he’s just saying it to get what he wants). It would have been so much more satisfying if some time had passed, giving the readers the chance to see the real actions Teddy took to show his development (like the AA meetings and finding someone better suited to him), before seeing him and Stella and Huck rekindle their friendship. To forgive his character so quickly sends the message that his behavior and manipulation is somehow okay (which it's NOT). He broke Stella’s trust, and downright disrespected her and Huck, and I would have liked the author take the time to show that trust rebuilt.
In short, I had high hopes for this, but it ultimately left me disappointed.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 21, 2025
3.5 stars! Not a bad book…just not necessarily a book that gave me all the feels. It was fine but I do think for the right person it’s going to be great!
September 17, 2025
Stella randomly meets her favorite author, Huck, in a bar in Iceland not knowing he’s a longtime friend of Teddy, one of her treasure hunting friends. There are immediate sparks between Stella and Huck, and he helps solve some of a riddle that leads to a treasure find for their group. Stella and Huck then spend a magical, passion-filled night together, but in the morning, Huck is gone with no explanation. He goes on to write a hit novel when a treasure hunting female character suspiciously similar to Stella.
One year later, much to Stella’s surprise, Huck is back to join their latest adventure hunting down sunken treasure in the Florida Keys. Stella’s not thrilled and determined to keep him at arm’s length. However, it’s obvious Huck is full of regret and it’s hard to resist when he’s so sweet.
I really felt for both Stella and Huck. They both had crappy parents and dealt with insecurities stemming from that, but I was not pleased with Huck when he just up and left Stella in the beginning. There was an explanation, but still. Being in his head during his chapters was a little frustrating at times as he was constantly berating himself, letting his father’s awful digs creep in. That being said, I did like him a lot and I was rooting for them to sort out the past and get to their HEA.
Loved Stella’s friend Zoe and Gus, both were supportive and steady. Teddy was another matter altogether! He was awful to both Stella and Huck!
Heart Marks the Spot was a fun, page-turning adventure romance and I really enjoyed the treasure hunting parts and the setting of Iceland and the Florida Keys!
I voluntarily read an advanced readers copy courtesy of the publisher. These are my thoughts and opinions.
One year later, much to Stella’s surprise, Huck is back to join their latest adventure hunting down sunken treasure in the Florida Keys. Stella’s not thrilled and determined to keep him at arm’s length. However, it’s obvious Huck is full of regret and it’s hard to resist when he’s so sweet.
I really felt for both Stella and Huck. They both had crappy parents and dealt with insecurities stemming from that, but I was not pleased with Huck when he just up and left Stella in the beginning. There was an explanation, but still. Being in his head during his chapters was a little frustrating at times as he was constantly berating himself, letting his father’s awful digs creep in. That being said, I did like him a lot and I was rooting for them to sort out the past and get to their HEA.
Loved Stella’s friend Zoe and Gus, both were supportive and steady. Teddy was another matter altogether! He was awful to both Stella and Huck!
Heart Marks the Spot was a fun, page-turning adventure romance and I really enjoyed the treasure hunting parts and the setting of Iceland and the Florida Keys!
I voluntarily read an advanced readers copy courtesy of the publisher. These are my thoughts and opinions.
August 25, 2025
teddy...... it's on sight
July 2, 2025
This is easily my new favorite Libby Hubscher book and I was already a HUGE fan!! A treasure hunter falls for an author with writer's block on one of her treasure hunting adventures in Iceland. Full of found family, multiple treasure hunting excursions, this was a will they won't they romance that was EXCELLENT on audio narrated by Brittany Pressley and Aaron Shedlock and perfect for fans of books like The reef by Nora Roberts or Something wilder by Christina Lauren. Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an early digital copy and @prhaudio for a complimentary ALC in exchange for my honest review!!!
August 1, 2025
I’ve been wanting a solid treasure hunting book lately, and this one was so fun! I loved the diving and treasure hunting content and would’ve loved more of it.
July 10, 2025
Thank you @berkleyromance for the traveling arc copy to and share. All thoughts are my own.
I cannot express to you how much @libbyhubscher's writing hits me every single time. None of her books really coincide with the others so every time I pick one up, I get something unexpected. And it's always been wonderful!
As the child of treasure hunters, Stella has dreamed of carrying on their legacy and finding what they couldn't. A happenstance meeting with Huck turns to heartbreak and years later she has to swallow her hurt and pride and accept his presence aboard as her team's hunt advances.
Starting this novel was one of those immediate five-star feelings. I am such a sucker for a book that wraps me up in such a way. I loved everything about it: the adventure, the setting, the determination, the heartbreak, the curiousity, and the successes. The found family is everything.
I cannot express to you how much @libbyhubscher's writing hits me every single time. None of her books really coincide with the others so every time I pick one up, I get something unexpected. And it's always been wonderful!
As the child of treasure hunters, Stella has dreamed of carrying on their legacy and finding what they couldn't. A happenstance meeting with Huck turns to heartbreak and years later she has to swallow her hurt and pride and accept his presence aboard as her team's hunt advances.
Starting this novel was one of those immediate five-star feelings. I am such a sucker for a book that wraps me up in such a way. I loved everything about it: the adventure, the setting, the determination, the heartbreak, the curiousity, and the successes. The found family is everything.
December 26, 2025
I love when a romance pairs up with an adventure or road trip, and HEART MARKS THE SPOT brought it all. When treasure hunter Stella reunites with novelist Huck, who once broke her heart.
With dual timelines, a fun adventure, and the same emotional depth author Libby pairs with lighthearted feels, made for an entertaining read.
*many thanks to Berkley Romance, PRH audio, and Netgalley for the gifted copy for review
With dual timelines, a fun adventure, and the same emotional depth author Libby pairs with lighthearted feels, made for an entertaining read.
