‘This is not a memoir. Not in the conventional sense, anyway.’
While I am always interested in analysis of Australian politics and the occasional memoir, I’ll confess that the left wing of the Australian Labor Party is not one of my usual areas of interest. Still, a friend of mine recommended this book and lent me a copy, so how could I resist?
Kim Carr is of a similar age to me, and the beginning of his story takes me back both to 1972, and the excitement of the Labor victory in my blue-collar home in regional Tasmania, and then to 1975. I was living in Canberra by then and was gobsmacked by the dismissal. In 1975, Kim Carr joined the ALP.
As I read this book and learned more about the byzantine manoeuvrings of the factions of the ALP, I wondered how such processes can ever deliver effective governance. Clearly, it has been at times (I am thinking of the first Hawke/Keating governments).
Kim Carr was elected to the Australian Senate in 1993. This was the election that Paul Keating claimed as a ‘victory for the true believers’. He served as a minister in both the Rudd and Gillard governments in several different portfolios. The history is interesting (I refuse to comment on the personalities, factional fights, and Gillard versus Rudd), but I found Kim Carr’s focus on a future in which Australia could still make things (provided that the right skill bases were developed and new technologies were embraced) inspiring. Yes, those of us with a blue-collar background deplore the loss of manufacturing jobs within Australia, as should those who worry about Australia’s future security.
Once upon a time, the ALP was the political party of choice for most blue-collar workers. Once upon a time the ALP had members (and members of parliament) who had actually worked in blue-collar jobs. Not these days. And I am unconvinced that a parliament full of university-educated representatives is actually doing a better job of governing Australia. Sigh.
Perhaps Bill Kelty’s label of ‘mired in mediocrity’ is accurate.
Me, I am nostalgic for the days of Paul Keating. I didn’t always agree with his vision for Australia, but at least he had one.
Jennifer Cameron-Smith