What do you think?
Rate this book
The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey
As spiritualism reaches its fevered pitch at the dawn of the 20th century, a Scottish girl crosses the veil to unlock a powerful connection within an infamous asylum in this thrillingly atmospheric, exquisitely evocative exploration of feminine rage and agency for readers of Sarah Penner, Alice Hoffman, and Hester Fox.
Now available in paperback!
Leaving behind a quiet life of simple comforts, Nairna Liath traverses the Scottish countryside with her charlatan father, Tavish. The duo scrapes by on paltry coins as Tavish orchestrates “encounters” with the departed, while Nairna interprets tarot cards for those willing to pay for what they wish to hear.
But beyond her father’s trickery, Nairna possesses a genuine gift for communicating with the spirit world, one that could get an impoverished country girl branded a witch. It’s a talent inherited from her grandmother, Lottie Liath, whose story of imprisonment and exploitation in a notorious asylum is calling out to Nairna from four decades past—a warning to break free from the manipulations, greed, and betrayals of others.
Rescued from homelessness by a well-connected stranger, Nairna is whisked into a new life among Edinburgh’s elite Spiritualist circle, including visiting American star Dorothy Kellings. Researchers, doctors, psychics, and thrill-seekers clamor for the rising young medium. But after a séance with
blood-chilling results, a shocking scandal ensues, and Nairna flees to a secluded community near Boston, where she assumes a new Nora Grey.
But Nora can’t stay hidden when Dorothy Kellings offers her the chance to silence skeptics at a spectacular séance, where Nora will come face to face at last with her spiritual the courageous Lottie Liath—whose profound messages are indelibly tied to Nora’s destiny.
Now available in paperback!
Leaving behind a quiet life of simple comforts, Nairna Liath traverses the Scottish countryside with her charlatan father, Tavish. The duo scrapes by on paltry coins as Tavish orchestrates “encounters” with the departed, while Nairna interprets tarot cards for those willing to pay for what they wish to hear.
But beyond her father’s trickery, Nairna possesses a genuine gift for communicating with the spirit world, one that could get an impoverished country girl branded a witch. It’s a talent inherited from her grandmother, Lottie Liath, whose story of imprisonment and exploitation in a notorious asylum is calling out to Nairna from four decades past—a warning to break free from the manipulations, greed, and betrayals of others.
Rescued from homelessness by a well-connected stranger, Nairna is whisked into a new life among Edinburgh’s elite Spiritualist circle, including visiting American star Dorothy Kellings. Researchers, doctors, psychics, and thrill-seekers clamor for the rising young medium. But after a séance with
blood-chilling results, a shocking scandal ensues, and Nairna flees to a secluded community near Boston, where she assumes a new Nora Grey.
But Nora can’t stay hidden when Dorothy Kellings offers her the chance to silence skeptics at a spectacular séance, where Nora will come face to face at last with her spiritual the courageous Lottie Liath—whose profound messages are indelibly tied to Nora’s destiny.
449 pages, Kindle Edition
First published July 29, 2025
469 people are currently reading
28995 people want to read
About the author
Kathleen Kaufman
9 books184 followersKathleen Kaufman is an author of magical realism and feminist gothic horror, exploring “the other” from ”the other’s” point of view. Her fiction explores how the horror of the past manifests in the present, and the inescapable intertwining of generational history. Her prose has been praised by Kirkus Reviews as “crisp, elegant” and “genuinely chilling” by Booklist. She is the author of the Diabhal trilogy, The Lairdbalor, soon to be a feature film directed by Nicholas Verso, Hag, and The Tree Museum. Kathleen is a professor at Santa Monica College and lives in Los Angeles with her husband, son, kitten, and hound.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 395 reviews
July 9, 2025
Basic Info:
Pub date: July 29th
Publisher: Kensington
Page Count: 448
Recommended for readers who enjoy:
- dual timelines
- historical fiction
- magical realism and feminist gothic horror
- spiritualists, occultists, Victorian era mysticism and mediums
- feminine rage & fighting the patriarchy
- father/daughter relationships
- generational family saga
- dark circus/carnival and asylum aesthetics
- spooky séance scenes
- Fall, moody, slow-burn
__
What I loved:
- while Nairna's father was a con man, she was the real deal with a true gift and she resented tricking people and using her natural ability to manipulate/cheat people
- Edinburgh as a setting (I think I'm in love with this city)
- the dual timelines are both compelling--the other story detailing the life of Nairna's grandmother, a young widow, with the same gifts who lives at an asylum controlled by a cruel doctor- she too is frustrated with her gifts being exploited by a man and her wrongful institutionalization.
- complex, fully realized characters who drive the story forward and keep it interesting providing emotional investment
- I liked the author's use of article snippets as chapter headings to preview upcoming story developments
- in-depth historical context and details--so much research went into this book
__
Minor complaints:
- Nora's character arc was a little predictable/obvious--I felt like I knew from the onset what was going to happen though I longed for a plot twist
- maybe a touch long? I feel like there were story beats that were repeated--scenes that could have been trimmed up to keep the pace
Final recommendation: This book is perfect for grey, moody, rainy days with an endless pot of tea and hours to burn immersed in this historical, gothic tale about two women bound together by blood and paranormal abilities destined to be exploited and misunderstood but determined to forge their own path. Kathleen Kaufman truly sets the stage with rich aesthetics and atmosphere to enfold readers into an intricately plotted storyline while also connecting the audience's heart to the complex characters--a Gothic-era gift! I was enraptured.
Comps: My Darling Dreadful Thing by Johanna Van Veen, Square of Sevens by Laura Shepherd-Robinson
Pub date: July 29th
Publisher: Kensington
Page Count: 448
Recommended for readers who enjoy:
- dual timelines
- historical fiction
- magical realism and feminist gothic horror
- spiritualists, occultists, Victorian era mysticism and mediums
- feminine rage & fighting the patriarchy
- father/daughter relationships
- generational family saga
- dark circus/carnival and asylum aesthetics
- spooky séance scenes
- Fall, moody, slow-burn
__
What I loved:
- while Nairna's father was a con man, she was the real deal with a true gift and she resented tricking people and using her natural ability to manipulate/cheat people
- Edinburgh as a setting (I think I'm in love with this city)
- the dual timelines are both compelling--the other story detailing the life of Nairna's grandmother, a young widow, with the same gifts who lives at an asylum controlled by a cruel doctor- she too is frustrated with her gifts being exploited by a man and her wrongful institutionalization.
- complex, fully realized characters who drive the story forward and keep it interesting providing emotional investment
- I liked the author's use of article snippets as chapter headings to preview upcoming story developments
- in-depth historical context and details--so much research went into this book
__
Minor complaints:
- Nora's character arc was a little predictable/obvious--I felt like I knew from the onset what was going to happen though I longed for a plot twist
- maybe a touch long? I feel like there were story beats that were repeated--scenes that could have been trimmed up to keep the pace
Final recommendation: This book is perfect for grey, moody, rainy days with an endless pot of tea and hours to burn immersed in this historical, gothic tale about two women bound together by blood and paranormal abilities destined to be exploited and misunderstood but determined to forge their own path. Kathleen Kaufman truly sets the stage with rich aesthetics and atmosphere to enfold readers into an intricately plotted storyline while also connecting the audience's heart to the complex characters--a Gothic-era gift! I was enraptured.
Comps: My Darling Dreadful Thing by Johanna Van Veen, Square of Sevens by Laura Shepherd-Robinson
July 27, 2025
I listened to the audiobook of this one and I really liked the narration a lot. It took me a little bit to get into this story, but once it had its hooks in me I could not put it down. This book is historical fiction that enters into the faked and perhaps not so faked fad of memerists. Nora Grey has always had a talent with reading the cards, but her father had them faking seances to make a thin living until she runs into some people who study skills like hers and she discovers she can do more than read the cards. The other perspective from this book is Lottie, a poor woman widowed and cheated and then thrown into an asylum for standing up for herself. This book is beautifully written and tragically sad and also somehow hopeful. I will definitely be looking out for more by this author.
