My god, what a mess! ***Spoilers**Sometimes a time jump can be a great narrative tool if done well, this ain't it. The first half of the book was pretty good, although a 10 year time jump with them being broken up for the majority of that time was too long and honestly made no sense. As in love as they were supposed to be it makes no sense she would feel smothered in less than a year and then they would live both their lives in limbo and build up 10 years of walls and excuses, just for her to decide to come and stay with him while he's sick. Anyways, that wasn't great, but getting to see them live their new lives and seeing how they were growing and fitting together was well done. I liked hearing about both their careers and how they'd changed as people and how the trama had effected them, but as soon as the reunion at school is brought up it's a downward spin around the toilet. Where to even start with what a mess it was. For one thing, 2 friends were murdered there and Arabella was nearly murdered there, and they agree to go for "closure"? No waaaaay is that believable! Maybe for an afternoon, but overnight? For a week? Get out of here! They're all adults, most adults hate going back to their highschool reunion for 1 night let alone an entire week and that's without the multi-murder baggage. They stay in the dorm rooms?? And NO one is married or in a relationship except Lacy and Brad and Miles and Ivan? Also, Lacy and Brad have kids and they just what? Dissappear on them for a highschool reunion summer camp? Like I get that it was supposed to be some FBI ploy, but that's such a shallow excuse at best and the fact that anyone showed up, least of all EVERYONE showing up for that long just is so beyond belief. Also, they remodeled it and yet ALL their old stuff is still in their rooms? ALL their projects are just sitting there? A car has been left in the lot for 10 YEARS? My god, what? No one picked up their stuff or sent it to them in 10 years? The school closing for that long doesn't make sense either, again if it would have been a year or 2 or at most 3 or 4 years, that would have been plausible, but there's no reason for it to be closed and untouched for as long as it was. It all felt like a very choreographed setup just to make a bunch of adults relive their entire highschool experience again, which really wasn't needed. Arabella had already forgiven Eli for all the things that happened between them, that isn't even why she left him, so the whole "Meeting each other in a different way" but continually reliving everything they experienced and lived through was just tedious and redundant. It felt like yet another excuse to drag the school drama on even longer. Both the main characters and the minor characters repeatedly make the most stupid decisions over and over and over again to the point of being ridiculous. The ending drama was just the cherry on the sh!t sundae that was this story. The FBI, the fact they they not once did anything remotely smart and instead just got lucky over and over again. And in the end, the original reason for Arabella leaving, her feeling smothered was NEVER addressed! She decide they want to be together alright, but she just gives up her whole life and moves back into the old house forever?! She gives up her whole career and stay locked up behind a security gate to have babies?! We never get hear more or see more about her stain glass career other than that she has a room dedicated to it? Uggh, just so incredibly dissappointed. Way too much time and filler wasted at the school and not enough time actually living their lives and working things out. Could have skipped this book all together and just done a long epilogue in the last book. Considering how invested I was in this series I want a do over!