3.5 stars
To me, House of the Beast feels like if you took the best elements of One Dark Window and Nevernight, blended them together, and then sprinkled some Ghibli-esque dark whimsy over it. I mean, we've got a revenge-driven and stab-happy FMC, lots of eldritch horrors, strange divine/mirror realm shenanigans, all the complicated family dynamics, and a deliciously twisted and toxic bond with a snarky imaginary guy who may or may not be an elder Dread God. Hellooo, talk about one hell of a strong and ambitious debut!
Now, I really loved how Wong laid such a strong foundation for this story by starting off all the way back in time with 11-year-old Alma to experience first-hand what kicked off her furious revenge quest and to see how exactly she ended up bonded to the 'monster' in her mind. The stakes are instantly sky-high, the intrigue immediately drips off the page, and Alma’s strong motivations are nice and clear from the very beginning.
However, once we got to the 8-year timeskip, I personally felt like the tone and characters didn't 'age up', which made for a bit of a jarring reading experience. On the one hand, Wong really doesn't pull any punches and goes hard on some of the horror aesthetics, gore, violence and morally questionable decisions (which I LOVED), yet on the other hand, the characters and their interactions felt quite juvenile to me. Maybe I would have interpreted the voices of the characters and the tone of the story differently myself if I had done an eyeball read instead of listening to the audiobook, but alas, I didn't, so here we are.
Most importantly of all though, I just never really connected with Alma and couldn’t fully get on-board with the dynamic between her and Aster, which is clearly the beating heart of this story. Yes, I found Alma’s internal struggle with trying to avenge her mother while also remaining the ‘good girl’ that her mother raised her to be very well written. Yes, the complicated family dynamics and strained father/daughter relationship (like, this man is really winning worst dad of the century award) were powerful and heartbreaking in all the best ways. And yes, I also really appreciated how Wong explored some dark and difficult themes of toxic love, manipulation, codependency, faith, morality and corruption through Alma's unconventional bond with Aster, but ultimately I just couldn’t help but feel like her/their whole journey was just a bit lacklustre and almost predictable?
All that said, those quibbles somehow didn't end up hindering my enjoyment and level of immersion all that much, not least because Wong is just a very talented storyteller with an incredible imagination. The world building is so imaginative, vivid and surprisingly complex, and I loved how the divine realm and human realm were so intricately intertwined in this world as we have different noble houses who are imbued with the power of the gods they serve. Moreover, the strong second half of the story definitely had me more invested and made up for the somewhat jarring beginning, and I especially loved all the diabolical twists and turns once the legendary Pilgrimage started.
Ultimately, I was expecting and hoping to love House of the Beast more than I did, but I also can’t deny that it is a very strong, ambitious and refreshing debut. If you like a good revenge quest fantasy full of eldritch horrors and complicated characters who you can love to hate and hate to love, then this is definitely the book for you. Just do yourself a favour and pick up the physical book, especially so you don’t miss out on all of Wong’s breathtaking interior illustrations.