*many thanks to Berkley Romance, PRH audio, and Netgalley for the gifted copy for review
July 27, 2025
I normally don't mind a second-chance romance, but for some reason, I could not get past what Huck did. As I kept reading, I just kept fuming, and I just couldn't forgive him for what he did to Stella.
That said, the writing is good. The adventures are grand. The romance just wasn't meant to be for me.
That said, the writing is good. The adventures are grand. The romance just wasn't meant to be for me.
July 4, 2025
This dual viewpoint romance introduces two interesting characters. Stella Moore is a treasure hunter. Huck Sullivan is a best-selling author.
Stella was abandoned by her treasure hunting parents when she was a teenager. It left her with the sure knowledge that everyone she loves will abandon her sooner or later. She is hoping that if she manages to find the treasure that her parents will come back because she has proven her worth.
Huck doesn't have abandonment issues, but he does have a deeply rooted sense of insecurity since he had spent most of his life being berated by his father for what his father perceived as "failures". While Huck did write a very successful series of adventure novels, the last tanked while he was dealing with the death of his father and abandonment by his fiancée who was only in it when he was at the top of the food chain.
The two meet in Iceland. Stella is on the hunt for a particular treasure along with her friends Ted, Zoe and Gus. Huck was sent there by his friend/agent in hopes that a new place will inspire his creativity and clear up the writer's block that has plagued him for more than a year.
Introduced by Ted who went to boarding school with Huck and who has been partners in adventure with Stella for a number of years, the two fall in love. But Huck leaves Stella in the night for reasons that aren't explained until a year and a half later. She's managed to patch over a broken heart, and he's written a new instant best seller starring a treasure hunter who greatly resembles Stella.
They meet again in the Caribbean when the four friends are on their annual treasure hunt looking for a lost Spanish treasure ship and all the secrets come out.
This was an engaging romance but not a light and fluffy one. Both main characters have serious therapy worthy issues which is not helped by the presence of Ted who has been keeping secrets of his own. I recommend this one because the struggle to reach a "happily ever after" was real in this story.
Stella was abandoned by her treasure hunting parents when she was a teenager. It left her with the sure knowledge that everyone she loves will abandon her sooner or later. She is hoping that if she manages to find the treasure that her parents will come back because she has proven her worth.
Huck doesn't have abandonment issues, but he does have a deeply rooted sense of insecurity since he had spent most of his life being berated by his father for what his father perceived as "failures". While Huck did write a very successful series of adventure novels, the last tanked while he was dealing with the death of his father and abandonment by his fiancée who was only in it when he was at the top of the food chain.
The two meet in Iceland. Stella is on the hunt for a particular treasure along with her friends Ted, Zoe and Gus. Huck was sent there by his friend/agent in hopes that a new place will inspire his creativity and clear up the writer's block that has plagued him for more than a year.
Introduced by Ted who went to boarding school with Huck and who has been partners in adventure with Stella for a number of years, the two fall in love. But Huck leaves Stella in the night for reasons that aren't explained until a year and a half later. She's managed to patch over a broken heart, and he's written a new instant best seller starring a treasure hunter who greatly resembles Stella.
They meet again in the Caribbean when the four friends are on their annual treasure hunt looking for a lost Spanish treasure ship and all the secrets come out.
This was an engaging romance but not a light and fluffy one. Both main characters have serious therapy worthy issues which is not helped by the presence of Ted who has been keeping secrets of his own. I recommend this one because the struggle to reach a "happily ever after" was real in this story.
July 22, 2025
✨️Thank you @berkleyromance for the free book! #berkleypartner #berkleybookstagram #berkley
This was such a beautiful, adventurous second chance romance.
When treasure hunter Stella meets famous author Huck Sullivan at a bar in Iceland, they hit it off instantly. But when he leaves her without a word of explanation, she knows she'll never trust him again. A year and a half later Huck finally has a new book out after his last one was a total flop. And Stella's friend Teddy announces that Huck will be joining their next expedition as research for his next one.
Unlike many second chance romances, which have dual timelines that roate throughout the book, this one had two distinct parts. Part one was when Stella and Huck met. I loved seeing them fall for each other. They had amazing chemistry, and I loved seeing them learn who the other was. The breakup was devastating and I was so confused as to why Huck simply left.
The second part was a little slower than the first, but that allowed for more in-depth exploration of these two broken characters and the ways they used their respective work to hide from their true feelings. I loved watching them learn to trust each other again and grow emotionally. It was also nice to learn more about why they are the way they are and how life circumstances affected the decisions they make now.
The treasure hunting aspect of the story was a lot of fun, and although it was exciting and adventurous, it felt low-stakes and exciting, even during times of peril.
From the minute I started this book, I knew it would be a 5 star read. Those vibes stayed with me throughout the whole book, even when there were things I didn't necessarily love. Some of the character's choices made me irritated and I felt like the story dragged a little in the middle.But the way I felt for the characters and the story never wavered and it was the perfect mix of romance, adventure, friendship and emotion. I definitely recommend this one!!
This was such a beautiful, adventurous second chance romance.
When treasure hunter Stella meets famous author Huck Sullivan at a bar in Iceland, they hit it off instantly. But when he leaves her without a word of explanation, she knows she'll never trust him again. A year and a half later Huck finally has a new book out after his last one was a total flop. And Stella's friend Teddy announces that Huck will be joining their next expedition as research for his next one.
Unlike many second chance romances, which have dual timelines that roate throughout the book, this one had two distinct parts. Part one was when Stella and Huck met. I loved seeing them fall for each other. They had amazing chemistry, and I loved seeing them learn who the other was. The breakup was devastating and I was so confused as to why Huck simply left.
The second part was a little slower than the first, but that allowed for more in-depth exploration of these two broken characters and the ways they used their respective work to hide from their true feelings. I loved watching them learn to trust each other again and grow emotionally. It was also nice to learn more about why they are the way they are and how life circumstances affected the decisions they make now.
The treasure hunting aspect of the story was a lot of fun, and although it was exciting and adventurous, it felt low-stakes and exciting, even during times of peril.
