“Total Defense is so impressive because Preston is the master of his craft; his clarity and sophistication are always buttressed by illuminating evidence and well-chosen quotations, bespeaking both a great expert’s depth and an expert writer’s talent.” –Samuel Moyn, The New Republic The story of how FDR and fellow New Dealers created the idea of national security, transforming the meaning of defense and vastly expanding the US government’s responsibilities.
National security may seem like a timeless notion. States have always sought to fortify themselves, and the modern state derives its legitimacy from protecting its population. Yet national security in fact has a very particular, very American, history―and a surprising one at that.
The concept of national security originates in the 1930s, as part of a White House campaign in response to the rise of fascism. Before then, national self-defense was defined in terms of protecting sovereign territory from invasion. But President Franklin D. Roosevelt and his circle worried that the US public, comforted by two vast oceans, did not take seriously the long-term risks posed by hypermilitarization abroad. New Dealers developed the doctrine of national security, Andrew Preston argues, to supplant the old idea of now even geographically and temporally remote threats were to be understood as harms to be combated, while ideological competitors were perilous to the “American way of life.”
Total Defense shows it was no coincidence that a liberal like Roosevelt promoted this vision. National security, no less than social security, was a New Deal the state was obliged to safeguard Americans as much from the guns and warships of Nazi Germany and imperial Japan as from unemployment and poverty in old age. The resulting shift in threat perception―among policymakers and ordinary citizens alike―transformed the United States, spearheading massive government expansion and placing the country on a permanent war footing.
This is an outstanding study of the idea of national security; I'm sure it will be a classic text for decades. National security is a pervasive term in the foreign policy world today; I literally just finished working for a Department of National Security Affairs. But it's often taken for granted how this term changed the way we think about foreign policy and defense.
In a concise but thorough book, AP shows how the idea of national security arose in the early 20th century, with the most critical time being the New Deal and WWII. While some of the Founders used the term nat sec, for the most part Americans thought about their safety in terms of national defense. This meant ensuring that the safety and integrity of the American state was safe from foreign invasion or interference, an inherently more limited concept. This didn't mean the US was disengaged from the world, but it did mean that it launched relatively few wars outside the Western hemisphere and avoided having a large peacetime military establishment.
This mentality started to change in the early 20th century as American society became more interdependent with the rest of the world, creating both opportunities and vulnerabilities. During the Progressive Era, Americans worked to rationalize, professionalize, and ultimately bring order to a modernizing society. That meant greater attention, across the board, to not only dealing with crises as they arose but managing life, the economy, society, and foreign relations. This mindset shift, embodied in Woodrow Wilson, led the US to care more about shaping the international environment in ways that best safeguarded the homeland.
But the concept of national security in its full, modern form didn't arise until the confluence of the New Deal and the Second World War "warfare state.' In the New Deal, the government took on the responsibility of bringing security into ordinary people's lives in an age where macro-economic shocks created the potential for democracy-destroying crises. The government became not only an intervener but a manager of the economy and much of social life. As the fascist threat built in the 30s and 40s, this expanded into a desire for national security, the assumption of which was that the US democratic/capitalist system could not survive in a world dominated by hostile powers. The US had to actively shape the international system, not only defeating threats as they arose but creating systems and capabilities that ensured the containment of threats.
Social security and national security went hand in hand in this era because ensuring domestic social order and prosperity, as well as a healthy and educated population, was seen as crucial to making national security possible. World War II solidified this mindset; this is one of Preston's key interventions, because it wasn't the Cold War that created the modern national security mindset; it was the confluence of the New Deal and WWII.
But the Cold War, especially the conservative backlash against the social welfare state, did distort the linkage of social and national security in favor of the latter. The US built up a huge national security state and basically defined the entire world as crucial national interests (leading to far-flung wars like Vietnam), but it underdeveloped the welfare state, at least in comparison to the warfare state. That's a really useful way for thinking about the key mentalities that shape America's role in the world to the present day.
This book is a great example of what historians should do: take a term that everyone takes for granted and then destabilizes it, showing that it came from somewhere, from a combination of human agency/ideas and larger contextual forces. It's not terribly long and moves briskly, and it's a bold interpretation of US diplomatic and political history that everyone in the field (and many people without) should read.
Persuasive, but unsatisfying. The longer I think about the book the more impressed I get with the points it makes. Preston has clearly thought and learned a ton about his subject. He covers national security as a concept, and his thesis is that our modern ideas about it were formed by Roosevelt in the 1930s, rather than in the late 1940s at the start of the Cold War as most assume. Preston carefully marshals his evidence, chapter by chapter, thinker by thinker and bureaucratic step by step.
I found the book a bit unsatisfying because the author seems more focused on amassing evidence than telling a story. This is a perfectly defensible choice. There's no reason a book arguing a historically complex point should have compelling narrative momentum. But there's no reason it shouldn't either. It's not that the book is overwhelmingly dense or complicated. It's just that on my first reading it seemed somehow shapeless and without momentum. In the week or so since I've finished the book, and as I've compared the points it raises with other elements of my research, the book has gotten more impressive. It's really a wealth of great information. It's just not that much fun to read. A useful addition to the literature on the era though.
Preston convincingly argues that the birth of the U.S. National Security State was actually a byproduct of The New Deal, and FDR's administration. He goes through the history of U.S. conceptions of National Security, and doctrines of defense, arguing that between 1812 through WW2, the United States had a "Free Security" view of national defense. Preston's definition of Free Security was that because of America's location, it was difficult to invade and surrounded by weak neighbors and two oceans. Additionally, when the United States went to war during this time frame, it could rapidly mobilize and demobilize on the fly.
However, this all changed during WW2, when the conception of NS shifted to "defending the American way of life". Ever since WW2, we have seen this conception used to justify our involvement in endless conflicts all around the World, to our detriment usually. I thought Preston made a fantastic case for this idea that The New Deal, and the rise of the Welfare State coincided with the birth of the National Security State. It's certainly a provocative idea, but Preston backed up his case with ample evidence.
An account of America’s pivot from a concrete ideology of defending borders to the abstract ideology of defending America’s Way of Life, characterized as going from national defense to national security. Preston builds on the luxury of “free security” that U.S. enjoyed from the War of 1812 to WWII. Protected by two vast oceans, unthreatened by two weak neighboring countries, and blessed with an abundance of natural resources, the country required very little relative investment in its defense capabilities. All of this changed with attack on Pearl Harbor and America’s entrance into WWII.
Preston argues that the welfare state erected by the New Deal enabled the warfare state that prosecuted the war and remained in place for the Cold War. He makes the case liberal impulses gave ever increasing momentum to the national security state which led to the strategies of containment, domino theory, and ultimately the debacle in Vietnam.
No complaints as to the line that this book followed - I think it was a great study in the epistemological assumptions underlying the modern security state, and compelling linked them to the New Deal, rather than the cold war. Would recommend reading.