Vendetta

Prefect Dreyfus Emergency #3

by Alastair Reynolds

Il prefetto Ingvar Tench di Panoplia, nel sistema di Yellowston, è una degli agenti più esperti e affidabili. Eppure resta uccisa in una missione apparentemente avventata e non autorizzata. Mentre i suoi colleghi raccolgono le prove e cercano piste da seguire per scoprire come sia potuto succedere, il prefetto Tom Dreyfus deve fare i conti con la propria coscienza. Quattro anni prima, quando l'indagine legata a uno dei suoi avversari più pericolosi era diventata troppo personale, Dreyfus aveva incaricato Tench di continuare al posto suo. Ma in questo modo l'ha anche messa sulla linea di tiro di un nemico che lui sperava ormai sopito?

Genres: Science Fiction, Fiction, Space Opera, Mystery, Audiobook, Crime, Speculative Fiction

517 pages, Kindle Edition

First published January 16, 2024

About the author

I'm Al, I used to be a space scientist, and now I'm a writer, although for a time the two careers ran in parallel. I started off publishing short stories in the British SF magazine Interzone in the early 90s, then eventually branched into novels. I write about a novel a year and try to write a few short stories as well. Some of my books and stories are set in a consistent future named after Revelation Space, the first novel, but I've done a lot of other things as well and I like to keep things fresh between books.

I was born in Wales, but raised in Cornwall, and then spent time in the north of England and Scotland. I moved to the Netherlands to continue my science career and stayed there for a very long time, before eventually returning to Wales.

In my spare time I am a very keen runner, and I also enjoying hill-walking, birdwatching, horse-riding, guitar and model-making. I also dabble with paints now and then. I met my wife in the Netherlands through a mutual interest in climbing and we married back in Wales. We live surrounded by hills, woods and wildlife, and not too much excitement.

Reviews

[Jamie · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is the best, most thrilling, and seemingly final book in the Prefect Dreyfus Emergency series. Reynolds achieves a masterful blend of mystery/police procedural, hard sci-fi, intrigue and action, all within the fascinating far future world of a distributed and loosely federated human civilization often barely recognizable as such due to radical genetic and/or cybernetic engineering. All that is nothing new in the series, yet Machine Vendetta ratchets the scope and scale of events up dramatically as Dreyfus and his colleagues at Panoply confront a devious, nearly omniscient AI that's gone rogue.

Reynold's efforts to portray meaningful depth in the characters also really shines. It's something he's been knocked for, especially in his early novels, but he's clearly grown to become an author fully capable of creating authentic characters with genuine emotional resonance.

I can't recommend this more highly, and though the story line here is essentially a new one there is enough essential background from the previous novels to make it worthwhile for new readers to start at the beginning of the series.

[Claudia · Rating 5 out of 5]

I would be beyond thrilled to see a TV series or a movie based on one of these books or, even more thrilled, on all of them: the Glitter Band with its habitats and unique inhabitants, the Panoply, the lighthuggers and their Ultras, the Clockmaker and its scarab, the whiphounds - what a visual feast would be! <3

But until then, I raise my hopes that this will not be the last book in this series; there is still a lot to be told about Aurora, and Dreyfuss and his wife's journey to the Pattern Jugglers.

Each of the three books has a standalone plot, but the general setting and characters have continuity, therefore it is better to read all of them in order - they are a marvel of science-fiction mystery subgenre.

And this third part has all I had expected, and more, even a "Noooooooooo!" moment, which I did not expect. I miss you already, Sparver

Loved it to the moon and back.

[Rachel (TheShadesofOrange) · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.0 Stars
Video Review: https://youtu.be/9q64BSnOQBg

This is the third book in a sci fi thriller series. As someone who enjoys mysteries I was most intrigued by those aspects of the plots.

This author's strength is in his ability to write epic worlds. So I always feel that his talent is lost on this intimate mystery series. Instead the series focuses more on the characters who are not as fleshed out and well rounded as I would like. The story itself is good, but leans into a lot of familiar plot twists and common tropes.

I would primarily recommend this story to readers who love the sci fi mystery subgenre.

Disclaimer I received a copy of this book from the publisher.

[Bee · Rating 3 out of 5]

Well I'm done. It was fine.

I suspect Reynolds might be getting old. This book left me a little cold, there was nothing new, nothing really exciting. It was just more of the same Dreyfus being stoic and getting stuff done.