From the minute I started this book, I knew it would be a 5 star read. Those vibes stayed with me throughout the whole book, even when there were things I didn't necessarily love. Some of the character's choices made me irritated and I felt like the story dragged a little in the middle.But the way I felt for the characters and the story never wavered and it was the perfect mix of romance, adventure, friendship and emotion. I definitely recommend this one!!
September 29, 2025
This is a review of both the audiobook and the ebook. The audiobook is performed by Brittany Pressley and Aaron Shedlock.
This is a contemporary romance with a past/present timeline. The book is divided into two parts. The second part takes place 1.5 years later.
The book has both the male (Huck) and female (Stella) POVs.
Stella was abandoned by her parents. And now she is a treasure hunter. I found this to be so fun.
Huck is a best selling author who has writer’s block. I loved this profession.
The first part of the story takes place in Iceland.
I did both the ebook and audiobook (listening while walking and driving). But I read almost all of part two. I’m not sure if I preferred the ebook or if I enjoyed the second part more but I really liked the second half of the book better.
I did like Brittany Pressley. She has a great voice for audiobooks. Aaron Shedlock was good doing the male parts. But I’ve been having issues recently with non-duet dual POV romance audiobooks. How they do the opposite sex voices is so crucial. Most male audiobook readers struggle with this. Honestly I would just prefer that they read it in their own voice.
The present part of the book (part 2) was so good. I loved the diving and looking for treasures. I liked Huck writing and researching his books. And I was even surprised by a great reveal.
This is a contemporary romance with a past/present timeline. The book is divided into two parts. The second part takes place 1.5 years later.
The book has both the male (Huck) and female (Stella) POVs.
Stella was abandoned by her parents. And now she is a treasure hunter. I found this to be so fun.
Huck is a best selling author who has writer’s block. I loved this profession.
The first part of the story takes place in Iceland.
I did both the ebook and audiobook (listening while walking and driving). But I read almost all of part two. I’m not sure if I preferred the ebook or if I enjoyed the second part more but I really liked the second half of the book better.
I did like Brittany Pressley. She has a great voice for audiobooks. Aaron Shedlock was good doing the male parts. But I’ve been having issues recently with non-duet dual POV romance audiobooks. How they do the opposite sex voices is so crucial. Most male audiobook readers struggle with this. Honestly I would just prefer that they read it in their own voice.
The present part of the book (part 2) was so good. I loved the diving and looking for treasures. I liked Huck writing and researching his books. And I was even surprised by a great reveal.
July 22, 2025
Okay, this book is just plain fun...perfect to toss in your beach bag or read on the couch for the perfect escape. Stella is a literal treasure hunter. She and her found family of friends spend time on a trip each summer hunting for missing treasure and have ever since her parents left her as a child. They were the ones that got Stella hooked on finding the Elephant's Heart, and Stella hasn't stopped looking for it ever since.
The book kicks off in Iceland where Stella runs into one of her favorite authors, Huck. Little does she know that Huck is long time friends with Stella's best friend, and fellow treasure hunter, Teddy. What is cool about this book is that we sort of get a second chance romance, but get to see both timelines. First is the initial budding romance between Huck and Stella in Iceland. The vibes were great and the connection believable. For reasons, Huck and Stella part ways until over a year later when they meet up on Stella's next expedition to Key West.
I loved both settings of Iceland and Key West. Hubscher does this so well. You feel like you can easily picture both locales right along with the characters. Stella's fiery determination was great. She had gumption. It was also hard not to love Huck, even though he wasn't perfect. Teddy, the best friend, was an adorable goofball who made me laugh so much. Really, the whole crew just made this book. It had all the vacation vibes with a side of friendship, fun, and adventure. Plus, there was true character growth. If you want to escape for any reason, this is the book I would pick up. You're going to have a great time in Hubscher's world.
Thank you to Berkley for an ARC of this book. The opinions here are my own.
The book kicks off in Iceland where Stella runs into one of her favorite authors, Huck. Little does she know that Huck is long time friends with Stella's best friend, and fellow treasure hunter, Teddy. What is cool about this book is that we sort of get a second chance romance, but get to see both timelines. First is the initial budding romance between Huck and Stella in Iceland. The vibes were great and the connection believable. For reasons, Huck and Stella part ways until over a year later when they meet up on Stella's next expedition to Key West.
I loved both settings of Iceland and Key West. Hubscher does this so well. You feel like you can easily picture both locales right along with the characters. Stella's fiery determination was great. She had gumption. It was also hard not to love Huck, even though he wasn't perfect. Teddy, the best friend, was an adorable goofball who made me laugh so much. Really, the whole crew just made this book. It had all the vacation vibes with a side of friendship, fun, and adventure. Plus, there was true character growth. If you want to escape for any reason, this is the book I would pick up. You're going to have a great time in Hubscher's world.
Thank you to Berkley for an ARC of this book. The opinions here are my own.
July 24, 2025
Libby Hubscher's latest offering, Heart Marks the Spot, delivers a romance that's as richly layered as the ancient treasures her characters seek. This fourth novel from the author of Meet Me in Paradise, If You Ask Me, and Play for Me combines the thrill of treasure hunting with the vulnerability of second-chance romance, creating a story that manages to be both escapist adventure and emotionally grounded contemporary fiction.
The Hunt Begins: Plot and Structure
The novel follows Stella Moore, a professional treasure hunter whose summer expeditions with her tight-knit crew have become as much about friendship as finding lost riches. When bestselling adventure novelist Huck Sullivan joins their Icelandic expedition seeking inspiration for his next book, what starts as a chance encounter evolves into an unforgettable connection on a black sand beach. However, when Huck disappears without explanation, Stella's heart becomes as buried as the treasures she seeks.
