What do you think?
Rate this book
Tales of Silverfern Hollow #1
Tansy's Tinctures
Tansy Glenmoss flees the horrors of war, seeking solace in the magical marshlands of Silverfern Hollow.
In a cozy cottage surrounded by blooming gardens and the warmth of a welcoming community, she begins to heal—brewing remedies, growing friendships, and finding an unexpected connection with Orsian, a man whose scars run as deep as her own.
But peace is fragile.
A shadow from her past emerges, and dark magic seeps into the marshlands. As the waters foul and the Folk fall ill, Tansy must confront the nightmares she thought she’d escaped and protect the family and home she never thought she’d find.
Filled with heartwarming moments, quiet resilience, and the healing power of second chances, Tansy’s Tinctures is a cozy fantasy tale of found family, living with PTSD, and finding light in the darkest places.
In a cozy cottage surrounded by blooming gardens and the warmth of a welcoming community, she begins to heal—brewing remedies, growing friendships, and finding an unexpected connection with Orsian, a man whose scars run as deep as her own.
But peace is fragile.
A shadow from her past emerges, and dark magic seeps into the marshlands. As the waters foul and the Folk fall ill, Tansy must confront the nightmares she thought she’d escaped and protect the family and home she never thought she’d find.
Filled with heartwarming moments, quiet resilience, and the healing power of second chances, Tansy’s Tinctures is a cozy fantasy tale of found family, living with PTSD, and finding light in the darkest places.
255 pages, Kindle Edition
Published February 9, 2025
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 143 reviews
February 1, 2026
Tansy’s Tinctures has a really charming premise, with a magical town and a focus on personal growth. The concept is cozy and appealing, and the nonhuman characters in particular were fun and memorable.
That said, the book just didn’t fully work for me. The human characters felt quite flat, and everyone seemed to trust each other very quickly in ways that didn’t always feel believable. The romance also felt rushed and underdeveloped, so I never really got invested in the relationship. On top of that, there are some editing issues and moments that don’t quite make sense in context, and the dialogue often reads a bit stiff and unnatural, which took me out of the story.
There’s a lot of potential in the world and concept, and I think readers who are more forgiving about editing and who mainly want a light, cozy magical romantasy read may still enjoy it. For me personally, it felt more like an early draft than a fully polished book.
That said, the book just didn’t fully work for me. The human characters felt quite flat, and everyone seemed to trust each other very quickly in ways that didn’t always feel believable. The romance also felt rushed and underdeveloped, so I never really got invested in the relationship. On top of that, there are some editing issues and moments that don’t quite make sense in context, and the dialogue often reads a bit stiff and unnatural, which took me out of the story.
There’s a lot of potential in the world and concept, and I think readers who are more forgiving about editing and who mainly want a light, cozy magical romantasy read may still enjoy it. For me personally, it felt more like an early draft than a fully polished book.
April 22, 2026
DNF at 22%. Too many errors to be an enjoyable read. A good editor could really turn this book into something! But as it stood, this books needs a LOT of work. A few things that jump out:
"It was right in the nightstand where Og said it would be." But he doesn't introduce himself by name until the next page.
"It was a small opening that looked covered in silk. It was easy to miss. 'How did I miss this?' She asked herself." - uhhh...you JUST said why.
"She sat down at her usual table". It was day 2. She'd been there once.
The day after meeting her, the innkeeper tells Tansy she's the ONLY one who decorate the in well enough for a wedding. Convenient timing.
"It looked like half owl, half cat, half griffon" - It's a griffon kitten. If you know what a griffon is, I think it would be obvious that its a smaller version of that.
I don't want to just rag on this book. It has the cozy cottage core vibes I LOVE in a book. The prose is beautifully descriptive. But there are too many inconsistencies and errors to make this an enjoyable read.
I hope an editor can do it some justice (or send me a copy and I'll take my red pen to it!) And it can be re-released under a publisher that sees it's potential, like Bramble or Tor because I'd love read the story I know is in there amid all the errors. It has so much potential.
"It was right in the nightstand where Og said it would be." But he doesn't introduce himself by name until the next page.
"It was a small opening that looked covered in silk. It was easy to miss. 'How did I miss this?' She asked herself." - uhhh...you JUST said why.
