Lisa Hodges, a middle-aged woman living on Nantucket, is running low on money because her dead husband had a secret gambling problem. She decides to open her home up to guests as a bed-and-breakfast. Meanwhile, her four adult children also live on Nantucket and also have lives and problems of their own- except her son Chase, who is in like one scene and then apparently busy for the rest of the book. Lisa’s oldest daughters, Kate and Kristen, are both very talented- Kate at writing and Kristen at art. But both are in relationships with men who aren’t quite good for them- perhaps some other prospects will come around. Meanwhile, Lisa’s youngest daughter Abby is having some trouble with her marriage, which has always felt rock-solid.
Pros:
•Uh…it was short? And pretty much nothing sad happens, so if you want a very light book, this one’s good.
Cons:
•Oh GOD, where do I start? This book was honestly terrible. The writing was horrendous, and showed clear signs of lack of editing- sometimes the wrong character name was written, there were spaces missing between words and Kristen’s name was sometimes Kirsten. Given the characters’ description of their own writing processes probably should have been a red flag- Kate figures out who the culprit is in her murder mystery halfway through writing it. Kate’s writing experience gives us another clue- she self-publishes her book, and I suspect this book was self-published as well.
•This book reads like a person wrote up a description of what they wanted to happen in their book and then just published it. There is no descriptive imagery, just plain statements about what happened to characters and how they felt without fleshing anything out. The only real descriptions are descriptions of food…maybe she should have written a cookbook.
•The characters LITERALLY have ZERO emotions, and it honestly made me angry. So many times throughout the story something happens that should make a character mad and/or upset, and they just move on “maturely”. Here are some: all the children glossing over the revelation that their dead father had a gambling addiction, walking in on your fiancé sleeping with someone else and getting over it in 1 hour, Lisa’s friend outing Abby as pregnant to her husband before Abby told her husband and Abby not being angry at Lisa for not keeping her secret, Kate’s ex showing up at Kristen’s art show as if he wouldn’t have recognized his ex’s twin sister’s name and knew she would be there. It’s like all of these things are used as plot devices and the characters don’t react to them at all.
•This is miniscule, but everyone in the book thinks “The Beach Plum Cove Inn” is a great name but it does not roll off the tongue, and if it was such a great name, why is it not the title of the book?
Recommendation: I am so confused as to how this book got so many good reviews, because I don’t think it had many redeeming qualities. I recommend if you are willing to sacrifice the quality of the writing, story, and characters, for a short book that’s not very emotional. Avoid if that’s not the case.