Rating: between 3 and 3.5*
What did you think about the emotional development especially of Alice, but also of Henry and Jay?
Aly: I think Alice advanced the most. She was more open about herself and her feeling then at the start. I liked how we could see the changes in them when comparing them to the start of the book.
Claudia: hm, for me she got more insecure with the book – not regarding her sexual preferences but regarding her feelings on the whole. Jay was the most open with his feelings, but Henry showed more possessiveness in the end
How did you feel about Henrys word choice of "performing"?
Aly: It seemed he didn’t see what they did as real, can’t say I liked that.
Claudia: me neither – it made what they had together seem a bit cheap
How would you describe the flow of this book?
Aly: At times it felt it dragged a bit, I can’t choose a specific moment when. All in all I think the author did well.
Claudia: I think it started out slow and there was a longer period before it really got somewhere, than in the second half it started slowing down again ... all in all I liked it
I liked Henry's idea with starting every night with the role-playing. What did you think of it? Did it enhance the experience?
Aly: For me it did, it gave the experience a surreal feeling. I think it also helped Alice relax.
Claudia: I think it showed how much effort Henry put into their relationship with Alice. I liked most of the set-ups and some were definitely enhancing the experience. I loved the Park-scene and the birthday present - I think these two were my favorite
Who was your favourite: Jay or Henry? Why?
Aly: I can’t choose either of them, maybe a combination of both *grin* I liked Jay’s playfulness and Henry’s confidence.
Claudia: Jay is a sweet character, but very much a boy. Henry, although sometimes a bit stodgy or stiff, was a more intense character for me
Describe each character in 3 words :D
Aly: Alice driven, confident, realistic; Jay fun, sweet, co-dependent; Henry smart, refined, stuffy.
Claudia: Jay: sweet, loveable, boy
Alice: vulnerable, curios, sexy
Henry: sexy, great voice, dominant
What did you think of Alice's need of relaying only on herself?
Aly: I think she took it to the extreme. I have a feeling it relates to her family, this need of hers on depending only on herself. At times it drove me nuts.
Claudia: I think this showed her vulnerable side. for me she started out as a very strong character but somehow the whole experience made her appear more touchy. she is not weak, but at the beginning she tries to hide her insecurities even from herself. during the relationship these insecurities start to show up
I do understand why it drove you nuts … I did not care for it as well, especially in the second half of the book
What did you like most in the book?
Aly: I liked that they were open with their sexual desires, that they didn’t feel the need to hide.
Claudia: that it made it very clear that there is no right or wrong - no matter if it relates to sexual matter, partners, relationships or anything else. the only important thing is that you are true to yourself
I would have appreciate it if Alice would have found her strength, but maybe that is the reason there are more books in this series. and I would have loved it if the ending was not so abrupt
What would you change?
Aly: I’d change Henry’s formal way of speaking, it drove me INSANE! I’d also make Jay a bit more sure of himself, I understand he is a submissive but it doesn’t translate to weak. I feel the author took this sexual desire to submit of Jay’s to the extreme.
Claudia: yes, definitely – Jay was a bit too much submissive for me … but ok
the second half was a bit slower ... I would have appreciate it if Alice would have found her strength, but maybe that is the reason there are more books in this series. and I would have loved it if the ending was not so abrupt
Favourite quote:
Aly:“All will be well, dearest.”[Henry]
Claudia: sure about that ... I think I have to go over it again for a favorite quote :)