A year later, as Stella prepares for another hunt—this time for the legendary San Miguel shipwreck off Key West—Huck reappears, seeking material for a sequel and a second chance. The dual timeline structure allows Hubscher to expertly weave the past and present, revealing how love can be both discovered and lost, then found again when we're finally ready to claim it.
Characters That Feel Like Found Family
Stella Moore: A Heroine Worth Rooting For
Stella emerges as a remarkably complex protagonist whose expertise in treasure hunting contrasts beautifully with her uncertainty in matters of the heart. Her backstory of parental abandonment—first her mother's death, then her father's disappearance—provides the emotional foundation that makes her reluctance to trust completely understandable. Hubscher avoids the trap of making Stella's past a mere plot device; instead, it informs every relationship and decision, particularly her friendship with Teddy and her complicated feelings for Huck.
Stella's professional competence never wavers, even when her personal life feels chaotic. She can decipher ancient Viking poems and navigate underwater treasure sites with expertise, yet struggles to interpret the map of her own heart. This juxtaposition creates a heroine who feels authentically human—strong in some areas, vulnerable in others.
Huck Sullivan: More Than a Pretty Face
Huck could have easily fallen into the "mysterious tortured artist" trope, but Hubscher gives him genuine depth. His writer's block stems not just from critical failure but from a crisis of purpose and self-worth that many creative professionals will recognize. His attraction to Stella feels organic, rooted in their intellectual compatibility and shared sense of adventure rather than mere physical chemistry.
The revelation of his family dynamics and the pressure he's faced as a public figure adds layers to his character that justify his past mistakes. When he writes a fictionalized version of their relationship in his comeback novel, it serves as both plot device and character development—showing his inability to let go while also demonstrating how thoroughly Stella has captured his imagination.
The Supporting Cast: Friends as Family
Perhaps the strongest element of Heart Marks the Spot is its portrayal of chosen family. Teddy, Zoe, and Gus aren't just supporting characters; they're integral to both the plot and Stella's emotional journey. Each brings distinct personality traits and relationship dynamics that feel genuine rather than functional.
Teddy's character arc deserves particular mention. His descent into alcoholism and unrequited love for Stella could have been handled heavy-handedly, but Hubscher treats his struggles with compassion and complexity. The underwater accident that serves as the novel's climax isn't just a plot device—it's the culmination of Teddy's internal struggles and serves as a catalyst for everyone's growth.
Zoe and Gus's relationship provides a lovely counterpoint to Stella and Huck's complicated dynamic. Their secret romance, revealed gradually throughout the story, demonstrates how love can flourish quietly alongside friendship, offering hope for Stella's own romantic future.
Writing Style: Accessible Yet Evocative
Hubscher's prose strikes an appealing balance between accessibility and literary merit. Her descriptions of both Iceland's stark beauty and Key West's tropical abundance are vivid without becoming overwrought. The technical aspects of treasure hunting are woven seamlessly into the narrative, educating readers without feeling like exposition dumps.
The dialogue sparkles with authentic banter, particularly in group scenes where the four friends' long history shines through their teasing and inside jokes. Hubscher has a particular gift for capturing the rhythm of close friendships—the way people who've known each other for years can communicate volumes with a look or a throwaway comment.
The romantic scenes between Stella and Huck are charged with genuine chemistry. Their initial meeting in the Icelandic bar crackles with the kind of intellectual attraction that forms the best foundation for lasting love. Their physical scenes are tastefully written, focusing more on emotional connection than explicit detail, which fits the overall tone of the novel.
Strengths That Shine Like Hidden Gold
Emotional Authenticity
The emotional core of the novel rings true throughout. Stella's fear of abandonment, Huck's creative struggles, and Teddy's self-destructive spiral all feel grounded in realistic human psychology rather than romance novel convenience.
Adventure Elements
The treasure hunting backdrop provides genuine excitement without overwhelming the character development. Hubscher clearly did her research, and the technical details of metal detecting, diving, and archaeological recovery feel authentic.
Friendship Dynamics
The portrayal of long-term friendship groups is particularly strong. The way the four main characters relate to each other feels lived-in and genuine, with each relationship having its own distinct flavor.
Second-Chance Romance Done Right
The novel avoids the common pitfall of second-chance romances where the original conflict feels manufactured. Huck's reasons for leaving are complicated and understandable, even if misguided, making their reunion feel earned rather than inevitable.
Areas Where the Treasure Map Could Use Fine-Tuning
Pacing in the Middle Act
The middle section of the novel occasionally feels slower than necessary, particularly during some of the diving sequences that don't directly advance either the plot or character development. While these scenes establish atmosphere and technical credibility, they sometimes interrupt the romantic momentum.
Teddy's Arc Resolution
While Teddy's struggle with alcoholism is handled sensitively, his recovery and acceptance of Stella and Huck's relationship feels somewhat rushed in the final act. A bit more space for this emotional journey would have strengthened the overall narrative arc.
Villain Absence
Unlike some romance novels that benefit from external antagonists, Heart Marks the Spot focuses primarily on internal conflicts. While this generally works well, the lack of any significant external threat (beyond natural diving hazards) occasionally makes the stakes feel lower than they could be.
Final Verdict: A Romance Worth the Hunt
Heart Marks the Spot succeeds as both adventure story and romance novel, offering readers the best of both genres without shortchanging either. Hubscher has crafted characters who feel like people you'd want to befriend and a romance that develops naturally from genuine compatibility and attraction.
While not without minor flaws in pacing and some rushed character resolutions, the novel delivers on its central promises: an exciting treasure hunt, a satisfying romance, and genuine emotional payoffs. The ending, which sees both couples finding happiness while the friend group remains intact, strikes the perfect balance between wish fulfillment and realistic relationship dynamics.
Hubscher continues to establish herself as a reliable voice in contemporary romance, capable of balancing humor with genuine emotion and familiar tropes with fresh perspectives. For readers seeking an escape that doesn't require checking their intelligence at the door, Heart Marks the Spot marks exactly the right spot.