"She sat down at her usual table". It was day 2. She'd been there once.
The day after meeting her, the innkeeper tells Tansy she's the ONLY one who decorate the in well enough for a wedding. Convenient timing.
"It looked like half owl, half cat, half griffon" - It's a griffon kitten. If you know what a griffon is, I think it would be obvious that its a smaller version of that.
I don't want to just rag on this book. It has the cozy cottage core vibes I LOVE in a book. The prose is beautifully descriptive. But there are too many inconsistencies and errors to make this an enjoyable read.
I hope an editor can do it some justice (or send me a copy and I'll take my red pen to it!) And it can be re-released under a publisher that sees it's potential, like Bramble or Tor because I'd love read the story I know is in there amid all the errors. It has so much potential.
May 23, 2026
I read a lot of cozy stories. The cover looked lovely, the setting nice, the reviews were good - and then I began to read. It was so.. over the top and at the same time full of artificial and wooden dialogues, plus logically mistakes and an little things that felt off, that I couldn't bring myself to read it until the end. Really - I'm bemoaning the lifetime I lost while reading this. It has a really heavy feeling of AI Slop. When I digged a little bit I read that the author uses AI for character research. Yeah. Sorry - just not my kind of book.
September 28, 2025
The cover is beautiful but is this self-published? Because this needs an editor to really make it shine.
February 13, 2025
I received this as an ARC and I was so honored! On the surface, this is a cozy story about a witch who finds her place in the world and the family she creates along the way. But when you look a little deeper, you find a truly touching story of healing, learning to trust oneself and others, friendship, and love.
I adored this story! As someone who suffers from PTSD, Tansy’s healing journey truly touched me and felt realistic. If you are looking for a new cozy fantasy with a mix of Kiki’s Delivery Service (a witch finding her way in the world) and Howl’s Moving Castle (magical house and a fire entity) vibes, I highly recommend!
I adored this story! As someone who suffers from PTSD, Tansy’s healing journey truly touched me and felt realistic. If you are looking for a new cozy fantasy with a mix of Kiki’s Delivery Service (a witch finding her way in the world) and Howl’s Moving Castle (magical house and a fire entity) vibes, I highly recommend!
June 3, 2026
I was thoroughly entertained with this book. A herbalist escapes the army she is with, they are forcing her to do things she is she is morally against. She goes through a mountain pass and finds a town that is a paradise. She is befriended by townspeople and woodland folk alike. The book is a journey, her journey into becoming a moral person.
March 9, 2025
The Fantasy You'll Wish Was Your Reality
"For those who seek to soothe a pain
They cannot name,.....
.. Healing unfolds in many ways."
This heartwarming novel is undoubtedly one of the best! Every artful word in Tansy's Tinctures gently applies a healing balm to the reader’s wounds and scars. Even for those not in need of healing, this jewel-toned narrative resounds like an utterly lyrical and peaceful melody, touching the tender chords of both heart and mind. The perfect balance of cozy charm and thrilling action, the dreamy romance, and the seamlessly crafted, bewitching world together create an unforgettable reading journey. As if that weren’t enough, the exquisite cast of characters—each with their own vivid, enchanting backstories, like sparkling, colorful stars—orbit around Tansy and Orsian, the endearing protagonists, and entice the reader into a whimsical, healing dance that leads to a harmonious, soul-stirring happy ending. I know I will return to this magical tale countless times.
R.S.S. Rodrigues’ spellbinding pen has soothed my heart, ignited my imagination, and transformed me into one of her most passionate admirers. What are you waiting for? Dive into her shimmering world now!
"For those who seek to soothe a pain
They cannot name,.....
.. Healing unfolds in many ways."
This heartwarming novel is undoubtedly one of the best! Every artful word in Tansy's Tinctures gently applies a healing balm to the reader’s wounds and scars. Even for those not in need of healing, this jewel-toned narrative resounds like an utterly lyrical and peaceful melody, touching the tender chords of both heart and mind. The perfect balance of cozy charm and thrilling action, the dreamy romance, and the seamlessly crafted, bewitching world together create an unforgettable reading journey. As if that weren’t enough, the exquisite cast of characters—each with their own vivid, enchanting backstories, like sparkling, colorful stars—orbit around Tansy and Orsian, the endearing protagonists, and entice the reader into a whimsical, healing dance that leads to a harmonious, soul-stirring happy ending. I know I will return to this magical tale countless times.
