I’m not sure if I just missed this on release or it was a busy week or if the title just made me shudder too much, but… look, it’s not even a pun. I know they’re probably working hard with that translation, but Rowdy With A Chance of Meatheads it is not.
Anyway, my point is, I skipped this. And for no good reason I decided to buy it anyway. Which all worked out in the end, since this is emphatically not heavy reading, but it is a seriously solid shojo romp that ticks just about every box you’d want from something like this.
As a bonus, it’s sweet AND funny. Early on there’s a very small image of Momose, our heroine, as she fails hard at the cooking club and it’s funnier on its own than anything in the entire last volume of Komi Can’t Communicate.
The conceit is that Momose has done her high school glow-up after being harried by delinquents all through middle school. She’s still a klutz, but wants to have a better time during the springtime of her etcetera. Enter Ichikura.
Glasses-wearing Ichikura ends up partnered with Momose in the Helpers Club, which Momose rightly deduces is shorthand for being everybody’s dogsbodies. They have to do a raft of tasks, which actually works in the story’s favour because it lets them do a variety of stuff (plus it lets us see Ichikura hunched over gardening like he’s smoking behind the gym).
What quickly becomes apparent is that, despite his glasses and studious nature, Ichikura is cut from the same ripped cloth as the delinquents who wrecked Momose’s middle school life. Except he’s trying to reform. Badly.
This sets the stage for something that’s a lot more heartfelt and friendly than it seems to be going, as Momose and Ichikura both try and move on from what people saw them as in middle school. This is another nice touch - they’re both trying to better themselves and Momose’s approach to not punching things meshes well with Ichikura showing her how to stand up for himself.
While a lot of this is from the basic shojo playbook, it is being done delightfully well and I loved watching these two bounce off one another. Momose is obviously falling for Ichikura and having a hard time with it because of his old persona, which is often closer at hand than his intentions to reform would suggest.
Naturally, Ichikura deploys his fists only in defence of others and to keep people from being jerks. Yet even this is already changing as the story rolls along, much as Momose is trying new things and fitting in so much better with her new class.
These two just work together, minus one really incongruous instance where Ichikura wrenches Momose’s face, and it’s incredibly easy to just sit back and enjoy this light-hearted romp. It feels weightless, but behind all the silliness there’s a good message to it and two great characters.
There’s always just that little bit extra that makes things really pop. When Momose needs some tutoring, the way Ichikura goes about it is actually really reasonable and some of the most believable tutoring I’ve seen in a manga. Is it necessary? Heck no, but it helps it feel a bit more natural all the same.
Yeah, Momose gets harried a bit, but she holds her own and the flashbacks to her middle school years aren’t the fraught moments of, say, A Silent Voice. This keeps its tone note perfect pretty much the entire time. A real testament to how you don’t have to be original, you can just be really darn good and that’s more than enough.
5 stars - no, really, I loved this that much. It’s one of the best shojo titles I’ve read in ages and there’s just something about it that made me smile the whole time. Very refreshing and very enjoyable.