The Hunt Begins: Plot and Structure
The novel follows Stella Moore, a professional treasure hunter whose summer expeditions with her tight-knit crew have become as much about friendship as finding lost riches. When bestselling adventure novelist Huck Sullivan joins their Icelandic expedition seeking inspiration for his next book, what starts as a chance encounter evolves into an unforgettable connection on a black sand beach. However, when Huck disappears without explanation, Stella's heart becomes as buried as the treasures she seeks.
A year later, as Stella prepares for another hunt—this time for the legendary San Miguel shipwreck off Key West—Huck reappears, seeking material for a sequel and a second chance. The dual timeline structure allows Hubscher to expertly weave the past and present, revealing how love can be both discovered and lost, then found again when we're finally ready to claim it.
Characters That Feel Like Found Family
Stella Moore: A Heroine Worth Rooting For
Stella emerges as a remarkably complex protagonist whose expertise in treasure hunting contrasts beautifully with her uncertainty in matters of the heart. Her backstory of parental abandonment—first her mother's death, then her father's disappearance—provides the emotional foundation that makes her reluctance to trust completely understandable. Hubscher avoids the trap of making Stella's past a mere plot device; instead, it informs every relationship and decision, particularly her friendship with Teddy and her complicated feelings for Huck.
Stella's professional competence never wavers, even when her personal life feels chaotic. She can decipher ancient Viking poems and navigate underwater treasure sites with expertise, yet struggles to interpret the map of her own heart. This juxtaposition creates a heroine who feels authentically human—strong in some areas, vulnerable in others.
Huck Sullivan: More Than a Pretty Face
Huck could have easily fallen into the "mysterious tortured artist" trope, but Hubscher gives him genuine depth. His writer's block stems not just from critical failure but from a crisis of purpose and self-worth that many creative professionals will recognize. His attraction to Stella feels organic, rooted in their intellectual compatibility and shared sense of adventure rather than mere physical chemistry.
The revelation of his family dynamics and the pressure he's faced as a public figure adds layers to his character that justify his past mistakes. When he writes a fictionalized version of their relationship in his comeback novel, it serves as both plot device and character development—showing his inability to let go while also demonstrating how thoroughly Stella has captured his imagination.
The Supporting Cast: Friends as Family
Perhaps the strongest element of Heart Marks the Spot is its portrayal of chosen family. Teddy, Zoe, and Gus aren't just supporting characters; they're integral to both the plot and Stella's emotional journey. Each brings distinct personality traits and relationship dynamics that feel genuine rather than functional.
Teddy's character arc deserves particular mention. His descent into alcoholism and unrequited love for Stella could have been handled heavy-handedly, but Hubscher treats his struggles with compassion and complexity. The underwater accident that serves as the novel's climax isn't just a plot device—it's the culmination of Teddy's internal struggles and serves as a catalyst for everyone's growth.
Zoe and Gus's relationship provides a lovely counterpoint to Stella and Huck's complicated dynamic. Their secret romance, revealed gradually throughout the story, demonstrates how love can flourish quietly alongside friendship, offering hope for Stella's own romantic future.
Writing Style: Accessible Yet Evocative
Hubscher's prose strikes an appealing balance between accessibility and literary merit. Her descriptions of both Iceland's stark beauty and Key West's tropical abundance are vivid without becoming overwrought. The technical aspects of treasure hunting are woven seamlessly into the narrative, educating readers without feeling like exposition dumps.
The dialogue sparkles with authentic banter, particularly in group scenes where the four friends' long history shines through their teasing and inside jokes. Hubscher has a particular gift for capturing the rhythm of close friendships—the way people who've known each other for years can communicate volumes with a look or a throwaway comment.
The romantic scenes between Stella and Huck are charged with genuine chemistry. Their initial meeting in the Icelandic bar crackles with the kind of intellectual attraction that forms the best foundation for lasting love. Their physical scenes are tastefully written, focusing more on emotional connection than explicit detail, which fits the overall tone of the novel.
Strengths That Shine Like Hidden Gold
Emotional Authenticity
The emotional core of the novel rings true throughout. Stella's fear of abandonment, Huck's creative struggles, and Teddy's self-destructive spiral all feel grounded in realistic human psychology rather than romance novel convenience.
Adventure Elements
The treasure hunting backdrop provides genuine excitement without overwhelming the character development. Hubscher clearly did her research, and the technical details of metal detecting, diving, and archaeological recovery feel authentic.
Friendship Dynamics
The portrayal of long-term friendship groups is particularly strong. The way the four main characters relate to each other feels lived-in and genuine, with each relationship having its own distinct flavor.
Second-Chance Romance Done Right
The novel avoids the common pitfall of second-chance romances where the original conflict feels manufactured. Huck's reasons for leaving are complicated and understandable, even if misguided, making their reunion feel earned rather than inevitable.
Areas Where the Treasure Map Could Use Fine-Tuning
Pacing in the Middle Act
The middle section of the novel occasionally feels slower than necessary, particularly during some of the diving sequences that don't directly advance either the plot or character development. While these scenes establish atmosphere and technical credibility, they sometimes interrupt the romantic momentum.
Teddy's Arc Resolution
While Teddy's struggle with alcoholism is handled sensitively, his recovery and acceptance of Stella and Huck's relationship feels somewhat rushed in the final act. A bit more space for this emotional journey would have strengthened the overall narrative arc.
Villain Absence
Unlike some romance novels that benefit from external antagonists, Heart Marks the Spot focuses primarily on internal conflicts. While this generally works well, the lack of any significant external threat (beyond natural diving hazards) occasionally makes the stakes feel lower than they could be.
Final Verdict: A Romance Worth the Hunt
Heart Marks the Spot succeeds as both adventure story and romance novel, offering readers the best of both genres without shortchanging either. Hubscher has crafted characters who feel like people you'd want to befriend and a romance that develops naturally from genuine compatibility and attraction.