R.S.S. Rodrigues’ spellbinding pen has soothed my heart, ignited my imagination, and transformed me into one of her most passionate admirers. What are you waiting for? Dive into her shimmering world now!
August 20, 2025
Overall: a witch escapes a brutal war to set up a house in the woods with lots of Folk around, and falls in love with a bear shifter.
Pros: some of the Folk characters were mildly interesting
Cons: the spelling and grammatical issues, the fact that the townsfolk knew her for TWO DAYS and were saying how she belonged and was one of them and that she was amazing etc etc… so unbelievable. And the love interest showed up on basically page 2 and was super duper obvious and there was no tension, plus the ‘grand struggle’ with the necromancer had no tension or stakes either. The pacing was off, and the conversations between characters was downright unbelievable (every conversation ending with, I have to go now, bye!).
Pros: some of the Folk characters were mildly interesting
Cons: the spelling and grammatical issues, the fact that the townsfolk knew her for TWO DAYS and were saying how she belonged and was one of them and that she was amazing etc etc… so unbelievable. And the love interest showed up on basically page 2 and was super duper obvious and there was no tension, plus the ‘grand struggle’ with the necromancer had no tension or stakes either. The pacing was off, and the conversations between characters was downright unbelievable (every conversation ending with, I have to go now, bye!).
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 21, 2025
Thanks to my bookclub pick for this month, this was my first experience with the cottagecore genre — and I have to say, I really enjoyed it!
This was such a cute, cozy read. I loved the storyline where paranormal beings like witches, shifters, and the Folk play an important role. The side characters were also super enjoyable to read about, and it was fun getting to know their little quirks.
What didn’t fully work for me was the main conflict — it felt a bit darker than I expected for a cozy fantasy vibe. And the biggest downside for me personally: the third-person point of view. I usually prefer first-person, so it made it a bit harder to really connect.
Overall, a charming and magical read with just a few personal misses!
This was such a cute, cozy read. I loved the storyline where paranormal beings like witches, shifters, and the Folk play an important role. The side characters were also super enjoyable to read about, and it was fun getting to know their little quirks.
What didn’t fully work for me was the main conflict — it felt a bit darker than I expected for a cozy fantasy vibe. And the biggest downside for me personally: the third-person point of view. I usually prefer first-person, so it made it a bit harder to really connect.
Overall, a charming and magical read with just a few personal misses!
July 10, 2026
3.5 ⭐️ I love the way this book is different from a lot of cozy fantasy books but some parts seemed to drag on longer than needed. I also normally love the beautiful descriptions of the magical surroundings but almost half of this book was just talking about how beautiful the hollow and marshlands were. Also the dialogue and banter felt very unnatural most of the time and definitely not how normal people would speak at all. The coziness is definitely here though and that’s what I went into this wanting.
May 31, 2026
Cozy Witchcore with Depth
Love this first book in the series! I had no idea this would turn into a five star read as it was very much a cover selection. I needed something cozy and sweet as an in between and now I'll be reading the rest of these. Orsian and Tansy, kindred spirits with torturous pasts; Bryony the innkeeper and single mom to a spirited young daughter, Ivy; all the fenfolk, particularly Adalbert and Lydia - sprinkles of warmth and humor, nascent love and support. If you need a feel good, quick read with good writing and depth then definitely pick this up. It's not perfect but really, who or what is? But the atmosphere and feels are all there to refill your reading cup.
Love this first book in the series! I had no idea this would turn into a five star read as it was very much a cover selection. I needed something cozy and sweet as an in between and now I'll be reading the rest of these. Orsian and Tansy, kindred spirits with torturous pasts; Bryony the innkeeper and single mom to a spirited young daughter, Ivy; all the fenfolk, particularly Adalbert and Lydia - sprinkles of warmth and humor, nascent love and support. If you need a feel good, quick read with good writing and depth then definitely pick this up. It's not perfect but really, who or what is? But the atmosphere and feels are all there to refill your reading cup.