[Vadim · Rating 3 out of 5]

For some reason I adore the Revelation Space universe, although the ratings I've given most of the books are usually average or below average, including the past adventures of Prefect Dreyfus. Perhaps the main thing Reynolds has managed to do in a quarter-century is to show a layered, thought-out authentic world building. Half of this charm is chopped by the translation, or rather, the inability or unwillingness to properly translate into Russian most of the terms that Reynolds scattered throughout the books. There's something appealing about the setting itself, bleak and cold, a tiny corner of a vast incomprehensible universe, separated by decades of sublight voyages with all the relativistic charms. Set on gothic lighthuggers with its Ultra crews often deprived of human beings' appearance. With a hundred interesting tidbits here and there — but with bloated prose whose volume begs for an editor; with often underdeveloped characters, even if there are a few books to develop them properly; with twists and turns that the author himself has worn out. And Machine Vendetta has all of these things, both charming and bad, and bleakly generic.

Almost a third of an already lengthy book to finally kick things off — not every author can afford that, nor should they. Even though I only read The Prefect and Elysium Fire a couple of years ago, I even had to refresh my memories with the plot summary of the first book. And there was so much going on in its synopsis alone that after a third of Vendetta, it felt like the plot was purely nominal this time round. Reynolds carefully reminded of all the characters, especially those he'd completely forgotten about in Elysium Fire, and began to slowly unwind the familiar structure: something was wrong again in some orbital, the Prefects were again bumping into inhospitable citizens of the Glitter Band, the Hyperpigs were again being mistreated, and someone in the Panoply was lying again.

At some point, you have to wonder if this is really the finale of the trilogy. Or does Emergencies counts as trilogy at all. Honestly, the first half of the book just doesn't carry the stakes and intensity required, just another novel in the Revelation Space universe. You can easily imagine that there will be more books with those characters, and we are in the middle of the road. Reynolds even allows himself a charming scene with the Ultra, which, even though it feels like it was written specifically for me, in such a slow plot development, looks like a filler. It wasn't, though, but it sure felt as one at the time. Sooner or later, things do come to a showdown with the titular Machines, which is underwhelming to say the least. And that goes for both Aurora and the Clockmaker. Reynolds delivers a technical victory against the main plot, but it doesn't evoke much of an excitement.

Near the end of Vendetta, I was rather thinking about the unrealized potential of the trilogy, with a solid set-up and an established setting. That there were no real dilemmas between legal enforcement and the authority of the Panoply, a rather unique system, in fact. The complex moral conflicts turned out to be one-sided; the protagonists represented by Dreyfus, Talia, Spraver, and Omanier all as one are upstanding and just; and attempts to bring gray ambiguity to some of them have failed. The Glitter Band communities blended into a homogeneous mass, despite the fact that “the Panoply has a thousand people and there are 100 million of them”, although in some places Reynolds still provided fascinating bits. The very existence of Elysium Fire raises more questions now, because Vendetta could have been caught up right after The Prefect, and literally nothing would have changed.

But in the last few pages, something really touched me. Reynolds made a heartwarming farewell to the series and didn't neglect the trilogy's major characters. In other words, managed to draw a fine conclusion. Vendetta, which I already planned to give a lower grade, suddenly left the feeling of a decent book, perhaps not really deserved with all my aforementioned criticism. I realized that even with all the problems of narrative and characters, I will return to the world of Revelation Space without a second thought, if only Reynolds invites us there again.

[AndiReads · Rating 5 out of 5]

The third and perhaps final edition of the Prefect Dryfus Emergency Series.

The series takes place in the Glitter Band - Ten thousand city-states orbiting planet Yellowstone. The Panoply is a small but mighty police and peacekeeping organization of which Tom Dreyfus is a high ranking officer.

In the third in the series Dreyfus has multiple emergencies on his hands including neural implants melting, attacks and two potentially war starting events involving his own colleagues. What is happening and why? Dreyfus works the scenes like a seasoned police officer and we do our best to keep up and play along!

