I wish it weren't the last 😭 with this series I always have so many thoughts I dont know how to articulate but this one got real philosophical. Kamiki will always be fumbling.
A nice ending for a overall good series. The final book in the series has a lot of the flaws that, to me, are spread through the whole thing. The most damning, for me, is the way that sometimes the author let the characters speak as if they are preaching to a crowd. I understand that the author wants to make it clear that the prejudice that the society makes people who are different is something awful and we should all condemn. However, sometimes it sounded like the characters were making a speech. Its something that made me get kind of annoyed sometimes, but I'm very glad that most of the times it was not Ushio who was talking like that, it was other characters. To make the trans character constantly have to defend itself against society in the text would be very tiresome and I'm glad that didn't happen. However, because of these long, sometimes preachy, speechs, it was very funny the way that some characters, especially considering how many of them are 16-19, sounded like try hard teenagers lmao. This is a thing that bothered me through the whole series tbh, but I don't think that this per se makes it awful. Or else I wouldn't have read until the end. Okay, regarding the last book per se. I was very afraid when Sakuma and Ushio got into a relationship because of a lot of things that, through the last 4 books, made me go "Wait, are they ready to get into a romantic relationship?" And god, I'm so glad that the author dealt with these issues. Not only Ushio is a girl who recently came out as a girl and has to deal with this newfound life of hers (as the last volume has shown to us), but Sakuma is a teenager with some hardships himself. When we got to the scene of them trying to kiss and Sakuma kind of rejects her, I saw the problems coming out [lol] and I was like "oh boy oh boy". And then, there's the whole scene with Sera in Hokkaido. To me thats like. One of the best scenes in the whole series. We are confronted with the way that Sakuma himself is afraid and has a kind of skewed view regarding relationships and how he is afraid of changing their relationship. When he admitted that he couldn't feel attraction to her because of issues my heart sank and I swear, I almost wanted to get together with Sera to punch Sakuma too lol. But damn, I gotta say, when Sera took Sakuma to that place in the car and the way that the talk went I got "oh god, does he have a crush on Sakuma?" AND WHEN THAT WAS CONFIRMED I GIGGLED SO MUCH, HOLY SHIT HAHAHAHA. Tbh, one thing I felt that was missing from this series was other people from the LGBT+ acronym. Being a part of this group myself, I know that we tend to band together lol so I was like "the author is going to ignore the LGB?" and then we got a good discussion regarding polyamorous relationships and the confirmation that two of Sera's girlfriends are dating and that Sera is bi??pan?? idk?? God, I wasn't expecting that, but I'm not complaining. I think some people can get defensive since Sera is shown to be kind of a little shit, but the author has shown to us that is something of his character, not like. Because he's poly bi pan whatever lol since his girlfriends sounds like normal people. But then we got Sakuma, and I swear I was really expecting the author to confirm him as aroace or something. I'm not too keen on having things said like "yes it is like this it's canon" but the way that he talked I swear it was going to be like that. I personally dont think that he has to be. The way that he talked he could be ace/demi or he could be someone that has some complicated feelings regarding sex (as he made explicit in the way that he saw Sera and his relationships) and that has to have a good romantic relationship to have sex or something. That's something that I felt like it could have been more....told more directly? Idk. Regarding his and Ushio's relationship. I swear to god I thought they wouldn't end up together, like. I was really glad when Sakuma asked her out, but as I dug through v.5 I was so afraid that they would get separated or something. I'm a big fan of messy conversations in relationships in which the people involved like each other but there's some issues. This volume is full of that. Not only the issue of Ushio being trans, but their old relationship as friends when Ushio still hadn't come out as a child, Sakuma's own self esteem issues. This all bundled together and exploded in this volume. I loved their trip together all the way to the northmost of Japan since their insecurities were so exposed and they bare themselves and decided to be together. I really loved this volume since, even before the Hokkaido's trip started, we could see Ushio acting like a "normal" girl together with Sakuma. It makes clear that it's where she feel the safest to act like herself and that she wouldn't feel less like a girl or less loved. I really enjoyed this volume. Like I said, it's not a perfect series, it has flaws, but I felt a lot of sincerity from the author to make these characters try their best to become better people for themselves and to be happier.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I fel frustrated on behalf of Ushio, feeling like she deserved better than this. The main issue of their lack of physical intimacy being resolved by a one liner in the epilogue feels like a cop out. I have invested time to read all five books of this series and frankly felt dissatisfied by that resolution. Happy to have a happy ending for Ushio.
I'm planning on writing all of my thoughts on this 5-volume story into this one to make my life a bit easier. I decided to not mark this as 'Spoiler' as it does not spoil any specific details from this volume, so do not engage with this in fear of spoilers from previous volumes in the franchise.
On this volume specifically, it had a very realistic depiction of the challenges of dating, particularly when in a relationship which already has big thorns poking at you. I didn't fully find the ending super conclusive, and felt there was a lot of room to develop on Sakuma and Ushio's relationship journey, but I'm not going to fuss about these details when the overall volume is well written and brings together a lot of the tension and ideas developed in the story.
On the story across the 5 volumes, it was my first time really engaging with a plot focused on transgender identity. I thought the first volume was by and away spectacular in creating the ideal Oregairu-esque tension of high school romance/drama but to elevate it with the focus of Ushino's new identity. I think the entire story was a great study of characters which returns the Light Novel categorisation of 'Coming of Age' to what it actually means - looking at a bunch of high schoolers dealing with massive changes to their worlds, and then examining the why's and how's of their interaction with growing up.