February 5, 2025
Arc reviewer
This books is really charming, it's filled with magic, friendship, love and truly is captivating. I love the main character, I love the side characters and I love the folk people. I wish it was longer but im smiling writing this review, content and I do love a book with a happy ending. Few little spelling/grammar mistakes but doesn't take the charm away from the book at all. I need me a handsome man like him, I need me a tuft and I love the bees.
Please please please, give this book a chance.
This books is really charming, it's filled with magic, friendship, love and truly is captivating. I love the main character, I love the side characters and I love the folk people. I wish it was longer but im smiling writing this review, content and I do love a book with a happy ending. Few little spelling/grammar mistakes but doesn't take the charm away from the book at all. I need me a handsome man like him, I need me a tuft and I love the bees.
Please please please, give this book a chance.
March 1, 2025
I loved this story!!!!!!!!!
February 17, 2026
Heartwarming cozy tale with magic and splash of danger
When Tansy escapes a cruel, magic fueled war, she wants to be at peace. Unsure of what she’ll find, she ends up finding more than she thought possible. Tandy and Orsian have both suffered war trauma yet optimistically push on with their lives, a positive theme. The characters are well written and fun, and the plot kept me reading. They had to face an evil foe with an expected outcome, yet being expected didn’t matter because it wasn’t the biggest part of the story. I liked how the magic embraced Tansy and would like to have some of that myself!
When Tansy escapes a cruel, magic fueled war, she wants to be at peace. Unsure of what she’ll find, she ends up finding more than she thought possible. Tandy and Orsian have both suffered war trauma yet optimistically push on with their lives, a positive theme. The characters are well written and fun, and the plot kept me reading. They had to face an evil foe with an expected outcome, yet being expected didn’t matter because it wasn’t the biggest part of the story. I liked how the magic embraced Tansy and would like to have some of that myself!
Did Not Finish
August 12, 2026Too slow and quiet, I couldn't get into it.
February 20, 2026
Wow!
This was so good!
It was both like a warm hug, and so cozy. But it still had adventure.
I’m speechless!
Highly recommend this one for everyone ❤️
This was so good!
It was both like a warm hug, and so cozy. But it still had adventure.
I’m speechless!
Highly recommend this one for everyone ❤️
May 24, 2026
3.5 stars rounded
August 5, 2026
This was a cute and cozy read.
August 5, 2025
The story is cute
It has potential. Tansy and Orsian and adorbs. The story is cute and the side characters steal your heart. Tuft 🥰. My big issue is the writing and editing. For such a small book the mistakes seem sloppy. And for the love of Gawd, why so many exclamation points ‼️ I counted like 5-6 on one page. My goodness. By the end I was rolling my eyes every time I saw one. Had those mistakes not existed I would have loved a longer book so I could love the characters even more 😍
It has potential. Tansy and Orsian and adorbs. The story is cute and the side characters steal your heart. Tuft 🥰. My big issue is the writing and editing. For such a small book the mistakes seem sloppy. And for the love of Gawd, why so many exclamation points ‼️ I counted like 5-6 on one page. My goodness. By the end I was rolling my eyes every time I saw one. Had those mistakes not existed I would have loved a longer book so I could love the characters even more 😍
September 26, 2025
This was cute and cosy but a little two slow for me. 2.5 rounded down.
May 11, 2026
I enjoyed this story. The MMC and FMC have been through great loss and deal with PTSD yet reach out for a better life. Found family and recognizing and appreciating diversity makes this a wonderful tale. I will definitely continue the series.
May 1, 2026
Dnf.
If you're into instalove and rushed plots, this one might be for you
If you're into instalove and rushed plots, this one might be for you
May 1, 2026
DFN. I really wanted to like this. The premise is lovely, but it was just too rife with errors to finish. The whole book is in DIRE need of an editor. Lots of repetition, stilted conversations, and continuity issues. A good edit would really make this the cozy book I was hoping for.
March 29, 2025
I was thrilled to receive an ARC for this cozy novel and what a pleasure it was to read!