Reynolds has the science fiction magic that allows him to create whole universes and even make a potentially ridiculous situation, such as a planet of babified adults seem real. The characters are all fully realized and it is great fun to catch up with some of the long standing themes, beings and storylines. How Alastair Reynolds creates not only a galaxy but a complex and multi prong plot that satisfies completely is beyond me! This is a fabulous book and highly recommended. I dare say you could read it as a stand alone it is so easily managed but the full experience is all three (Aurora Rising, Elysium Fire). #MachineVendetta #AlastairReynolds
#Orbit

[Hank · Rating 4 out of 5]

Just barely a 4. Hopefuly this is the wrap up for Prefect Dreyfus, the story line is a bit thread bare and the chess match at the end was a bit too complicated for me to absorb. As usual, lots of interesting far future tech and of course the idea that the ability to constantly vote on one thing or another being the central tenant keeping this particular civilization going is fascinating.

Will read another Reynolds unless it is another Dreyfus

[Dan Trefethen · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is the third, and probably last, of the Prefect Dreyfus stories that Reynolds has crafted in his Revelation Space universe but in a different time period. The Prefects are the cops of the Glitter Band, the ring of artificial environments orbiting a planet in the Epsilon Eridani solar system. But 'cop' is not the correct term – it's more like they are the public safety monitors, trying to deal with any issues with a light touch but willing to bring in the heavy support as needed. They are laregly resented by the citizens but seen as necessary.

For those who have followed this series it is not a spoiler to say that rogue AI machines are the bete noire of the series. I'm getting a little jaded on evil AI stories, but Reynolds has a different approach that is intriguing.

I confess that I did not find this episode as compelling as the others, partly because I could get the mystery pretty early, it's telegraphed pretty easily for anyone paying attention. Still, once things started popping a little over halfway through the book, I found myself racing through it.

Reynolds seems to want to make a point of the dedication to the police force (Panoply) by the prefects, and the lengths they will go to in order to maintain their integrity. I don't know if this is a counterpoint to some of the police abuse stories we've seen recently, but it's hard not to see it as such.

In any event, don't start here, start with the first book, originally titled 'The Prefect' then reissued as 'Aurora Rising'.

[Spad53 · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was a bit of a struggle to get through. I can’t explain why, a little too predictable perhaps. Or maybe I’ve simply read too much Reynolds. I’d recommend reading Chasm city, rather than this one, for various reasons, it’s much better for one, but it also gives a background to the Prefect Dreyfus series. The first books in this series are also better by the way.
I have to get one thing off my chest; one of the most important characters is called Ingvar. Fine, I know authors like to give people Nordic names, and what could be more Nordic than Ingvar, the founder of IKEA was called Ingvar. Except…it’s a man’s name, this Ingvar is a female Prefect, do some basic research Mr. Reynolds, the female form of Ingvar is Ingvor, that’s what you should have called her!
Finally I must credit Alastair Reynolds for being clairvoyant, here’s what one of the bad guys in the book said about elections. Didn’t a well-known American ex-president say something like this very recently?
“There’ll be no need for voting now, so I’ve lifted that burden from you. You had to make hard choices in the past because I wasn’t there to make them for you. That’s all over: you’ll live easier, more carefree lives without that pressure.”

“No more worrying about voting. No more worrying about the future. It’s all taken care of. And all you need do is . . . carry on as normal.”

3.5 raised to 4 because I liked the ending.

[Anna · Rating 4 out of 5]

Machine Vendetta is the third in the Prefect Dreyfus Emergency series. Like the other two, it is exciting and dramatic, starting slowly and escalating suddenly. I commend it for making Dreyfus and his colleagues such interesting space cops. What really elevates this series is its thoughtful engagement with the politics of law enforcement. Panopoly has a technically well-defined and specific remit, yet its work is no straightforward thing. In Elysium Fire Panopoly faced the perils of space brexit; in Machine Vendetta the main threat also has contemporary dimensions. Beware of mysteriously well-funded tech startups! They may unbalance a standoff between rival superpowers, causing huge collatoral damage.

I found the plot suitably compelling, with some shocking twists. For a hard sci-fi future with advanced life-preservation technologies, a surprising number of named characters died. I was very relieved that Thalia at least survived, despite being poisoned and shot. Working for Panoply is remarkably hazardous these days. Events are neatly orchestrated and the ending satisfying. It was obvious from the start that something was weird about Hafdis; she is a character-shaped gun on the mantelpiece. She was deployed well nonetheless. As always with this series, a lot of the enjoyment is exploring worlds within the Glitter Band. Reynolds can always be relied upon for high quality far future worldbuilding.