While not without minor flaws in pacing and some rushed character resolutions, the novel delivers on its central promises: an exciting treasure hunt, a satisfying romance, and genuine emotional payoffs. The ending, which sees both couples finding happiness while the friend group remains intact, strikes the perfect balance between wish fulfillment and realistic relationship dynamics.
Hubscher continues to establish herself as a reliable voice in contemporary romance, capable of balancing humor with genuine emotion and familiar tropes with fresh perspectives. For readers seeking an escape that doesn't require checking their intelligence at the door, Heart Marks the Spot marks exactly the right spot.
July 22, 2025
Well, that book was definitely one of a kind, might be worth to some.
Writing style ain’t for me though, I found myself drifting away from this book and so relieved to finish it, was bored 80% of the time. Now look, the treasure-hunting thing was cool, but the plotting itself wasn’t it, and I didn’t find myself interested in any of the characters.
Eventually, I was doom-reading and skipping lines because I really couldn’t keep up and wanted to finish it so bad.
Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange of a honest review.
Writing style ain’t for me though, I found myself drifting away from this book and so relieved to finish it, was bored 80% of the time. Now look, the treasure-hunting thing was cool, but the plotting itself wasn’t it, and I didn’t find myself interested in any of the characters.
Eventually, I was doom-reading and skipping lines because I really couldn’t keep up and wanted to finish it so bad.
Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange of a honest review.
February 3, 2025
4.5 stars, rounded up. This is such a fun summer adventure rom-com, perfect for fans of Outer Banks!
This book follows treasure hunter Stella and novelist Huck; they first meet in Iceland where they have instant sparks, but Huck leaves Stella behind without explanation. To add insult to injury, Huck turns their encounter into a bestseller, not that Stella is willing to read it. Roughly a year later, the pair are forced together on another adventure hunting for treasure in the ocean.
I loved the high-stakes situations, cast of characters, and unique and entertaining plot! I felt that the elements kept hidden from the reader were revealed in a satisfying way that kept me interested and wanting to know more about what went wrong during the couple’s first encounter and the intervening period between parts 1 and 2 of the book.
I enjoyed this one a lot, but I do wish there would have been more time spent on the characters’ emotional connection and pining.
Thank you to Berkley and NetGalley for the free ARC in exchange for my honest review!
This book follows treasure hunter Stella and novelist Huck; they first meet in Iceland where they have instant sparks, but Huck leaves Stella behind without explanation. To add insult to injury, Huck turns their encounter into a bestseller, not that Stella is willing to read it. Roughly a year later, the pair are forced together on another adventure hunting for treasure in the ocean.
I loved the high-stakes situations, cast of characters, and unique and entertaining plot! I felt that the elements kept hidden from the reader were revealed in a satisfying way that kept me interested and wanting to know more about what went wrong during the couple’s first encounter and the intervening period between parts 1 and 2 of the book.
I enjoyed this one a lot, but I do wish there would have been more time spent on the characters’ emotional connection and pining.
Thank you to Berkley and NetGalley for the free ARC in exchange for my honest review!
July 9, 2025
4.5 stars
This is the treasure hunting book I wanted to read this summer!
Y'all. I am smitten with this story! Thank you so much to Berkley Romance for the ARC and PRH Audio for the audiobook! These are my honest thoughts.
Stella's whole life has been about treasure hunting, and when both her parents abandoned her as a teenager, she focused even harder to find the treasure they dreamed about, to find value and prove to them she was worth staying for. Instead, she finds an incredible group of friends who journey with her every year to find treasure. They bond, and even though Stella is a stickler for actually hunting for treasure, her friends love her enough to go along with their antics.
This store is split into two: the before and the after.
The before takes place in Iceland, where Stella randomly bumps into her favorite author, Huck Sullivan, in a bar one night. His inspiration has dried up, and there's just something so compelling about Stella. His prep school buddy happens to be Stella's best friend, in that *it's a small world* kinda way, and Huck joins in on the adventure to find the treasure.
Stella and Huck's chemistry is electric. Their banter and the way they communicate brings both of them to life. And then, something afters.
The after takes place a year later, on another treasure hunting adventure. There's heartbreak and miscommunication and tension and DRAMA amongst the one solid crew, and no one really knows what's going on, not fully. But Stella and Huck, one moment at a time, find their way back to each other. And even as things fall apart, heart marks the spot for magic.
I binged the audiobook in 24 hours, and it's dual POV, which I usually LOVE. While the male narrator, Aaron Shedlock, unfortunately really bothered me for Huck, I adored Brittany Pressley as Stella. I felt ALL the feelings that Stella was feeling through Pressley's performance, and I was able to eat those chapters up. I've listened to DOZENS of Aaron Shedlock books... but I just wasn't on board for this performance.
This one is out July 22nd, and I hope people pick it up! I've loved all the books I've read by Libby Hubscher.
This is the treasure hunting book I wanted to read this summer!
Y'all. I am smitten with this story! Thank you so much to Berkley Romance for the ARC and PRH Audio for the audiobook! These are my honest thoughts.
Stella's whole life has been about treasure hunting, and when both her parents abandoned her as a teenager, she focused even harder to find the treasure they dreamed about, to find value and prove to them she was worth staying for. Instead, she finds an incredible group of friends who journey with her every year to find treasure. They bond, and even though Stella is a stickler for actually hunting for treasure, her friends love her enough to go along with their antics.
This store is split into two: the before and the after.
The before takes place in Iceland, where Stella randomly bumps into her favorite author, Huck Sullivan, in a bar one night. His inspiration has dried up, and there's just something so compelling about Stella. His prep school buddy happens to be Stella's best friend, in that *it's a small world* kinda way, and Huck joins in on the adventure to find the treasure.
Stella and Huck's chemistry is electric. Their banter and the way they communicate brings both of them to life. And then, something afters.