This gives so many Studio Ghibli vibes, especially Howl's Moving Castle. Much like a Ghibli movie, there are moments in this story where the lush, gentle focus on nature put me into so much peace, which as someone who, much like the main character, is recovering from PTSD, was magical. I felt like I was actually there in those magical places.
The opening chapter pulled me in immediately and kept me interested. The story is more character driven than action and the characters are very lovable, particularly the main characters little sidekicks.
This gives so many Studio Ghibli vibes, especially Howl's Moving Castle. Much like a Ghibli movie, there are moments in this story where the lush, gentle focus on nature put me into so much peace, which as someone who, much like the main character, is recovering from PTSD, was magical. I felt like I was actually there in those magical places.
The opening chapter pulled me in immediately and kept me interested. The story is more character driven than action and the characters are very lovable, particularly the main characters little sidekicks.
August 14, 2025
Not for me
I loved the cover of this book. The art is beautiful.
I very much enjoyed the non-human characters; the Folk, dryads, and mythological creatures. The descriptions of plants and nature areas were lovely.
I did not care for the humans, who became annoying as the story progressed. Another pass with an editor could have helped the writing a lot. There was a lot of repetition and some word choices that took me out of the story.
The last 2 chapters weren't bad. There's potential for a 4-5 star story here, but for me this wasn't it.
I loved the cover of this book. The art is beautiful.
I very much enjoyed the non-human characters; the Folk, dryads, and mythological creatures. The descriptions of plants and nature areas were lovely.
I did not care for the humans, who became annoying as the story progressed. Another pass with an editor could have helped the writing a lot. There was a lot of repetition and some word choices that took me out of the story.
The last 2 chapters weren't bad. There's potential for a 4-5 star story here, but for me this wasn't it.
October 14, 2026
DNF at 33%.
I read a lot of cosy fantasy and I was sure I'd love this based on the comparison to the Spellshop. Newsflash, I didn't.
This story actually reminded me a lot of that baking show, Nailed It. All of the ingredients are technically there in the finished product but something has gone really wrong in the execution and a healthy heaping of pretty icing on the top doesn't quite manage to hide the cracks in the foundations.
I really do think this story has potential but there were SO MANY inconsistencies, typos and grammatical errors. And that's not even covering the issues with how stilted and unnatural the writing felt at times. It really felt like I was reading a draft rather than a finished project and it pulled me out of the story so many times, I just gave up. I think I spent 95% of my actual reading time wishing I could read it on my KLC instead of my kindle just so I could take a red pen to it.
My other major issue was how insta everything was. There's nothing necessarily wrong with instalove in a cosy fantasy but it's a bit boring for everything to be like that. A combination of instant friendship, trust AND love was just a bit too sickeningly sweet for me. Like really? Nobody had any problems with her? Didn't feel like she was replacing Hazel? Didn't feel any bit distrustful because she was a witch? Or have any reservations about a new person in their midst at all??
Within 2 days she was "one of them" and "the best person for the job". How do you know that? You don't actually know each other?! I'm also not quite sure how a herbalist who brews potions, poisons and teas instantly translates into being a top notch wedding florist. Without much trial and error seemingly. Same goes for the MMC. "You're so much more than you think" .....you've known her less than 24 hours. You can't possibly know that. It just all felt a bit...shallow?
Like, I get that it's a "cosy" fantasy but that doesn't mean that the only conflict has to be external. A little internal conflict can add a lot of depth to a story and be a bit more believable. Think Sophie cutting up Howl's suits or dying his hair (accidentally I know but still, conflict).
I do think there were some redeeming qualities, as some of the Folk I was introduced to before DNF'ing seemed really interesting and Tuft just sounds adorable (although I'm not sure how a GRIFFON kitten could look half griffon, half owlcrate, half cat? Surely he just looks like a....griffon?). Also, Og is giving Calcifer from Howl's moving castle vibes but for me, it fell a bit flat. Like a temu version of Calcifer rather than having his own personality and presence on the page.
FINAL VERDICT: I can definitely see what the author was trying to do and with a bit of work, I think it could be an excellent story. But seriously, it is in DIRE need of an editor.
I read a lot of cosy fantasy and I was sure I'd love this based on the comparison to the Spellshop. Newsflash, I didn't.