[Neal · Rating 4 out of 5]

A fitting end (??) to the stories of Prefect Tom Dreyfus as he once again works to save the millions of residents of the Glitter Band which orbits the planet of Yellowstone. Machine Vendetta takes place several years after Elysium Fire, but revisits some of the ground covered in Aurora Rising (The Prefect). Quite a lot is resolved from the previous two books, but there's just enough meat left on the bone if Reynolds should decide to revisit Dreyfus in the future. At one time he said he had 5 Prefect Dreyfus Emergency books planned, but recently he's stated he plans to step away from the Revelation Space setting and focus on standalone science fiction, which I'm equally excited about.

[Daniel · Rating 4 out of 5]

Decent TV/thriller style space police procedural from Reynolds. I was a little overly conscious of the TV style edits and I didn't feel the book did the character development necessary to sell me on the eventual solution Jane and Dreyfus come up with, but a fun read even with its flaws.

[Michael Finocchiaro · Rating 5 out of 5]

I thought that this final episode for Dreyfus was a fantastic way to go out. We get some closure on the Aurora vs. Clockmaker story, a fan favorite exists stage left, and we are left wanting...more from this Revelation Space universe. I don't know if Reynolds has left the Glitter Band and Yellowstone for good, but what a great ride this has been!

[Yev · Rating 4 out of 5]

Six years have passed both in the real world and in-universe since the last book was published. From early on the characters begin referencing events from four years ago, a text search shows they directly do so twenty times throughout the book, and that confused me. Had I entirely forgotten what had happened and these characters? No, I hadn't, this was simply a case of Reynolds having a lot of stuff happen outside of the written story. The way it's presented though is as if the reader is already aware of everything. Usually when a book follows up from events that occurred it's something that happened in previous books. That's not the case here, as it's mostly a follow-up to the events of four years ago, which sought to resolve the Clockmaker and Aurora situation.

Tom Dreyfus and Thalia Ng are the two major perspectives, though there's a few other minor ones. This is probably one of the least convoluted books that Reynolds has written. It's almost entirely a straightforward investigation going from place to place and talking with people. Most of the thriller, survival, and action scenes are gone, as is much of the stuff from the wider Revelation Space series. Depending on your preferences this may be considered mundane, if not dull, because there isn't anything particularly exciting and certainly nothing epic. Yet, somehow it worked better for me than what the previous books did.

If you've read a few books from Reynolds before, you're aware that identity issues may be his favorite plot device. They're present here, but I think for first time Reynolds has a scene where he acknowledges and intervenes with the identity issues because he knows you're speculating about the identity of a character. The identity issues are eventually resolved in a way that could be considered divisive.

This is where I admit that I don't know what it is about this time, but for some reason I felt especially charitable about all the issues that would've otherwise bothered me. Others may feel the problems to be of greater severity, but unlike the previous books there wasn't anything here that lessened my enjoyment. There were several questionable narrative choices, but it seems I've become inured to them or maybe it was my mood.

I didn't notice it until I was doing text searches, but I realized whenever Ng is mentioned by itself I unconsciously replaced it with Thalia. This led to me wondering why she was always referred to by her first name while Dreyfus is almost always referred to by his last. Stuff like this has happened before.

The ending concludes Dreyfus's story and I'm satisfied with both that it has ended and how it has. It took some plot contrivances to get to this point, but apparently I don't mind.

Rating: 3.5/5

[Luke Burrage · Rating 3 out of 5]

It's a perfectly fine ending to a trilogy. It's good to have some of the storylines wrapped up. But, you know what, I expect much more from Alastair Reynolds than "fine" and "good". Hence the three star rating.

Full review on the podcast, SFBRP episode #534.



Luke and Juliane review Machine Vendetta by Alastair Reynolds, a book they mostly enjoyed, but spend the whole podcast trying to work out why there weren’t fully satisfied.

https://www.sfbrp.com/archives/2181

[Jeroen · Rating 4 out of 5]

Good ending to the Dreyfus novels.