July 31, 2025
Kathleen Kaufman lifts the veil and invites readers and welcomes spirits into The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey, a novel infused with Gaelic folklore set against the gritty backdrop of Victorian Scotland. From its first pages, the prose hypnotised me with its rhythmic hum, lulling me into a mesmeric state, much like Nora Grey.
Plunged into the 20th-century Scottish countryside, we follow tarot-reader and enchantress Nairna Laith and her conniving father, Tavish Laith, as they prey on wealthy patrons and commoners alike in exchange for a few shillings. In this atmospheric tale, Kaufman offers rich, convincing historical fiction traversing poverty, mysticism and society in a seamless narrative, weaving gothic elements with period detail to explore the spiritualist movement – a blend of science and theology. Nairna is a clever, sharp-edged girl with a special talent for the arcane arts. Alongside her father, she journeys through the countryside to Edinburgh in pursuit of a better life. Their fortunes change upon their encounter with the Edinburgh Spiritualists where, after a few séances, Nairna gains fame as a medium, trailing a dangerous thread in a conservative, post-witch-craze Victorian society.
Despite the overuse of the dual-timeline trope, Kaufman frames it compellingly. Soon after Nairna’s chapters, we follow Lottie, a coal-miner’s widow. Alike Nairna, Lottie could be considered a “cunning woman”—a dangerous label for any woman who dared to outwit men or even fight for her rights. The coal-mining industry did not allow women underground, and when a tragic accident struck the mine, all the widows in that small village lost their husbands and their livelihood, now facing eviction. Having decided to fight for the pending wages owed to their spouses, Lottie embarked on a fight she was never meant to win. Sentenced to Argoll Asylum for hysteria, she enters a dark reality faced by many women of that era. Lottie’s chapters are darker and more difficult to read; however, they stop short of pure horror. Instead, Kaufman uses the eerie to meditate on violence against women, poverty and mysticism, with most happing backscene – only suggestions.
In the late 19th century, psychiatry gained notoriety for applying mesmerism to treat patients, from surgery to psychotherapy. These treatments were controversial and frequently mishandled. Dr Soekan serves as an archetype of the ambitious psychiatrist obsessed with innovative treatments, electroshock therapy included. Here, mesmerism is not utilised as a stunt but as an instrument of ambiguity and connection – each session a performance, belief, bluff, ritual and experiment all at once. This device serves as the hinge between both timelines, unfolding slowly and symmetrically across five parts and short chapters that feel more like vivid snippets. Kaufman opens each part with documents, news clippings, séance transcripts and medical records, adding texture and suggesting historical accuracy – even though Nora Grey was not a real person, or was she? That is the skillfulness of Kaufman’s prose.
If the novel falters, it is in its slow pace and the superficial exploration of St Cyprian’s Order. St Cyprian was a famous necromancer who converted to Christianity later in life, and his influence still runs deep in ritualistic mysticism to this day. In the book, the Order operates in the background – a missed opportunity to weave in more horror-heavy elements. As the plot progresses, Nairna and Lottie begin to coax their power, maintaining tension throughout. The ending is elusive, deliberately so. Questions are left unanswered yet easily inferred. This ambiguity is part of the novel’s charm. Kaufman mentions that writing this book felt like stepping off a cliff and hoping for wings. I believe she swooped. The Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey is a fantastically atmospheric read, steeped in folklore, gothic sensibility, feminism and mysticism, recommended to readers of historical fiction, spiritualism, Scottish society and slow-burn narratives.
Audiobook: Mhairi Morrison is a classically trained actress who attained her BA in Acting at The Royal Conservatoire of Scotland before studying theatre and movement at Jacques Le Coq School of Theatre in Paris. She worked in filmed, theater, TV and an award-winning voice over artist narrating audiobooks, commercials, video games and documentaries. In practical terms, she is competent and it can be attested through the numerous accents and voices she uses in The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey, giving the novel the perfect narrative style one can wish for, evoking life from the novel. Morrison slowly and precisely enunciates each and every word, whether speaking in a Scottish or American accents and even Gaelic. I highly recommend the audiobook for full immersion.
Disclaimer: I received an Advance Reader Copy (ARC) of this book from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest and unbiased review. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
Plunged into the 20th-century Scottish countryside, we follow tarot-reader and enchantress Nairna Laith and her conniving father, Tavish Laith, as they prey on wealthy patrons and commoners alike in exchange for a few shillings. In this atmospheric tale, Kaufman offers rich, convincing historical fiction traversing poverty, mysticism and society in a seamless narrative, weaving gothic elements with period detail to explore the spiritualist movement – a blend of science and theology. Nairna is a clever, sharp-edged girl with a special talent for the arcane arts. Alongside her father, she journeys through the countryside to Edinburgh in pursuit of a better life. Their fortunes change upon their encounter with the Edinburgh Spiritualists where, after a few séances, Nairna gains fame as a medium, trailing a dangerous thread in a conservative, post-witch-craze Victorian society.
Despite the overuse of the dual-timeline trope, Kaufman frames it compellingly. Soon after Nairna’s chapters, we follow Lottie, a coal-miner’s widow. Alike Nairna, Lottie could be considered a “cunning woman”—a dangerous label for any woman who dared to outwit men or even fight for her rights. The coal-mining industry did not allow women underground, and when a tragic accident struck the mine, all the widows in that small village lost their husbands and their livelihood, now facing eviction. Having decided to fight for the pending wages owed to their spouses, Lottie embarked on a fight she was never meant to win. Sentenced to Argoll Asylum for hysteria, she enters a dark reality faced by many women of that era. Lottie’s chapters are darker and more difficult to read; however, they stop short of pure horror. Instead, Kaufman uses the eerie to meditate on violence against women, poverty and mysticism, with most happing backscene – only suggestions.
In the late 19th century, psychiatry gained notoriety for applying mesmerism to treat patients, from surgery to psychotherapy. These treatments were controversial and frequently mishandled. Dr Soekan serves as an archetype of the ambitious psychiatrist obsessed with innovative treatments, electroshock therapy included. Here, mesmerism is not utilised as a stunt but as an instrument of ambiguity and connection – each session a performance, belief, bluff, ritual and experiment all at once. This device serves as the hinge between both timelines, unfolding slowly and symmetrically across five parts and short chapters that feel more like vivid snippets. Kaufman opens each part with documents, news clippings, séance transcripts and medical records, adding texture and suggesting historical accuracy – even though Nora Grey was not a real person, or was she? That is the skillfulness of Kaufman’s prose.
If the novel falters, it is in its slow pace and the superficial exploration of St Cyprian’s Order. St Cyprian was a famous necromancer who converted to Christianity later in life, and his influence still runs deep in ritualistic mysticism to this day. In the book, the Order operates in the background – a missed opportunity to weave in more horror-heavy elements. As the plot progresses, Nairna and Lottie begin to coax their power, maintaining tension throughout. The ending is elusive, deliberately so. Questions are left unanswered yet easily inferred. This ambiguity is part of the novel’s charm. Kaufman mentions that writing this book felt like stepping off a cliff and hoping for wings. I believe she swooped. The Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey is a fantastically atmospheric read, steeped in folklore, gothic sensibility, feminism and mysticism, recommended to readers of historical fiction, spiritualism, Scottish society and slow-burn narratives.
Audiobook: Mhairi Morrison is a classically trained actress who attained her BA in Acting at The Royal Conservatoire of Scotland before studying theatre and movement at Jacques Le Coq School of Theatre in Paris. She worked in filmed, theater, TV and an award-winning voice over artist narrating audiobooks, commercials, video games and documentaries. In practical terms, she is competent and it can be attested through the numerous accents and voices she uses in The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey, giving the novel the perfect narrative style one can wish for, evoking life from the novel. Morrison slowly and precisely enunciates each and every word, whether speaking in a Scottish or American accents and even Gaelic. I highly recommend the audiobook for full immersion.
