"Back Spin" is a conundrum, even for those who love Harlan Coben's books. On the one hand, this fourth entry in Coben's Myron Bolitar series is an engaging, page-turner that keeps the reader guessing up until the very end. On the other hand, the author's usual regimen of twists and turns goes way too far, turning the cleverness of the story into a series of serendipitous contrivances, and over-the-top red herrings.
The story starts out kind of weak. Sports Agent/Crime Fighter Myron Bolitar is hired to help his partner in crime Win's cousin's golf dynasty family get back their kidnapped teenage son, WITHOUT the help of Win! For those who have read the Myron Bolitar novels, the appearance and participation of Win is essential to the story, every story. Without Win, Myron Bolitar is just a lone wolf, and arguably far less interesting a character study in general. As Harlan Coben himself might say, Win is "Yang" to Bolitar's "Yin." Sure, Win IS in "Back Spin,' but only as a background player, a peripheral piece of the story's puzzle. Needless to say, the lack of "Win" in "Back Spin," ended up weakening the novel as a whole.
Ironically, Win's absence played an important part into who Windsor Horne Lockwood III really is. Though Coben doesn't reveal everything, "Back Spin" features some interesting, new insight into Win's background, and why Win ended up the way he is. He has an aversion to his family, possibly because of how he was raised, and the betrayal he felt from both of his parents. Win's coldness towards his cousin's family though, never felt right to me. More to the point, I just did not understand it at all.
Here lies the chief rub with "Back Spin," the big reveal at the end was at best vague, and at worst completely nonsensical. I still don't understand the backstory that set the entire novel off. So, back in the day, a young 8-year-old Win was supposed to be with his cousin's boyfriend Jack Coldren, getting golf lessons. Yet instead of golf lessons with Jack, Win went with his father to the horse stables and stumbled upon Win's mother having sex with a horse riding instructor. Traumatized for life, Win never spoke with his mother again, and lost respect for his father. The family was ruined.
Win's mother, refusing to accept her own responsibility in the matter, sought out vicious revenge on Jack Coldren, for she felt it was Coldren who destroyed her life, and ruined her family. Does that make sense? I don't get it, and Coben never fully explains what this meant. All he writes is that Jack Coldren was a bully as a teenager, and mischievous, and that somehow his involvement with Win seeing his mother have sex with another man was part of a prank, but...I...I still don't get what the prank was, or supposed to have been.
Regardless, Win's mother refused to let it go, and years later got revenge on Jack Coldren by bribing his caddy Lloyd Rennart to deliberately ruin Coldren's likelihood of winning at the U.S. Open. Rennart did as he was paid to do, and Coldren lost the tournament, and was ruined. As a result, Lloyd Rennart was rich, but ruined in the golf world, so he became a drunk...which in turned ruined Rennart's family.
Years later, Rennart's long lost daughter Esme becomes a sports marketing exec, and discreetly places herself near Jack Coldren's family, as her company Zoom has an endorsement deal with Jack's superstar golfer wife Linda. Secretly, and just like Win's mother Cissy, Esme blames Jack Coldren for ruining her family, and it is her intension to sabotage Jack's second attempt at winning the U.S. Open.
Then, the author throws a huge and totally unnecessary red herring/monkey wrench into his story. It is revealed that not only is Jack Coldren homosexual, he is also having an affair with Esme's boss, the likable Jewish hippie Norm Zuckerman. The question is, why? Why add this extra layer to an already convoluted story, especially when it does not pay off at all?
Then you have Esme's revenge plan. First she takes Jack and Linda Coldren's son Chad to a cheap motel in order to seduce him, but in reality she wanted to have Chad catch his gay father in a tryst with Norm Zuckerman. When that didn't work out, she hired neo-Nazi street thug Tito to help her kidnap Chad, with the ransom being Jack Coldren deliberately losing at the U.S. Open. This would please Esme as it would forever ruin Jack Coldren for good, AND it would help her big star client Tad Crispin win the U.S. Open, and put her company Zoom on the map for all things golf. When the neo-Nazi street thug Tito goes crazy (hmm, you would think she would have seen that coming) and chops off Chad Coldren's finger, Esme kills Tito gangster style.
Then you have Jack Coldren, who lies to everyone about the kidnapper's demand in order to keep up his winning streak at the U.S. Open. And you have Linda Coldren, who not only was having an affair with Jack's chief opposition Tad Crispin, but who also was responsible for murdering her husband Jack, and hiding the evidence! It's all too much, TOO MUCH story, TOO many red herrings, TOO many twists. And what was the payoff, some vague story about Jack Coldren being directly or indirectly responsible for ruining Win's family? Whaaaat??????
However, I am sucker for Harlan Coben's prose, and even his novels that go beyond the notion of rational sense have their entertainment value (read "Tell No One" to confirm). As frustrated as I was by the ending of "Back Spin," I did have a good time reading the book, and more often than not, I was highly compelled to turn to the next page, and the one after.