This story actually reminded me a lot of that baking show, Nailed It. All of the ingredients are technically there in the finished product but something has gone really wrong in the execution and a healthy heaping of pretty icing on the top doesn't quite manage to hide the cracks in the foundations.
I really do think this story has potential but there were SO MANY inconsistencies, typos and grammatical errors. And that's not even covering the issues with how stilted and unnatural the writing felt at times. It really felt like I was reading a draft rather than a finished project and it pulled me out of the story so many times, I just gave up. I think I spent 95% of my actual reading time wishing I could read it on my KLC instead of my kindle just so I could take a red pen to it.
My other major issue was how insta everything was. There's nothing necessarily wrong with instalove in a cosy fantasy but it's a bit boring for everything to be like that. A combination of instant friendship, trust AND love was just a bit too sickeningly sweet for me. Like really? Nobody had any problems with her? Didn't feel like she was replacing Hazel? Didn't feel any bit distrustful because she was a witch? Or have any reservations about a new person in their midst at all??
Within 2 days she was "one of them" and "the best person for the job". How do you know that? You don't actually know each other?! I'm also not quite sure how a herbalist who brews potions, poisons and teas instantly translates into being a top notch wedding florist. Without much trial and error seemingly. Same goes for the MMC. "You're so much more than you think" .....you've known her less than 24 hours. You can't possibly know that. It just all felt a bit...shallow?
Like, I get that it's a "cosy" fantasy but that doesn't mean that the only conflict has to be external. A little internal conflict can add a lot of depth to a story and be a bit more believable. Think Sophie cutting up Howl's suits or dying his hair (accidentally I know but still, conflict).
I do think there were some redeeming qualities, as some of the Folk I was introduced to before DNF'ing seemed really interesting and Tuft just sounds adorable (although I'm not sure how a GRIFFON kitten could look half griffon, half owlcrate, half cat? Surely he just looks like a....griffon?). Also, Og is giving Calcifer from Howl's moving castle vibes but for me, it fell a bit flat. Like a temu version of Calcifer rather than having his own personality and presence on the page.
FINAL VERDICT: I can definitely see what the author was trying to do and with a bit of work, I think it could be an excellent story. But seriously, it is in DIRE need of an editor.
October 12, 2026
not exactly cozy, it’s ok
First off I read this solely because it compared itself to The Spellshop. I haven’t read the others it compares to but I can definitely say that is it NOTHING like The Spellshop. That was an excellent book. This one not so much.
It has potential but it reads more like a first attempt or draft. The story is cute and with a little work it could be good. At least the first half. The second half starts going downhill. The conversations get a little better but there are so many errors and inconsistencies. Typos and things that just don’t fit with what was described in the beginning.
At the start everything seems unnaturally rushed. Instant friends, instant trust, instant love, nothing is built. It’s all shallow and superficial. With no foundation at all.
For example this conversation “Bryony gave her a knowing stare. “Of course I do. You’re good with plants, Tansy. You’re the best for the job. And I want it to be magical, something to remember.”” This is literally the second time they meet. Tandy arrives, buys the cottage, eats breakfast at home, and goes to the tavern to eat breakfast again. And Bryony says this about a job offer. Exactly how do you know this when you’ve just met?
And this, I’m going to call it the instalove instead of friend but very similar: “Tansy, hearing you say that hurts. You’re so much more than you think” THEY HAVE JUST MET. This is not how people who have JUST met talk to each other. How does he know what she thinks? How does he know she’s more?
And all the conversations are awkward. And I don’t just mean the character is awkward but the writing. It’s stilted, disjointed, and just awkward. Also there’s WAY too much name usage. How often do you use someone’s name when talking to them? Maybe once or twice a conversation? Yeah not these people. They name drop every other sentence. And if you wondered, yes, I checked. Tandy’s name is used about 750 times in a 240 page book.
In all will I continue the series? Probably not. I may check out the next but if the writing hasn’t improved I won’t push thru to finish like I did this one. The second half of this one actually ended up being worse than the first was.
First off I read this solely because it compared itself to The Spellshop. I haven’t read the others it compares to but I can definitely say that is it NOTHING like The Spellshop. That was an excellent book. This one not so much.