Disclaimer: I received an Advance Reader Copy (ARC) of this book from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest and unbiased review. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
July 22, 2025
The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey is split into two timelines. We have Nora's story, which begins in Scotland where she and father, Lavish, work the fairs and neighbourhoods by Nora reading cards and giving a purely manufactured show of Nora being spoken to by spirits. This ends one night when Nora is booked by a rich client who sees something in her that her father has not noticed - that she can actually see spirits.
The second timeline deals with Lottie Liath who is used to fighting for her rights and those of other miners' wives. That is until there's a tragedy at the mine in Aberdare when her husband is killed. Lottie's reaction is considered unreasonable and she finds herself locked in an asylum. Pregnant and afraid Lottie comes under the "care" of Dr Bothelli who sees a psychic ability in her and sees a way to make his name.
The historical part of the book is a well worn one - women who are strident or speak up are locked away or burned as witches; men rule everything and must be obeyed. We follow both Lottie's and Nora's stories as their connection becomes stronger despite being decades apart.
It is certainly clear enough who the "baddies" are in this story and it's left up to the characters of Nora and Lottie to carry the story. There are a few surprising helpers to both women, which made a nice change and both the women have strong characters.
However I found the story somewhat repetitive and drawn out. The inclusion of a devilish aspect seems lost in the narrative and I'm not sure what I was meant to conclude. There were also certain trigger words that began to irritate me - settle, for one - perhaps it was more noticeable on the audio. There was also a strange obsession with people's accents, which didn't seem to play any part in the plot but was mentioned.
As I say I listened to the audio and read the book alternately. The narration by Mhairi Morrison was, on the whole, very good. Ms Morrison has a lilting and pleasant Scottish accent. The only thing that let it down were other accents - which was made much of in the story - which were often confused and odd. Otherwise it was a pleasure to listen to.
On the whole, I would recommend this book for lovers of historical fiction and those interested in psychical phenomena.
Thankyou to Netgalley, Kensington Publishing and RB Media for the advance review and audio versions of this novel.
The second timeline deals with Lottie Liath who is used to fighting for her rights and those of other miners' wives. That is until there's a tragedy at the mine in Aberdare when her husband is killed. Lottie's reaction is considered unreasonable and she finds herself locked in an asylum. Pregnant and afraid Lottie comes under the "care" of Dr Bothelli who sees a psychic ability in her and sees a way to make his name.
The historical part of the book is a well worn one - women who are strident or speak up are locked away or burned as witches; men rule everything and must be obeyed. We follow both Lottie's and Nora's stories as their connection becomes stronger despite being decades apart.
It is certainly clear enough who the "baddies" are in this story and it's left up to the characters of Nora and Lottie to carry the story. There are a few surprising helpers to both women, which made a nice change and both the women have strong characters.
However I found the story somewhat repetitive and drawn out. The inclusion of a devilish aspect seems lost in the narrative and I'm not sure what I was meant to conclude. There were also certain trigger words that began to irritate me - settle, for one - perhaps it was more noticeable on the audio. There was also a strange obsession with people's accents, which didn't seem to play any part in the plot but was mentioned.
As I say I listened to the audio and read the book alternately. The narration by Mhairi Morrison was, on the whole, very good. Ms Morrison has a lilting and pleasant Scottish accent. The only thing that let it down were other accents - which was made much of in the story - which were often confused and odd. Otherwise it was a pleasure to listen to.
On the whole, I would recommend this book for lovers of historical fiction and those interested in psychical phenomena.
Thankyou to Netgalley, Kensington Publishing and RB Media for the advance review and audio versions of this novel.
April 1, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington for allowing me to read this book in advance of its publication in exchange of an honest review.
I have always been fond of themes such as female rage, young women emancipating themselves from men, spiritualism in the Victorian era and the supernatural. So, on paper, this book had nothing not to be liked. Unfortunately this wasn't the case. Don't get me wrong, it was a pleasant read: it kept its promises on the themes stated above, but the thing is, it didn't add anything new to the genre. The writing was fairly simple, the connections between the two female MCs was almost farfetched in that, since the theme allows for a lot of freedom, I felt like the author didn't bother to provide for even an hypothesis regarding how the two get in touch. The rest was same old same old: I expected more historic insights on the period chosen as background, more well rounded characters (one searches for independence and the other is struck by grief, and it's all that's said about them, not much more)... What I liked most was Nairna (Nora)'s relationship with her father and how it evolved (not much, but at least somewhat) during the course of the story in light of a certain discovery I won't spoil.
I have always been fond of themes such as female rage, young women emancipating themselves from men, spiritualism in the Victorian era and the supernatural. So, on paper, this book had nothing not to be liked. Unfortunately this wasn't the case. Don't get me wrong, it was a pleasant read: it kept its promises on the themes stated above, but the thing is, it didn't add anything new to the genre. The writing was fairly simple, the connections between the two female MCs was almost farfetched in that, since the theme allows for a lot of freedom, I felt like the author didn't bother to provide for even an hypothesis regarding how the two get in touch. The rest was same old same old: I expected more historic insights on the period chosen as background, more well rounded characters (one searches for independence and the other is struck by grief, and it's all that's said about them, not much more)... What I liked most was Nairna (Nora)'s relationship with her father and how it evolved (not much, but at least somewhat) during the course of the story in light of a certain discovery I won't spoil.
July 18, 2025
3.5 🌟 rounded up
The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey - the title rolls right off the tongue, doesn't it?
The book is told from two POVs - Nairna and Lottie. Slowly, the reader learns of their connection. I enjoyed this story and both FMCs. I felt Lottie's frustration in the asylum and Nairna's need to belong somewhere. It went on a bit too long, though. Overall, the book could have been condensed by about 15-20%. It was heading towards a 5-star rating for me until the last third or so started to feel sluggish.
Mhairi Morrison narrates the audiobook. Her voice reminds me of a Scottish Phoebe Judge (IYKYK). I like her voice, but sometimes I struggle with understanding Scottish accents. I did have to listen to this at a slower speed to ensure I could understand everything she said. If that's not generally an issue for you, then you'll likely enjoy the narration.
Recommended for readers who don't mind a slower-paced historical fiction/magical realism story.
Thank you to NetGalley and RBmedia for the ALC.
The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey - the title rolls right off the tongue, doesn't it?
The book is told from two POVs - Nairna and Lottie. Slowly, the reader learns of their connection. I enjoyed this story and both FMCs. I felt Lottie's frustration in the asylum and Nairna's need to belong somewhere. It went on a bit too long, though. Overall, the book could have been condensed by about 15-20%. It was heading towards a 5-star rating for me until the last third or so started to feel sluggish.
Mhairi Morrison narrates the audiobook. Her voice reminds me of a Scottish Phoebe Judge (IYKYK). I like her voice, but sometimes I struggle with understanding Scottish accents. I did have to listen to this at a slower speed to ensure I could understand everything she said. If that's not generally an issue for you, then you'll likely enjoy the narration.
Recommended for readers who don't mind a slower-paced historical fiction/magical realism story.
Thank you to NetGalley and RBmedia for the ALC.
May 26, 2025
Fantasy + Horror is that strange combo that keeps growing in my TBR.
And I don’t know if it’s because I’m hungry for revenge and redemption or if I’m curious how well dark elements play with lighter ones. Probably both, hence why it peaked my interest.
(So, TY to @netgalley for this ARC.)
If you want your feminist hackles raised, look no further. 😅 I bet the audio would be awesome (if this is your mood reading vibe) to listen to with the different accents at play.
Kaufman does a decent job building the some dramatic tension, but I wonder if this would thrived more in first person vs not. I did like the newspaper/letters at the start of the chapters.
I have to say, I tend to like the magical elements a little heavier and a little better explained. 🤷🏽♀️
Overall, a decent read- but unsure if it’ll stick in my long term memory.
And I don’t know if it’s because I’m hungry for revenge and redemption or if I’m curious how well dark elements play with lighter ones. Probably both, hence why it peaked my interest.