The after takes place a year later, on another treasure hunting adventure. There's heartbreak and miscommunication and tension and DRAMA amongst the one solid crew, and no one really knows what's going on, not fully. But Stella and Huck, one moment at a time, find their way back to each other. And even as things fall apart, heart marks the spot for magic.
I binged the audiobook in 24 hours, and it's dual POV, which I usually LOVE. While the male narrator, Aaron Shedlock, unfortunately really bothered me for Huck, I adored Brittany Pressley as Stella. I felt ALL the feelings that Stella was feeling through Pressley's performance, and I was able to eat those chapters up. I've listened to DOZENS of Aaron Shedlock books... but I just wasn't on board for this performance.
This one is out July 22nd, and I hope people pick it up! I've loved all the books I've read by Libby Hubscher.
August 29, 2025
Huck and Stella. Author and treasure hunter.
Yeesh, seriously. What is going on with 2025 and shitty parents?
Stella and her friends, Zoe, Gus, and Teddy, are treasure hunters. Every year, they go on a trip to search for a lost diamond, the Elephant's Heart. At a bar in Iceland, Stella meets Huck, her favorite author and celebrity crush. Huck is in a writing slump. and happens to be Teddy's roommate/friend from boarding school. Huck joins them, they find treasure, Stella and Huck share a magical evening on the beach. And when Stella wakes in the morning, Huck is gone.
Fast forward one year later, and Huck has written another NYT bestseller. Based on the cover, the hero/FMC shares many similarities with Stella and the MMC is too much like Huck.
Huck needs to write more books, so he convinces Teddy to let him join their next trip to Florida.
And we learn:
- Stella's mom walked out.
- Stella's dad left her on a beach, promised to come back, and broke his promise.
- Huck's dad was a toxic asshole who was only around to express how disappointed he was with Huck before he died.
- Stella's friends Gus and Zoe are growing up and moving on without her. In fact, Zoe is pregnant.
- Teddy, the trust fund baby and bank roller of all the expeditions, is broke.
- Huck loves Stella.
- Teddy loves Stella.
Teddy forces Huck to leave the expedition. Stella confronts Huck, then Teddy, and it looks like she is going to lose both of them. Teddy goes out alone on a dive, and almost dies.
But this is a romance novel.
Teddy is taken to the hospital, Huck comes to apologize, epilogue and HEA for everyone.
Yeesh, seriously. What is going on with 2025 and shitty parents?
Stella and her friends, Zoe, Gus, and Teddy, are treasure hunters. Every year, they go on a trip to search for a lost diamond, the Elephant's Heart. At a bar in Iceland, Stella meets Huck, her favorite author and celebrity crush. Huck is in a writing slump. and happens to be Teddy's roommate/friend from boarding school. Huck joins them, they find treasure, Stella and Huck share a magical evening on the beach. And when Stella wakes in the morning, Huck is gone.
Fast forward one year later, and Huck has written another NYT bestseller. Based on the cover, the hero/FMC shares many similarities with Stella and the MMC is too much like Huck.
Huck needs to write more books, so he convinces Teddy to let him join their next trip to Florida.
And we learn:
- Stella's mom walked out.
- Stella's dad left her on a beach, promised to come back, and broke his promise.
- Huck's dad was a toxic asshole who was only around to express how disappointed he was with Huck before he died.
- Stella's friends Gus and Zoe are growing up and moving on without her. In fact, Zoe is pregnant.
- Teddy, the trust fund baby and bank roller of all the expeditions, is broke.
- Huck loves Stella.
- Teddy loves Stella.
Teddy forces Huck to leave the expedition. Stella confronts Huck, then Teddy, and it looks like she is going to lose both of them. Teddy goes out alone on a dive, and almost dies.
But this is a romance novel.
Teddy is taken to the hospital, Huck comes to apologize, epilogue and HEA for everyone.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Read
July 28, 2025Stella Moore has been determined to prove both to her parents and herself that the treasure she has been searching for for years is out there. When Stella unexpectedly meets writer Huck Sullivan during an expedition in Iceland with her friends, she can’t deny the sparks that fly between them. After Huck tags along with Stella and her crew and helping them solve clues along the way, Huck then disbands from the group leaving Stella hurt and confused. When the two reconnect again, this time in the Florida Keys, discoveries will lead to life changing decisions.
As usual, Libby Hubscher tugs at your heartstrings while also crafting a wonderful romance. The character's learn to deal with their own demons such as divorce and verbal abuse. I also connected with Stella feeling like she is stagnant while the world is moving on around her. Not the mention the locations for the expeditions were so immersive and fun to read about! I absolutely loved this adventure romance!
As usual, Libby Hubscher tugs at your heartstrings while also crafting a wonderful romance. The character's learn to deal with their own demons such as divorce and verbal abuse. I also connected with Stella feeling like she is stagnant while the world is moving on around her. Not the mention the locations for the expeditions were so immersive and fun to read about! I absolutely loved this adventure romance!
did-not-finish
June 21, 2025DNF at 54%
This one just didn’t work for me. It felt very mid and honestly kind of boring. The world felt too polished, like the characters were living in their own happy little bubble with no real depth or stakes.
I really tried to keep going, but I had to DNF. The story just didn’t feel believable to me, and some character choices left me scratching my head. Things happened that didn’t make a lot of logical sense, and a good bit of dialogue felt like filler, which made it hard to stay invested.
What I did like was the concept, it had a lot of potential and sounded like something I’d usually enjoy. But the execution just didn��t land for me.
If you’re looking for something super light and low-stakes for a summer read, this might be more your style.
Thank you to NetGalley and Berkley for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.
This one just didn’t work for me. It felt very mid and honestly kind of boring. The world felt too polished, like the characters were living in their own happy little bubble with no real depth or stakes.
I really tried to keep going, but I had to DNF. The story just didn’t feel believable to me, and some character choices left me scratching my head. Things happened that didn’t make a lot of logical sense, and a good bit of dialogue felt like filler, which made it hard to stay invested.