It has potential but it reads more like a first attempt or draft. The story is cute and with a little work it could be good. At least the first half. The second half starts going downhill. The conversations get a little better but there are so many errors and inconsistencies. Typos and things that just don’t fit with what was described in the beginning.
At the start everything seems unnaturally rushed. Instant friends, instant trust, instant love, nothing is built. It’s all shallow and superficial. With no foundation at all.
For example this conversation “Bryony gave her a knowing stare. “Of course I do. You’re good with plants, Tansy. You’re the best for the job. And I want it to be magical, something to remember.”” This is literally the second time they meet. Tandy arrives, buys the cottage, eats breakfast at home, and goes to the tavern to eat breakfast again. And Bryony says this about a job offer. Exactly how do you know this when you’ve just met?
And this, I’m going to call it the instalove instead of friend but very similar: “Tansy, hearing you say that hurts. You’re so much more than you think” THEY HAVE JUST MET. This is not how people who have JUST met talk to each other. How does he know what she thinks? How does he know she’s more?
And all the conversations are awkward. And I don’t just mean the character is awkward but the writing. It’s stilted, disjointed, and just awkward. Also there’s WAY too much name usage. How often do you use someone’s name when talking to them? Maybe once or twice a conversation? Yeah not these people. They name drop every other sentence. And if you wondered, yes, I checked. Tandy’s name is used about 750 times in a 240 page book.
In all will I continue the series? Probably not. I may check out the next but if the writing hasn’t improved I won’t push thru to finish like I did this one. The second half of this one actually ended up being worse than the first was.
October 18, 2025
My reviews are my own. If you liked this book, I’m glad you enjoyed it. If not, I respect your opinion. This is merely my opinion, so let's keep it courteous. My review is honest and voluntary.
I decided to read it because of the beautiful cover and the title. Sadly, that and the magical maneagery of creatures were the only good things about the book.
I'm all for stories about stories for new beginnings. That said, I do not enjoy it when a character needs a romantic interest to achieve a new beginning. I believe that a new beginning is something personal, and to achieve it, that person needs to be in a peaceful mental state with themselves first, then the rest of the world. Similar to loving yourself first, then others. Also, she acts like a virgin teen who has never seen a male...which makes no sense since she was part of the "army", so I bet she had tons of opportunities to see half-naked males in the trenches. She is not a kid, but reads like one.
All the humans are bland and incredibly trusting. You just met someone, and everyone acts like they have been friends since childhood. I get the town is "magical," but the whole idea of trusting someone so fat is a bit ridiculous.
The storyline about the wedding and her knowledge of herbs makes no sense...herbs and flowers are not the same. Yes, some flowers can be used as herbs and vice versa, but they are not the same. It is like asking a pharmacist to be a wedding decorator because they know mint is a great herb. Then she spent more time on the wedding planning than actually doing what she decided to be her new beginning.......sigh.
It needed a better editor; it is incredibly repetitive. Making it unnecessarily long. I mean, I GET IT, She has PTSD because of war, but I did not need to be reminded of it every time she did anything!
This story was definitely not for me. The whole story is full of inconsistencies and lame, corny lines.
On to my next adventure, Happy Readings!!!
I decided to read it because of the beautiful cover and the title. Sadly, that and the magical maneagery of creatures were the only good things about the book.
I'm all for stories about stories for new beginnings. That said, I do not enjoy it when a character needs a romantic interest to achieve a new beginning. I believe that a new beginning is something personal, and to achieve it, that person needs to be in a peaceful mental state with themselves first, then the rest of the world. Similar to loving yourself first, then others. Also, she acts like a virgin teen who has never seen a male...which makes no sense since she was part of the "army", so I bet she had tons of opportunities to see half-naked males in the trenches. She is not a kid, but reads like one.
All the humans are bland and incredibly trusting. You just met someone, and everyone acts like they have been friends since childhood. I get the town is "magical," but the whole idea of trusting someone so fat is a bit ridiculous.
The storyline about the wedding and her knowledge of herbs makes no sense...herbs and flowers are not the same. Yes, some flowers can be used as herbs and vice versa, but they are not the same. It is like asking a pharmacist to be a wedding decorator because they know mint is a great herb. Then she spent more time on the wedding planning than actually doing what she decided to be her new beginning.......sigh.