(So, TY to @netgalley for this ARC.)
If you want your feminist hackles raised, look no further. 😅 I bet the audio would be awesome (if this is your mood reading vibe) to listen to with the different accents at play.
Kaufman does a decent job building the some dramatic tension, but I wonder if this would thrived more in first person vs not. I did like the newspaper/letters at the start of the chapters.
I have to say, I tend to like the magical elements a little heavier and a little better explained. 🤷🏽♀️
Overall, a decent read- but unsure if it’ll stick in my long term memory.
September 18, 2025
3.5/5
Quite randomly and without intent, this is the third book I’ve read this week with adders. New phobia activated.
Loved the themes and messages in the novel but it has some serious pacing issues.
Quite randomly and without intent, this is the third book I’ve read this week with adders. New phobia activated.
Loved the themes and messages in the novel but it has some serious pacing issues.
July 1, 2025
This historical fantasy was such a great read! I really enjoyed the dual timelines. The asylum setting in particular was fascinating, and I loved uncovering the eerie history tied to it. Set at the height of the spiritualist movement in the early 1900s, the story follows a Scottish girl who crosses the veil and discovers a powerful connection to a notorious asylum, unearthing secrets that have long been buried.
The dual POVs added depth, and the dark, gothic atmosphere pulled me in right away. It did slow a bit after the halfway point, but not enough to take away from my enjoyment. Overall, this was a solid and compelling read. Big thanks to Kensington for the gifted ARC!
The dual POVs added depth, and the dark, gothic atmosphere pulled me in right away. It did slow a bit after the halfway point, but not enough to take away from my enjoyment. Overall, this was a solid and compelling read. Big thanks to Kensington for the gifted ARC!
July 29, 2025
1901: Nairna Liath and her father are con artists traveling the Scottish countryside, pulling parlor tricks for a few meager coins and scraps of food. Until one day when Naira catches the eye of a spiritualist society based in Edinburgh. While in Edinburgh, Nairna uncovers her true metaphysical powers. She is able to see past the veil and make contact with spirits, making her a hot commodity. With her new found powers com fame, and many from the spiritualist community - doctors, researchers, and other psychic mediums - can't wait to get a piece of her. Nairna goes from one man (her father) ruling her life to another and another, leading her to bouts of anger. During these outbursts she is unable to control her powers, and is eventually run out of Scotland to America, where she assumes her new name: Nora Grey. In Boston even more people of the spiritualist community are waiting to cash in on her abilities.
1866: Lottie Liath is facing desperate times. Newly pregnant and widowed, she is dead set on getting her husband's wages and life insurance from the mine where he died. After several tense encounters with the owner of the mine Lottie's anger gets the best of her, leading her to be admitted to Argoll Asylum outside of Cardiff. While imprisoned she is subjected to hypnosis sessions aimed to cure her of her "melancholia and female hysteria". Lottie learns she is able to travel from one plane to another, transcending time and space. Her path eventually merges with Nora's, and they must help each other with the abuse and manipulation they both face.
This is a great story for lovers of historical fiction, magical realism, dual timelines, and horror. Personally, I don't think I'd call this gothic horror like I've seen stated elsewhere. It has some of the same elements that I think it's close enough, and it does deal with some sensitive and dark topics that readers of gothic horror can appreciate. Even though the subject matter was tough to read at times the story also gave a feeling of hope and determination. The mood was consistent and well done throughout. The intertwining stories of Nora and Lottie was very well done. If it weren't for other commitments taking up my time I could have easily read this in a couple of days.
If I had one criticism it would be that the writing felt clunky and disjointed at times, especially in the first few chapters of the book. On more than one occasion I found myself reading entire passages over again because I got lost between the past and present while setting up Nairna's backstory. Luckily it didn't impact the development of her character or my enjoyment of the story.
Thank you NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for this ARC in exchange for an honest review. Happy publication day! (July 29)
1866: Lottie Liath is facing desperate times. Newly pregnant and widowed, she is dead set on getting her husband's wages and life insurance from the mine where he died. After several tense encounters with the owner of the mine Lottie's anger gets the best of her, leading her to be admitted to Argoll Asylum outside of Cardiff. While imprisoned she is subjected to hypnosis sessions aimed to cure her of her "melancholia and female hysteria". Lottie learns she is able to travel from one plane to another, transcending time and space. Her path eventually merges with Nora's, and they must help each other with the abuse and manipulation they both face.
This is a great story for lovers of historical fiction, magical realism, dual timelines, and horror. Personally, I don't think I'd call this gothic horror like I've seen stated elsewhere. It has some of the same elements that I think it's close enough, and it does deal with some sensitive and dark topics that readers of gothic horror can appreciate. Even though the subject matter was tough to read at times the story also gave a feeling of hope and determination. The mood was consistent and well done throughout. The intertwining stories of Nora and Lottie was very well done. If it weren't for other commitments taking up my time I could have easily read this in a couple of days.
If I had one criticism it would be that the writing felt clunky and disjointed at times, especially in the first few chapters of the book. On more than one occasion I found myself reading entire passages over again because I got lost between the past and present while setting up Nairna's backstory. Luckily it didn't impact the development of her character or my enjoyment of the story.
Thank you NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for this ARC in exchange for an honest review. Happy publication day! (July 29)
July 16, 2025
Thank you to Netgalley, the publisher, and the author for providing a free ALC in exchange for an honest review.
This book was very interesting at some parts, but lulled at others. The premise sounded great with female empowerment in the Victorian era, spiritualism/occult practices, and seances, and it was executed well, but I just wish we got a little bit more out of the story. We did not get much character development, which I would have liked a little more from. Nora was probably the most interesting character, and you did see good development with her character. The magical elements could have been explained a little more as well as it seems like they just are, and that's it. Definitely give it a try if you're interested as it's still a good book, just nothing outside the box.
This book was very interesting at some parts, but lulled at others. The premise sounded great with female empowerment in the Victorian era, spiritualism/occult practices, and seances, and it was executed well, but I just wish we got a little bit more out of the story. We did not get much character development, which I would have liked a little more from. Nora was probably the most interesting character, and you did see good development with her character. The magical elements could have been explained a little more as well as it seems like they just are, and that's it. Definitely give it a try if you're interested as it's still a good book, just nothing outside the box.
June 25, 2025
3.6/5
This historical gothic novel weaves a dark, enchanting tale steeped in heavy themes, but it falls short of the five-star mark for me, leaving me wanting more depth and intensity.
The dual timeline and perspectives are a highlight, vividly painting the world across different times and connecting the main characters’ stories.
Lottie’s arc, with its intensity and heartbreak, captivated me more than Nairna’s, though I appreciated the complex father-daughter dynamic in Nairna’s narrative.
The gradual unraveling of the plot, revealing the origins of Nairna’s supernatural abilities and Lottie’s pivotal role in her story, kept me engaged, as the book satisfyingly explains the strange occurrences that drive the narrative.
The inclusion of news excerpts and letters at the start of each chapter is a brilliant touch, grounding the story in a tangible, immersive reality and enriching the context. Kaufman’s prose is another strength; it is vibrant and vivid that every scene springs to life with ease, making visualization effortless.
However, despite a promising start that drew me in, the story loses momentum after the halfway mark. The pacing slows significantly, and the narrative becomes repetitive, failing to build toward the climactic payoff I had anticipated.
The heavy themes, such as women’s medical and legal rights and sexism in the 19th century, and magical elements like telekinesis, resurrection, mesmerism, and fortune-telling are intriguing but underexplored, scratching just the surface when they could have been delved into with greater depth and excitement.
Lottie’s ending, while quite sad, felt predictable due to clues in Nairna’s timeline, and Nairna’s conclusion was disappointingly flat and uninspired.
I also wished for more perspectives from characters like Dr. Bothelli and Sister Therese, whose roles in Lottie’s story hinted at untapped potential.