[Vincent Clark · Rating 5 out of 5]

I love Alastair Reynolds’ books, if I could get them tatted across my forehead I would

[Noémie J. Crowley · Rating 5 out of 5]

When I tell you I have been waiting for this one ! Aah I loved the first two so much I couldn’t wait to know the ending of this great story. I love everything about it. I love the characters, I love the setting (how fucking cool is the name Glitter Band ??), I love the thriller aspect, I love love love the ending. I love it all. Great pace, great action, great questions, how fucking dare you kill one of my faves, Dreyfus you’re a good man, see ya around and I’m going to cry into a pillow now. Cheers.

[Brandon · Rating 5 out of 5]

Book review: 5/5 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

Reynolds does it again! Machine Vendetta by Alastair Reynolds is a thrilling science fiction mystery novel, and the final book in the Prefect Dreyfus trilogy. I’ve made it no secret that Reynolds is my favorite author, and I expect a high quality from his writing. He consistently delivers on that quality and does it again in his newest novel. Reynolds knows how to encapsulate everything that makes science fiction great to read, world-building, exploration of future technology, imaginative settings and characters, and much more. While this book was the third in a trilogy, it is also part of the wider Revelation Space universe. Sadly, this is the last Revelation Space novel we will get for a long while, but I’m eager to see what Reynolds comes up with next.

In Machine Vendetta, Prefect Dreyfus of Panoply gets diverted to a habitat where one of his operatives, Ingvar Tench, has inexplicably entered, walking into a dangerous situation that is completely unexpected from her. Dreyfus must figure out why Tench went alone into a hostile area. In another habitat, Thalia Ng investigates a terrorist attack carried out by one of Panoply’s own. The habitat is occupied by heavily altered humans known as the Lemurs, a seemingly peaceful people. An investigation is undertaken by both Dreyfus and Thalia, each chasing a separate thread in a much wider conspiracy.

Machine Vendetta has everything you’d expect if you’d read the series this far. The Glitterband is a truly imaginative and fascinating piece of science fiction world building. An area in space composed of ten thousand artificial habitats with over one hundred million people, all with their own rules and ways of life except for one, they must maintain the tenants of democracy. Panoply is the police force designed to make sure they do just that. We also get out of control AI, far future technology, advanced body modification, space travel, and the plot of a police procedural to keep us hooked until the end.

This novel is a perfect conclusion to an excellent trilogy, and one that fans of Alastair Reynolds shouldn’t skip out on.

[Icy_Space_Cobwebs · Rating 5 out of 5]

MACHINE VENDETTA is an enormously engrossing Hard SF Space Opera, third in Alastair Reynolds' PREFECT DREYFUS EMERGENCY (which Series includes the also exceptional AURORA RISING and ELYSIUM FIRE). Although set far, far into the future, in an era of faster-than-light travel and extensive human (and hyperpig) Colonization of Interstellar Space, the concerns on which it focuses are very apropos to our present day. Rogue Artificial Intelligence; genetic engineering; cloning; post-humanism; hubristic families; found (or orchestrated) family; all of these themes are essentially and magnificently interwoven, and always, always, the overweening theme is Doing the Right Thing.

Release January 2024.

[Ralph Blackburn · Rating 4 out of 5]

Machine Vendetta by Alistair Reynolds(Prefect Dreyfus Emergencies #3)- A new prefect arrives at one of the thousand habitats in the Glitter Band to do her regular maintenance, when she finds the habitat seemingly deserted, then she is shot. Prefect Tom Dreyfus is on his way and along with him his once archenemy Aurora, who has formed an uneasy alliance with him to each other’s benefit. But can Dreyfus trust her. Meanwhile something treacherous is happening again, and it will take all their knowledge and power to find the culprit and save the day. Excellent story. Thank you NetGalley for this ARC

[Robert · Rating 4 out of 5]

And this is a wrap for the Revelation Space universe. I can't believe there is nothing else left to read from this awesome series.
Even though this wasn't my favorite Dreyfus story, it was interesting, had a nice mystery and it made me feel a bit nostalgic about the main RS trilogy with all the talks about Ultras and Glitter Band.

[DJNana · Rating 4 out of 5]

Reynolds’s sci-fi is cold and hard, like the vacuum of space. So when he includes a little touch of human warmth, it’s much appreciated.

Prefect Dreyfus is once again a fascinating character: a rather chunky man, ever chafing at his over-tight uniform, ever tired and overworked, doing his best at Panoply - a celestial police force that has very little actual power or jurisdiction.

And, using that small amount of power that he has, he has to overcome an apocalyptic threat. Somehow.