It needed a better editor; it is incredibly repetitive. Making it unnecessarily long. I mean, I GET IT, She has PTSD because of war, but I did not need to be reminded of it every time she did anything!
This story was definitely not for me. The whole story is full of inconsistencies and lame, corny lines.
On to my next adventure, Happy Readings!!!
April 3, 2026
Bear shifter? Check. Magical salamander? Check. Half-owl-half-cat-half-griffon? Check. A Herbalist Witch? I’m never leaving this enchanting new world!
I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this story… the magic, the quirky creatures like Og the flamewhisker salamander and Tuft, and the heartwarming friendships kept me smiling!
🌙 “You see a cat; one day, the cat lets itself in, and then, the next thing you know, you own a cat. Or the cat owns you, depending on the perspective.”
Amid magic and whimsy, this story had some darkness… showing how healing and growth from past wounds, whether heartbreak, loss, or trauma from war, can lead to trust, love, and a sense of belonging.
🌙 "For those who seek to soothe a pain they cannot name... Healing unfolds in many ways."
The romance is sweet and satisfying, and the worldbuilding is so vivid that I could easily imagine myself wandering through it. The side characters are charming, each adding their own spark to the story, making it feel like a living, breathing community.
Overall, it’s a cozy, magical read that left me smiling and hopeful. I can’t wait to return to this whimsical world again.
💫 Tansy’s Tinctures (Tales of Silverfern Hollow, 1) by R.S.S Rodrigues
Cozy Romantasy | Cottagecore | Found Family | Trauma x Healing | 255 pp | ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (4/5)
💫 Favorite Quote:
“Some things cross our life, bright and beautiful like a shooting star, and they’re gone just as fast. That’s why I want to make every moment count.”
I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this story… the magic, the quirky creatures like Og the flamewhisker salamander and Tuft, and the heartwarming friendships kept me smiling!
🌙 “You see a cat; one day, the cat lets itself in, and then, the next thing you know, you own a cat. Or the cat owns you, depending on the perspective.”
Amid magic and whimsy, this story had some darkness… showing how healing and growth from past wounds, whether heartbreak, loss, or trauma from war, can lead to trust, love, and a sense of belonging.
🌙 "For those who seek to soothe a pain they cannot name... Healing unfolds in many ways."
The romance is sweet and satisfying, and the worldbuilding is so vivid that I could easily imagine myself wandering through it. The side characters are charming, each adding their own spark to the story, making it feel like a living, breathing community.
Overall, it’s a cozy, magical read that left me smiling and hopeful. I can’t wait to return to this whimsical world again.
💫 Tansy’s Tinctures (Tales of Silverfern Hollow, 1) by R.S.S Rodrigues
Cozy Romantasy | Cottagecore | Found Family | Trauma x Healing | 255 pp | ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (4/5)
💫 Favorite Quote:
“Some things cross our life, bright and beautiful like a shooting star, and they’re gone just as fast. That’s why I want to make every moment count.”
May 11, 2026
I loved this book so much, for me this was the perfect cozy fantasy and it gave me absolutely everything I’d want from one and so much more. I absolutely loved the characters, each had so much depth to them and felt so alive on the page. Tansy and Orsian as the main characters were amazing and I absolutely loved their interactions. I felt like I knew them both so well and thought their back stories added so many layers to both them and the story itself. They’re both such loyal, kind, warm-hearted people that you root for them from the minute you meet them. The side characters also had so much personality, I loved Bryony, Ivy, Nettle, Marigold and Humphry whose friendship with Orsian was hilarious as well as the folk! Their interactions with Lydia and Adalbert were so fun! I’ve got to give a special mention to Tuft and Og who I absolutely loved, they’re adorable!! The plot itself is super interesting and definitely kept me reading and I loved how much the story was about healing and self acceptance as it was a really beautiful, touching storyline and also very relatable. The setting was so easy to visualise and felt so comforting, I definitely want to move to Silverfern Hollow! This was such a comfort read for me and I know I’ll come back to read it again and again when I want pure cozy escapism full of found family and whimsical magic! I thoroughly enjoyed it from start to finish and would recommend it to anyone!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 143 reviews