More action, heightened magical stakes, or deeper emotional resonance could have elevated the narrative, stirring the plot and making me care more deeply for the characters.
Like I said, the novel feels like it’s scratching the surface of its potential, leaving an itch for something more.
Overall, this book has much to admire: the lush prose, a haunting atmosphere, and a compelling structure, but its lack of intensity and unfulfilled promise prevent it from soaring.
Fans of gothic fiction may enjoy its dark charm and magic, but those craving a more gripping, action-packed tale might share my view for a bolder execution.
Thank you to Netgalley and Kensington Publishing for the ARC copy in exchange for my honest opinion.
This historical gothic novel weaves a dark, enchanting tale steeped in heavy themes, but it falls short of the five-star mark for me, leaving me wanting more depth and intensity.
The dual timeline and perspectives are a highlight, vividly painting the world across different times and connecting the main characters’ stories.
Lottie’s arc, with its intensity and heartbreak, captivated me more than Nairna’s, though I appreciated the complex father-daughter dynamic in Nairna’s narrative.
The gradual unraveling of the plot, revealing the origins of Nairna’s supernatural abilities and Lottie’s pivotal role in her story, kept me engaged, as the book satisfyingly explains the strange occurrences that drive the narrative.
The inclusion of news excerpts and letters at the start of each chapter is a brilliant touch, grounding the story in a tangible, immersive reality and enriching the context. Kaufman’s prose is another strength; it is vibrant and vivid that every scene springs to life with ease, making visualization effortless.
However, despite a promising start that drew me in, the story loses momentum after the halfway mark. The pacing slows significantly, and the narrative becomes repetitive, failing to build toward the climactic payoff I had anticipated.
The heavy themes, such as women’s medical and legal rights and sexism in the 19th century, and magical elements like telekinesis, resurrection, mesmerism, and fortune-telling are intriguing but underexplored, scratching just the surface when they could have been delved into with greater depth and excitement.
Lottie’s ending, while quite sad, felt predictable due to clues in Nairna’s timeline, and Nairna’s conclusion was disappointingly flat and uninspired.
I also wished for more perspectives from characters like Dr. Bothelli and Sister Therese, whose roles in Lottie’s story hinted at untapped potential.
More action, heightened magical stakes, or deeper emotional resonance could have elevated the narrative, stirring the plot and making me care more deeply for the characters.
Like I said, the novel feels like it’s scratching the surface of its potential, leaving an itch for something more.
Overall, this book has much to admire: the lush prose, a haunting atmosphere, and a compelling structure, but its lack of intensity and unfulfilled promise prevent it from soaring.
Fans of gothic fiction may enjoy its dark charm and magic, but those craving a more gripping, action-packed tale might share my view for a bolder execution.
Thank you to Netgalley and Kensington Publishing for the ARC copy in exchange for my honest opinion.
May 9, 2025
This novel is a mystical mix of historical fiction, mesmerism, and the occult. With lyrical writing and an important message about self-perseverance, this book was hard to put down! The quick chapters and fast pace had me staying up all night to finish it!
July 30, 2025
A slow-burn historical novel with 2 female voices, years apart but similar in many ways.
This one started a bit slow, drawing me in two the perspectives with backstory and rich detail. Nora's work at fairs and with her dad were interesting to start and slowly became shocking. As she worked her way into being invited into the group, I was fully intrigued.
Lottie is our other POV. We're brought in as her husband is off to mine and then a tragedy - a group of wives lose their husbands to a mining accident and, suddenly, the company doesn't want to pay out the insurance or the past wages the men were owed.
The two POV and timelines are obvious how they are similar and it takes time and story to draw the parallels. And even though I found the story interesting, I did feel like it went a bit long. I didn't love the narrator, she was a bit sing-songy and oddly whispery but I flipped to the kindle and enjoyed the story a lot!
A huge thank you to the author and publisher for providing an e-ARC via Netgalley. This does not affect my opinion regarding the book.
This one started a bit slow, drawing me in two the perspectives with backstory and rich detail. Nora's work at fairs and with her dad were interesting to start and slowly became shocking. As she worked her way into being invited into the group, I was fully intrigued.
Lottie is our other POV. We're brought in as her husband is off to mine and then a tragedy - a group of wives lose their husbands to a mining accident and, suddenly, the company doesn't want to pay out the insurance or the past wages the men were owed.
The two POV and timelines are obvious how they are similar and it takes time and story to draw the parallels. And even though I found the story interesting, I did feel like it went a bit long. I didn't love the narrator, she was a bit sing-songy and oddly whispery but I flipped to the kindle and enjoyed the story a lot!
A huge thank you to the author and publisher for providing an e-ARC via Netgalley. This does not affect my opinion regarding the book.
August 31, 2025
Thank you so much to NetGalleyand the publisher for providing an ALC copy of this book in exchange for an honest review
This book sounded so intriguing and grand on page, and even though the atmosphere was definitely its strongest point, it just failed to deliver more than a surface level, femine rage with some magical realism in the mix. Basically, it did nothing new.
Besides in the beginning of the story neither Nora nor Lottie had any agency whatsoever, things just happened to them (in Lottie's case it wasn't really her fault there wasn't much she could do, but still) which made them just feel like vessels for the story. None of the side characters really stood out besides Nora's dad. I enjoyed how their dynamic changed and was explored throughout the novel.
I am really not the biggest fan of magical realism, and this book did not change that sentiment whatsoever. The connection between Lottie and Nora once again just felt convenient.
Intriguing concept, not the best execution.
Audiobook review:
I immensely enjoyed the narrators voice and accent. She definitely did some heavy lifting bringing the story to life.
This book sounded so intriguing and grand on page, and even though the atmosphere was definitely its strongest point, it just failed to deliver more than a surface level, femine rage with some magical realism in the mix. Basically, it did nothing new.
Besides in the beginning of the story neither Nora nor Lottie had any agency whatsoever, things just happened to them (in Lottie's case it wasn't really her fault there wasn't much she could do, but still) which made them just feel like vessels for the story. None of the side characters really stood out besides Nora's dad. I enjoyed how their dynamic changed and was explored throughout the novel.
I am really not the biggest fan of magical realism, and this book did not change that sentiment whatsoever. The connection between Lottie and Nora once again just felt convenient.
Intriguing concept, not the best execution.
Audiobook review:
I immensely enjoyed the narrators voice and accent. She definitely did some heavy lifting bringing the story to life.
December 8, 2025
Nairna Liath is a teenage girl pulling scams with her father in order to make ends meet in 1901 in The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey by Kathleen Kaufman. She pretends to be able to commune with the dead, but it’s her actual, true skill with seeing what her cards have to predict that brings her attention from a spiritualist society. With their help, she’s connecting with Lottie Liath in the past, and she has her name changed to Nora Grey as she arrives in America and explodes in popularity. Lottie is languishing in Argoll Asylum in 1866, and is desperate to escape before giving birth to her child and losing him forever. She, too, is being tested with mesmerism, and this allows her to bridge the gap and communicate with Nora.
My thoughts:
•The dual timeline is done precisely right. As a reader, I never felt impatient to get back to either Nora or Lottie; rather, each time it switched, I wanted to stay with who I’d been reading about, and then the same occurred at the end of that part when the swap-off happened again.
•I like the parallel of Lottie and Nora. They’re caught in places where they don’t have free will, and then they’re both introduced to men who have new ideas and theories they want to test out on them. They also keep undergoing the mesmerisation even though they hate it because they want to connect with each other.
•To me, the stronger plot line would have to be Lottie’s. The story is unwinding what exactly happened to her, and how her stay in the asylum turns out; with Nora, she’s basically just doing a bunch of seances.
•The ending was bittersweet, but it was also satisfying, too. I enjoyed the use of newspaper articles, letters, and, in one instance, a ghost hunting show transcript to supplement the text.
•I REALLY enjoy reading about supernatural stuff where the supernatural stuff is actually real, so this book was fun for me.
