Thank you Netgalley and Viking Books for Young Readers for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!
In “Water in Her Veins,” Shannon Schuren delivers a captivating story filled with mystery, supernatural intrigue, and generational trauma that is wrapped in a small-town gothic atmosphere. At the heart of this twisty, emotionally charged story is Lola Boyd who is a teenage girl battling a debilitating, undiagnosed illness and a past that refuses to stay buried.
After inheriting a sprawling estate in Colorado from the father she never knew, Lola moves across the country with her mother and controlling new stepfather. But what begins as a fresh start soon turns ominous. Lola’s symptoms worsen, including nosebleeds, fatigue, and haunting visions, and even the house seems alive with secrets. The local legend of healing waters and a mysterious doctor who once “cured” a town during an epidemic only deepens the mystery. Is there truth in the myths, or is something darker coursing beneath the surface?
One of the book’s strengths lies in its nuanced portrayal of invisible illness. Lola’s chronic fatigue-like condition, which is dismissed by doctors and ignored by her new stepfather, makes her a deeply relatable character for anyone who has struggled to be believed. The medical mystery is handled with empathy and authenticity, adding depth and urgency to Lola’s journey. Her strength and determination make her easy to root for, even as she’s repeatedly gaslit and sidelined by the adults in her life.
Schuren’s writing is richly descriptive, especially when portraying the eerie, supernatural elements. There’s a creeping sense of dread as Lola uncovers the secrets of her family history like the visions passed down through generations, a mansion that may or may not be haunted, and an unsettling conspiracy surrounding the ownership of the house. The book brings together themes of epigenetic memory, inherited trauma, and the burden of legacy in a way that feels fresh and thought-provoking.
The cast of supporting characters adds variety to the story, though not all are equally fleshed out. Lola’s new group of friends, particularly Clare, Sage, and Fletcher, introduce found family themes, moments of levity, and a hint of romance. Fletcher, the son of the estate’s caretaker, brings both emotional support and romantic tension to the story, while Bryn, Lola’s best friend, adds some welcome LGBTQ+ representation. That said, some relationships felt underdeveloped, and a few side characters kept significant secrets for a bit too long. Open communication would have solved a lot of problems in this book.
The story leans into mystery and thriller territory with unexpected twists, including a satisfying reveal about who’s been breaking into the mansion and why. The town’s obsession with healing waters and the tangled motives around the property’s deed add layers to an already multi-threaded plot. While a few reveals feel slightly implausible, the final resolution ties up the threads well, delivering closure without undermining the emotional journey.
Overall, “Water in Her Veins” is an engaging and genre-blending YA novel that mixes small-town secrets, supernatural folklore, and the deeply personal fight to reclaim one’s identity and truth. It’s especially resonant for those interested in stories where the past bleeds into the present—sometimes literally.