This story definitely changed how I view reading lgbt+ fiction as a heterosexual individual, and made me more willing to engage with stories which are outside the classic boy-meets-girl romance, so I thank it for that. The Mimosa Confessions is fantastic in building tension, discussing difficult questions, and putting people under a microscope to understand how we conceptualise gender, identity, and family. Although it lacks some overall depth in the latter stages, especially in this volume, it is a fantastic story that I would urge anyone to read.
A gentle and quiet finale to the series. The characters remain realistic all the way to the end, which also means there’s a lot of frustrating moments as some issues are dealt with rather crassly. The main focus is, of course, Sakuma’s relationship with Ushio that can’t be easily labelled as simply friends or lovers. I did like the emphasis on not boxing things in, but I also feel like the delivery is quite persistent in this last volume. It comes off as preachy at times, especially when characters are giving lengthy lectures, masked as anecdotes, on why different perspectives should be respected.
Sera’s relationship with his girlfriends, while interesting, is basically just presented as a plot device to get Sakuma to shed off his narrow-minded views and evaluate what truly matters to him. Sera is a necessary character because Ushio wouldn’t tell Sakuma about what’s bothering her and Sakuma is too obtuse to notice, but sadly Sera himself is reduced to just that. A character to drive the plot forward, because the main couple can’t do it on their own. I also find Sakuma pretty insufferable in this book. His reaction to polyamory is one thing, but he’s even judging something as harmless as savory crepes. They’re just CREPES.
The ending is a tender one, though I find it a bit too rushed. I like this series a lot, I just wish some of the love comedy-style school life scenes were taken out to make room for more character development. The running away part during the field trip especially feels so unnecessary when all Sakuma and Ushio had to do was just… talk. Then again, they are teenagers, and I guess it is realistic for them to be so dramatic at that age.
I loved Arisa’s interview log though. Best character development.
I do not want rate early each book, because I do not want say something before time, so I will use this Volume 5 for give a review for the whole series.
Volume 1 is very interesting, because this can be the first time I read a story with a main character like Ushio. And other characters are interesting too. But Volume 2 is a little bit down, and Volume 3 has a very good development for the characters, especially Nisizhono and her change with a surprise twist.
But Volume 4 is a volume that makes me quite disappointed, because I thought that the writer would follow the way of Volume 3 and give a Volume 4 full of argument and a happy ending for Ushio and his sister. But no. Half of it is a very long flashback. And even if it is interesting enough for me to continue, the second half has a step back in the way of making things happen. And the problem looks like it is solved very easy.
Going to Volume 5, it makes me feel more disappointed. Instead of focusing only on the Ushio - Kamiki pair, it is almost all Sera. And the pair does not even develop anything in the whole volume 5 (not counting the last chapter). And I say honestly that even though the ending is very beautiful, but if I say it is perfect? No. I do not think it is completely good, but as the writer said in the book, I think this Mimosa Confession should receive a compliment. And I believe it did not waste my time, because after all, I very much enjoy it.
I enjoyed this volume and thought that it was a fitting conclusion to the series but I can't help but feel that it has some flaws that make it less than perfect. This book is full of Socratic dialogues that act as if they are saying something profound while coming to fairly obvious conclusions.
I also can't help but feel that the epilogue of this book takes a lot of liberties with the relationship between the main characters. We just cut from a relationship which seems to be on its last legs to a happy couple without much explanation. It would have been nice to see them make up in a more tangible way.
Overall, this series is pretty good and has some of the best trans representation in literature (although that's not much of a competition) but it has some flaws that leave me feeling unsatisfied.
A wonderful end to an already fun read. The characters and story are so realistic and well written. I was enthralled from the onset and was not expecting some very interesting turns of event. This series touches on parts of my life and very real issues that some of have to deal with alot. Mei Hachimoku does such a good job at representing groups of people in very nice but realistic ways. I very much enjoyed my time with the series, and while I will miss the series and its' characters, I will always look back fondly on these books. Thanks so much Mei Hachimoku for creating a story that touched my heart, and hit closer to home than any other book I have read to date.
I really don't know how to put into words how good this series is. Honestly if u made it this far then this will probably be ur favorite volume. Not even just because of writing but more because of all the great moments in the book, especially the first and last chapters. There's just so many moments throughout where I was just smiling while reading. The whole book is just great. I'm gonna miss all the characters, especially Ushio. Great series all around.
I'll be sad to never get another new story about Ushio. She is such an inspiration to me, one of my favorite characters. There was a lot to this novel in terms of drama, but I'm glad it seems to have worked out in the end. Sakuma is absolutely one of the luckiest guys on Earth to have someone as amazing as Ushio love him.
i really enjoyed this last volume, but ushio and sakuma's resolution felt pretty forced. sure they agreed to compromise with each other when they have issues, but wdym ushio got back together with him so easily? she addressed real problems that affected their relationship and was completely justified in wanting to break it off, to just stay friends. there's no way she still isn't hurt that sakuma was so put off when they last kissed. there's still the problem of sakuma not wanting physical intimacy with her, and it's obvious ushio wants more from him yet.. they made up so easily just by him agreeing to give her 2 hugs a day. i found myself sharing sera's opinion, thinking they wouldn't last if they made up like that.
other than that, i really enjoyed this volume and this series :) i was really happy to see ushio and sakuma living together and attending college in tokyo, fulfilling their dream of leaving tsubakioka. i especially loved arisa's development. i'll definitely be looking to read more from this author!!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
wow what a great journey this series was, and im so glad i stuck with it to the end!! this story hit too close to home for me so i couldn't help but cry when i got to the ending 🥹💗 and weirdly enough i grew to like nishizono in this volume even though she only appeared at the end. anyways if you're thinking of reading this series, go for it don't hesitate any longer. trust me you won't regret it!!!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.