This is the third book in the series and it’s a great return to form after a somewhat middling middle book

I’m not generally a fan of detective or whodunnit stories, but Reynolds's sci-fi worlds are so fascinating that I’m completely invested throughout.

Add to the sci-fi chops some genuinely good character writing - which is not generally given in this genre - I'm very impressed.

Would I re-read: I wouldn't be against re-reading, although much of the joy is wrapped up in initial discovery of the concepts. I'd need some time to forget my first read.

[Thomas Lööf · Rating 3 out of 5]

Nja

[Geoff · Rating 3 out of 5]

Another strong Dreyfus novel from Alastair Reynolds. I'd say the difference between 3 & 4 stars is the fact that I couldn't remember much of what had happened in the previous Dreyfus novels. But I'm always a fan of returning to Reynolds' Revelation Space world.

[Mike · Rating 5 out of 5]

Alastair Reynolds is still about one of the best sci fi writers out there.

[Jim Mann · Rating 5 out of 5]

Rating 4.5/5

The books in the Prefect series combine cutting edge space opera with police procedural. In the latest volume, apparent terrorist attacks and the murder of a prefect set into motion an investigation that turns up evidence that the group trying to capture the two rogue artificial super intelligences in the Glitter Band may still be active. The Panoply opposes this effort, as the two virtual beings keep one another in check, and an effort to capture them could be disastrous if only one is captured. But there are plots within plots, and the more Dreyfus and team uncover the more danger they expose.

Machine Vendetta succeeds on several levels. The world — or should I say system — building is impressive. The characterization is well done, including that of the megalomaniac super intelligence Aurora. And the plot is exciting and fast moving.

This will be on my Hugo ballot next year.

[WorldconReader · Rating 5 out of 5]

I really like the universe that Alastair Reynolds creates in the space opera "Machine Vendetta": A massive swarm of over 10,000 independent orbital habitats, a fleet of far flung post-human spacefarers, an elite team of agents protecting the voting rights of the local citizens in a colonized solar system, and just to keep things interesting, a couple of god-like AI's that do not share empathy with humanity. Although this is the third book in the Prefect Dreyfus series, and I had not read the previous books, I found "Machine Vendetta" to be perfectly readable, understandable, and highly enjoyable. Now I really look forward to reading the previous books in this series. This series is just too good to miss.

As with the the other Alastair Reynolds space opera novels I have read, this was quite entertaining and was just what I needed. As fan of the Culture novels by Iain M. Banks, I really appreciated the aspect of sophisticated agents using high technology, intelligence, and courage to "do the right thing". Likewise, the prefects in Reynolds' series reminded me quite a bit of E. E. "Doc" Smith's Lensmen. The action, technology, character development, and scope of "Machine Vendetta" really worked for me.

I unhesitatingly recommend this book for Science Fiction fans.

I thank Alastair Reynolds and Orbit Books for kindly providing a temporary electronic review copy of this work.

[Julie T. · Rating 5 out of 5]

A conclusion to the trilogy perhaps? Seems like it is. Not a perfect final book but I enjoyed it immensely, hence the 5 star rating. I really loved the book all the way up until the last 3-4 chapters where we got our resolution. It wasn’t a great resolution, not even as good as the rest of the book, but acceptable all things considered. I’m not entirely convinced that the threat could be neutralized the way our heroes arranged it. It seemed unreliable considering the immensity of the threat. It is also entirely psychological.
Overall, it’s a great trilogy. A worthy addition to the Revelation Space universe. Not a starting place for new readers but a treat for the veterans who made it through the previous books and stories.

[Ross · Rating 4 out of 5]

An enjoyable book with lots of reveals and betrayals.

However I simply did not buy the ending: SPOILER the psychotic super-intelligent AI for some reason cares so much for her suddenly-revealed clone that she would immediately and unconditionally surrender on threat of the clone's suicide. What?! Maybe it would make sense if they tricked Aurora into downloading/seizing control of the clone via implants, and then she would be unwilling to give up that human part of herself. Maybe. With the Aurora taking control two-thirds through the book, perhaps there were not enough pages to satisfactorily defeat her, but okay, just set it up for book #4.

Good endings are difficult in science fiction and it was my only serious gripe with the book, so I don't mean to sound too harsh. I guess this will be the last Dreyfus book, which is a bit sad, but I'm always excited to see what Reynolds does next.