2,5-3 stars - tbh it probably deserves the full All That Fills Us, Autumn Lytlethree , the 2,5 is more reflective of me becoming older and growing bitter, and also growing more particular with my taste in books.
I've read so many books by now that I easily recognise "familiar plots" and "well used concepts" . Reading this I know I was getting myself into a sugary romance set on a farm and a small town-setting, I knew where the story would go, that it would be simple, easy to read, pure feel good, I knew not to expect anything ground breaking or "new", I wasn't looking for any of those things to. I wante tje sweetness and escapism, mindless enjoyment. And I did get it all.
So why not rate the book any higher? Simply put: because this felt just a bit too simple! For me, the whole setup was a bit weird and un-natural - both our main characters sharing the farm. I could get past that, but then when Sky finds exactly what she was hoping to find, (won't say what as to not to spoil it) without actuallt really even giving it any effort, it just felt too easy. More importantly, it felt so unlikely that my dose of good will fell short. The potential things standing in the way of a relationship also felt very small, which is fine, I prefer small stuff over huge traumas, but they were so insignificant that it almost seemed like they were just thrown in to add a little conflict and give the story more of a ... story? because that's the thing, there isn't really much of a story here at all. This is the third book in the series and by far the weakest one. It felt a bit like it was written just to keep the series going, and the result is that the story just kind of stretches the series out without adding much value.
also, At times it's a bit overly explanatory and repetitive - spoon feeding me little bits of information that I've already swallowed and digested several times over.
sorry to be so negative and blunt - I really did enjoy the previous two books. So... to add some positivity and end on a good note: the characters are likeable, the general vibe is feel-good, there's a good mix of humor and some real emotion. I love the setting - a farm on a small island. I appreciated that the story could be read as a stand alone, but that it did include previously mentioned characters (without requiring the reader to be familiar with them or the plots they were involved with).
I might have enjoyed this more if I were younger, or if the characters were a bit closer to my own age (just on the "wrong"/high side of 35+). So that's on me, though, I don't think I let that affect my review. I do prefer a bit older characters that Sky's 25, but I've read and enjoyed several books with 20-somethings, so that alone shouldn't matter that much.