What I did like was the concept, it had a lot of potential and sounded like something I’d usually enjoy. But the execution just didn��t land for me.
If you’re looking for something super light and low-stakes for a summer read, this might be more your style.
Thank you to NetGalley and Berkley for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.
August 2, 2025
This was a fun and adventurous read, my second treasure hunting romance of the summer!
Stella and her friends are hunting for treasure when she meets Huck, the author of her favorite book series. The pair hit it off, and Stella is shocked when Huck abruptly leaves after a whirlwind time together. We then fast forward to them meeting again a year later for another summer treasure hunt and a second chance romance.
I have been loving action romances lately, and thought the treasure hunting in this one was made for the screen! Diving for treasure, searching behind waterfalls, traveling the world? All such a fun and cinematic part of this book! I enjoyed the characters and their relationships as well, even as I found a few relationship moments to be slightly predictable.
Read if you enjoy:
💫 Treasure hunting storylines
💫 Found family
💫 Second chance romance
💫 Adventure romance
Stella and her friends are hunting for treasure when she meets Huck, the author of her favorite book series. The pair hit it off, and Stella is shocked when Huck abruptly leaves after a whirlwind time together. We then fast forward to them meeting again a year later for another summer treasure hunt and a second chance romance.
I have been loving action romances lately, and thought the treasure hunting in this one was made for the screen! Diving for treasure, searching behind waterfalls, traveling the world? All such a fun and cinematic part of this book! I enjoyed the characters and their relationships as well, even as I found a few relationship moments to be slightly predictable.
Read if you enjoy:
💫 Treasure hunting storylines
💫 Found family
💫 Second chance romance
💫 Adventure romance
April 2, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an eACR of the book in exchange for an honest review!
Heart Marks the Spot follows the story of Stella Moore, a treasurer hunter, and Huck Sullivan, an author who broke her heart. Huck and Stella meet by chance in Iceland and after a successful treasure hunting expedition and one night of perfect passion, Huck abandons Stella. Now, a year and a half later, he's back in life as he tags along for her crew's next treasure hunting adventure, hoping to find inspiration for his next novel and to atone for breaking her heart.
I enjoyed the treasure hunting aspect of this novel. I actually haven't read many books with a focus on that, so it felt new and refreshing. I also really enjoyed the cast of characters, especially Stella's best friend Teddy (for the most part anyway).
I didn't give the book a higher rating because I felt like the chemistry between Stella and Huck was just a tad lacking. They seemed to have more chemistry during their first meeting in Iceland and it was never quite captured again in my option. I also found long stretches of the novel to include more exposition than I would have liked; telling instead of showing, you know?
Overall, it was a fun novel and I was able to get through it at a fairly quick pace. The book comes out in July and with the summer, sun, and sea diving vibes, I think this will be a great book for the summer season!
Heart Marks the Spot follows the story of Stella Moore, a treasurer hunter, and Huck Sullivan, an author who broke her heart. Huck and Stella meet by chance in Iceland and after a successful treasure hunting expedition and one night of perfect passion, Huck abandons Stella. Now, a year and a half later, he's back in life as he tags along for her crew's next treasure hunting adventure, hoping to find inspiration for his next novel and to atone for breaking her heart.
I enjoyed the treasure hunting aspect of this novel. I actually haven't read many books with a focus on that, so it felt new and refreshing. I also really enjoyed the cast of characters, especially Stella's best friend Teddy (for the most part anyway).
I didn't give the book a higher rating because I felt like the chemistry between Stella and Huck was just a tad lacking. They seemed to have more chemistry during their first meeting in Iceland and it was never quite captured again in my option. I also found long stretches of the novel to include more exposition than I would have liked; telling instead of showing, you know?
Overall, it was a fun novel and I was able to get through it at a fairly quick pace. The book comes out in July and with the summer, sun, and sea diving vibes, I think this will be a great book for the summer season!
July 27, 2025
I’m not sure why I keep reading Hubscher’s books. I feel like the plot pulls me in, but then it’s just not well done (compared to what I feel like it could be). I did enjoy one of her other books, but for this one, I kind of just kept feeling like, really, that’s what you’re having them do? Okay then.
August 19, 2025
"Even if he didn’t think I was good enough then & lost the right to have me care what he thinks about me now…I still do. I have no intention of letting Huck get close to me again, but that doesn’t mean that I don’t want to prove that I was something special—not to win him over, but to show him that he was wrong. To tell him that leaving me was a mistake." - 😬🙄 yikes girl.. where is ur self-respect? Grow a spine!
she really let this man leave her (more than once), and it took over 7 hours of reading to get to his FIRST apology for it?!?! boy, bye!!
his "excuse" was LAME & not something someone who truly "loves you" would do. and he's not even mature enough to TELL her the excuse. she has to read about it in his stupid book?!? So he broke her heart AND makes her do her own homework to find out why?!
we need to stop normalizing women being stupid for men who are unable to communicate on even a basic 2nd grade level. no chemistry. no effort. crumbs. crumbs. motherf**kin CRUMBS!!!!! 🤬
and also? this was just boring as hell 😴 it wanted to be Outer Banks sooooooo bad! and it was executed soooooo horribly.
she really let this man leave her (more than once), and it took over 7 hours of reading to get to his FIRST apology for it?!?! boy, bye!!
his "excuse" was LAME & not something someone who truly "loves you" would do. and he's not even mature enough to TELL her the excuse. she has to read about it in his stupid book?!? So he broke her heart AND makes her do her own homework to find out why?!
we need to stop normalizing women being stupid for men who are unable to communicate on even a basic 2nd grade level. no chemistry. no effort. crumbs. crumbs. motherf**kin CRUMBS!!!!! 🤬
and also? this was just boring as hell 😴 it wanted to be Outer Banks sooooooo bad! and it was executed soooooo horribly.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 170 reviews