Nitpick: there’s a reference of a sceptic who worked with Houdini. Houdini was making it big at the turn of the century, but his dedicated work with scepticism wasn’t until later, into the twenties. Regardless, you can tell the author really looked up sources and what spiritualists did during their heyday and who said spiritualists were.
I recommend this for people who like historical fiction and a book focused on women and their struggles.
I received a copy of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
My thoughts:
•The dual timeline is done precisely right. As a reader, I never felt impatient to get back to either Nora or Lottie; rather, each time it switched, I wanted to stay with who I’d been reading about, and then the same occurred at the end of that part when the swap-off happened again.
•I like the parallel of Lottie and Nora. They’re caught in places where they don’t have free will, and then they’re both introduced to men who have new ideas and theories they want to test out on them. They also keep undergoing the mesmerisation even though they hate it because they want to connect with each other.
•To me, the stronger plot line would have to be Lottie’s. The story is unwinding what exactly happened to her, and how her stay in the asylum turns out; with Nora, she’s basically just doing a bunch of seances.
•The ending was bittersweet, but it was also satisfying, too. I enjoyed the use of newspaper articles, letters, and, in one instance, a ghost hunting show transcript to supplement the text.
•I REALLY enjoy reading about supernatural stuff where the supernatural stuff is actually real, so this book was fun for me.
Nitpick: there’s a reference of a sceptic who worked with Houdini. Houdini was making it big at the turn of the century, but his dedicated work with scepticism wasn’t until later, into the twenties. Regardless, you can tell the author really looked up sources and what spiritualists did during their heyday and who said spiritualists were.
I recommend this for people who like historical fiction and a book focused on women and their struggles.
I received a copy of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
August 18, 2025
Great vibes to keep on your radar for low-key autumn spooky season! This book covers the tales of Lottie and Nairna, two Scottish women with sensational minds seemingly capable of seeing beyond the realm of our physical world. Alternating between their two time periods and narratives, the book gradually delivers an understanding on how their lives and stories overlap. I found myself wishing this meshing had come a bit sooner in the book, but I did enjoy it overall. 3.5 stars rounded down, only because, while it is well written, I found myself never too eager to pick it back up — maybe it was just the wrong time of year for me to read it?
July 11, 2025
The entirely true story of how the author pulled shit out of her ass.
Overall Review
The lack of research makes me wonder of Kathleen likes magical realism as an aesthetic or if she is actually interested in the occult at all. As a pagan who knows tarot enough to know what certain cards mean without looking at them, this book was a huge disappointment. It showed a complete lack of understanding and honesty mocked those who actually read tarot. Even if Nora Grey wasn’t supposed to be well versed in tarot, the fact that she is said to possess a gift for the spiritual world tells me that she should have had enough intuition to been somewhere in the ballpark with her readings. Instead we are left with another book where the author uses the occult as a gimmick for the backdrop of her book.
Dyslexic Reader Insight
This book was easy to read aside from the (what i think is ) Gaelic or Welsh, which I cannot say with confidence was researched well considering the problems it had with the tarot readings. These phrases were sometimes translated and sometimes left to the reader to look them up or guess what they meant. Constantly having to pull out my phone for pronunciation and fact checking left me feeling like this book was more of an assignment than an enjoyable read.
Review
Honestly i am disappointed. Lottie’s story was far more compelling than Nora as she felt real and relatable. Again, i felt like Nora was just a character to serve as the author’s fascination with magical realism without actually putting much thought into how realistic the magic was. With Lottie i went on an emotional journey, Nora just felt like a gimmick.
Overall Review
The lack of research makes me wonder of Kathleen likes magical realism as an aesthetic or if she is actually interested in the occult at all. As a pagan who knows tarot enough to know what certain cards mean without looking at them, this book was a huge disappointment. It showed a complete lack of understanding and honesty mocked those who actually read tarot. Even if Nora Grey wasn’t supposed to be well versed in tarot, the fact that she is said to possess a gift for the spiritual world tells me that she should have had enough intuition to been somewhere in the ballpark with her readings. Instead we are left with another book where the author uses the occult as a gimmick for the backdrop of her book.
Dyslexic Reader Insight
This book was easy to read aside from the (what i think is ) Gaelic or Welsh, which I cannot say with confidence was researched well considering the problems it had with the tarot readings. These phrases were sometimes translated and sometimes left to the reader to look them up or guess what they meant. Constantly having to pull out my phone for pronunciation and fact checking left me feeling like this book was more of an assignment than an enjoyable read.
Review
Honestly i am disappointed. Lottie’s story was far more compelling than Nora as she felt real and relatable. Again, i felt like Nora was just a character to serve as the author’s fascination with magical realism without actually putting much thought into how realistic the magic was. With Lottie i went on an emotional journey, Nora just felt like a gimmick.
July 17, 2025
**Received ARC from NetGalley. I received before officially published, Publish date July 2025**
I really enjoyed this book. I felt it was super unique and very intriguing to follow. I love the witchy dark feel and the writing matched the ambiance very well. I love when stories connect through multiple generations and this book did a very good and unique job at doing just that. At times there were parts that didn’t match the two timelines and how they connected but it was a small error that didn’t take away from the story. There were some parts that felt brushed passed or irrelevant but at the end of the day I also dont think it took away from anything. Overall I really enjoyed this and this authors ghost stories never seize to amaze me
I really enjoyed this book. I felt it was super unique and very intriguing to follow. I love the witchy dark feel and the writing matched the ambiance very well. I love when stories connect through multiple generations and this book did a very good and unique job at doing just that. At times there were parts that didn’t match the two timelines and how they connected but it was a small error that didn’t take away from the story. There were some parts that felt brushed passed or irrelevant but at the end of the day I also dont think it took away from anything. Overall I really enjoyed this and this authors ghost stories never seize to amaze me
July 24, 2025
This was an interesting read. The setting was great. The imagery really sets the scene for dark gothic vibes. I found the asylum, dual POV/Timeline, and magical realism interesting.
Nairna travels around with her father who is a con man. While Nairna has to also con people she hates it. She actually is gifted. I enjoyed reading about her powers. You have to deal with female rage and patriarchy in this story. While I found the premise interesting I was left wanting more from this book. A great read for spooky season.
Thank you for the gifted ebook NetGalley
Nairna travels around with her father who is a con man. While Nairna has to also con people she hates it. She actually is gifted. I enjoyed reading about her powers. You have to deal with female rage and patriarchy in this story. While I found the premise interesting I was left wanting more from this book. A great read for spooky season.
Thank you for the gifted ebook NetGalley
October 18, 2025
Spiritualism reached its heights around the turn of the 20th century and a young Scottish girl with a gift as a medium rode the crest of that wave with a Victorian Era woman named, Lottie, trapped in an asylum for her spirit guide. Kathleen Kaufman’s atmospheric story straddles the genres of Gothic Horror and Magical Realism to thrilling results.
The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Gray is told in two timelines and following the lives of two women separated by time with intervals at the beginning of each chapter for news reports and letters leading to what comes next.
Nora’s story begins when she joins her charming, but poor charlatan father, Tavish on the road in 1900 playing on people’s emotions and needs to earn their bread and coin. Nora is eventually discovered and becomes the toast of Scottish spiritualism fans until a bad incident has she and Tavish fleeing across the ocean for a fresh start.
Lottie’s story opens in 1866 when a mine collapse takes her husband and while grieving and pregnant, she bravely fights for the rights the mine manager denies their families to the wages and insurance. Her bravery leads to a pivotal event that leads to the incarceration of an asylum where the doctors do unspeakable things to her in the name of their research. Only the sisters at the asylum in limited ways try to aid her. Lottie crosses time to warn Nora about trusting the wrong people to guide her with her gift.
I was more emotionally vested in Lottie’s poor plight and felt tears burning at the tragedy of her life, but Nora was aloof to me and yet I wanted to see what came of her bid to leave behind the artificial show-woman life her da and others exploited her in. There was an interesting mixed feelings relationship between her and her da.
