Read for SPFBO, this is only my personal opinion, group verdict might differ widely!
City of Stone by K.T. Holder
This is one of those books I really enjoyed while reading, the kind I moved through in long stretches without losing interest. It has a strong emotional core, a cast that’s easy to care about, and a clear love for found family and loyalty. I liked it a lot, even when I could see the rough edges.
The story follows a group of young people who survive years in brutal labor camps with their magic bound, and then have to figure out who they are once they’re free. What stood out to me most was the way they come together. They are all from different backgrounds, different peoples, different experiences, and yet the bond between them feels natural and warm. The banter, friendship, and quiet loyalty are some of the book’s biggest strengths, and they carried me through the whole story.
One thing I really appreciated was how calmly and kindly the book treats unlearning. Kas starts out very empire centric in the way he thinks and speaks, using the names he grew up with for other peoples. Over time, he learns that those names can be hurtful or dismissive, and that groups like the Jatte and the Kikachi have their own names for themselves. Once he realises this, he simply makes an effort to do better. It’s not framed as a big moral moment, just a quiet adjustment, learning and respecting what matters to others.
The same approach shows up in more personal moments too. The book is very light on romance, which I loved. There is a bit of attraction here and there, mostly the awkwardness of young people figuring themselves out, but it never takes over the story. One scene in particular worked really well for me, when a character assumes romantic interest, gets corrected, blushes, apologises, and accepts it. There’s a touch of first attempts at love awkwardness, but it stays gentle and kind. It’s about friends recalibrating, teasing a little, and moving on. LGBT existence isn’t turned into a source of drama, just something that requires a moment of rethinking and adjustment between people who care about each other. That baseline of acceptance and willingness to learn felt genuinely comforting to read.
Alongside the main group, we also get POV chapters from a young empress trying to rule while surrounded by nobles who would rather protect their own power and wealth than care for their people. She’s lonely, sharp, and deeply frustrated by entitlement and patriarchy, and I found her chapters engaging and emotionally grounded. They add political weight to the story and show how difficult it is to do the right thing inside a system built to resist change.
There is also a POV from the opposing side, which I liked in theory for the added perspective and moral tension. Seeing the world through different eyes added an interesting contrast, even if that arc sometimes felt like it moved a little too quickly. The ideas behind it are strong, and I would have loved to see them given more space to unfold. This ties into a broader issue, as the book does sometimes feel a bit too easy. Conflicts resolve quickly, people often get along faster than expected, and answers tend to appear just when they’re needed. Nothing ever pulled me out of the story, but there were moments that made me pause with a raised eyebrow before continuing.
Overall, this is a book with a solid foundation, a lot of heart, and characters I genuinely enjoyed spending time with. It already shines in its found family, kindness, and emotional clarity, and that’s exactly why the rougher edges stood out to me. The frustration I felt came from caring, from seeing how close this story is to something truly excellent. With a bit more depth and polish, it could dazzle, and I’d happily follow these characters wherever the next book takes them.