❄️❄️
TL;DR - If you enjoy Christian, clean romances with wholesome themes, you’ll probably find more here than I did. But if you’re looking for sharp dialogue, strong pacing, and a fully developed fake-dating storyline, this one might leave you frustrated.
I really struggled with The Après-Ski Proposal. On paper, it sounded like my kind of cosy winter read: a fake-dating romance set against the backdrop of skiing, with themes of healing after heartbreak. But the reality didn’t quite live up to the promise for me.
The biggest sticking point was the writing style. The dialogue often felt stiff and unnatural — packed with words like “misconstrued” or “tremendously” that people just don’t use in everyday speech. It pulled me out of the story and made conversations feel clunky.
I did appreciate some of the character development. It was refreshing to see Claire going to therapy to unpack her failed relationship. A grounded and realistic touch you don’t always find in romances. But even here, the therapist felt more like a bossy narrator telling her how it is, rather than someone guiding her to find her own way.
I feel like this relationship/conversation with the therapist would have been better if she had a female bestie to talk to.
The faith element was another challenge for me. I’m not religious, so I found it difficult to connect with the Christian mindset the book leans on. For example, Claire’s therapist tells her: “You need to take charge of your life by giving Jesus the reins.” For me, that felt contradictory. How is surrendering control the same as taking responsibility? I imagine readers who enjoy Christian romance will connect with this, but it didn’t resonate personally.
As for the plot and structure, the fake-dating setup had potential, but it wasn’t developed as much as I’d hoped. The romance was cute at times, but lacked tension. And the epilogue was a real head-scratcher: instead of focusing on tying up the central love story, it introduced a whole “new team” of people, which felt irrelevant and misplaced.
Also - how many designers does it take to design an airport lounge..?
That said, there were glimmers I enjoyed. The ski setting is fun escapism, and the little romance at its heart is sweet in places. But overall, I found the execution awkward, and it didn’t deliver the satisfying, uplifting rom-com experience I was expecting.