Side by side, -pacing out very slowly at first and lagging at times, until the book really gets going in the latter portion- the two women’s stories are separate and then start to intersect. I was riveted and flashing through the pages at the end.
The historical settings including the background of the spiritualist movement on both sides of the pond, the two women main characters and surrounding cast were richly drawn and terribly interesting.
Women in the past with agency to achieve their results, a chilling asylum and encounters with the dearly departed blend for a spectacular spooky season read.
I rec'd an ARC print copy from Kensington books to read in exchange for an honest review.
My full review will post on 10.6.25 at my Instagram page @sophiarose1816
The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Gray is told in two timelines and following the lives of two women separated by time with intervals at the beginning of each chapter for news reports and letters leading to what comes next.
Nora’s story begins when she joins her charming, but poor charlatan father, Tavish on the road in 1900 playing on people’s emotions and needs to earn their bread and coin. Nora is eventually discovered and becomes the toast of Scottish spiritualism fans until a bad incident has she and Tavish fleeing across the ocean for a fresh start.
Lottie’s story opens in 1866 when a mine collapse takes her husband and while grieving and pregnant, she bravely fights for the rights the mine manager denies their families to the wages and insurance. Her bravery leads to a pivotal event that leads to the incarceration of an asylum where the doctors do unspeakable things to her in the name of their research. Only the sisters at the asylum in limited ways try to aid her. Lottie crosses time to warn Nora about trusting the wrong people to guide her with her gift.
I was more emotionally vested in Lottie’s poor plight and felt tears burning at the tragedy of her life, but Nora was aloof to me and yet I wanted to see what came of her bid to leave behind the artificial show-woman life her da and others exploited her in. There was an interesting mixed feelings relationship between her and her da.
Side by side, -pacing out very slowly at first and lagging at times, until the book really gets going in the latter portion- the two women’s stories are separate and then start to intersect. I was riveted and flashing through the pages at the end.
The historical settings including the background of the spiritualist movement on both sides of the pond, the two women main characters and surrounding cast were richly drawn and terribly interesting.
Women in the past with agency to achieve their results, a chilling asylum and encounters with the dearly departed blend for a spectacular spooky season read.
I rec'd an ARC print copy from Kensington books to read in exchange for an honest review.
My full review will post on 10.6.25 at my Instagram page @sophiarose1816
July 16, 2025
Dearest book lovers, prepare to be utterly captivated by a story that feels like a secret garden blooming under a moonlit sky! 🌸✨ The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey is an exquisite tapestry of magic, history, and the beautiful strength of the feminine spirit. 💖
Imagine stepping back to the turn of the 20th century, where the air hums with spiritual energy, and a young Scottish girl, Nairna Liath, possesses a gift as delicate and powerful as a butterfly's wing. 🦋 She journeys with her charming, if sometimes mischievous, father, reading fortunes that hint at destinies far grander than simple coins can buy. Yet, her true connection to the spirit world, a legacy from her grandmother Lottie, is a shimmering secret, both wondrous and perilous. 🌿
Lottie's poignant echoes from the past, from the shadowed confines of a notorious asylum, call out to Nairna like a siren's song. It's a tale of resilience, a quiet rebellion against the chains of manipulation and deceit. Can our sweet Nairna embrace this ancestral wisdom and truly unfurl her wings? 🌼🕊️
Swept into the glittering, often deceptive, world of Edinburgh's elite Spiritualist circles, Nairna becomes a beacon, her unique talents drawing every curious gaze. But a séance, oh, a séance that sends shivers down your spine, ignites a scandal that forces our brave heroine to flee, seeking refuge and a new identity as Nora Grey in a tranquil American haven. 🏡✨
But fate guides her onward! When the captivating Dorothy Kellings offers a grand stage, Nora knows she must answer the call. And at Boston's historic Old South Meeting Hall, amidst the hushed anticipation, she will finally encounter her truest spiritual guide: the courageous Lottie. Their profound connection, a dance of past and present, promises a revelation that will resonate deep within your soul. 💫📖
This novel, gentle readers, is a breathtakingly atmospheric embrace, rich with evocative details and a tender yet fierce exploration of a woman's journey to reclaim her voice and power. Suppose your heart yearns for the intricate historical magic of Sarah Penner, the soulful whispers of Alice Hoffman, or the haunting beauty of Hester Fox. In that case, this fantastical adventure is waiting just for you. Come, let the enchantment begin! 🌟💖
Imagine stepping back to the turn of the 20th century, where the air hums with spiritual energy, and a young Scottish girl, Nairna Liath, possesses a gift as delicate and powerful as a butterfly's wing. 🦋 She journeys with her charming, if sometimes mischievous, father, reading fortunes that hint at destinies far grander than simple coins can buy. Yet, her true connection to the spirit world, a legacy from her grandmother Lottie, is a shimmering secret, both wondrous and perilous. 🌿
Lottie's poignant echoes from the past, from the shadowed confines of a notorious asylum, call out to Nairna like a siren's song. It's a tale of resilience, a quiet rebellion against the chains of manipulation and deceit. Can our sweet Nairna embrace this ancestral wisdom and truly unfurl her wings? 🌼🕊️
Swept into the glittering, often deceptive, world of Edinburgh's elite Spiritualist circles, Nairna becomes a beacon, her unique talents drawing every curious gaze. But a séance, oh, a séance that sends shivers down your spine, ignites a scandal that forces our brave heroine to flee, seeking refuge and a new identity as Nora Grey in a tranquil American haven. 🏡✨
But fate guides her onward! When the captivating Dorothy Kellings offers a grand stage, Nora knows she must answer the call. And at Boston's historic Old South Meeting Hall, amidst the hushed anticipation, she will finally encounter her truest spiritual guide: the courageous Lottie. Their profound connection, a dance of past and present, promises a revelation that will resonate deep within your soul. 💫📖
This novel, gentle readers, is a breathtakingly atmospheric embrace, rich with evocative details and a tender yet fierce exploration of a woman's journey to reclaim her voice and power. Suppose your heart yearns for the intricate historical magic of Sarah Penner, the soulful whispers of Alice Hoffman, or the haunting beauty of Hester Fox. In that case, this fantastical adventure is waiting just for you. Come, let the enchantment begin! 🌟💖
July 22, 2025
I thought this story was a really interesting read. I always enjoy when a story has dual timelines, as this one does. We go from the current time, early 1900s where we follow the FMC Nairna Liath later known as Nora Grey as she is "discovered" by a wealthy woman while reading tarot cards at a fair. After having spent time traveling the Scottish countryside with her father Tavish, she is happy to be finally living in a home, and getting regular meals. As Nora continues to do readings, her life is turned upside down as she is brought into the world of psychic mediums. The other timelines we visit is in the past, Lottie Liath, who not only goes through her own horrible experience, but also becomes Nora's spirit guide.
This story was a little bit sad but also totally realistic in its depiction of how women were treated at the time, especially reading about Lottie and all that happens to her. It is horrible that women could just be committed for disagreeing with a man. I was angry on the character's behalf, and then as poor Lottie was experimented on, it was horrible. It was really interesting to read about the whole psychic medium society, and how they were all looking for someone who could resurrect the dead. The amusing part of all of this is that as much proof and talent that Nora had shown, some of the people in the societies still didn't believe what she could do was real...until they experienced it first hand. I felt that Nora, while very talented in her medium abilities, was still just being used by one person after another for monetary or social gain in this story. I was so proud of Nora when she finally said enough was enough, and decided to begin her life by her choice and help others like her.
I have never read a book quite like this, and I think that a lot of people would really enjoy it!
Thank you to Netgalley, Kensington, and the author for a copy of this book!
This story was a little bit sad but also totally realistic in its depiction of how women were treated at the time, especially reading about Lottie and all that happens to her. It is horrible that women could just be committed for disagreeing with a man. I was angry on the character's behalf, and then as poor Lottie was experimented on, it was horrible. It was really interesting to read about the whole psychic medium society, and how they were all looking for someone who could resurrect the dead. The amusing part of all of this is that as much proof and talent that Nora had shown, some of the people in the societies still didn't believe what she could do was real...until they experienced it first hand. I felt that Nora, while very talented in her medium abilities, was still just being used by one person after another for monetary or social gain in this story. I was so proud of Nora when she finally said enough was enough, and decided to begin her life by her choice and help others like her.
I have never read a book quite like this, and I think that a lot of people would really enjoy it!
Thank you to Netgalley, Kensington, and the author for a copy of this book!
July 25, 2025
Thank you to Kensington Publishing for providing this ARC for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
The True Story of the Fantasitical Mesmerist Nora Grey by Kathleen Kaufman is a historical fiction/magical realism story about a young woman who’s been using her tarot reading and faux spiritual seances to get by. When she’s found to have much more spiritual ability, she’s thrust into a life of fame and renown while simultaneously uncovering the truth about her family’s past.
This book is a tickles a lot of the different preferred tropes of magical realism AND historical fiction. There’s fake Victorian era spiritualism, real Victorian era spiritualism, asylums, and several different flavors of strong female characters. I think that there is a lot that makes this book relatively compelling, including to people who may not usually prefer historical fiction (in the sense that this is really just such a small sliver of history.)
What I think makes this story so effective is that it has a lot of mass appeal. The story moves at a fast but not breakneck pace. The characters are interesting and have some depth to them. The writing is both polished and accessible. This is not by any means a piece of experimental or very innovative magical realism. While the themes are dark at times, there’s no feeling of being punishingly dark or transgressive. The best thing about this book is its mass appeal with a very compelling and immersive story.
I could easily recommend this title to a book club or a broad group of readers. For me this is a 4.5/5.
The True Story of the Fantasitical Mesmerist Nora Grey by Kathleen Kaufman is a historical fiction/magical realism story about a young woman who’s been using her tarot reading and faux spiritual seances to get by. When she’s found to have much more spiritual ability, she’s thrust into a life of fame and renown while simultaneously uncovering the truth about her family’s past.
This book is a tickles a lot of the different preferred tropes of magical realism AND historical fiction. There’s fake Victorian era spiritualism, real Victorian era spiritualism, asylums, and several different flavors of strong female characters. I think that there is a lot that makes this book relatively compelling, including to people who may not usually prefer historical fiction (in the sense that this is really just such a small sliver of history.)
What I think makes this story so effective is that it has a lot of mass appeal. The story moves at a fast but not breakneck pace. The characters are interesting and have some depth to them. The writing is both polished and accessible. This is not by any means a piece of experimental or very innovative magical realism. While the themes are dark at times, there’s no feeling of being punishingly dark or transgressive. The best thing about this book is its mass appeal with a very compelling and immersive story.
I could easily recommend this title to a book club or a broad group of readers. For me this is a 4.5/5.
August 13, 2025
I haven't read much magical realism with a historical setting, but I definitely enjoyed this! It covers a lot of ground that focuses on wider issues - women who were institutionalized for "hysteria" when they were really just angry at how they were being treated by those in positions of power, horrible medical experiments performed throughout history on those who are confined to institutions, exploitation of vulnerable people, and much more. The vessels for this story are two women, Lottie and Nairna, who lived a few decades apart and found themselves to have the gift of communicating with the spirit world. This gift proves to be comforting and important for them but also the invitation for others to use Lottie and Nairna for their own advantage. Even though it's a 400+ page book, it read quickly. I listened to part of it on audio, which was well done.
June 2, 2025
I really enjoyed this book! It was dark and mystical, while still having hope at the center of the story. It reminded me of Houdini, and how all these impossible tricks were just illusions and traps, and what it would be like if not all of it was fake.
Lottie’s story was heartbreaking, and it’s not the only one of how far men are willing to go in the name of “science”. If the betterment of man is made of the backs of people with little to no power than are we really becoming better? The ending while giving me a sense of peace, is not a true happy ending for all if that is something you seek. This is gothic fantasy and it did truly deliver!
I received this ARC for free and all thoughts and opinions are my own.
Lottie’s story was heartbreaking, and it’s not the only one of how far men are willing to go in the name of “science”. If the betterment of man is made of the backs of people with little to no power than are we really becoming better? The ending while giving me a sense of peace, is not a true happy ending for all if that is something you seek. This is gothic fantasy and it did truly deliver!
I received this ARC for free and all thoughts and opinions are my own.
July 25, 2025
Thank you NetGalley and HighBridge Audio for this audio ARC!
This was a very enjoyable listen, especially the accents of the narrators and performance of the audiobook. This mystical tale of generational connection and trauma was an engaging and well paced read. There were parts that felt slow, but overall the pacing kept my attention throughout. I was more enamored with Lottie’s timeline, and enjoyed her strength and convictions throughout, especially in regard to her pregnancy. The nuns at the asylum were a delightful addition to the character landscape and stood out even though they were more minor characters.
Definitely for fans of Emilia Hart or Alix E Harrow!
This was a very enjoyable listen, especially the accents of the narrators and performance of the audiobook. This mystical tale of generational connection and trauma was an engaging and well paced read. There were parts that felt slow, but overall the pacing kept my attention throughout. I was more enamored with Lottie’s timeline, and enjoyed her strength and convictions throughout, especially in regard to her pregnancy. The nuns at the asylum were a delightful addition to the character landscape and stood out even though they were more minor characters.
Definitely for fans of Emilia Hart or Alix E Harrow!
August 15, 2025
3.5 stars
Really enjoyed the characters and atmosphere as well as the dual timelines and POV, but the story felt a bit repetitive and drawn out.
Characters 8
Atmosphere 8
Writing Style 7
Premise 7
Plot 7
Pace 4
Length 4
Structure/Setup 8
Enjoyment/Engrossment 6
Narration 8
Really enjoyed the characters and atmosphere as well as the dual timelines and POV, but the story felt a bit repetitive and drawn out.
Characters 8
Atmosphere 8
Writing Style 7
Premise 7
Plot 7
Pace 4
Length 4
Structure/Setup 8
Enjoyment/Engrossment 6
Narration 8
August 3, 2025
I tried. I tried so hard! But this book is just a big no for me. I thought the description sounded great but the book fell very flat for me.
I didn’t find it to be an “easy” read, a lot of pronunciations I had to figure out, words/names i haven’t seen before.
The book is just too slow. I’m waiting for this “shocking scandal” to occur and feel like I’m just going through sludge to get there.
Maybe this genre isn’t for me!
Thank you to netgalley and Kensington publishing for the ARC in exchange for my honest review,
I didn’t find it to be an “easy” read, a lot of pronunciations I had to figure out, words/names i haven’t seen before.
The book is just too slow. I’m waiting for this “shocking scandal” to occur and feel like I’m just going through sludge to get there.
Maybe this genre isn’t for me!
Thank you to netgalley and Kensington publishing for the ARC in exchange for my honest review,
September 14, 2025
Tive uma certa dificuldade em envolver-me completamente nesta história. Talvez seja pelo facto de a história de Nora não ter me convencido, tendo como "fantastical mesmerist"no título esperava que ela fosse de facto uma personagem que nos deslumbrasse com os seus poderes de médium. Mas acabei por me aborrecer nalguns dos seus capítulos, e não achei a sua trajetória fantástica.
Pelo contrário, gostei bastante da história de Liath. Apesar de passar momentos bastante traumáticos, Liath não deixa de lutar pela sua liberdade e acreditar no impossível. Gostei da sua amizade com a Irmã Teresa. E acompanhar a vida dela naquele asilo.
É também interessante descobrir que parte da inspiração partiu da própria história da família da escritora.
Pelo contrário, gostei bastante da história de Liath. Apesar de passar momentos bastante traumáticos, Liath não deixa de lutar pela sua liberdade e acreditar no impossível. Gostei da sua amizade com a Irmã Teresa. E acompanhar a vida dela naquele asilo.
É também interessante descobrir que parte da inspiração partiu da própria história da família da escritora.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 395 reviews